WatchSo I'm smugly tootling along, renting a nice 3 bedroom 2 bath house in the Oakland hills, waiting for RE prices to go down, when I receive a certified letter from my landlady (who's also a RE agent) informing me that the rent is going up from $3100 to $4000 effective November 1. She had put out a feeler a couple of months ago, asking if we might be interested in buying the house, so I'm guessing she's just trying to drive us out so she can sell before all those REOs the B of A is about to dump on the market change things.
Anyway, now I've got to find a new rental (in the same area where my son just started middle school), do a ton of work to do getting ready to move, spend thousands on moving, and disrupt my life in an unplanned, very significant way over the next two months. It's got me thinking about how much nicer it would be to own a house and not be subject to the potential for such disruptions.
I'm not sure how much that would be worth to me, but it is something. Any thoughts?
Follow
Befriend
1 threads
13 comments
Oakland has rent control but it does not, because of state law, apply to single family homes. And unfortunately condominiums are counted as single family homes (since each unit has a separate owner). And moving does cost pots. While we hired movers for $500, you also have to consider the cost of first, last and security deposit, as well as possible costs in switching cable service etc.
Follow
Befriend
4 threads
68 comments
I have been booted from a rental three times in my life, once for the owner to sell, once for the owner to move back in, and once for the owner to move his in-laws in. It was a *HUGE* inconvenience every time, and right now it would be damn near fatal given what's going on in my household. This is a significant advantage of owning and a big part of the reason I'm still looking while I wait.
Follow
Befriend (4)
26 threads
1,566 comments
Laguna Beach, CA
Premium
I think all things not in a bubble, most of us would like to own rather than rent.
It's really a question of whether the increased cash outlay to own compared to the mental anguish of having to move is of more or less value to you as an individual.
Follow
Befriend
1 threads
15 comments
Kew Gardens, NY
OMG renting is so much cheaper. I dont know anyone who has or intends to stay in same freakn house for 30 years. People change divorce get sick die, neighborhoods change, jobs change. You would have to live at same location at least 20 years to get a better deal buying. First portion of loan is almost ALL interest cause banks know you wont have loan for 30 years most likely Majority of people move after 7 years.
Follow
Befriend
1 threads
15 comments
Kew Gardens, NY
Also, it is mentioned that one cannot control rent. Can a home owner control his property taxes? inurance? repairs? natural disasters? Heating bills? I notice home owners never add in heating costs in their calulations. Could be 5K a year or more in areas that have real winters.
Follow
Befriend (3)
15 threads
5,718 comments
NickO says
Another uneducated renter....
Follow
Befriend
1 threads
15 comments
Kew Gardens, NY
Uneducated? lol thats why I sold my house in Mineola ny learly last year after 5 years just in time for 455K and the house is worth about 425 now. Thats why I pay $1550 to rent for a small attached house in kew gardens queens with a backyard and driveway when the house is worth like 425K. Boiler already needed replacement oops not my problem owner had to replace. Hurricare Irene? no worries for me. I just rent. Im no slave to bank or at mercy to tenants. Free to leave whenever I want. You owners keep paying $1 to get back 30 cents in tax deductions. Also pPrices to continue falling for many years. Sorry if your locked into your homes and underwater - not me. Got out in time. Also i had an 4 family bought in 1999 and sold in 2004 for 250K profit. You wont see that again in this lifetime. Whoever owns now your house will BE WORTH 5 PERCENT LESS NEXT YEAR HOW U FEEL ABOUT THAT? AND THE YEAR AFTER AND SO ON
Follow
Befriend
38 threads
2,313 comments
Bellingham Bob says
Nope. As long as un-updated 1940's, 2-3 bedroom houses command 450-500k prices... which were 250k prior to 2003, then yes- we're still in "Market madness". Even now you will be hard-pressed to find a halfway decent house in a halfway decent area in the Bay Area for anything less. We're still in a bubble here. Very much so.
Follow
Befriend (4)
26 threads
1,566 comments
Laguna Beach, CA
Premium
tatupu is a troll. Not a particularly good one. Save your fingers NickO.
Follow
Befriend (3)
15 threads
5,718 comments
NickO says
GoranK says
That hurts my feelings. I was simply pointing out how similar your post sounded to a similar one by someone espousing owning whcih got this is response
Hysteresis says
Not everyone lives the in Bay Area. In many, many areas it is cheaper to own right now. From day 1. Speaking in such broad generalities is almost never going to be correct.
You sound a little bitter--why? It sounds like you made the right decision to sell when you did and rent. You should be happy!
PS--you have to heat your home whether you rent or own...
Follow
Befriend
2 comments
We've been renting a 4BR/3BA home in the Lamorinda area for $3400/mo for about a year and a half. It's fairly spaceous at 2500 sq.ft., and looked great when we first looked at it (appeared to have been updated within the last decade with granite/stainless when they started to become fashionable). We would have been very happy to rent the house long term, but our landlord would not repair or replace anything - - says he has very little income (which I believe since he is a realtor).
