0
0

So... Mr. Bernanke, what would you say ya do here?


 invite response                
2006 Jun 27, 2:31pm   19,853 views  277 comments

by HARM   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

Bob

Randy H Said:

Abolish the Fed

I hope that is a joke. I’m trying to imagine a global economy without Central Banks, or a global economy in which one country unilaterally dissolves its Central Bank.

*shiver*

HARM Replied:

Explain to me in plain English exactly HOW the Fed’s mission has anything to do with “helping” the public (non bankers) and how they’ve actually succeeded in that role, and perhaps I’ll consider retracting that statement.

Federal Reserve System from Wikipedia
Roles and responsibilities
The main tasks of the Federal Reserve are to:

–Supervise and regulate banks
Not doing so well on that score lately from my POV.

–Implement monetary policy by open market operations, setting the discount rate, and setting the reserve ratio
Yes, they’ve done a “mah-velous” job of flooding capital markets with unlimited liquidity, blowing asset bubbles and destroying the value of the USD –kudos to them!

–Maintain a strong payments system
No argument here –creditors/lenders of all kinds have enjoyed limitless cash-flow under the Fed. Debtors on the other hand…

–Control the amount of currency that is made and destroyed on a day to day basis (in conjunction with the Mint and Bureau of Engraving and Printing)
Kind of depends on what you mean by “control”, doesn’t it? If you mean “set the money-creation spigot permanently to ‘ON’ and flood asset/capital markets until you have one speculative bubble after another”, then they’ve done a bang-up job!

In short, I believe the Fed has failed miserably at serving the public’s interests (assuming that it ever really had anything to do with this –I doubt it) and has only succeeded in making the business cycle even more volatile/extreme than it already was. Let’s not forget that the 1930s Great Depression, 1970s Stagflation and several severe recessions occurred on the Fed’s watch (founded in 1913), as has the consistent destruction of the purchasing power of the USD, in the interests of fake nominal “growth” through inflation.

The Treasury handles the production of paper money and coinage just fine. What exactly do we (the public) need a Federal Reserve System for?

Discuss, enjoy...
HARM

« First        Comments 60 - 99 of 277       Last »     Search these comments

60   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 3:50am  

Randy H,

I'm going to have to differ with you slightly on this one. Had the HB been "unintended" they would have pulled the punch bowl much more quickly. I don't consider having your choice of 89 different varieties of hardwood flooring of any real benefit.

61   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 3:50am  

A requirement of being a hedge fund manager is truly believing you are smarter than the Fed Governor, and everyone else on the planet for that matter.

You only need to think that you are luckier than most.

62   Randy H   2006 Jun 28, 3:51am  

FRIFY,

I think you attributed a quote not mine to me. That was Peter P I think.

I'm a renter too with the task of protecting substantial equity savings from inflation. I still do not see the Fed as my "enemy". I see global imbalances, massive deficit spending, irresponsible tax policy, and time as my enemies.

63   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 3:51am  

Randy H,

If all those hedge fund managers are SO smart why do they keep calling me for ideas? Me?

64   FRIFY   2006 Jun 28, 3:55am  

RH,

I was agreeing with Peter P who responded to your quote. I'm just joining the pile on top of Randy crowd. ;-)

I certainly agree that our Tax policies are a bigger threat to my long term economic health than the Fed meddling.

65   Red Whine   2006 Jun 28, 4:29am  

"predictable for the average Joe so he can plan accordingly and avoid getting stolen from."

Hopefully this would not include Uncle Al suggesting ARMs for mass-consumption in a rising-rate environment AND when rates are already at historical lows.

66   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 4:36am  

Red Whine,

Yo! Even the financial media struggled with the logic of that one! Those comments should have served as a warning to GTFO! Yo!

67   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 4:44am  

Just for a laugh check out www.sdcia.com. Man, talk about "equity locusts"! Got to the message boards and check out "Losing Shirt in Tucson". Freaking hysterical!

68   tsusiat   2006 Jun 28, 4:53am  

Harm wrote at the top, regarding FED priorities -

–Implement monetary policy by open market operations, setting the discount rate, and setting the reserve ratio
Yes, they’ve done a “mah-velous” job of flooding capital markets with unlimited liquidity, blowing asset bubbles and destroying the value of the USD –kudos to them!

Actually HARM, don't you think out of control federal, personal and corporate debt might be more responsible for the freefall of the US Dollar than anything else.

Don't forget, the Fed incluences world economics, but the exchange rate of the dollar is a complicated thing, influenced by the world.

If you are talking about the intrinsic worth of a US Dollar, what it will buy, as opposed to its exchange rate, I still don't think the Fed can take much of the blame.

If not for the carousel of financial instruments for cash for crap from China, bombs and bail outs, would not the whole position of the US economy be completely reversed? And the Treasury Dept sets the rates that matter in this arena. And they were influenced by rates in Japan as much as by the Fed, I'm sure.

You can't blame the ceaseless trade deficit entirely on the fed. And the deficit, and debt financing of America by Asia, are factors not under the sway of the Fed. Just my opinion.

69   Red Whine   2006 Jun 28, 4:59am  

I didn't know sdcia.com existed until I visited this board. Can these people possibly be for real? Someone here coined a phrase "irrational lust for depreciating assets" or similar -- perfect.

70   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 5:14am  

tsusiat,

Yeah I can kind of go along with that but; when in the last 5 years + was the "cost of money" a deal killer? I mean seriously, as individuals or corporations? If you can think of examples where an aquisition or expansion plans were shelved b/c the board decided not to move forward b/c int. rates would mean the investment would have to make sense I'm open. Be it an SUV or a whatever?

71   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 5:18am  

What I should have said is that a lot of things may have "died on the vine" for various reasons but it wasn't b/c of the cost of money. Especially so soon after pets.com! Fast, loose and easy money for everyone with a ONE page business plan!

72   Michael Holliday   2006 Jun 28, 5:29am  

Randy H:

Good input. Thanks!

73   Randy H   2006 Jun 28, 5:44am  

DinOR,

If all those hedge fund managers are SO smart why do they keep calling me for ideas? Me?

I surely didn't mean to imply that they really are as smart as they think they are. Since installing site monitoring on my cap2.0 blog I have discovered 6 or 7 hedge funds that are regularly downloading my "research".

After I finished laughing I got the bright idea to create a contra-hedge-hedge-fund. Seed these "geniuses" with my own research then take bets against what I've told them to be true.

74   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 6:17am  

Since installing site monitoring on my cap2.0 blog I have discovered 6 or 7 hedge funds that are regularly downloading my “research”.

Randy, rename the site to "Center for Capitalism Research" and you will get even more hits. :)

75   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 6:19am  

Randy H,

LOL! Lord, that is too much. Well, these guys are relentless if nothing else. As if we were in need of more folly check out www.sdcia.com. In the boards there's this guy losing his shirt in Tucson. These guys are almost in pure "damage control" mode and if you needed evidence of "equity locusts" look no further!

76   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 6:32am  

>>If all those hedge fund managers are SO smart why do they keep calling me for ideas? Me?

Dinor,

I'm getting into that racket and I wouldn't mind talking to you. I always want to hear what everyone is thinking.

77   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 7:19am  

Michael Anderson,

I think SQT or Randy H can get you my e-mail, so no problem. Can't speak for Bend but I think we reached 106 degrees on Monday (much cooler now).

78   Chuck Ponzi   2006 Jun 28, 7:29am  

–Maintain a strong payments system
No argument here –creditors/lenders of all kinds have enjoyed limitless cash-flow under the Fed. Debtors on the other hand…

That's not what I think they meant (although I agree with the connotation). The payments system is the Automated Clearinghouse System (ACH origination and inter-bank check clearing). That, actually, is one of the reasons that you don't have to take your check to another bank for cashing and deposit into your bank. This is also the basis for much of the online banking in the US since ACH originations go over the US clearinghouse overseen by the Federal Reserve Bank.

79   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 8:10am  

$200k in credit card debt

Huh? Did you mean 20K?

80   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 8:11am  

Thanks SQT.

81   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 8:13am  

No Peter, it really is $200k.

200K? 8O

82   HARM   2006 Jun 28, 8:14am  

Bottom line is they owe $600k against the house and have $200k in credit card debt.

OMFG :shock:

83   HARM   2006 Jun 28, 8:21am  

It was appraised in 2001 for $1million, but since the property needs some repairs

There may be a silver lining here. If it was appraised at that much way back in 2001 (the very earliest phase of the HB), then it must be valued at WAY more than that now. Appreciation for the Sacramento area since 2001 is something like 150-200% on average, right? Even assuming the place needs a ton of big repairs (new roof, plumbing, electrical), I can't imagine that would amount to more than $100-200K in buyer credits. This, plus the $600K mortgage(s) plus $200K CC should still leave them with a couple of million dollars free & clear (assuming they sell fast).

84   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 8:28am  

But it might not be enough to cover the debt and put money down on a new place.

Commision to sell + closing costs for the new place may amount to more than 70K - 80K.

Can they try to sub-divide and sell part of the land away? 1/2 acre of prime raw land should worth something.

85   HARM   2006 Jun 28, 8:29am  

That full-acre lot is where most of the "house" value is, not the structure itself. You may be (pleasantly) surprised at what it appraises for today, especially if local zoning allows it to be sub-divided into multiple SFH lots.

Even if it's not worth $3 million, you must impress upon them that the high-interest CC debt alone will eat them alive if they don't act quickly. And the longer they wait in a falling market, the worse their prospects will be (as in BK).

86   HARM   2006 Jun 28, 8:30am  

Funny, Peter P & I said almost the exact same thing.

87   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 8:31am  

I do not know if sub-dividing triggers a Prop 13 reset though.

88   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 8:36am  

>>The land isn’t divided up in a way that would make that possible.

Well, how much would the land be worth if the house was knocked down?

89   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 8:42am  

SQT,

Oh, thank you for the e-mail exchange! Just another plus for Patrick regulars.

I am curious though as to why folks in that age group never seem to be able to confide in their children (or anyone for that matter) until it's too late or certainly in the 11th hour?

I've always been SO candid with my daughters about money matters. During the 90's (when they took karate lessons and everything under the sun) Mrs. DinOR and I took care to explain that things may not always be like this. We further explained that neither of their parents are anticipating any kind of an inheritance so we're pretty much it. (There really isn't a DinOR family fortune). When it came time for college the expectations (particularly after a long and difficult bear market) were pretty realistic.

It certainly didn't seem to suprise you all that much but I can't help but feel that there was much consolation in being that right either. I'm sure they'll be fine but it looks like their "expectations" will have to come around as well?

90   Different Sean   2006 Jun 28, 8:43am  

DinOR says:
Myself and others have been most vocal regarding “dis-enrollment” for 401K participants! Meaning you’re new on board, we automatically enroll you into the plan and if you really, really want out you have to jump through hoops.

it's compulsory for nearly all workers here - including a mandatory employer's contribution of 8% of earnings. plus a voluntary employee's contribution. all with tax advantages, of course.

91   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 8:45am  

Are we having fun yet?

Here's my situation. Moved to a rental in June. Sold my house in October. Investor owner of the house we're in let us know they were selling (I don't blame them--smart). Finding another rental was horrible--three kids, big dog, cat. Tons of houses for sale, hardly anything for rent.

Finally found something. Now trying to move my stuff with little kids on summer break. Have to pick up a few appliances. Have to change mail, bank accounts, brokerage accounts, garbage, cable, phone, electric water, etc.

Good lord.

Moving into a nice 4-bedroom place. I talked with the neighbor there. I asked about the owner of the place I'm going into. He says they are waiting for the top of the market to sell. I only hope they wait until the one-year lease is over before they decide to sell. If they break the lease, sure, I get to pocket a little money, but then it's back to trying to find another rental in the same school district again.

"Why don't you just buy?" everyone asks.

92   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 8:50am  

SQT,

Kick-ass mom.

93   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 8:50am  

DS,

Good on ya mate! Perhaps there is a thing or two we can learn from the Aussies! It's so crazy it just might work! With our Pension Benefit Gaurantee Corp. about 28 bil. under funded (steel and airline bailouts) maybe they can assert pressure in the right places? That or keep the canned "roo" meat coming.

94   DinOR   2006 Jun 28, 8:55am  

SQT,

Well that is an alarming situation. Can keeping up appearances be THAT important to Dad? I've got to be honest, after surviving a 3 yr. bear market I'm a little beyond caring about what other people think.

95   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 9:09am  

At least the cat is out of the bag. Your Dad hates the exposure, no doubt, but at least he doesn't have to hide things anymore. Hard to sleep with secrets.

96   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 9:14am  

Any good way to reduce food expenses?

97   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 9:17am  

>>Any good way to reduce food expenses?

http://eatyourpantry.blogspot.com/

98   Peter P   2006 Jun 28, 9:20am  

Cultivate lobsters in the swimming pool.

We do not have a swimming pool. Only two tubs. I do not want to bathe with clawed creatures.

99   MichaelAnderson   2006 Jun 28, 9:24am  

>>I do not want to bathe with clawed creatures.

Wear a cup.

« First        Comments 60 - 99 of 277       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste