patrick.net

stereotomy says

Right now it's HODLers and speculative banks.

.
.

News about this much of an inflow tells me Bitcoin has greater chance of being mainstream adopted and there is no progressive or cumulative exodus after a +22% drop from its recent all time high.

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/bitcoin-etf-investors-bought-dip-142303411.html

.

AD says

Its about adoption, which is about the Blackrock's and Fidelity's getting its retail investors to buy their Bitcoin ETFs.

No. It's about service fees on the accounts. You get 1 million bitcoiners and you buy it for them and charge monthly or annual service fees for holding bitcoin for you that you'll never be able to access. If it goes down, you lose the money not Blackrock or Fidelity.

Blackrock and Fidelity are looking at it like someone would a rental property. You buy bitcoin and rent it out to the public and collect rent. It's the same for gold and silver EFT's. You'll never physically hold what you bought in your home. That's why bitcoin is so stupid. I can hold a gold bar or silver coins. There have been multiple example of people losing millions from exchanges with bitcoin.

And that's on purpose to jack up the prices for the whales that run the game. Which it is a game. All stocks are this way. But you can walk into a Walmart. You can go to a Toyota dealership. You can see the real estate and the product. Bitcoin is literally nothing. Even those that invest in it have no clue what it is. So Blackrock and Fidelity buy some for you and you pay them rent. If it goes up you win, they still get the rent. If it goes down you lose and they still get rent.

WookieMan says

AD says

Its about adoption, which is about the Blackrock's and Fidelity's getting its retail investors to buy their Bitcoin ETFs.

No. It's about service fees on the accounts. You get 1 million bitcoiners and you buy it for them and charge monthly or annual service fees for holding bitcoin for you that you'll never be able to access. If it goes down, you lose the money not Blackrock or Fidelity.

I was saying its about adoption by the masses of retail investors, and that a Blackrock makes it easier for them to invest in Bitcoin through their ETF just like its easier to invest in gold and silver through ETFs then to actually hold the gold and silver such as in a home safe, bank safety deposit box; as well as the ETF has more liquidity as I would have to find a physical buyer for the silver coins and conduct the transaction in person.

I was saying that if the floor does not closely come out from under Bitcoin and it recovers, then it has a better chance of attracting retail investors.

There was about a 27% drop from Bitcoin's all time high of around $73,000 in March to $53,000 recent low.

Its now $56,000.

It was $53,000 and $56,000 back in February 2021. So the gains for last 3.5 years have been wiped out.

And a 10% drop or correction in the S&P 500 to around 5000 which would mean the real gains since June 2021 would be 0%.

https://www.multpl.com/inflation-adjusted-s-p-500

,

AD says

I was saying its about adoption by the masses of retail investors, and that a Blackrock makes it easier for them to invest in Bitcoin through their ETF just like its easier to invest in gold and silver through ETFs then to actually hold the gold and silver such as in a home safe, bank safety deposit box; as well as the ETF has more liquidity as I would have to find a physical buyer for the silver coins and conduct the transaction in person.

I'd rather conduct physical trading in person and store myself. The problem with bitcoin is there's no physical value. It's technically worthless besides people being suckered into paying for it. EFT's just sucker more people into something that will ultimately collapse. Gold and silver are used in products that can be made and sold if you hold physical.

Hell if you go to home depot and buy 2k feet of 1/2" copper pipe you'd probably make more in 5 years. Sell it 5% under market and you'd still make out like a bandit unless we get deflation and in that case bitcoin would crater as it's tied to the dollar or other foreign currencies.

Bitcoin market movements are pointless to discuss. It's worthless at the end of the day. The dollar is at least backed by the biggest military, oil, minerals, farmland, infrastructure on the planet. Bitcoin is a spreadsheet.

AD says

Will it only take 2 Bitcoins when the next halving occurs around 2028 ?

Why not just pay cash?

Onvacation says

Why not just pay cash?

That question does not pertain to the discussion on this thread as far as Bitcoin storing value in dollars , no different than Wookie saying below that buying and holding 2000 feet of copper pipe as a long term asset like gold, silver and Bitcoin.

but yes, buy with cash the diesel or gasoline at the gas station pump for your vehicle

AD says

long term asset like gold, silver and Bitcoin.

but yes, buy with cash the diesel or gasoline at the gas station pump for your vehicle

Pay with credit. Get the kickbacks. Bitcoin is not even an asset. Is there real estate? No. Is there a product? No. Can you do anything with it? No. Is it regulated and you know who holds it? No.

Is there insider trading? Yes. Is it a spreadsheet? Yes. Do whales control the price? Yes. Have multiple trading platforms screwed over people for billions? Yes.

Better off going to Vegas over BTC. Or just put your money in funds that pay dividends and are likely to appreciate. Sit back and relax.

WookieMan says

Better off going to Vegas over BTC. Or just put your money in funds that pay dividends and are likely to appreciate. Sit back and relax.

I understand as the argument is there is "nothing backing" Bitcoin (BTC). Its a digital asset stored on a ledger or spreadsheet called the Blockchain.

But with the Blockrock's and Fidelity's in the BTC market by offering BTC exchange traded funds, its a more "adopted" asset by retail investors than it was before these ETFs were approved by Gary Gensler's SEC.

And who wants to go up against a Blackrock's Larry Fink to tell him he got it all wrong such as with BTC. Not me.

.

The SEC approved BTC ETF's probably because they can be used as a sink for hot money. The largest cap stonks are wildly overvalued, even against gross revenues, let alone net profits. BTC ETF's probably lance the boil somewhat, possibly limiting the fallout in the broader market once panic ensues.

stereotomy says

The SEC approved BTC ETF's probably because they can be used as a sink for hot money. The largest cap stonks are wildly overvalued, even against gross revenues, let alone net profits. BTC ETF's probably lance the boil somewhat, possibly limiting the fallout in the broader market once panic ensues.

That makes sense as far as rotating gains from a hot asset class or stock to a different asset or asset class.

I wonder if BTC has done similarly to silver going back to around 2011.

A lot of the silver bugs would be attracted to BTC based on their investing or speculative trading style.

From what I gather such as from The Mooch, keep about 4% in BTC, 7% in gold and silver, and 9% in oil and gas.

.

AD says

From what I gather such as from The Mooch, keep about 4% in BTC, 7% in gold and silver, and 9% in oil and gas.

What about yams and ammo?

Onvacation says

AD says

From what I gather such as from The Mooch, keep about 4% in BTC, 7% in gold and silver, and 9% in oil and gas.

What about yams and ammo?

What I proposed was a hedge as far as significant devaluation of the dollar. Of course its not about preparing for the collapse of society, as in The Road or Mad Max-style collapse.

But I appreciate your satire.

.

AD says

What I proposed was a hedge as far as significant devaluation of the dollar.

Bitcoin is valued in the dollar. It will follow the dollar. The fact it's not higher means it's a bad hedge. With inflation it should have been over $100k.

I can't explain this enough. There are under 100 people controlling bitcoin specifically. No regulation. You're getting into a trap if you invest in it. You will freak at some point and sell to the whales. This has been going on since the beginning of bitcoin. It was a plan. Really think why our government hasn't regulated it?

I'm dealing with this shit now with our government. In a prevailing wage state we have to get union bids from fucking Chicago. If the government isn't regulating bitcoin, they're running it. Throw out some Asian name as the creator of it. lol. Not saying you're a fool or can't make money on it, but I won't touch it.

To echo Wookie, the reason BTC is not suppressed while gold is actively suppressed is because central banks, with the exception of fucked up places like Nicaragua, stockpile gold, not BTC. The central banks already print value from nothing, so BTC makes no sense for them - besides being redundant, it costs more energy to mine BTC than run printing presses.

stereotomy says

BTC is not suppressed while gold is actively suppressed is because central banks, with the exception of fucked up places like Nicaragua, stockpile gold, not BTC.

Yes, also I think they don't want precious metals like silver to increase much in value (relative to inflation rate) because it is used in different applications like Pentagon weapon systems.

Yes a gold standard or where precious metals crowd out investment dollars is not desired by the central banks (and the companies that they buy shares of).

Yes, as far as the BRICS especially China are increasing their gold reserves.

.

WookieMan says

Bitcoin is valued in the dollar. It will follow the dollar. The fact it's not higher means it's a bad hedge. With inflation it should have been over $100k.

give BTC some time

.

There was all that noise about bitcoin halving last April which was supposed to make it skyrocket. Didn't happen.

RWSGFY says

There was all that noise about bitcoin halving last April which was supposed to make it skyrocket. Didn't happen.

Examine the BTC price chart. Notice it did not significantly increase within 12 months of the halving.

give BTC some time

.

WookieMan says

Bitcoin is valued in the dollar. It will follow the dollar. The fact it's not higher means it's a bad hedge. With inflation it should have been over $100k.

Get outta here!

"Bitcoin’s price has climbed a staggering 9,000,000% between 2010 and 2020, making it the top-performing asset of any class over the past decade."

"As of 2024, Bitcoin’s price has a change of 31.40% so far this year."

@AD I think maybe you're just posting in the wrong thread. This thread is for misinformation, like what Wookie posted. There are one, maybe two other threads for bitcorn information.

SoTex says

Get outta here!

"Bitcoin’s price has climbed a staggering 9,000,000% between 2010 and 2020, making it the top-performing asset of any class over the past decade."

No one ever gets my point. You can trade it and make money. It is worthless besides the trade. Cool, make some money on it. Could be $90k tomorrow or it could be $20k. There is ZERO intristic value. At some point it goes to $0. And that's not a hypothetical. And for that reason I'll never invest or get caught up in the scheme.

There are tons of companies that had the same rate of return over a similar time span, not the same years. They have assets though. Real estate. Products. Bitcoin is nothing. Literally nothing. You can't go buy up the miners in a liquidation sale. There's literally nothing besides the people that are willing to buy it. That's it.

AD says

RWSGFY says

There was all that noise about bitcoin halving last April which was supposed to make it skyrocket. Didn't happen.

Examine the BTC price chart. Notice it did not significantly increase within 12 months of the halving.

give BTC some time

.

I see. The people who were pitching this sounded like it was supposed to happen almost immediately. I was too lazy to go look at the charts then.

https://boriquagato.substack.com/p/the-road-back-from-serfdom

BTC is certainly not a currency in any meaningful sense.

it is not a minimally viable product as either a means of exchange or as a means or escape.

and that latter one is the real doozie.

i came grudgingly to this viewpoint having been in and around BTC since it was in the single digits. i came to bitcoin through cryptography and early public key crypto projects like PGP that were so seminal in the whole idea of open source.

let me be clear: i am a huge believer in crypto-currency.

i think it’s probably the most important idea in the world right now.

but i also think it’s been stuck in an alley that ends in a brick wall as the early promise and purpose was lost among ponzi games, “coin have dog,” and lost vision and execution to the point where i was having a conversation with the founder of one of the major exchanges and he literally could not describe his order matching algo in even rudimentary terms, the primary purpose of ETH is ponzi casino games, and the best argument for BTC right now is “publicly traded ETF’s gotta buy it!”

this last one, of course, only makes the problem worse by generating not just greater fiat links but massive KYC systems. it’s all an increasingly curated garden of surveillance.

BTC was the AOL of crypto, a good start but unable to move forward out of early days; but now, BTC is predominantly spyware. and that’s not going to work out for people who want to leave governments behind.

when one looks at a currency there are a number of features that are needed:

1 sound

2 secure

3 scalable

4 widely accepted

6 stable

6 private

7 anonymous

BTC is 1 for 7, maybe 2 for 7, but probably not in the long run. it is sound. but it is not secure in the sense you really want it to be and the security around block integrity and ability to spam empty or altered ones inherently stands in opposition to “scalable” because its security lies in processing power and that makes scale expensive/prohibitive.

simple fact: until 100 million of us can buy lunch with it tomorrow, it’s not even in the discussion as a currency.

SoTex says

"Bitcoin’s price has climbed a staggering 9,000,000% between 2010 and 2020, making it the top-performing asset of any class over the past decade."

"As of 2024, Bitcoin’s price has a change of 31.40% so far this year."

AD I think maybe you're just posting in the wrong thread. This thread is for misinformation, like what Wookie posted. There are one, maybe two other threads for bitcorn information.

I am posting information to counterbalance the misinformation posted in this thread. Its similar to point and counterpoint.

Why not conveniently have a debate about BTC in one thread ?

.

AD says

Why not conveniently have a debate about BTC in one thread ?

We can debate in any thread. No one on this forum or any other thread or any other site has told me the value of bitcoin.

Why does anyone NEED bitcoin? I can always sell a bar of gold. Silver. I can sell a house. I can sell a stock that owns millions of commercial retail spaces or the land. What do I own with bitcoin? You know the answer. Nothing. That's why this topic is so touchy. If you own it, you know it's technically worthless, so you pump if you own and knock the thinking people.

Enjoy gains. Never have said otherwise. Not buying in though. It's bull shit and you know it.

WookieMan says

No one on this forum or any other thread or any other site has told me the value of bitcoin.

I have.

Bitcoin is speculation. People buy a share with fiat in the hope of cashing out by finding someone to pay more for that share.

Or it can be used for blackmail like those assholes who are ransoming access to Patelco Credit Union.

WookieMan says

No one on this forum or any other thread or any other site has told me the value of bitcoin.

Onvacation says

simple fact: until 100 million of us can buy lunch with it tomorrow, it’s not even in the discussion as a currency.

It's not a currency we discussed this years ago it's a commodity. Red herring.

AD says

I am posting information to counterbalance the misinformation posted in this thread. Its similar to point and counterpoint.

Why not conveniently have a debate about BTC in one thread ?

Well. My hat's off to you.

RWSGFY says

I see. The people who were pitching this sounded like it was supposed to happen almost immediately. I was too lazy to go look at the charts then.

There was a lot of that but anyone who's followed it knows it's 6-12 months after a split that it takes off. However, the splits are so small most people I know didn't think it would have any impact except buy on the rumor sell on the news type thing.

WookieMan says

SoTex says

Get outta here!

"Bitcoin’s price has climbed a staggering 9,000,000% between 2010 and 2020, making it the top-performing asset of any class over the past decade."

No one ever gets my point.

BS. I got your point: your point was it's been a crappy hedge. You don't have to like it and have whatever opinion you'd like but that's just wrong.

SoTex says

It's not a currency we discussed this years ago it's a commodity. Red herring.

commodity
noun
com·mod·i·ty kə-ˈmä-də-tē
plural commodities
Synonyms of commodity
1
: an economic good: such as
a
: a product of agriculture or mining
agricultural commodities like grain and corn
b
: an article of commerce especially when delivered for shipment
reported the damaged commodities to officials
c
: a mass-produced unspecialized product
commodity chemicals
commodity memory chips
2
a
: something useful or valued
that valuable commodity, patience
also : THING, ENTITY
b
: CONVENIENCE, ADVANTAGE
… the many commodities incidental to the life of a public office …
—Charles Lamb
3
: a good or service whose wide availability typically leads to smaller profit margins and diminishes the importance of factors (such as brand name) other than price
4
: one that is subject to ready exchange or exploitation within a market
… stars as individuals and as commodities of the film industry

I think bitcoin is more like a bingo card than a commodity. Though one could say bingo cards are commodities.

Onvacation says

I think bitcoin is more like a bingo card than a commodity. Though one could say bingo cards are commodities.

You can make more money selling shit. Actual manure. Not a joke. Crypto is worth less than shit. The price jumps are whales moving the market and taking your money. You can't make a cow shit more and fertilize your crops. You need more crops to feed and more cows fucking.

WHAT IS CRYPTO? Please explain.

Wookie you should buy some, make a huge profit, contribute to the family nut.

SoTex says

Wookie you should buy some, make a huge profit, contribute to the family nut.

Nope. Family nuts are massive for my age. Might need to remove one and put it in a safe deposit box. Stop worrying about my plums.

WookieMan says

WHAT IS CRYPTO? Please explain.

SoTex says

Wookie you should buy some, make a huge profit, contribute to the family nut.

I'm pretty sure he is the family nut.

WookieMan says

WHAT IS CRYPTO? Please explain.

Webster's Definition:
cryptocurrency
noun
cryp·to·cur·ren·cy ˌkrip-tō-ˈkər-ən(t)-sē -ˈkə-rən(t)-sē
pluralcryptocurrencies
: any form of currency that only exists digitally, that usually has no central issuing or regulating authority but instead uses a decentralized system to record transactions and manage the issuance of new units, and that relies on cryptography to prevent counterfeiting and fraudulent transactions

So it's like imaginary money but unlike fiat money only so much can be printed. People buy it in the belief that because of its (artificial) scarcity they will be able to sell it to someone else for more money.