We finally got fed up living with a non-working AC (esp. when it's been so freakin HOT lately), leaky faucets, windows that would not properly open/close all the way, etc.. so we recently bought. Spouse and I believe that house prices (including ours) will continue to fall, and that a house purchase is, in general, a poor investment. So, even though we qualified for enough of a loan to purchase our dream house at 4.5%, 30 yr fix, we chose instead to buy something more modest for less than 2x our annual income. We do not ever want to be in a position where we'll worry about making the house payments, nor do we want to cut back on the things we enjoy doing as a family (skiing, traveling to exotic destinations) because we stretched to buy a home. And finally, we do not want to deal with the situation we were in with our last rental, nor move (barring unforeseen circumstances) ever again.
Oh, and by the way, our last move cost $4,000.
Follow
Befriend (48)
274 threads
12,655 comments
47 male
Lafayette, CA
Premium
Bellingham Bob says
How do you get $900?
I get a mortgage payment of $1700 on a $360,000 30-year loan @ 4%
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
iwog says
900x12/3%
Follow
Befriend (48)
274 threads
12,655 comments
47 male
Lafayette, CA
Premium
Bellingham Bob says
Okay, well the interest payment on a 30-year 4% mortgage is going to be around $1300.
I don't know where you're getting 3% money, but if you're lending it I'll be happy to borrow it.
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
iwog says
Uncle Sam's MID.
Follow
Befriend (12)
141 threads
1,367 comments
Emeryville, CA
Hey smart folks:
My underwater house is in the 94602. Is there a solution for TClement that involves my house? (It's a nice one, neighbor).
Follow
Befriend
4 threads
2,115 comments
Is there a solution for TClement that involves my house?
That's legal? Not that I can think of...
BTW CL, I found your house. The tax basis on your property is $505k (tax year July 1, 2010 - June 30, 2011). I have to admit, I'm leaning more towards the walk away option for you. I hope that Wells makes you an offer you can't refuse. Let us know how it turns out.
Follow
Befriend (3)
8 threads
48 comments
Oakland, CA
Hi CL,
Wish I knew, neighbor, I'd probably jump at the chance. And how the heck does EBGuy figure out which is your house?
Follow
Befriend (31)
34 threads
2,612 comments
San Jose, CA
Premium
iwog says
5/1 ARM. So it's less than 3% after MID. :o)
Follow
Befriend (4)
26 threads
1,566 comments
Laguna Beach, CA
Premium
CL says
I have a feeling you're going to get foreclosed on.
Follow
Befriend
18 threads
166 comments
With renting the problem are greedy property corporations like AIMCO and Archstone who jack up the rent each year. Archstone is notorious for doing this to renters in the bay area.
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
^ I'll push a pencil through my cheeks before I rent from a corporate apt complex again.
$1320/mo, $1450/mo, $1750/mo. Fuckers.
Follow
Befriend (6)
5 threads
2,368 comments
edvard2 says
Yeah, but wealthy foreigners do not covet to own a residence in Rick PerryLand. Not the kinda Exit Strategy they are interested in.
It is different here and it is different this time.
Follow
Befriend (6)
5 threads
2,368 comments
E-man says
Well suppose the borrower gets laid off and is out of work for awhile. Like that never happens to anyone. Just ask the 1,000 former Solyndra workers.
Or suppose the one of the two-income borrowers leaves the workforce for awhile to take care of young children (I know, I know, Cool Hipsters don't like icky-poo children). Like this has never happened before.
You don't get the impact of the MID if you are not in a high income bracket. But you do get the privilege of being a slave to your possessions, at least until you walk away from them.
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
Sybrib says
Fannie & Freddie are more lenient about missed checks than the LL.
http://www.ezlandlordforms.com/documents/3722/california_3_day_notice_to_pay_or_quit/
You don't get the impact of the MID if you are not in a high income bracket.
$34,500 single, $69,000 married filing joint to reduce a 4% interest rate to 3%.
Well, po' people don't get past the $5800/$11600 std deduction I guess.
Follow
Befriend (6)
5 threads
2,368 comments
Bellingham Bob says
Could be, in that case, frame the discussion like that, it's not about the MID working in one's favor. It's more about the moral hazard.
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
Well, the MID does give an immense advantage to wealthy people buying po' peoples' houses, like iwog is doing.
MID doesn't give any real advantage for buying houses in the higher ranges, since the MID serves as a price support by making the payment "more affordable".
The MID is really fucked up. Should get rid of it for investment properties fo' shizzle.
Follow
Befriend
1 comments
Bellingham Bob says
Same thing is happening to me right now, though not as bad. $1445/mo (first month free!), then $1516/mo, now $1786 (or $1636/mo if I sign a new 12 mo lease). An apartment similar to mine in the same complex is listed on craigslist for $1995/mo now.
I used to be a "hardcore renter", but now I'm more and more considering to buy. Most apartments just suck. They may put in new carpets and granite countertops, but the insulation, windows, the build quality in general leaves a lot to be desired.
Thing is, I might move in a few years, or I might stay put. And I don't know how much sense it makes to buy a tiny house or a 1br condo if hell might freeze over and I start a family?
Follow
Befriend (1)
1 threads
45 comments
Los Angeles, CA
When you rent you have to stay fluid. Having a kid works against that. When I rent (as I am now) I'm ready to go in 5 days... and why not? I'm renting right?
Here's a tip: If you rent again, don't rent from and Agent. Also try find a rental that has been a rental FOR A LOOONG TIME. The best senario is a home owned by multiple family member. The best part is... they keep multiplying and will never reach a consensus to do anything with the property. I'm, lucky I live in just such a property...
Oh F*ck did I just jinxed it, didn't I?
Follow
Befriend (12)
141 threads
1,367 comments
Emeryville, CA
tclement says
I've been posting my situation for a while, so if you give enough details one can figure it out.
If I shortsell, and you need to buy (or choose to) it could be a smart thing. I barely ever manufacture meth in it, and when I do, it's usually in the garage. :)
I guess what I'm asking is is there a solution for TClement that involves my house? Timing, real assessing of the improvments I made, etc?
I'm not a money guy, so if there's a solution out there I'd listen. I am wrestling with the idea of a short or a FC, or some magic offer from Wells to keep me there.
Follow
Befriend (4)
26 threads
1,566 comments
Laguna Beach, CA
Premium
CL, just do a short sell. You obviously can't keep the house, time to move on.
Follow
Befriend (12)
141 threads
1,367 comments
Emeryville, CA
Right--I'm cool with that, Gorank. I was thinking of it for him and his family. It's a nice house and wouldn't have the normal icky feeling that a typical FC might have. At the very least, I can tell him to keep his eyes on my address when it is auctioned, no?
Follow
Befriend (5)
27 threads
2,073 comments
SJ says
That is not my experience with Archstone, although admittedly somewhere other than the Bay Area, but then any easy solution is to rent from someone other than Archstone. They certainly don't have anywhere near a market monopoly.
I always feel like the biggest problem people have mentally with renting is that they equating it to the shitty slumlord they had in college. It doesn't have to be like that.
Nested says
Nested, do we take that to mean that you didn't buy in Lamorinda?
Follow
Befriend (31)
34 threads
2,612 comments
San Jose, CA
Premium
CL says
Short sale your home to TClement?
EBGuy says
Leaning? Dude, you're being generous in what you're saying. :o)
To me, it doesn't make any sense to hang onto a house that's about $300k underwatered. Of course, that's just my opinion. You could prove me wrong however. :o)
Follow
Befriend
35 threads
5,700 comments
Bellingham, WA
E-man says
No sense at all.
Bank gave you money, secured by the house.
If you haven't refi'd, that's a purchase money loan, and if you're in a non-recourse state, it's the bank's problem not yours.
Walk-away with no 1099 issue ends next year.
http://www.irs.gov/individuals/article/0,,id=179414,00.html
but banks can't 1099 you if you have a non-recourse loan anyway.
Follow
Befriend (3)
8 threads
48 comments
Oakland, CA
CL says
Hey, CL, I appreciate it. Buying is a possibility for us. Let me know how to get in touch, and maybe we can go to the bank with a proposal.
Follow
Befriend (12)
141 threads
1,367 comments
Emeryville, CA
Bellingham Bob says
I wondered that...non-recourse will mean that the forgiven amount can't be taxed as income? So the forgiveness act really only applies to recourse states? Makes sense, but that's good to know.
TClement--I'll friend you or whatever the kids are saying nowadays.
Follow
Befriend (3)
8 threads
48 comments
Oakland, CA
Sure, CL
Follow
Befriend
4 threads
2,115 comments
tclement, I couldn't help myself and looked up your old place. I wanted to fault you for giving up your low tax basis (and King Middle School for you child), but all I can say is: Well played! Way to take the (tax free!) money and run. Not many people could do what you did; best of luck finding a new place (did you write your landlord a letter?)
Follow
Befriend (3)
8 threads
48 comments
Oakland, CA
Hi EBGuy, I guess I did all right with my old place in Berkeley and I'm still waiting for the right time to upgrade. Today I spoke with a realtor who showed us a nice rental (still a bit too high for my tastes, but not $4k.) The great thing was that when I said I was waiting for a few years to buy, she said: "depends on the price range. If you're looking for a more expensive house, there's a long way for them to fall." I have to say, I was impressed (not to mention validated).
I've now heard 4 different stories about the law pertaining to this abusive rent increase. The latest (from the aformentioned honest real estate agent) is that if she has more than one rental property, rent control applies, regardless of whether it's a SFH. Oh well, I'll be glad to be out from under her incompetent and arrogant landlordship anyway. :)