1
0

Detroit Chapter 9 Bankrucpty


               
2013 Dec 8, 10:41pm   19,659 views  110 comments

by spydah_hh   follow (1)  

Not sure if this was already posted, I did a search in the forums and nothing came up. But hey like I've stated before, it was only a matter of time before pensions were cut. I wouldn't be surprised if other cities follow suit.

A federal judge declared Tuesday that Detroit is eligible for bankruptcy protection, giving a green light to the nation's largest municipal bankruptcy filing in history.

The contentious dispute pits the city's finance officials against its unions, creditors and retirees, ahead of what are expected to be steep cuts in pensions, as well as fire sales of treasured assets.

"The city no longer has the resources to provide its residents with basic police, fire and emergency services that its residents need," Judge Steven Rhodes said in a ruling that was over 140 pages long.

Carlos Osorio | AP
Detroit city workers and supporters protest outside the federal courthouse in Detroit while awaiting the bankruptcy decision, Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2013.
In the meantime, Detroit's emergency financial manager, Kevyn Orr, is expected to proceed toward the city's next major step: submitting a plan to restructure Detroit's approximately $18 billion in debt.

(Read more: Illinois to vote on pension proposal)
Immediately after the ruling, Detroit's largest public workers union, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, said it will appeal.

"We're very disappointed. It's a very sad day for the people of Detroit and we've already filed a notice of appeal," AFSCME attorney Sharon Levine told CNBC. "We think that if there had been more time and actual good faith in negotiations, that there could have been potentially a solution that could have avoided this bankruptcy case and been less scary and devastating for the citizens of Detroit."

The judge's decision listed the city's long litany of financial woes, including the loss of manufacturing jobs and population in recent decades.

"As of April 2013, about 48 percent of the city's street lights were not working," Rhodes said. "In 2012 the average police response time was 30 minutes. In 2013, 58 minutes, and the national average is 11 minutes."
There were a number of quirks in the judge's ruling. Among other things, Rhodes said that the city did not negotiate in "good faith" with the unions to whom Detroit owes money—normally a prerequisite for allowing bankruptcy.

At the same time, he noted the obstinacy of the unions in the negotiations saying that the city could not realistically negotiate with a "stone wall.

http://www.cnbc.com/id/101242616

Comments 1 - 15 of 110       Last »     Search these comments

1   HEY YOU   @   2013 Dec 10, 1:52am  

What will happen to your pensions Red State Rep/Con/Teas?
You know the Right is against entitlements? Red State city govt. is a great place to start eliminating these Socialist Programs.

2   spydah_hh   @   2013 Dec 10, 8:42am  

HEY YOU says

What will happen to your pensions Red State Rep/Con/Teas?

You know the Right is against entitlements? Red State city govt. is a great place to start eliminating these Socialist Programs.

It won't just be the red states who will eventually eliminate these programs. I am sure at some point all states will because they're just to costly.

3   thomaswong.1986   @   2013 Dec 10, 9:51am  

HEY YOU says

You know the Right is against entitlements?

you put in 100 in taxes and get out 300 somehow...

if not a ponzi scheme sounds broken to me.

where did the 200 come from ?

Reminds me of the CA govt working getting something like $400K upfront
and over 100K in pension. Heck my vacation pay is capped at max like
everyone else in private industry... use it or lose it...
yet these govt workers dont cap their vacation accrual... and ring it up
based on final wage/salary rates.

4   spydah_hh   @   2013 Dec 10, 10:38am  

thomaswong.1986 says

HEY YOU says

You know the Right is against entitlements?

you put in 100 in taxes and get out 300 somehow...

if not a ponzi scheme sounds broken to me.

where did the 200 come from ?

Reminds me of the CA govt working getting something like $400K upfront

and over 100K in pension. Heck my vacation pay is capped at max like

everyone else in private industry... use it or lose it...

yet these govt workers dont cap their vacation accrual... and ring it up

based on final wage/salary rates.

Yep. Some people who work for CA would get an entire years or more worth of income just from accumulating vacation leave and retiring. It's ridiculous.

5   AverageBear   @   2013 Dec 12, 1:35am  

Stockton, Detroit... Chicago is next! You think the brew-haha in Wisconsin was a big deal? It will look like a Book Club Meeting if Chicago doesn't address its fiscal irresponsibility. Start wearing the body armor, Rham!

6   upisdown   @   2013 Dec 12, 2:04am  

AverageBear says

Stockton, Detroit... Chicago is next! You think the brew-haha in Wisconsin
was a big deal? It will look like a Book Club Meeting if Chicago doesn't address
its fiscal irresponsibility. Start wearing the body armor, Rham!

The lyin' sack-o chimes in with more of his BS. Does Illinois allow municipal bankruptcy?

7   HEY YOU   @   2013 Dec 12, 2:38am  

spydah_hh says

HEY YOU says

What will happen to your pensions Red State Rep/Con/Teas?

You know the Right is against entitlements? Red State city govt. is a great place to start eliminating these Socialist Programs.

It won't just be the red states who will eventually eliminate these programs. I am sure at some point all states will because they're just to costly.

I agree.
I can see pension collapse in all states. Detroit might be the precedent. I'm just waiting to see how happy Red State retirees will be with cuts in "Big Govt." pensions since we hear all the talk about smaller govt.

Rep/Con/Teas are such easy targets.
BTW,I didn't vote Democratic.

8   upisdown   @   2013 Dec 12, 2:48am  

HEY YOU says

I can see pension collapse in all states.

But, was it pension debt that led to Detroit's BK?

Look at this:

http://www.governing.com/gov-data/municipal-cities-counties-bankruptcies-and-defaults.html

Bankrupt Cities, Municipalities List and Map
729 2.8k 34 22
Share on email Many local governments across the U.S. face steep budget deficits as they struggle to pay off debts accumulated over a number of years. As a last resort, some filed for bankruptcy.

9   FortWayne   @   2013 Dec 12, 3:12am  

If they don't have the money what are they to do? They can't pay people with IOY's.

Either way this is a result of years of theft and mismanagement. Unions got what they had coming to them.

10   spydah_hh   @   2013 Dec 12, 3:57am  

upisdown says

But, was it pension debt that led to Detroit's BK?

Yes, it was. Detroit has about 18 billion in debt and about $9 billion of that comes from retiree pension and health care obligations.

No way the city will be able to recovery without attacking both pension benefits.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/07/19/detroits-pension-problems-in-one-chart/

11   upisdown   @   2013 Dec 12, 4:24am  

spydah_hh says

Yes, it was.

Spider/bear, whatever. But seriously, a blog?

Well, the governor of Michigan says you're full of crap.

"Now's our opportunity to stop 60 years of decline," Snyder said at a Friday news conference with Orr. "How long had this been going on and people were kicking the can down the road and not doing something? We're doing something."

Snyder has said that 38% of the city's budget is being spent on "legacy costs," such as pensions and debt service.

http://money.cnn.com/2013/07/18/news/economy/detroit-bankruptcy/index.html

12   upisdown   @   2013 Dec 12, 4:25am  

FortWayne says

Either way this is a result of years of theft and mismanagement. Unions got
what they had coming to them.

You're advocating that employers steal from their employees?

You MUST be a right winger.

13   spydah_hh   @   2013 Dec 12, 5:17am  

upisdown says

spydah_hh says

Yes, it was.

Spider/bear, whatever. But seriously, a blog?

Well, the governor of Michigan says you're full of crap.

"Now's our opportunity to stop 60 years of decline," Snyder said at a Friday news conference with Orr. "How long had this been going on and people were kicking the can down the road and not doing something? We're doing something."

Snyder has said that 38% of the city's budget is being spent on "legacy costs," such as pensions and debt service.

http://money.cnn.com/2013/07/18/news/economy/detroit-bankruptcy/index.html

Right that is correct 38% is spend on pensions. But what's not counted in that 38% is the health care costs associated as well. When you combine both of them (you can even check Detroits balance sheet). The costs goes over 50%.

But even then, 38% is still a big chunk of your finances that goes towards people who don't even work for the city.

Sorry to say it's not a sustainable cost.

14   spydah_hh   @   2013 Dec 12, 5:19am  

upisdown says

FortWayne says

Either way this is a result of years of theft and mismanagement. Unions got

what they had coming to them.

You're advocating that employers steal from their employees?

You MUST be a right winger.

Honestly, I am advocating that Unions steal from employers. Which is why most private sector jobs around the world got rid of them.

And a big reason why public sector jobs (Cities, States, and etc) who still hold onto to unions demands are tanking.

15   upisdown   @   2013 Dec 12, 7:34am  

spydah_hh says

Right that is correct 38% is spend on pensions.

Can you read?

Snyder has said that 38% of the city's budget is being spent on "legacy costs," such as pensions and debt service.

FFS, your own post said that it was half ($9Billion of the $18 Billion), and then you claim it was all the debt, just how stupid are you?

spydah_hh says

And a big reason why public sector jobs (Cities, States, and etc) who still hold
onto to unions demands are tanking

Maybe you should learn a few things like:

Deferred compensation
An amount that has been earned but is not actually paid until a later date, typically through a payment plan, pension, or stock option plan.
http://financial-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Deferred+Compensation

And;

Definition of 'Deferred Compensation'

An amount of earned income that is payable at a later date. Most deferred-compensation plans allow the wage earner to defer tax now so that the funds can be withdrawn and taxed at some point in the future.
Investopedia explains 'Deferred Compensation'

The most common form of deferred compensation is a retirement plan. Deferring income allows the earner to use the income later in life when they have a lower tax rate. Other examples include pension plans and stock-option plans.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deferred-compensation.asp

Not to mention WHY there are constitutional protections against whacking away at public employees' pensions, because of the ability of right wingers to skip payments and underfund public pensions. Michigan has a section of their constitution to specifically address public pensions, as do many other states.

FYI, if you bothered to read the link above that I gave, it would show you why the majority of municipal bankruptcies are for failed public projects, and not for pensions(although the common theme for piss-poor public fund (mis)management coincides with underfunded pension funds).

Comments 1 - 15 of 110       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste