Patrick.net

Why gun control wont really work.

By Kevin   Follow   Thu, 10 Jan 2013, 7:32pm   2,929 views   94 comments
Watch (2)   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (4)   Dislike (1)  

I'm completely anti gun, but I've concluded that in the long run, gun control can't work.

The reason is 3d printers. I've now seen two very good proposals for how guns can be printed, and shells to go with it (ammo making still requires manual work to fill the shells)

Given that reality, I expect gun control to be about as successful as piracy control.

I think we should instead focus on making people just not want guns. Think about the PSA from childhood telling us not to smoke. Now my generation doesn't smoke.

I have zero desire to own a gun and even less to shoot somebody with one. If we could raise a generation to not want to use guns, maybe we could prevent them from killing each other. The nut jobs who are afraid of the government or just like to shoot things would still print their guns and shoot them, but most people wouldn't.

I was raised around violent movies and video games, but never saw a gun in person other than police officers until I was an adult. As a result, I only associated guns with murder and war. Maybe we could replicate that experience to kids now and keep them from viewing guns as a tool that was used for solving every day conflict.

« First     « Previous     Viewing Comments 55-94 of 94     Last »     See most liked comments

1. thomaswong.1986 Follow Befriend 15 threads 3,093 comments

   55   8:43pm Mon 14 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike (1)   StillLooking says THere is some dispute about whether this guy was in a gang. that is why you have massive murders in places like Chicago and Oakland. NO... we got no gang problems ! we got no drug trafficking problems ! we got no organized crime problems !

2. marcus Follow Befriend (5) 171 threads 5,214 comments

   56   9:17pm Mon 14 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (1)   All that has to happen for "gun control to work" is for access to guns without background checks, and access to military grade guns to both significantly decrease. Regardless of whether homemade guns or pipe bombs or whatever still can be had, the goal is only to slowly decrease the number of gun murders. This can be accomplished with gun control. Especially controlling access via secondary markets and background checks. This would include sales of homemade or 3d printed guns. MAke the penalty extremely high for anyone selling these. (PLEASE COMPREHEND THAT I AM NOT SAYING GUN CONTROL WILL CAUSE GUN VIOLENCE TO GO TO ZERO OR ANYTHING CLOSE TO ZERO - AND I AM ALSO NOT SAYING IT WILL WORK IMMEDIATELY - IT WOULD TAKE DECADES TO SEE RESULTS) This is not to dismiss benefits of changing the culture, or better still decreasing the wealth and income gaps, and improving education (also related to socioeconomic well being).

3. marcus Follow Befriend (5) 171 threads 5,214 comments

   57   9:52pm Mon 14 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (1)   Sane Americans (including about 3/4 of NRA members): "We're totally for sensible common sense restrictions such as background checks, and shutting down the secondary market where criminals buy their guns. We're also okay with restrictions on automatic and some semiauto type military "assault weapons." Insane paranoid wacko response: "It's another totalitarian takeover !!We need our guns for after WWIII when it's mad max time. This is stalin and mao all over again. AAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH !!! They're coming to take our guns oh my, They're coming to take me away, HA HA They're coming to take me away, HO HO HEE HEE HA HA To the funny farm Where life is beautiful all the time And I'll be happy to see Those nice, young men In their clean, white coats And they're coming to take me away, Ha-haaa!

4. JodyChunder Follow Befriend (3) 21 threads 1,524 comments Victorville, CA Premium

   58   11:04pm Mon 14 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (2)   Dislike   Protected   Kevin says I have zero desire to own a gun and even less to shoot somebody with one. Just guessing here, but something tells me you're probably a creative person. You see a gun, and you make associations; you see a machine designed for destruction. I am not creative, but I understand. If you lived in Victorville, I think you would feel differently. I see a well-designed, well-maintained weapon, and I see an economic means for threat mitigation; a last resort buffer between me and the abridged version of things.

5. JodyChunder Follow Befriend (3) 21 threads 1,524 comments Victorville, CA Premium

   59   11:05pm Mon 14 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   Protected   Billybigrig says They can have my gun when they remove it from my cold stiff hands... I felt that way about gorilla's when they were all over the news. http://www.theonion.com/articles/gorilla-sales-skyrocket-after-latest-gorilla-attac,30860/

6. tatupu70 Follow Befriend (3) 15 threads 5,718 comments

   60   4:20am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   thomaswong.1986 says do you run around with $5000 cash a week and a gun like a drug dealer ? seems to me that there is no economic disparity to mention given how profitable drug dealers make .. thats why they care guns, protect their turf / operations and kill rival gang members... Low level pushers actually make very little. Freakanomics has a good writeup on the pay of gangs. Regardless, if there were other opportunities available to inner city folks, gangs would not be so appealing. Economic disparity is very much to blame.

7. JodyChunder Follow Befriend (3) 21 threads 1,524 comments Victorville, CA Premium

   61   4:32am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   tatupu70 says Freakanomics What a couple of bozos. I think it was Levitt who made the case in a paper of his that an increase in abortion rates among blacks in the '70s was the primary reason behind a fall in violent crime in the 90s. I'd be wary of anything Levitt or Dubner had to say on any subject. But I do agree with you about the need for more inner city opportunities to combat the allure of gangs.

8. Vaticanus Follow Befriend (1) 77 threads 1,139 comments

   62   7:17am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (2)   Dislike   "This is not to dismiss benefits of changing the culture" Making something illegal does not change the culture. Look at drug and alcohol prohibition. It just establishes a new class of "criminals" and a few hard core criminals willing to resort to violence by exploiting the law abiding people and/or fighting with rival criminals.

9. Thedaytoday Follow Befriend 46 threads 530 comments

   63   8:30am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   Do 3D printers print gun powder? Can 3D printers print bullets?

10. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    64   8:38am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   Protected   If I have a super-duper 3D printer I won't care about printing guns. I will create an army of world domination robots. LOL!

11. FortWayne Follow Befriend (13) 106 threads 3,863 comments

    65   8:48am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   kentm says Gun control seems to work quite well to reduce gun deaths in other countries. You know, out there, in the world. You mean like Cambodia, or Indonesia where rounding up and executing a few million politically inconvenient people was not a problem. How about other ethnic and political purges throughout history?

12. Call it Crazy Follow Befriend 249 threads 2,915 comments

    66   8:59am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   Peter P says If I have a super-duper 3D printer I won't care about printing guns. I will create an army of world domination robots. LOL! That's the way to think... Go BIG, or go home!!

13. zzyzzx Follow Befriend (9) 436 threads 4,261 comments Baltimore, MD

    67   9:20am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   Thedaytoday says Do 3D printers print gun powder? Can 3D printers print bullets? I doubt it. In fact I suspect that the only gun part that it could make anytime soon which might actually be reliable enough to use would be a high capacity clip.

14. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    68   9:44am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Thedaytoday says Do 3D printers print gun powder? Can 3D printers print bullets? No, but anyone with the know how to print a gun could mix up some gun powder. Bullets could be printed as soon as there is a printer that does so in lead; baring that casting bullets is easier than making gun powder.

15. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    69   9:49am Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   JodyChunder says I think it was Levitt who made the case in a paper of his that an increase in abortion rates among blacks in the '70s was the primary reason behind a fall in violent crime in the 90s. I'd be wary of anything Levitt or Dubner had to say on any subject. I don't think they were saying it was the primary reason, just a big factor in the reduction of crime. I thought they had a pretty compelling argument. The best counter argument I have seen is the recent discussion of lead poisoning: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/jan/07/violent-crime-lead-poisoning-british-export

16. CaptainShuddup Follow Befriend (1) 303 threads 5,299 comments

    70   12:32pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   Here's why guns are good. Here's a story from my home town. It's about time someone nabs one of those bastards, there's not a day that goes by, there's not at least 2 stories how a clerk got robbed and or shot and killed. I think they should hire off duty cops only for these jobs. The crazy ones with the itchy fingers want a merit of glory but have never once fired their weapon in the line of duty. I bet that would put a moratorium on armed robberies at convenient stores. HOLLYWOOD, Fla. (WSVN) -- A would-be robber is dead after being shot by a store clerk at a South Florida gas station. The shooting sometime around midnight, Tuesday, at the Exxon Mart near South State Road Seven and 52nd Street. Twelve hours later, the investigation still remains active as detectives work to piece together what led to the fatal shooting. Investigators said two armed robbers barged into the store firing at the store clerk, forcing the clerk to return fire with his own gun. "One tried to rob the gas station, and one was shot by the clerk," said an unidentified employee. "The clerk was armed, at which point multiple shots were exchanged between the clerk and the suspect; the suspect was struck," said Hollywood Police Sergeant Pablo Venegas. Police said a homeless man, identified as Hasib Kuric, alerted the store clerk prior to the robbery. "He is alone," said Kuric. "He's maybe not ready. The door was open at the time." Kuric usually stays inside a U-Haul truck parked behind the Exxon. He said that he noticed something strange going on behind the convenience store at around 11:30 p.m. He said he watched as the two men put on hooded sweatshirts and masks moments before they rushed into the store. He quickly rushed inside to alert the clerk, a friend Kuric calls Leo. "I tell Leo just lock his door and call police, behind the building is two guys with masks." Only seconds later, two men rushed in with guns. "Right behind them, before the clerk had called 911, the suspects entered," said Venegas. "They brandished a firearm ... He didn't even have time to call 911 coz that's how quickly it happened." The wounded would-be robber succumbed to his injuries and died on scene. "It's sad someone died but got to make a living," said the employee. Police said the second subject, 19-year-old Joshua Stuart, was nabbed a few blocks away in a white getaway car. Police credit Kuric for saving the clerk's life. "I don't feel like a hero, I just feel happy because I'm still alive," Kuric said. Other employees were shaken by events that transpired at their job. One man said, "It's kinda scary." "I was scared," said another when she heard the news. The store clerk will not face any charges. Stuart faces attempted armed robbery and felony homicide charges, as his accomplice died in the act. Surveillance video captured all that transpired inside the Exxon Mart. 7News is working on obtaining that footage.

17. Thedaytoday Follow Befriend 46 threads 530 comments

    71   1:19pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (2)   Dislike (1)   CaptainShuddup says Here's why guns are good. We certainly know why they are bad.

18. Dan8267 Follow Befriend (17) 785 threads 7,962 comments Boca Raton, FL Premium

    72   1:58pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Billybigrig says They can have my gun when they remove it from my cold stiff hands... Actually, they can have your gun if you carry a small bag of weed on you. So much for gun ownership being a right.

19. Thedaytoday Follow Befriend 46 threads 530 comments

    73   2:08pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (2)   Dislike   New York legislature passes tighter gun laws http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-politics/wp/2013/01/15/new-york-set-to-pass-tighter-gun-laws/ The new law includes provisions that would: Change the definition of an assault weapon as one having two “military rifle features” to one. Ban Internet sales of assault weapons. Make private sales of assault weapons between anyone besides family members subject to outside background checks. Make it a misdemeanor to own a magazine of more than 7 bullets (the previous limit was 10). Persons owning higher ammunition magazines would have a year to sell them. Require therapists to report to the state mentally ill patients who they believe may use guns illegally. Authorities could confiscate those patients’ weapons. Increase sentences for gun crimes.

20. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    74   2:15pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Thedaytoday says Make it a misdemeanor to own a magazine of more than 7 bullets (the previous limit was 10). That is just silly, the 10 limit was fine. You can get a S&W 327 .357 revolver that holds more than 7 shots.

21. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    75   2:21pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   leo707 says Thedaytoday says Make it a misdemeanor to own a magazine of more than 7 bullets (the previous limit was 10). That is just silly, the 10 limit was fine. You can get a S&W 327 .357 revolver that holds more than 7 shots. They want to frustrate gun manufacturers. It has nothing to do with being sensible.

22. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    76   2:30pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Peter P says They want to frustrate gun manufacturers. It has nothing to do with being sensible. I don't know....It can't be that difficult to just start making clips with lower capacities. I think they just wanted to feel they were doing something without actually doing anything. I would be willing to bet they settled on 7 round max because of the 1911.

23. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    77   2:34pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Thedaytoday says Require therapists to report to the state mentally ill patients who they believe may use guns illegally. Authorities could confiscate those patients’ weapons. This sounds like it is the most effective law, in the group, when trying to prevent mass shootings. They should have also required gun owners with mentally ill family members--and children for that matter--to have secure gun storage.

24. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    78   2:36pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   leo707 says Peter P says They want to frustrate gun manufacturers. It has nothing to do with being sensible. I don't know....It can't be that difficult to just start making clips with lower capacities. I think they just wanted to feel they were doing something without actually doing anything. I would be willing to bet they settled on 7 round max because of the 1911. Now they need a 7-round for NY, a 10-round for CA, and larger ones for other states. Some manufacturers will just give up. Will there be a return to single stack pistols?

25. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    79   2:42pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (1)   Protected   Peter P says Will there be a return to single stack pistols? Yeah, with higher calibers, and I would not be surprised if the 1911 increases in popularity.

26. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    80   2:44pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Single-action semi-autos are scary. :-)

27. FortWayne Follow Befriend (13) 106 threads 3,863 comments

    81   2:48pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike (2)   leo707 says They should have also required gun owners with mentally ill family members--and children for that matter--to have secure gun storage. They should emphasize gun safety more often. Won't stop someone really determined though. But that's the cost of having violent mentally ill people in society. No free lunch there.

28. Thedaytoday Follow Befriend 46 threads 530 comments

    82   2:50pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   Peter P says Some manufacturers will just give up. They will not.

29. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    83   2:52pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Thedaytoday says Peter P says Some manufacturers will just give up. They will not. A lot of them stopped selling in CA and MA.

30. Quigley Follow Befriend (6) 17 threads 575 comments Huntington Beach, CA

    84   2:52pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (2)   Dislike (1)   It's all the Chinese people's fault! Didnt they invent gun powder? Before then, humanity was peaceful and murders rarely happened. Wars were accomplished with much more humane swords, arrows, pikes, and maces. Nothing says pacifism like spreading an enemies cranial contents across a battlefield with a well aimed mace strike! My solution: let's put 80% of the GDP into research to build a time machine. Then send Seal Team Six back to assassinate the Chinese bastard who ruined the world with his darn invention!

31. Peter P Follow Befriend (4) 117 threads 17,655 comments Premium

    85   2:56pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like (1)   Dislike   Protected   If I had a time machine I would be busy trading CDS.

32. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    86   2:56pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   FortWayne says They should emphasize gun safety more often. Yep, gun safety can not be emphasized too much. Last year my sister went to the funeral of a teenage nephew (from here husbands side) who was accidentally shot by his brother. From a family of avid hunters and the kids grew up around guns. FortWayne says Won't stop someone really determined though. Some years ago I had a friend who, while in a bout of severe depression, tried getting into his parents gun safe. Fortunately his was unsuccessful. FortWayne says But that's the cost of having violent mentally ill people in society. No free lunch there. Yep, if only we had places and funding to lockup the dangerously mentally ill like we did in the 1950s.

33. FortWayne Follow Befriend (13) 106 threads 3,863 comments

    87   3:16pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   leo707 says Fortunately his was unsuccessful. Yes, I always kept mine locked up and stored ammo in a separate location too. Kids are smart, but usually not really determined, and they give up at some point. leo707 says Yep, if only we had places and funding to lockup the dangerously mentally ill like we did in the 1950s. We were supposed to build half way houses to replace those, but no one wanted them near their neighborhood so we never really did what we were supposed to do. So politicians just dance around the issue, and do everything else that they can to prolong their political careers instead of finding cures to societal ills.

34. leo707 Follow Befriend (12) 10 threads 3,520 comments Oakland, CA leo707's website Premium

    88   3:22pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   FortWayne says eo707 says Fortunately his was unsuccessful. Yes, I always kept mine locked up and stored ammo in a separate location too. Kids are smart, but usually not really determined, and they give up at some point. Oh, he was in his late 20s when he tried. He went at the safe with a sledgehammer and power tools. FortWayne says We were supposed to build half way houses to replace those, but no one wanted them near their neighborhood so we never really did what we were supposed to do. That may have fixed the homeless problem, but I don't know if it would really prevent the dangerously mentally ill from running amok. Don't most of them (the spree killers) have homes anyway?

35. FortWayne Follow Befriend (13) 106 threads 3,863 comments

    89   3:28pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   leo707 says Oh, he was in his late 20s when he tried. He went at the safe with a sledgehammer and power tools. That is one impressive kid, he'll go far in life if he keeps that level of determination. I don't think our daughter ever tried, girls might be different. leo707 says That may have fixed the homeless problem, but I don't know if it would really prevent the dangerously mentally ill from running amok. Don't most of them (the spree killers) have homes anyway? Good point, all these spree killers have all been living at home and on some sort of meds. But at the same time, I bet a lot more crime is committed by others. Spree killers there is only a handful I can think of.

36. Call it Crazy Follow Befriend 249 threads 2,915 comments

    90   3:47pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (2)   leo707 says They should have also required gun owners with mentally ill family members--and children for that matter--to have secure gun storage. They did, that's part of the new law.

37. thomaswong.1986 Follow Befriend 15 threads 3,093 comments

    91   9:44pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (1)   Peter P says Now they need a 7-round for NY, a 10-round for CA, and larger ones for other states. Some manufacturers will just give up. so ... you buy two barrel.. with two 7 round clips.. 7+7 = 14...

38. JodyChunder Follow Befriend (3) 21 threads 1,524 comments Victorville, CA Premium

    92   9:52pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Protected   Thedaytoday says Can 3D printers print bullets? You could knock some together in your garage easily enough. Need to mix up some cordite -- nitro, guncotton, and petroleum jelly. You could even cast the brasses yourself.

39. deepcgi Follow Befriend 118 comments

    93   10:14pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike   Or a South American country could just invite and legally allow weapons production factories which would receive the full support of the pro-gun lobby who wouldn't have ordinarily - if the US weren't being hostile to gun ownership at the time. We can't control drug trafficking, why would gun trafficking WITH popular support be more easily controlled. Venezuela makes another mint.

40. thomaswong.1986 Follow Befriend 15 threads 3,093 comments

    94   10:17pm Tue 15 Jan 2013   Share   Quote   Permalink   Like   Dislike (1)   FortWayne says Good point, all these spree killers have all been living at home and on some sort of meds. But at the same time, I bet a lot more crime is committed by others. Spree killers there is only a handful I can think of. Drug dealers / gang bangers go on a shooting spree everyday in big cities... same people same gang infested corner of the city.. same time every day...

« First     « Previous comments