6
0

Wtf is wrong with Americans ?


 invite response                
2014 Nov 12, 11:57am   24,535 views  59 comments

by marcus   ➕follow (6)   💰tip   ignore  

You would think a political campaign could actually be won with this kind of talk.

http://www.tickld.com/x/wtf-is-wrong-is-wrong-with-americans-this-guy-nails-it

Comments 1 - 40 of 59       Last »     Search these comments

1   smaulgld   2014 Nov 12, 2:12pm  

Interesting thanks for posting.

The US higher ed system is the blue print for Obama care- private schools subsidized by government.

This ensures higher tuition with no corresponding increase in quality.

The debate should be over free market education/healthcare vs state subsidized education/single payer healthcare.

Govt involvement in the private markets leads only to govt waste and gifts to corporate interests -the vast majority of taxpayer/consumers are worse off in blended govt/market endeavors.

2   indigenous   2014 Nov 12, 3:28pm  

Actually education might not be as important as you think, regarding a higher standard of living, of course it is on the list.

I like this list regarding what is important to a better economy:

1 Competition
2 Scientific discoveries
3 Property Rights
4 Modern Medicine
5 The consumer society
6 The work ethic

Along with the recent government decimation of education with it's FUBAR plan of common core. Which with the others on this list have been decimated by the Feds.

1 Yup through ever greater cronyism

2 This is where the education system really shines, not to mention the sheer
volume of graduates in China

3 No better way to steal wealth than by inflation.

4 The ACA and Medicare take care of that quite nicely and the gift that keeps on giving

5 This has been steadily declining.

6 Huh, what time do I get the disability check?

3   Oilwelldoctor   2014 Nov 12, 3:59pm  

People taking advantage of federally funded student loans at for profit schools. Just using the money to live on with the intent of never paying it back.

People getting useless degrees where there are no job opportunity upon graduation. Many don't belong in college.

4   Bigsby   2014 Nov 12, 9:02pm  

bgamall4 says

Oh, and Kristol and Kagan cofounded PNAC that called for a new Pearl Harbor a year before 9/11.

So you keep saying. Except this is what was written:

"Further, the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor."

The transformation referred to was a technological one - and that the change would be a long drawn out affair unless the need for such a transformation was made more apparent by a catalyzing event. This is not remotely the same as what you constantly and wrongly claim.

5   Bigsby   2014 Nov 12, 10:52pm  

The bananas in the supermarket are a bit soft. It's a zionist plot!

6   Blurtman   2014 Nov 12, 11:12pm  

It is an apples and oranges comparison.

7   Bellingham Bill   2014 Nov 12, 11:16pm  

College is run by the debil.

Christians lose their faith when they go to secular colleges.

It must be destroyed, along with public education in general, since it is a liberal institution.

Actually, come to think of it, if you've ever played a game of Illuminati you've seen this sort of dynamic before.

GOP destroys Liberal Colleges with assistance of UFOs + 22 Megabucks

8   Strategist   2014 Nov 12, 11:22pm  

marcus says

You would think a political campaign could actually be won with this kind of talk.

http://www.tickld.com/x/wtf-is-wrong-is-wrong-with-americans-this-guy-nails-it

Loved it.

indigenous says

Actually education might not be as important as you think, regarding a higher standard of living, of course it is on the list.

I like this list regarding what is important to a better economy:

1 Competition

2 Scientific discoveries

3 Property Rights

4 Modern Medicine

5 The consumer society

6 The work ethic

You can't achieve all of above without the right education.

9   indigenous   2014 Nov 12, 11:28pm  

Strategist says

You can't achieve all of above without the right education.

Tell that to Bill Gates or Steve Jobs.

10   Strategist   2014 Nov 12, 11:42pm  

indigenous says

Strategist says

You can't achieve all of above without the right education.

Tell that to Bill Gates or Steve Jobs.

They were drop outs as were many others who made billions. However, they hired hundreds of thousands of highly educated, highly skilled scientists and engineers, to achieve success.
Take the example of cancer research and robotics, it will be impossible to make any progress without hordes of PhD's. Specific fields will require a specific skill set. An individual can always be successful at whatever natural skills he or she may have.

11   indigenous   2014 Nov 12, 11:46pm  

Don't disagree but the current education system is FUBAR and getting worse.

12   Strategist   2014 Nov 12, 11:54pm  

indigenous says

Don't disagree but the current education system is FUBAR and getting worse.

That is true. We are turning out too many liberal arts majors with huge debt that work at Starbucks. I remember reading 76% of those in STEM PhD programs are foreign students, mostly Indian and Chinese.
One way to solve that problem.....Give them green cards. Problem solved.

13   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 12:03am  

Strategist says

Problem solved.

That is really what has saved us thus far. But far from problem solved, as it is a systemic problem. That list of 6 items is not negotiated any more than gravity.

14   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 12:06am  

Oilwelldoctor says

People getting useless degrees where there are no job opportunity upon graduation. Many don't belong in college.

This is VERY true, however, since we've outsourced our manufacturing, what are non-college bound people supposed to do? They can't all be plumbers or electricians.

Work 2 P/T Jobs at 15 hours a week, just to survive, with no hope of anything better, just barely staying off welfare - in fact would be a lot better of on it?

15   Blurtman   2014 Nov 13, 12:09am  

Comparing Nordic countries to the USA is an inapt comparison. The USA's Anatolian Plain is on its border, versus Denmark, for example, where it is over 1,000 miles away. The Nordic countries are more ethnically homogeneous versus the USA. And the USA is a federation of states versus the Nordics.

People vote primarily to improve the lot of their own kind. Recall the outrage surrounding property tax dollars going to fund education in California for the brown skinned folks, which resulted in Proposition 13.

16   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 12:14am  

thunderlips11 says

This is VERY true, however, since we've outsourced our manufacturing, what are non-college bound people supposed to do? They can't all be plumbers or electricians.

Allow price discovery.

This means quit borrowing to fund the budget, only possible because of the reserve currency status.

The reality is that the BRICS will likely become a reality, at which point the above will no longer be possible and the US is in for a rude awakening.

Like Japan the US needs to go through the business cycle and correct to allow price discovery.

17   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 12:24am  

A compelling body of research is now available, from many leading academic researchers and from respected research organizations such as the National Bureau of Economic Research, the RAND Corporation, and the Urban Institute. No one has been able to find any evidence indicating current widespread labor market shortages or hiring difficulties in science and engineering occupations that require bachelors degrees or higher, although some are forecasting high growth in occupations that require post-high school training but not a bachelors degree. All have concluded that U.S. higher education produces far more science and engineering graduates annually than there are S&E job openings—the only disagreement is whether it is 100 percent or 200 percent more.


And as I say like a broken record on this board:
Were there to be a genuine shortage at present, there would be evidence of employers raising wage offers to attract the scientists and engineers they want. But the evidence points in the other direction: Most studies report that real wages in many—but not all—science and engineering occupations have been flat or slow-growing, and unemployment as high or higher than in many comparably-skilled occupations.

Because labor markets in science and engineering differ greatly across fields, industries, and time periods, it is easy to cherry-pick specific specialties that really are in short supply, at least in specific years and locations. But generalizing from these cases to the whole of U.S. science and engineering is perilous. Employment in small but expanding areas of information technology such as social media may be booming, while other larger occupations languish or are increasingly moved offshore. It is true that high-skilled professional occupations almost always experience unemployment rates far lower than those for the rest of the U.S. workforce, but unemployment among scientists and engineers is higher than in other professions such as physicians, dentists, lawyers, and registered nurses, and surprisingly high unemployment rates prevail for recent graduates even in fields with alleged serious “shortages” such as engineering (7.0 percent), computer science (7.8 percent) and information systems (11.7 percent).
http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/03/the-myth-of-the-science-and-engineering-shortage/284359/

Science majors make peanuts; really gifted Math graduates go to Wall Street to write up Trading Algos.
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/09/why-the-s-in-stem-is-overrated/279931/

18   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 12:26am  

In looking at the latest government data available, my co-author and I found the following: In 2012, there were more than twice as many people with STEM degrees (immigrants and native-born) as there were STEM jobs — 5.3 million STEM jobs vs. 12.1 million people with STEM degrees. Only one-third of natives who have a STEM degree and have a job work in a STEM occupation. There are 1.5 million native-born Americans with engineering degrees not working as engineers, as well as half a million with technology degrees, 400,000 with math degrees, and 2.6 million with science degrees working outside their field. In addition, there are 1.2 million natives with STEM degrees who are not working.

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/378334/what-stem-shortage-steven-camarota

Currently, U.S. colleges graduate far more scientists and engineers than find employment in those fields every year — about 200,000 more — while the IT industry fills about two-thirds of its entry-level positions with guest workers.

At the same time, IT wages have stagnated for over a decade. We cannot expect to build a strong STEM workforce and encourage domestic innovation by developing policies that undermine the quality of STEM jobs. Before asking government to intervene in labor markets by handing out more guest worker visas and green cards to STEM graduates, we should ask for audits of shortage claims and workforce impacts as a first step toward developing evidence-based policy on this issue, an issue critical to the nation’s future.

Asking domestic graduates, both native-born and immigrant, to compete with guest workers on wages is not a winning strategy for strengthening U.S. science, technology and innovation.

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/making-sense/the-bogus-high-tech-worker-sho/

So, more STEM degrees than jobs.

Not a surprise when you have a bottom-feeder economy dedicated to creating as few jobs as possible, outsourcing and insourcing whenever possible, and keeping wages flat whenever possible.

19   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 12:29am  

indigenous says

This means quit borrowing to fund the budget, only possible because of the reserve currency status.

And quit offering H1-Bs, right? Since that is government intervention that alters the market price for labor.
Blurtman says

People vote primarily to improve the lot of their own kind. Recall the outrage surrounding property tax dollars going to fund education in California for the brown skinned folks, which resulted in Proposition 13.

This is why the Multi Cult is a terrible thing. We already have two disadvantaged minority groups that need a leg up, plus plenty of our own White hillbillies too. Why are we adding to our burden? Especially when we're having trouble with labor participation overall?

Multi Cults are a cornerstone feature of Empires, and Empires collapse from their inconsistences and their inability to provide for their core, dare I say White, population.

Europe is experiencing the same thing - the Left loses because it kowtows to the Multi Cult while ignoring the Native Whites, and especially Poor White Males, who are generally insulted and mocked if mentioned. You see it with UKIP, with Jobbik, with Marie Le Pen.

20   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 12:45am  

thunderlips11 says

Multi Cults are a cornerstone feature of Empires, and Empires collapse from their inconsistences and their inability to provide for their core, dare I say White, population.

Europe is experiencing the same thing - the Left loses because it kowtows to the Multi Cult while ignoring the Native Whites, and especially Poor White Males, who are generally insulted if mentioned. You see it with UKIP, with Jobbik, with Marie Le Pen.

That is not true.

The bottom line on it is debt. With as much inertia as the US has or Rome had they can do some really fucking stupid stuff and not suffer for it. But eventually the inertia will fade as will the US economy. That list, I posted is the touchstone.

21   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 12:49am  

Indigenous, read a bit of Sam Huntington.

From the Clash of Civilizations to Davos Man, the 1%er Neoliberal without loyalty to his own Nation, the man has been spot on.

I say this when I disagree with him politically on many issues.

22   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 12:54am  

thunderlips11 says

Indigenous, read a bit of Sam Huntington.

Read this article, it might put what you are saying in context?

http://mises.org/daily/6959/War-Making-and-Class-Conflict

23   dublin hillz   2014 Nov 13, 1:15am  

Blurtman says

People vote primarily to improve the lot of their own kind

That is the most puzzling phenomenon of all. In a capitalist society this tribal instinct should be extremely muted if not outright submerged, yet in politics we find that it manifests itself time and time again.

24   Blurtman   2014 Nov 13, 1:18am  

thunderlips11 says

Europe is experiencing the same thing - the Left loses because it kowtows to the Multi Cult while ignoring the Native Whites, and especially Poor White Males, who are generally insulted and mocked if mentioned. You see it with UKIP, with Jobbik, with Marie Le Pen.

I've told Dem friends of mine that the party has got to drop its support of affirmative action. The movers and shakers in the Dem party are not adversely affected and many are positively affected by affirmative action. Poor and lower working class whites are adversely affected.

Another case of iberals having someone else pay to get their rocks off.

25   Blurtman   2014 Nov 13, 1:19am  

dublin hillz says

Blurtman says

People vote primarily to improve the lot of their own kind

That is the most puzzling phenomenon of all. In a capitalist society this tribal instinct should be extremely muted if not outright submerged, yet in politics we find that it manifests itself time and time again.

What's capitalism got to do with it? People are people.

26   NDrLoR   2014 Nov 13, 1:21am  

Blurtman says

Comparing Nordic countries to the USA is an inapt comparison.

Plus there's 25 million of them, all probably no more than three or four degrees of being related to each other resulting in tremendous social trust as opposed to 300 plus million of us from every tribe that ever existed with half trying to figure out how to game the system.

27   dublin hillz   2014 Nov 13, 1:23am  

Blurtman says

dublin hillz says



Blurtman says



People vote primarily to improve the lot of their own kind


That is the most puzzling phenomenon of all. In a capitalist society this tribal instinct should be extremely muted if not outright submerged, yet in politics we find that it manifests itself time and time again.


What's capitalism got to do with it? People are people.

Because in capitalism, in princple, it's supposed to be every man or every family for itself. Thus, even people of the same skin color/culture are potential competitors for resources to be secured/obtained. Ironically, in western europe which has a more collectivist ethic vs U.S., people are much more likely to vote in their class interest as opposed to here where people routinely vote against their economic self interest due to unresolved racial tensions.

28   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 3:07am  

I'm not really talking about Class Conflict here, but rather Identity Conflict. That "Davos Man" and the international MBA crowd see themselves as "above" petty national concerns and as Internationalists. They consider anything for the benefit of the Citizens of a Country to be base and ignorant, no matter how tepid or minor - except, of course, when motivating those citizens to support a "Police Action" somewhere. Oh, and anything that is no cost to them, like pro/anti- Gay Rights and Abortion. Those are to be used as levers to distract the populace with eternal Theological/Philosophical debates while pursuing Neoliberal goals.

I disagree with the article, but I'm gonna skip it for now because it's slightly different than what I'm about with Identity.

29   Blurtman   2014 Nov 13, 3:08am  

Turks = Mexicans.

30   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 3:11am  

Blurtman says

I've told Dem friends of mine that the party has got to drop its support of affirmative action. The movers and shakers in the Dem party are not adversely affected and many are positively affected by affirmative action. Poor and lower working class whites are adversely affected.

Another case of iberals having someone else pay to get their rocks off.

Exactly. And it'll be worse now that out/in-sourcing is attacking STEM careers, where STEM people probably somewhat lean democratic to begin with.

Poor Blacks AND Whites (and Native Americans) are absolutely slammed by immigration, since it keeps wages at the bottom jobs low while creating more competition for them.

31   dublin hillz   2014 Nov 13, 3:16am  

thunderlips11 says

That "Davos Man" and the international MBA crowd see themselves as "above" petty
national concerns and as Internationalists

"National sovereignty" has been used by despots to justify crimes against humanity against their own people while they enjoy all spoils that absolute power brings.

32   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 4:03am  

thunderlips11 says

I'm not really talking about Class Conflict here, but rather Identity Conflict. That "Davos Man" and the international MBA crowd see themselves as "above" petty national concerns and as Internationalists.

I don't see any difference. You are dimissing, without cosidering a profound point. Which I don't, think you philisophically disagree with.

33   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 4:05am  

dublin hillz says

"National sovereignty" has been used by despots to justify crimes against humanity against their own people while they enjoy all spoils that absolute power brings.

Yes. But the point here is that Davos Men/International MBAs don't care about crimes against humanity, so long as the bottom line is fine - even against their own people.

Trade has also been used by criminals, like the Opium War. Or the entire conquest of India.

For example, our unparalleled World #1 incarceration rate to fuel private prisons, while allied with a country that lashes rape victims, while demonizing another for putting a few national monument vandals in jail for a few months.

34   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 4:07am  

indigenous says

I don't see any difference. You are dimissing, without cosidering a profound point. Which I don't, think you philisophically disagree with.

I'm not dismissing - I'm not interested in exploring class issues at this point in the thread (I will in another thread if you want later) - though that certainly has something to do with it. I'm more interested in other aspects of identity like ethnicity and citizenship for Sam Huntington's point about a Clash of Civs and International Men.

35   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 4:13am  

thunderlips11 says

I'm not dismissing - I'm not interested in exploring class issues

The article in not about class issues!

36   MisdemeanorRebel   2014 Nov 13, 4:21am  

indigenous says

The article in not about class issues!

It's the fundamental point of the article:

We thus arrive at a universal, praxeological truth about war. War is the outcome of class conflict inherent in the political relationship — the relationship between ruler and ruled, parasite and producer, tax-consumer and taxpayer.

I'm happy to refute it - later - but right now I am interested in exploring how the "International Men" or "Neoliberals" consider themselves "Citizens of the World" and don't care about their own populations' well being and pursue strategies directly detrimental to them.

37   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 4:49am  

thunderlips11 says

We thus arrive at a universal, praxeological truth about war. War is the outcome of class conflict inherent in the political relationship — the relationship between ruler and ruled, parasite and producer, tax-consumer and taxpayer.

It is about the creation of the class conflict, not the conflict itself.

38   humanity   2014 Nov 13, 5:28am  

indigenous says

Don't disagree but the current education system is FUBAR and getting worse.

At least that's what the propagandists tell you.

What's happening is the underclass is growing, and our public schools don't work well for these groups, because they are geographically together, and going to schools comprised almost entirely of kids from poor homes, often highly dysfunctional poor homes does not work.

For middle class and upper middle class, our public schools are as good or probably better than they were 30 or 50 years ago.

39   indigenous   2014 Nov 13, 5:34am  

humanity says

What's happening is the underclass is growing, and our public schools don't work well for these groups, because they are geographically together, and going to schools comprised almost entirely of kids from poor homes, often highly dysfunctional poor homes does not work.

For middle class and upper middle class, our public schools are as good or probably better than they were 30 or 50 years ago.

Good point, OTOH what about the Fed uniform testing?

40   humanity   2014 Nov 13, 6:01am  

Not a big fan of NCLB ,or standardized testing in general, usually done by the state, but those have always been there. For the good schools, the problem with these tests is mostly the wasted time and money, both of which could have been better spent.

But it's a complex issue. Some on the right want to privatize, or move towards merit pay or other government imposed reforms. All of these require testing to give us the data on which decisions can be based. Testing is the way the schools performance is measured and compared to other schools.

Meanwhile the people in the testing business are laughing their way to the bank.

Comments 1 - 40 of 59       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions