0
0

Stock market performance vs. general economy...6 month lag?


 invite response                
2012 May 5, 4:38pm   11,420 views  23 comments

by American in Japan   ➕follow (1)   💰tip   ignore  

My knowledge of economics is limited, but I have heard from friends and family who are in finance, that the general economy basically lags 6 months behind the (forward-looking) stock market (Dow Jones, Nasdaq, Amex, etc.)

For the Dow I personally like to look at the S&P 500 since it includes more companies than the DJIA.
It was at 1253.2 (October 31,2011) and rose to 1369.1 (April 30, 2012)..an increase of over 9% (not bad for 6 months). Based on this you would think that we are on an upswing... However, all I can say is *I have a bad feeling about this...*

From Wikipedia :"Stock market returns are a leading indicator: the stock market usually begins to decline before the economy as a whole declines and usually begins to improve before the general economy begins to recover from a slump."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_indicator

#investing

« First        Comments 3 - 23 of 23        Search these comments

3   American in Japan   2012 May 6, 9:52pm  

I suspect that a decoupling between worker productivity and their wage renumeration has occured. It began under Reagan's term and has gotten worse over the years. Troy (Bob) had a good graph showing that. The six month rule may no longer apply (if it ever did).

4   xenogear3   2012 May 8, 10:13am  

It only applies in a bull market.
In a secular bear market, both economy and stock drop at same time.

5   mdovell   2012 May 9, 5:00am  

Productivity and wages don't have to go hand in hand with one another. Automation largely changed things. That coupled with an expansion of the marketplace and technology that replaced some forms of employment.

6   hanera   2012 May 9, 5:42pm  

In SV, there are always bidding wars. Reasonably priced properties always attract more bids (over 10) than badly priced properties (No bid to less than 10).

7   American in Japan   2012 May 10, 7:24pm  

Thanks again E-man.

E-man says

Just take a look at the last two bubbles. In the late 90's and early 2000's, you hear stock tips everywhere. From a cab driver to your cashiers at the grocery. After the dot bomb, did you any anyone offer stock tips? A lot of people made fun of Warren Buffett during the dot bomb years. Guess who has the last laugh?

It sound like at this point you can make money shorting whatever they are talking about.

It

9   hanera   2012 May 11, 5:19am  

My glasses are very blurred but lady luck is with me. Btw, I have a telescope.

10   American in Japan   2012 Aug 10, 6:46pm  

If there really is a 6 month lag (which I am still in doubt about these days), the general economy is ready to take off. Just look at the stock market the last 6 - 8 months...spectacular improvement.

11   American in Japan   2012 Aug 13, 1:10am  

@Call it Crazy

You took the words right out of my mouth.

12   FortWayne   2012 Aug 14, 3:44am  

There isn't always correlation. Stock market is not an indicator of good economy. Especially with the PPT stepping up lately.

13   StoutFiles   2012 Aug 14, 3:49am  

Until unemployment lowers and, more importantly, average wages for the lower / middle classes increase, the economy isn't going to shoot back up.

How can things get better if the majority of the country can't afford the things they once could?

14   uomo_senza_nome   2012 Aug 14, 5:05am  

American in Japan says

that the general economy basically lags 6 months behind the (forward-looking) stock market (Dow Jones, Nasdaq, Amex, etc.)

I don't think you can substantiate that statement with real data.

We did not have a stock market crash until Oct 2008, but everybody was aware that we are heading into a recession since December 07.

Check this out.

There are two ways you can reduce the frequency of recessions:
a) increase trend growth
b) dampen cycle volatility.

We have very weak growth (GDP hovering around 1.5 to 2% range) and much higher cycle volatility ==> more frequent recessions.

15   uomo_senza_nome   2012 Aug 15, 2:09am  

American in Japan says

Thanks Clint!

Cheers. The stock market and GDP numbers are usually lagging and not leading. More facts:

1. There are dozens of coincidental indicators (job growth, income growth, sales growth etc.) which are all trending down.

2. There are leading indicators (ECRI's WLI being one example) which are also trending down.

3. GDP is usually positive going into a recession or while we are in a recession. NBER's definition of two quarters of negative GDP for a recession is faulty because you don't know you are in a recession until it has already happened.

16   TMAC54   2012 Aug 17, 12:12am  

True markets are based simply on supply & demand. Demand in the present market is heavily influenced by gumint QEs, bond buying programs, zero interest rate, etc.
They are throwing the dice because they liked all that profit made during the introduction of the computer and Internet tech.
We set a bad example for them. How many of us threw dice during the housing bubble ?
When will gubmint stop providing sugar to the rush ?

When they do, will all roads lead to ........ ?

17   American in Japan   2012 Aug 29, 4:11pm  

There is now a major disconnect...

18   Eman   2012 Aug 29, 5:21pm  

American in Japan says

There is now a major disconnect...

6-9 months lag is about right. I got really nervous when the market kissed its 52 week high recently so I sold a bunch of stocks. 42% of the IRA portfolio in cash now. 33% is in REITs, and the rest is in miscellaneous stocks. Looking to buy back on a pullback. Hopefully in September.

Amazingly the homebuilders and Home Depot are at 52 week high.

19   American in Japan   2012 Sep 6, 11:34am  

The market hit a multi-year high yesterday. My friend still feels happy days are coming soon (due to the lag effect to the general economy) as the gains have been spectacular the last 9 month. I am still not convinced...

20   Eman   2012 Sep 6, 2:43pm  

American in Japan says

The market hit a multi-year high yesterday. My friend still feels happy days are coming soon (due to the lag effect to the general economy) as the gains have been spectacular the last 9 month. I am still not convinced...

Convince or not, the trend is your friend. Don't fight it. At least not until the market breaks its uptrend.

21   Eman   2012 Sep 11, 2:33am  

robertoaribas says

the stock market has predicted 12 of the last 5 economic upswings, and 11 of the last 4 recessions...

So you mean it's wrong more than half of the time? LOL! I'm still sitting on 42% cash in my IRA since we hit the double top. Patiently waiting to buy back.

22   FortWayne   2012 Sep 11, 3:02am  

Cash is king, and will be with reduced government spending. And if Obama gets reelected, with more constant fights between parties cash will be even a bigger deal over next 4 years.

The price of politics.

23   American in Japan   2012 Oct 5, 9:46pm  

>Amazon can't sell shit outside the USA and no one in China, Mexico, Japan or Brazil wants a kindle.

Mainly true, but not completely. There are some sales of Amazon in Japan.

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions