patrick.net
An Antidote to Corporate Media
1,363,656 comments by 15,741 users - declarethecauses, FortWayneHatesRealtors, PeopleUnited, WookieMan online now
Comments 1 - 3 of 77 Next » Last » Search these comments
toothfairy
2010 Feb 3, 12:36am
I'm not for or against walking away, but the way these things usually turn out...the biggest losers end up being the people who thought they could get ahead by taking the easy way out.
I walked because, most importantly, I would have been flat broke and not able to pay. I sold the house for more than the purchase price, but I was underwater. Long, stupid story.
Anyway, it never occurred to me just to default on the second while still paying the first, but had I done that, any chance of a short sale would have evaporated quickly. I short-sold the home in '08 for about $850k, and now, based on sales in the area, the place would probably only be worth $450K. Would I still want to be paying for that? No comment. ;)
Do what's best for you, but know all the facts. I may end up declaring bankruptcy over this one day (if the second lender sues and wins), but at this point, I don't care. I would love nothing more than to move on, renting for the rest of my life if I have to.
Bankruptcy is OK, for, after all, what is a credit score other than a tool to just get into more debt? I'm tired of debt.
wow, quite a post. It has the feeling that there's an entire melancholy novel behind it somewhere...
Comments 1 - 3 of 77 Next » Last » Search these comments
I am one of those homeowners with a house "underwater" and awaiting a final decision on a loan modification. I hear many stories of people walking away from their homes. I do not blame these homeowners in many respects. But one has to consider what happens "the day after" as follows:
1) You will be put on a black list operated by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. You will not get another home loan for ten years.
2) You will avoid Federal income tax liability through 2012. You will owe State of California income tax on any losses to the lender.
3) Yes, for now, you will find a rental. What happens when all of the landlords also default and all of the real estate is owned by the banks? When you go and apply for a rental, you might get turned down because you're on the big bank's black list.
4) You may believe that if everyone walked away, it would "bring the big banks to their knees." This is a false assumption. The monster banks will turn to the taxpayers for reimbursement. Your grand children will still be paying for this.
5) With a foreclosure on you record you will have employment problems and problems with your security clearance.
6) One day the market will come back. I have seen crashes like this in HOuston and Buenos Aires.
A saner strategy is to default on your second lien. If there is no equity to secure it, the bank will not be able to foreclose. If the second lien was purchase money, the bank will not be able to sue you. Your credit will take a temporary hit but you will survive it.
#housing