0
0

Population Shifts and Housing Prices


 invite response                
2006 Mar 10, 7:09am   17,255 views  178 comments

by Randy H   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

Our resident sociologist demographic expert, Davis_renter, pointed out a very interesting article recently:


Boomers leaving the US and taking their wealth with them?
http://tinyurl.com/njyk9

We go from geriatric ghetto to geriatric banana republic.
I’m really getting fascinated by how are population is shifting.

The first paragraph of that article (2nd in a series):

It's a good bet that most people at one time or another have thought about running away to a tropical paradise. For most, it remains just a fantasy. But booming housing prices in the United States and a rising cost of living for retiring Baby Boomers is prompting more Americans to look to retiring abroad.

Davis_renter studies, among other things, the effects that housing prices are having on the financially distressed in the US; something which is discussed here often. Specifically, how the inordinate rise in prices is informing real decisions about where people choose to live and work.

Nomadtoons and others have provided real-world examples of what drives family decisions about where to live. Once, more of a choice relating to family-roots, career opportunities, and weather, are people destined to now ,become economic refugees from ever rising house prices? And, as Nomadtoons ponders, what happens when all this population shift increases house prices in small metro and rural safe harbors? Are we creating (or have we already created) a feedback loop which will be near impossible to break, with families forced to continually flee encroaching house price inflation?

Myself and others have continually made arguments here about related things like affordability, theoretical prices, regression-to-the-mean, inflation, wages, etc. But these are mostly theoretical arguments which, while providing insight into the situation, do not portend to tell the future. Is it possible that "population arbitrage" is the mysterious sustaining force behind this stubborn real-estate bubble? How long can the music keep playing? Until the last boomer finally cashes out for a tropical tax haven? Seriously though, these are profound questions.

#housing

« First        Comments 149 - 178 of 178        Search these comments

149   Peter P   2006 Mar 13, 3:34am  

more well respected .. than ... the UN

I have no respect for the UN. What have they done for humanity lately? They only do pointless things like banning Caspian caviar export. They are unable to mitigate human suffering anywhere. They are not even a paper tiger.

Their NY HQ should be converted into condos.

150   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 3:37am  

The state with the largest number of KKK chapters is California. Just thought you would find that intresting.And this is Circa 2006.. not the 50’s.

This is an artifact of absolute numbers. CA comes no where near per-capita chapters or membership. I'll agree that such ultra-right blight as the KKK and Aryan Nation are rising pretty much everywhere. But places like Clinton County, Ohio have an order of magnitude higher membership participation per capita than any CA county. Google New Vienna (pronounced Veeanna by locals), Ohio if you're interested in learning more about just how pervasive the KKK and AN are in this area. I grew up a few miles from there.

151   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 3:38am  

I have no respect for the UN.

Me either, but I don't put them on a moral equivalency with the KKK.

152   Peter P   2006 Mar 13, 3:42am  

Me either, but I don’t put them on a moral equivalency with the KKK.

The UN is morally irrelevant. However, on the other hand, all forms hatred are pointless and counter-productive. And I am speaking as a "crime-hater".

153   edvard   2006 Mar 13, 3:44am  

Davis renter,
You and SFwoman are intelligent people, as seen on this forum. I'm not trying to be condescending, but I don't understand this fear that seems to imenenate from people sometimes from Californians and other non-native southerners that somehow, someway, if you move or visit that region that suddenly malicious demons will come out and get you.
The real question here is can you live somewhere that has people that think diffrently than yourself. I'll admit that for the first year of me living here in the Bay Area, I found it both refreshing and scary at first for the same reasons that you and SFwoman seem to show concerns for, which is that people here are somewhat diffrent here than other places. I got used to it, and know all the little local and regional intrests and attitude towards various things. I have aclimated and accepted this change, and while there are people who disagree with me, I don't see how this could be diffrent than someone doing the opposite and moving from CA to NC,TN, or somewhere else besides the Bay Area. Again- it is totally up to you. All I can say is that there will not be anyone in these other regions who will try to force you to do anything you don't want to. You'll find a refreshing change from Ca in an affordable lifestyle, less people to clog up the freeways, better schools, and so forth. You'll also find christians who follow a faith that they brought with them from Europe hundreds of years ago, who believe that the church and community are one. You'll also find Jews, Hindus, and buddhists, aetheists, and the whole gamut of what the US has to offer. You may not find what you are used to in California, but you will find something diffrent, including the people. Perhaps people in some areas, even in CA cannot grasp diversity, which again I think is too generalized to categorize. It isn't our jobs to convince them to be any diffrent than who they are and what they believe as it isn't theirs to project their beliefs onto you. You'll find that MOST people are good, decent, respectful people. It's too bad that a few rotten apples have to be used to define the average.

154   Peter P   2006 Mar 13, 3:44am  

But I also hate rats, cockroaches, and imitation crab.

155   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 3:49am  

But I also hate rats, cockroaches, and imitation crab.

Your right. I hate people with bad grammer on the internets to. Its a real pet peeve of mine. Their annoying.

156   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 3:55am  

When that happens, how will stocks handle it? Will consumer spending start a steady decline as well? That could be precursor to the tumble we are projecting.

I think it is the precursor to a long downtrend in consumer sentiment. I'd be careful about trying to correlate stocks to this, however. Stocks are very liquid, and moved by a lot of forces unrelated to consumer sentiment (although the consumer is a major factor).

I think the consumer purchasing downslide will be the most devastating part of the RE bubble pop. This will have national effects on everyone, regardless of whether their local RE market declines.

157   LILLL   2006 Mar 13, 4:01am  

OK. A lot of good posts/topics here.
Nomad
The most popular question to newcomers in N.Carolina, for me, was"so, what church do ya go ta?" I know they were being friendly, just making conversation, but I agree with SF Woman. Religion is very personal to me. I actually believe that those who are most vocal about it , are also the most judgmental. In other words...walk the walk instead of talk the talk. In my family we have a word for it....

hypachristian

Also, when I stopped at a neighborhood convenience store and asked where the teens hang out(concern for my only child who is 13) the guy who couldn't have been over 22 said"Have ya joined a church yet?"Again, very neighborly...but not for me.

Also, I may be naive, but I believe just alot of media coverage will serve to deflate that bubble. Sheeple believe what's on TV.If it's on TV then it must be true! So if the TV finally admits prices are declining, it will inspire fear which will cause further declines. Finally...

158   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 4:11am  

And here is more information on those pesky economic fundamentals I go on and on about:
http://tinyurl.com/qhxjq

If you are willing to treat rising RE prices as a form of inflation, then apply inflation expectation theories like Adaptive Expectations and Inflation Inertia (Phillips Curve aggregate supply stuff) and Wage Rigidity/Structural Unemployment, that article seems not only plausible but consequential.

***Disclaimer, not econometrically tested***

159   DinOR   2006 Mar 13, 4:13am  

I stopped by the "overvalued" blog and I gotta say the guy is funny. People from all across the U.S send in ridiculously priced PoS listing photos and this guy does commentary on them. Very funny!

I must admit though I did break one of his rules. That is to NOT visit open houses! No matter how much fun this might be to jerk some realt-whore around for 1/2 an hour with absolutely no intention of buying it gives them the sense that there is some market activity. I agree. From now on I think I'll just park out front with the Mrs. and laugh hysterically and when the come out to see if you are a viable prospect just slowly roll away. Of course laughing all the while.

160   OO   2006 Mar 13, 4:14am  

SFWoman,

rest assured we will all pay for the greed and stupidity of the RE flippers and subprime lenders. When Fed bails out GSEs, REITs, pension funds, or whatever financial institutions that are deemed too important to fail with manufactured money off their printing press, we will pay our fair share of "inflation tax".

161   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 4:23am  

Taking suggestions for a new thread...

162   DinOR   2006 Mar 13, 4:28am  

Fannie/Freddie Bail-out/re-structuring? Careful what you wish for, will only those w/considerable resources be able to "cash in" at the bottom? Can mortgage lenders get along fine w/out Fannie? What would the lending landscape look like without them? Who cares?

163   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 4:42am  

New Thread:

Fiscal Exposures, Debt; and the threat of Another Huge Bail-out?

Thanks to George and DinOR.

164   Michael Holliday   2006 Mar 13, 4:55am  

Owneroccupier Says:

"One house down my block is trying to sell for 1.8M, and I looked it up on zillow, the owner paid for 550K in 2004. Speaking of bubble!!"

God almighty!

165   Michael Holliday   2006 Mar 13, 4:55am  

Owneroccupier Says:

"One house down my block is trying to sell for 1.8M, and I looked it up on zillow, the owner paid for 550K in 2004. Speaking of bubble!!"

God almighty!

166   LILLL   2006 Mar 13, 5:00am  

Does anyone have a link to the "overvalued" site mentioned previously? Sounds like a hoot!

167   Phil   2006 Mar 13, 5:25am  

Aryan Nation - You got to be kidding me.
http://www.dictionary.net/aryan
Stupid white American's in prison dont have anything better to do. Geez.

168   HARM   2006 Mar 13, 5:27am  

I have a cousin who is a Lesbian in Atlanta. An Aunt who is an atheist and best friends with a lesbian black couple in Memphis. My immediate family and I are not particularly religious and live in a very rural part of the state.In all that time, I have NEVER had anyone tell me what to believe, how to act, where to go to school, or that what I believed was wrong. Needless to say, I was never persecuted for me beliefs. Nor did I openly proclaim my beliefs on others. I, like yourself take me convictions very privately, as most people should do.

Ironically, I have had PLENTY of people here in the Bay area tell me how WRONG I am, as in how wrong the people in general that carry my drawl are.

nomadtoons2 / SF Woman,

I have to chime in here, as a Californian who has both lived in the South and often visits family, who are spread all across the "Bible Belt" (KY, AL, NC, GA). Thirteen years ago, at the urging of my family (and thanks to an almost complete lack of jobs in recessionary CA), I relocated to Atlanta along with my future wife. I'll grant you I went there with a considerable amount of trepidation. While many in my family are either Southerners, or long-time transplants, I was a native Californian with very little direct experience with that part of the country until that time.

Living nearly two years around Atlanta opened my eyes on a number of fronts. Firstly, I agree with nomadtoons2 that not all Southerners are sheet-wearing, Bible-thumping racists out to proselytize everyone they come into contact with. OTH, there are quite a few of these types around, and the dominant culture is far more WASP/Christian/Bible-centric than other parts of the U.S., for better or for worse. Fyi, Stone Mountain, GA (not far from where I lived) is one of the birthplaces of the Klan. As a non-religious type myself, I can certainly empathize with SF Woman in feeling like an "outsider".

While I never experienced direct racism myself (as a very white guy), my wife --who is hispanic-- did. I saw her apply for many jobs, get called up for interviews (she has no accent, and her maiden name sounds Italian), just to show up, watch the friendly expressions turn to ice, and be told "no thanks". Even I got hit with the occasional anti-Yankee, "you're not from around here", and "Californicator", etc. It took a while for either of us to find decent employment, despite having a bit of help from my family. To keep things in perspective, we eventually did develop a network of friends, some of whom were Southerners, while others were transplants like ourselves. In the end, we moved back, mainly due to better job opportunities for me (at that time) in IT, not mainly because of prejudice/cultural reasons.

I have also seen/experienced the kind of arrogant lefty self-righteousness in the Bay Area that nomadtoons2 describes, though I would take care to distinguish it from the more extreme, violent kind of bigotry that still (unfortunately) permeates much of small town life in the deep South. I have never heard of anyone having a pentagram burned on their front lawn for not worshipping Wicca or voting for Nader, for example. While not entirely reflective of the current situation, it’s important to keep in mind that not all horror stories about Southern racism are complete fabrications, and there is still a good measure of it around. This is why many from “blue states” are reluctant to move to the Bible Belt region.

169   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 6:11am  

Just a couple of clarifications since I fear the reactions that nomadtoons and others have to my opinions tend to override my main points and beliefs.

* I don't think any region of the country has any absolute advantage over the other. What is so great about the US is that we, as citizens, are quite willing to move around. And we do it *a lot*. Much more so than balkanized places of the "free world" like the EU.

* Since we move around so much, and we have a very distinct common national culture, we are more alike than different. Stereotypes tend to focus on the minor distinctions, and are very easily to find counter examples defying. This is why my mother-in-law doesn't like gays, but has a very good neighbor friend who is a lesbian.

* Currently, politics are being forged by dividing, not uniting. Elections are won or lost on abortion, evolution, gay marriage, gun rights. Not that these aren't important issues, but they are only important because things like nation-state wars and financial system collapse aren't real fears for most people. More people fear their child will/won't be taught evolution than an invasion by the Red Army or another Great Depression.

* I'm not so sure the West is religiously "tolerant", as much as it is historically "libertarian". The story of the west has helped to form the current attitude of religious (or new age or atheist) beliefs being private. This isn't some great enlightenment that Westerns have, but a luxury of lots of space, until the past few decades fewer people, and a need to get along to survive the environment. The East, Midwest, and South all had a very different view towards community, privacy, and religion. In order for communities to survive people needed to be much more public and conformist about their beliefs. Even the "liberal" New England communities weren't at all libertarian, but instead very institutionally religious, just more Catholic and Protestant, and less Evangelical (from the old-world definitions of these).

* And, for the record, I believe the midwest tends to be more racist than the south on balance. The south had a history of institutionalized racism, while the midwest did not. This ironically has allowed the south to progress past this point in history while the midwest has become mired in a vicious circle of subtle, nefarious racism. Cities like Cincinnati are much more racist at the core than Atlanta. Atlanta works very hard to counter racism, while Cincinnati generally denies it exists.

170   Randy H   2006 Mar 13, 8:13am  

Tends to happen here when a new thread starts. This tends to be a post to the last thread community.

171   Different Sean   2006 Mar 13, 8:44am  

I have no respect for the UN. What have they done for humanity lately? They only do pointless things like banning Caspian caviar export. They are unable to mitigate human suffering anywhere. They are not even a paper tiger.

Their NY HQ should be converted into condos.

That's a pretty standard view amongst standard people in the standard US lately. Something to do with the Security Council not ratifying a 2nd resoluton to invade Iraq mostly, as the UN was set up as a democracy of countries to attempt to maintain world peace as its main goal and look for constructive alternatives.

I think they do things like peace-keeping in Sudan, running UNICEF to give mass vaccinations against disease and provide uncontaminated drinking water in 3rd world countries, etc.

Sure it's got the usual problems of bureaucratic bloat, comfort zones and goal displacement. Still, better than nothing...

172   lunarpark   2006 Mar 13, 10:44am  

Linda in LA-LA Land -

Here is the link you requested.

http://overvalued.blogspot.com/

Enjoy!

173   OO   2006 Mar 13, 11:27am  

Whoever claimed that San Jose price still climbs should go to Ziprealty and select all the San Jose properties, then select properties with reductions only. 118 properties have reduced price. Moreover, most reductions happen quietly, which means, the seller delists and relists with a lower price as a *hot new listing!". So the number of properties with price reductions can easily surpass 200.

With 200+ homes undergoing price reductions, some of them more than one round, do you believe that price is going up?

174   OO   2006 Mar 13, 11:28am  

If including condos as well, South San Jose is showing 20 price reductions. I won't call 20 *apparent* price reductions out of 140 total listings "still going up".

175   LILLL   2006 Mar 13, 3:20pm  

lunarpark
Thanks...very enjoyable!

176   Different Sean   2006 Mar 15, 10:54am  

Bush and the republicans long ago have turned on the money faucet and are spending more money in foreign nations with their goofy “nation building” instead of getting their priorities straight and spending it on the many problems here on the homeland.

But they're not interested in 'nation-building', it's aways an attempt at an 'investment' with a payoff -- e.g. loads of cheap oil, or strategic bases, or preserving the USD as the world's chief petrocurrency, or all 3 if possible. The neocons miscalculated because they thought they would be accepted and welcomed by the overwhelming majority of iraqis for delivering them from a tyrant. middle eastern politics and the cultural mindset are not so simple. further, people in that region are sick of decades of having puppet leaders foisted on them by the west in order to ensure a steady supply of oil, so you are battling that distrust and desire for autonomy as well.

that's why they don't do nation-building in africa - they're just not interested - unless there's a big pile of oil or some other valuable, indispensable commodity underneath it, e.g. oil in southern sudan or nigeria. clearly the iraq and caspian sea oil and gas resources were of primary interest. it doesn't matter if there's a hit to govt if industry benefits - because the two are intertwined in the national self-interest.

look at the US undermining of democratically elected left-wing leaders in S. America practising assassination, training thugs and putting in right-wing despots when it suits - usually because Chiquita or some other vested interest says it will increase the price of bananas, or reduce profitability, or get chucked out of the country altogether...

there are huge oil and infrastructure connections with the current administration of course - they are the most conflicted and corrupted in america's history. rice is an ex-texaco oil exec with a ship formerly named after her. bush - say no more. cheney is bribed by an infrastructure company he headed for 5 years. then there's the military-govt connection - lockheed martin are the current favourites in the administration, with a revolving door of jobs between the two.

anyhow, he was 'selected, not elected' - the 2000 and 2004 elections were both stacked and rigged so that the republicans need never worry about something so trifling as a democratic election obstructing them in their agendas ever again.

i don't think terrorists are really even a problem - there's a big question mark over who the terrorists even were - half of them had stolen identities, they conveniently found a lot of passports in the wreckage, etc. why would the middle east be so angry with the US in particular anyway? they don't normally attack the UK, Australia, france, germany, scandinavia, all of western europe, etc, all similar sorts of countries with oil contracts. so clearly it has nothing to do with 'they hate freedom and democracy', that's just a propaganda line for local consumption to gain support. america always gets to name the enemy and prescribe the remedy, usually military or otherwise coercive. but america is completely financially self-interested and self-absorbed also, and can only be expected to try to steer every situation to its own economic advantage, so how can they be trusted to name the rules, be the umpire and become the 'new world order'? that's meant to be the job of the UN, as a democracy of nations of sorts. that's where the neocons are particularly just a blinkered, elitist failure and completely mistaken in their thinking.

177   Different Sean   2006 Mar 15, 11:04am  

oh, and the 'smoking gun' theory about the neocons, where they actually put in writing for public consumption (!) that the US should invade iraq post haste, take control of caspian sea resources before someone else did, such as the russians, and that america needed another 'pearl harbour' to work them up into a frenzy to do it. all this in the late 1990s...

178   Different Sean   2006 Mar 17, 10:40pm  

anyone heard of the fact that most lender banks are setting up brand new, and/or larger repo departments???

there's record foreclusures in sydney for the last 2 years already... apparently largely young, burnt investors...

« First        Comments 149 - 178 of 178        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste