patrick.net

 
  forgot password?   register

#housing #investing #politics more»
736,918 comments in 75,805 posts by 10,911 registered users, 3 online now: joeyjojojunior, lostand confused, Patrick

new post

Do I have to pay federal income tax?

By Scagnetti   2012 Nov 15, 4:06pm   4,001 views   20 comments   watch (1)   quote      

Wow. This video was really cool. Check it out. It is almost 2 hours long, but it's good stuff.

The part that interests me the most is about the income tax. Apparently it's voluntary? The supreme court has ruled that a persons wages (fruit of their labor) is not taxable? The IRS is a bunch of thugs who rule on intimidation instead of the law? Anyone know more about this?

Comments 1-20 of 20     Last »

1   Tenpoundbass   994/996 = 99% civil   2012 Nov 15, 11:27pm  ↑ like (2)   ↓ dislike   quote    

No but you do have to file.

edited to add, "accurately" file.

People don't go to jail for paying taxes, they go to jail for tax evasion.
If you don't file or don't file accurately, then that is how they get you.

2   lostand confused   225/225 = 100% civil   2012 Nov 15, 11:44pm  ↑ like (1)   ↓ dislike   quote    

I guess Lauryn Hill must have seen the same video and Wesley Snipes?

3   leo707     2012 Nov 16, 1:36am  ↑ like (1)   ↓ dislike   quote    

lostand confused says

I guess Lauryn Hill must have seen the same video and Wesley Snipes?

Makes one wonder why they did not use the video as evidence when they went to court, because I am sure it would have proven them innocent...

Anyway, to the OP question: Yes, you have to pay federal taxes; it is not optional.

4   upisdown     2012 Nov 16, 2:20am  ↑ like (2)   ↓ dislike   quote    

Maybe somebody could email an expert, to Peter Schiff, and ask him. Don't forget to also ask him where he sends his father's day cards to.

5   leo707     2012 Nov 16, 2:48am  ↑ like (1)   ↓ dislike   quote    

upisdown says

Maybe somebody could email an expert,

Actually, Wesley Snipes is probably now a expert on whether or not Federal Income Taxes are voluntary.

6   upisdown     2012 Nov 16, 3:16am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

LOL, the Wesley Snipes defense. He can't be guilty because he's stupid. And innocent. Or both. Or was he framed by a tax system put in place long before he was born?

He should be in prison(is he still?)for listening to stupid advice from a stupid person. But, the criminal code doesn't directly cover stupidity, just acts done because of it.

7   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 16, 3:33am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Scagnetti invited Mystery X to fact-check this discussion.

Invite another expert to fact-check this discussion.

8   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 16, 3:56am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

upisdown says

Maybe somebody could email an expert, to Peter Schiff, and ask him. Don't forget to also ask him where he sends his father's day cards to.

Good idea....thanks!

9   upisdown     2012 Nov 16, 4:05am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Now you've got me curious, but not enough to email him and have to read all of his doom and gloom-sky-is falling crap, while trying to sell me gold. And his books too. One thing to remember about Schiff, there's a reason why his first name is Peter.

10   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 16, 4:23am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

upisdown says

Now you've got me curious, but not enough to email him and have to read all of his doom and gloom-sky-is falling crap, while trying to sell me gold. And his books too. One thing to remember about Schiff, there's a reason why his first name is Peter.

Actually I didn't email Peter Schiff, but the givemeliberty foundation. Robert Schulz in particular. They are the biggest proponents of the anti income tax movement (if you can call it that).

11   upisdown     2012 Nov 16, 4:57am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Makes you wonder how many of those so-called tax experts utilize the whistleblower statutes when tax dodgers come to them on how to evade/ not pay any taxes.

12   Dan8267   2638/2671 = 98% civil   2012 Nov 16, 7:19am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

I saw this movie. First of, when you file your 1020, line 43 is labeled "Taxable Income" and line 44 is labeled "Tax". And you have no choice but to state that your tax is such-n-such even if you are claiming you do not have to pay taxes.

And if you fill out a tax form the federal government can and will confiscate your property and add fines and penalties for not paying by the due date. Try getting those fines and penalties removed or getting your property back.

The bottom line is yes, it is illegal for the federal government to force you to pay income tax as they didn't go through due process. However, that doesn't matter. Since the government enforces the law based on its own self-interest rather than the law, the government can and will jail you for not paying taxes regardless of how illegal it is to do so. The laws on paper and the laws in practice are not necessarily the same.

Short of violent revolution, there is no way to prevent our government from violating these laws. The few people who managed to convince a jury, rightfully so, that the income tax is not compulsory simply got lucky that they had a jury with brains. Most people will not have such a jury.

Since the government has grown so dependent on the income tax -- a huge mistake itself -- it should at least have the integrity to lawfully pass the income tax so that it's not breaking the law going forward. However, all politician are pussies and won't dream of putting this on the table.

Of course, we wouldn't need the income tax if we didn't have parasites at the top of the food chain, but those parasites pay little tax anyway. Funding for general government and services would be better done as appropriated taxes. Such taxes would avoid the Tragedy of the Commons in which tax money gets wasted.

13   elliemae     2012 Nov 17, 5:07am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

I had a friend who believed this line of shit. Followed some guy who stated that taxes were illegal, they didn't pass the law or something, had a system.

He ended up paying a hefty fine and his guru was nowhere to be found...

14   Christopher     2012 Nov 17, 5:37am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

You can find a preparer that will run your numbers free if you need to file and charge you only if you file.

15   elliemae     2012 Nov 17, 7:55am  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Christopher says

You can find a preparer that will run your numbers free if you need to file and charge you only if you file.

Yes, and you get what you pay for IMHO. Like H&R Block, that hires a shitload of people in the tax season and trains them to use a computer program that you can either get free or for substantially less than you'd pay if you went into their office.

You get what you pay for there, too.

16   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 18, 12:08pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

I found a great quote for this thread....

"Take, for example, the institution of taxation, which statists have claimed is in some sense really "voluntary". Anyone who truly believes in the "voluntary" nature of taxation is invited to refuse to pay taxes and to see what then happens to him. If we analyze taxation, we find that, among all the persons and institutions in society, only the government acquires its revenues through coercive violence. Everyone else in society acquires income either through voluntary gift (lodge, charitable society, chess club) or through the sale of goods or services voluntarily purchased by consumers. If anyone but the government proceeded to "tax", this would clearly be considered coercion and thinly disguised banditry. Yet the mystical trappings of "sovereignty" have so veiled the process that only libertarians are prepared to call taxation what it is" legalized and organized theft on a grand scale."

(Rothbard, For a New Liberty, pg. 30)

17   Bellingham Bill   74/74 = 100% civil   2012 Nov 18, 12:42pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Rothbard was a dishonest clown.

Fitting joker for the joke that is libertarianism, though.

18   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 18, 1:06pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Bellingham Bill says

Rothbard was a dishonest clown.

Fitting joker for the joke that is libertarianism, though.

You're pretty hostile! Ad hominem much?

What is wrong with his logic?

19   Bellingham Bill   74/74 = 100% civil   2012 Nov 18, 2:37pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Rothbard says

Everyone else in society acquires income either through voluntary gift (lodge, charitable society, chess club) or through the sale of goods or services voluntarily purchased by consumers

All entitled ownership of natural resources -- ie. land -- have a dodgy chain of title.

This is Rothbard's central lie and the central flaw of (right-) libertarianism. And it's intentional.

http://fraggle.wordpress.com/rothbard-v-georgism/

There's a larger point here that government is just a formalized, structural way to eliminate violence in day-to-day life. We come to government because the alternative sucks more.

20   Scagnetti     2012 Nov 18, 4:12pm  ↑ like   ↓ dislike   quote    

Soooooo....you don't think I have a right to the fruits of my labor? I thought that was one of the main tenants of "Single Taxers"?

Were talking about income tax.....remember?

By the way, thanks for the link, half way through it now.

Comments 1-20 of 20     Last »

users   about   suggestions   contact  
topics   random post   best comments   comment jail  
patrick's 40 proposals  
10 reasons it's a terrible time to buy  
8 groups who lie about the housing market  
37 bogus arguments about housing  
get a free bumper sticker:

top   bottom   home