patrick.net

Winnnie says

Research also what some Jewish historians who ran DNA tests on Palestinians and Israelis concluded

I already explained this, but people don't seem to list. The modern proposed state of Palestine isn't a continuation of a people, a tribe, or a nation-state any more than modern Israel is, or any more than the modern Olympics are a continuation of the ancient Greek Olympics.

Furthermore, even if it were, that would not justify a Palestinian state. After all, every American can trace his or her ancestry to Africa. Does that mean America has the right to annex its ancestral land in Africa?

Every person, except Africans can literally trace their ancestry to the Middle East as well as the Middle East was the first place humans migrated to when they left Africa. This is called the Southern Route Hypothesis and has been unequivocally confirmed with archeological, genetic, and linguistic evidence. So Russia could just as legitimately claim the land Israel and Jordon are on because its THEIR ancestral stomping grounds as well.

Furthermore, the next place our ancestors migrated to was India. So England could legitimately claim that recolonizing India is their birthright since its their ancestral land.

Are you willing to accept all those claims?

Furthermore, it is stupid to suggest that the right to form a Palestinian state is contingent upon some ancestral claim. If people wish to form their own government and nation-state, they should be allowed to do so, regardless of tribal land claims. So the very motivation to state that the Palestinians have a greater "birthright" claim to the land is both unnecessary and counter-productive. It's not a convincing argument to anyone who is objective, and you can't get more objective than an atheist who thinks both sides are acting like children.

But hey, if you think you are more objective than me, then list three atrocities committed by each side. If you can't do this for BOTH sides, including the one you like, then you are completely irrational. Please prove to me that you are rational.

curious2 says

I do agree that Palestinians want the land for reasons that have nothing to do with Jews, so it was inaccurate and hyperbole to say that the only reason was because Jews are occupying it.

And that's my only beef with Dan8267 -- he is taking an extreme Zionist position solely on this particular issue.

curious2 says

On the other hand, Golda Meir was generally considered left wing, not right wing; she taught schoolchildren in America and then moved to British colonial Palestine where she met with Palestinians and began advocating socialism, then she helped form the Israeli Labor party.

Golda Meir isn't simple on the political spectrum. Yes, left-wing economically, right-wing with respect to Palestine.

Dan8267 says

If you want to convince me that you are right, you need to present a rational, evidence-based argument.

I'm not wasting my time with your BS -- you have no facts on your side and are basically descending into 49th Parallel-level stuff here with the "I know you are, but what am I?" non-sense.

Dan8267 says

You have to prove to me that you can acknowledge the crimes committed by YOUR side.

Again, it's not my side. I have no stake in this. No idea why you're obsessed with saying I'm on a particular side because you made two stupid statements that no reasonable person would make. I've objected to nothing else but those two moronic statements -- again, quoted above in all their lack of glory

I've already stated numerous times that both states are in the wrong -- I don't need to state it again because you are going around making stupid Zionist claims.

Winnnie says

Dan8267, you are either trying to rewrite history or you are genuinely ignorant. Go to any library and research the history of Palestine and who lived there prior to the creation of the state of Israel.

Agreed.

Dan8267 says

Furthermore, it is stupid to suggest that the right to form a Palestinian state is contingent upon some ancestral claim.

Are you borderline retarded? Where is it based on an ancestral claim and who is making that argument? It's based on the fact that they lived there before they were forcefully evicted. Regardless of what ethnicity you believe Palestinians are and whether they have an identifiable culture or not, do you deny that they lived there before? Yes or no?

The Right of Return is solely based on having lived there before and being evicted by Israel.

The Israeli claim is based solely on birthright, as far as I can tell -- at least for people who aren't Palestinian Jews (i.e. the ones who lived there prior to partition), and it's particularly true for settlers. Where do you get this crap?

GARY: SHUT UP

Gary,
You have a serious chemical imbalance that makes you paranoid. Your chemical imbalance causes you to believe in "Zionists" which is really a not very well disguised way to talk about Jews. You are not the first and you will not be the last anti-semite but your paranoia will eventually destroy you and ruin your life.

bgamall4 says

The Original Bankster says

GARY: SHUT UP

Shut up yourself. You are a Zionist racist pig too.

Portal says

Gary,

You have a serious chemical imbalance that makes you paranoid. Your chemical imbalance causes you to believe in "Zionists" which is really a not very well disguised way to talk about Jews. You are not the first and you will not be the last anti-semite but your paranoia will eventually destroy you and ruin your life.

bgamall4 says

The Original Bankster says

GARY: SHUT UP

Shut up yourself. You are a Zionist racist pig too.

my guess is his life is already destroyed, he's just a lonely old loser who bought a cheap house in vegas, he has no friends, so he just sits and rants on the internet all day. Hating Jews is popular with this sort of person.

do you see ANY responsible media outlet reflecting this nutbag viewpoints on this military action? NOPE, none of them are that stupid. It's an effect of the internet, if you see some ideas that have no reference in reputable media outlets, best stay away- it's propaganda, and my spreading it you make yourself liable.

jazz music says

Your a shit-flinger, and I already have 5 of you assholes on ignore.

why not just put entire STATES on ignore? is it possible to block the entire internet that's not in California?

jazz music says

He has well thought out views

Oh God!

jazz music says

I already have 5 of you assholes on ignore.

Am I one of the assholes?

Gary, do you have a life? you should get one. retirement sucks, getting old sucks, try to do something useful with whatever little time you have left.