0
0

Does inflation matter for RE prices in the BA?


 invite response                
2005 Oct 17, 10:06am   19,388 views  130 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

Inflation coverage in the financial press is growing daily. The headline (total) official inflation numbers for the US are the highest in 30 years, but the core inflation numbers (which excludes energy and food), is barely noticable. The stock market has been reacting to inflation data, selling off globally (despite the laughable dow 40000 stories). Precious metals are hitting records. But the bond market is slow to react, only now inching into bearish territory. There are arguments that inflation helps RE (real estate is a good store of value during general inflation); there are arguments that it hurts RE (reduced purchasing power and rising debt burdens depress affordability). I’d like to hear everyone’s take.

By Randy H

#housing

« First        Comments 59 - 98 of 130       Last »     Search these comments

59   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 3:22am  

Jamie, just throw a bag of doritos at him as he's likely just put the bond down and will need them.

60   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 3:22am  

dang, not "bond", BONG!

61   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 3:23am  

Maybe Peter P is actually the Easter Bunny.

No, I am the were-rabbit.

62   Jamie   2005 Oct 18, 3:26am  

"Jamie, just throw a bag of doritos at him"

I believe in Marin County, when they get the post-bong munchies, they eat all-natural gourmet baked garlic and parmesan soy chips.

63   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 3:26am  

American homeowners are going to be slapped with bigger monthly payments just when they’re already drowning in debt and lining up at the bankruptcy courts by the thousands.

Fuck em.

64   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 3:53am  

I have a question regarding “core inflation” what is in the “consumer basket”?

You can use FRED, at the St. Louis Fed Reserve to research this. It is complex, and the basket is huge.

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/categories/9

Something to remember about CPI, it is a fixed basket of goods, those only bought by consumers. It tends to overstate inflation, currently by about 1%. The GDP deflator is a variable index, which covers all goods purchased, and it tends to understate inflation. CPI and GDP deflator have been within 2% of one another except during the late 70s, when CPI was probably overstating inflation quite a bit. Fixed baskets overstate because (1) they don't account for consumer substitution, (2) they don't account for new goods introduced--like iPods, (3) they don't measure changes in quality--like price increases due to product upgrades such as in cars.

65   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 4:31am  

The Tax Panel is goint to make some recommendations...

http://tinyurl.com/9wlnc

I have a feeling that it may go through this time because many US voters can benefit from the changes.

For those who are considering a home purchase, please assume that no deduction is possible in your calculations.

The mere talk of these changes may cool/crash the California market, unless Bush shoots it down quick enough.

66   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 4:32am  

Indicators of market distress are still largely absent. Foreclosure rates are low, down payment sizes are stable and there have been no significant shifts in market mix, DataQuick reported.

DQ likes to copy and paste this.

67   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 4:34am  

And I like to copy and paste this,

Newly Abundant liquidity can readily disappear - Alan Greenspan

68   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 4:36am  

Soon enough...

Newly abundant liquity is largely absent. Buying interest is low, prices are unstable and there have been huge shifts in market psychology.

69   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 4:42am  

Newly abundant liquity is largely absent. Buying interest is low, prices are unstable and there have been huge shifts in market psychology.

Well that should be fine, everyone in the BA has a secure job at a start-up software company and earns 150K +, and the peons that lick their toliets have secure manufacturing day jobs, plus the robust economy will weather the storm.

ahahahahhahahahahahahhahahahahaha oh my god thats funny ahahahahahhaahahahahahahahhah

70   Jamie   2005 Oct 18, 5:09am  

"and the peons that lick their toliets have secure manufacturing day jobs"

And all the crappy low-paying, no-benefits service sector jobs are actually filled by GRUD's (Google Robotic Underling Drones). They look remarkably like people, but they're not. This is Google's latest venture -- creating robots to replace humans in all the jobs that Bay Area residents are too educated to do.

71   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 5:31am  

Just checked Uhauls site,

4-5 bedroom truck from SF to Phoenix $2170

4-5 bedroom truck from Phoenix to SF $199

Now that's really really odd, especially given the high salaries and positive intangibles of the BA. Oh, now I get it, the BA companies are subsidizing the moves, and Phoenix isn't. That must be it.

72   Jamie   2005 Oct 18, 5:37am  

"4-5 bedroom truck from SF to Phoenix $2170"

Uhaul knows that Bay Area residents will settle for nothing but the best (except in the case of housing, and choice of cities to flee to when they can no longer afford to live in the Golden Land), so these trucks departing SF are actually upscale luxury Uhauls with Mercedes engines, deluxe leather air-cooled seats (so the Arizona sun won't burn their precious asses), and built-in espresso machines.

73   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:37am  

Just checked Uhauls site,

4-5 bedroom truck from SF to Phoenix $2170

4-5 bedroom truck from Phoenix to SF $199

Now that’s really really odd, especially given the high salaries and positive intangibles of the BA. Oh, now I get it, the BA companies are subsidizing the moves, and Phoenix isn’t. That must be it

The price difference is big, and probably reflects some of the net outflow of people from the BA. However, very different prices like this are common in logistical network optimization pricing functions. The fact that the BA is so much bigger, and has more absolute demand, would account for a need to discount trucks inbound into the BA. The same thing is true in rental cars, airline pricing and schedules, or any other system that needs to move around assets.

74   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 5:38am  

Uhaul knows that Bay Area residents will settle for nothing but the best (except in the case of housing, and choice of cities to flee to when they can no longer afford to live in the Golden Land), so these trucks departing SF are actually upscale luxury Uhauls with Mercedes engines, deluxe leather air-cooled seats (so the Arizona sun won’t burn their precious asses), and built-in espresso machines.

And gold-threaded tires for Bay Area's gold-paved roads.

75   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:43am  

H.Z.

I agree with your read on GDP deflator data. The problem with CPI is the inverse, however, vis-a-vis substitution effects. CPI tends to (sometimes dramatically) overstate inflation during certain supply shocks. This is some of the reasoning behind removing food and energy. Although energy demand is inelastic, a lot of substitution between energy types occurs fairly quickly in response to price changes. These numbers force up CPI but have less of a real impact on the aggregate national income.

Whether we like CPI or not (and I don't) is a bit moot because so many contracts and entitlements are tied to CPI; so it affects us nonetheless.

76   KurtS   2005 Oct 18, 5:44am  

The fact that the BA is so much bigger, and has more absolute demand, would account for a need to discount trucks inbound into the BA.

Or--I bet there's so many trucks heading out of CA they need to pay overhead for shipping available ones in? Still, that price difference is outrageous!

77   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:45am  

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm, now why would that be?

Not to be devil's advocate, but even if the emmigration rates were exactly identical, there would be more accumulation of trucks in smaller cities than larger ones, simply because of the math.

78   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 5:46am  

and has more absolute demand, would account for a need to discount trucks inbound into the BA

Huh? Kind of an inverse supply/demand theory?

79   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:49am  

Huh? Kind of an inverse supply/demand theory?

Logistical optimization of asset placement trumps supply-demand. You can't supply-the-demand if you don't have a truck there. So long as the revenue less cost of the discount is above marginal costs, you can discount to try to get something (0 is better then

80   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 5:50am  

Logistical optimization of asset placement

I wouldn't want to say that five times fast ;)

81   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:51am  

(0 is better than

82   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:52am  

[one more time] (0 is better than

83   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 5:53am  

{time to work anyway}

84   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 5:54am  

To be fair, Phoenix also gets a lot of immigration from other places. It would be more telling if we get the same data from other city-pairs like NY/SF and LA/SF.

85   KurtS   2005 Oct 18, 5:54am  

Bay Area residents will settle for nothing but the best (except in the case of housing, and choice of cities to flee to when they can no longer afford to live in the Golden Land), so these trucks departing SF are actually upscale luxury Uhauls with Mercedes engines, deluxe leather air-cooled seats

There's a new business model realtors can move into...showrooms of moving vans, "staged" to suit individual tastes...modern, tradtional, or sporty--there's a van for every lifestyle. Rates begin at $5/mile, financing available.
"Flee the Bay Area in style: you're moving up--not moving out!â„¢"

86   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 5:59am  

NYC - BA, BA - NYC roughly the same cost

BA - DALLAS $3699
Dallas - BA $860

87   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 6:01am  

c'mon surfer-x. i know you've had linear algebra somewhere in your schoolin'. You know that mathematically these systems of equations often yield non-intuitive results.

88   KurtS   2005 Oct 18, 6:03am  

Here's some local stats on population changes.
http://tinyurl.com/9vqgf

Judging by Surfer-X's findings, I'd guess the exodus has picked up recently.

89   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:03am  

these systems of equations often yield non-intuitive results

Randy for Fed Chief, Randy for Fed Chief! Let the nomination process begin!

90   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 6:07am  

Randy for Fed Chief, Randy for Fed Chief! Let the nomination process begin!

Ok, I deserved that.

So the problem with looking at u-haul data is this: trucks don't frickin only go back and forth between 2 cities! a truck can go from the BA, to Phoenix, to Dallas, to NYC, then to Buttcrack Indiania. There are so many variables that when they put this crap in their big, expensive computers, they get wierd "proper pricing" out the other end. The pricing may have everything to do with demand, or nothing to do with demand. Some cities are just natural nexus points, and lots of trucks move through them.

91   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:09am  

equity refugees from California

My new favorite saying.

92   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:09am  

Randy H. again Sir your knowledge of these types of matters is astounding!

93   Peter P   2005 Oct 18, 6:15am  

Randy H. again Sir your knowledge of these types of matters is astounding!

Sir? Randy H, KBE?

94   Randy H   2005 Oct 18, 6:22am  

allah,

my point is you cannot prove or disprove anything with rental quotes. the prices may be because of what you say, or may be because the city is accumulating trucks (or short of trucks) because it is just unlucky in the grand scheme of u-haul's system. demand is not the only thing driving prices of trucks; there is a logistical force at work too. when u-haul optimizes pricing, they can purposefully take negative revenues on some runs because it increases revenues by more than that in others.

95   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:28am  

Parsed the pop data and here's what is says:

47 cities together lost 1.8% of their pop

and

47 cities gained population, 2.1% rise.

Kind of a push in my book. So much for the "exploding" population element to BA RE prices.

96   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:30am  

Wayne, take if from me, tell them that it gets to -20 below in the winter, for 6 months, that the re-introduction of the grizzly bear and wolf packs and adversely effected prop. values, and that you just plain can't get good brie there.

97   surfer-x   2005 Oct 18, 6:33am  

Wayne, nooooooooooooooooooooo

98   Jamie   2005 Oct 18, 6:48am  

"So the winters have lots of bright sunny days, but nights are pretty cold. I was able to run or hike very comfortably last winter,"

Hey, sounds just like the So Cal high desert...well, except here we have all the sex offenders, west coast rednecks, and other assorted derelicts.

« First        Comments 59 - 98 of 130       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions