forgot password?   register

#housing #investing #politics more»
736,127 comments in 75,731 posts by 10,908 registered users, 11 online now: curious2, Dan8267, joeyjojojunior, marcus, P N Dr Lo R, Quigley, Strategist, Tenpoundbass, Tim Aurora, YesYNot, Zee

new post

Benjamin Franklin and Glass-Steagall

By Patrick   2012 Nov 8, 12:47am   796 views   5 comments   watch (0)   quote




Nature and Necessity



THERE is no Science, the Study of which is more useful and commendable than the Knowledge of the true Interest of one’s Country; and perhaps there is no Kind of Learning more abstruse and intricate, more difficult to acquire in any Degree of Perfection than This, and therefore none more generally neglected. Hence it is, that we every Day find Men in Conversation contending warmly on some Point in Politicks, which, altho’ it may nearly concern them both, neither of them understand any more than they do each other.

Thus much by way of Apology for this present Enquiry into the Nature and Necessity of a Paper Currency. And if any Thing I shall say, may be a Means of fixing a Subject that is now the chief Concern of my Countrymen, in a clearer Light, I shall have the Satisfaction of thinking my Time and Pains well employed.

Pennsylvania assembly. When the assembly assented, Franklin wrote in his Autobiography, "My friends there, who consider I had been of some service, thought fit to reward me by employing me in printing the money; a very profitable job, and a great help to me." There are many interesting aspects to Franklin's monetary theory.

Comments 1-5 of 5     Last »

1   Patrick   1812/1812 = 100% civil   2012 Nov 8, 1:05am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

I think old Ben contradicts himself by first claiming the virtues of inflating the currency, and later pointing out that all real value is derived from labor, and that as the quantity of silver increased, its value in purchasing labor decreased.

2   curious2   553/553 = 100% civil   2012 Nov 8, 4:38pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

I love Ben Franklin, and the wonderful phrasing of the 18th century. For example, "contending warmly" sounds much more pleasant than "arguing heatedly." Though, human nature being ever constant, the two phrases probably describe the same scene.

3   Elwood P Dowd     2012 Nov 8, 9:02pm  ↑ like (1)   ↓ dislike   quote    

I think part of the reason Franklin adopted the position he did is that when he first arrived in Philadelphia there was such a shortage of currency that it was strangling legitimate exchanges and trades. People were being forced to resort to barter in some cases, simply because there was no currency to be found This must have raised transaction costs, if nothing else.

But the rest of his reasoning I'm not following. He seems to presume a stable or perhaps slowly increasing value to land, when I think you can find cases in Franklin's own life where the value of land effectively fell to zero in certain places. As with the stereotype of the farmer emptying his house, closing the front door and hopping in his wagon going westward. Granted Franklin missed the craze for migration to Texas, I think in the 1820s, when people simply hammered a sign "G.T.T." for "Gone to Texas" on their door and just up and left. And these were working farms in places like Tennessee, on arable land, that produced a living if not exactly riches. But were still not deemed even worth attempting to sell. Can't see a land backed currency working under those circumstances.

'Course I can't see how today's Funny Money, excuse me, Quantitative Easing Parts I, II, III, and IV, with doubtless more sequels on the horizon, works either. (Must be quite a box office smash? Not having seen any of them at my local megaplex, I can only hope this is the one movie series out there where who I take to be the main actors all keep their clothes ON. The alternative is too frightening to contemplate.)

Also, I must admit I had a chuckle when I got to the bottom of the link and saw that Franklin had written this under a pen name, "B.B." Whose initials might THOSE be?

4   Elwood P Dowd     2012 Nov 8, 9:48pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Oh, duh. As interesting a read as I found that piece I'm not connecting the dots between it and Glass-Steagall. Was Franklin advocating that this currency be issued by private citizens or private banks, something like that? I'm afraid with his slightly archaic language and sentences of 600 words plus, I didn't suss that part out. But I did kind of presume they'd come out of government at some level, given the bit in the opening paragraph about him being given the (apparently) plum job of printing Pennsylvania's currency.

5   Dan8267   2544/2576 = 98% civil   2012 Nov 8, 11:59pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

all real value is derived from labor

Value is always derived from the talents and efforts of man building things, not the atoms from which things are built. Atoms are cheap. There are 10^78 of them in the observable universe. Talent and innovation are not cheap. Good ideas with excellent implementation are far more rare than gold.

Comments 1-5 of 5     Last »

users   about   suggestions   contact  
topics   random post   best comments   comment jail  
patrick's 40 proposals  
10 reasons it's a terrible time to buy  
8 groups who lie about the housing market  
37 bogus arguments about housing  
get a free bumper sticker:

top   bottom   home