0
0

Ben Jones & Patrick: Psychics or Super-Geniuses?


 invite response                
2007 Mar 6, 9:13am   19,406 views  179 comments

by HARM   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

Patrick's alter ego? Ben Jones - mathematical genius?

As the rolling bubble crash gathers steam, and even formerly hostile MSM sources now reluctantly admit the bubble --and its bursting-- is undeniably real, one question remains: how did people like Patrick Killelea and Ben Jones correctly predict all this so accurately beforehand?

Nearly two years ago, Ben and Patrick founded their now-famous blogs, dedicated to the national housing bubble. They boldly predicted its demise as "inevitable" long, long before most industry experts would even admit the bubble even existed. Now events are unfolding almost like clockwork, almost exactly as predicted:

  • Exhaustion and unaffordability leads first to falling sales & rising inventories, but very sticky prices (at first).
  • Inability to continue flipping and/or serially refinancing forces flippers and over-leveraged FBs to try to exit, spiking inventories and gradually un-sticking prices in successive waves of option-ARM resets.
  • Failure to indefinitely to hide default/foreclosure/repurchase losses off the balance sheets forces many sub-prime operators and MSB issuers out of business, drying up liquidity.
  • The MEW-ATM shutdown spills over into the general economy and either triggers a general recession, or at the very least, localized recessions in extreme-bubble regions.
  • The crash slowly grinds away over years, eroding homedebtor equity via a combination of inflation and nominal price drops, until the price-rent/price-income equilibrium is finally restored.
  • Finally, the rolling crash becomes obvious even to the most clueless FB and the cheerleading MSM. Newsweek issues it's "Housing: Worst Investment Ever!" cover story, close to the exact market bottom.
  • My questions: how could such seemingly average Joes ever predict such events when the brightest, most highly paid industry experts could not? I mean, David Lereah went from "no bubble" to "correction's over" in like 30 seconds flat! If the danger signs were so obvious, then why didn't we hear about them beforehand from the NAR... the Fed... Wall Street? It's not as if these frequently quoted (and rarely challenged) "industry experts" could possibly have known about this mess beforehand, but just kept it to themselves for some reason. Like, that's just conspiratorial, tinfoil-hat wing-nuttery, right?

    So, if the only way to perceive an asset/credit bubble is after-the-fact (as Sir Alan Greenspan has asserted), then how could Ben and Patrick possibly have known about it that far back? Are they psychic? Are these guys prescient modern-day Nostradamus-es? Or, are they financial super-wizards --real-life Hari Seldons-- who can accurately predict the future with mathematical precision, but posing as regular guys? If the housing bubble was so impossible to predict, even with access to the very best market data and cutting-edge computing power (as the experts insist it was), then how could two ordinary working-class stiffs manage to pull off such a feat by themselves?

    Should we be concerned that Patrick and Ben are some form of genetically mutated super-geniuses hiding in plain sight?? How else could they possibly have foreseen the unforeseeable?

    Spooky, isn't it? :roll:

    Discuss, enjoy...
    HARM

    #housing

    « First        Comments 55 - 94 of 179       Last »     Search these comments

    55   Different Sean   2007 Mar 6, 9:35pm  

    Many taxi drivers here make only $8 an hour on average. They pay the license owner $100 a day for 'borrowing' the cab, and they keep whatever's left over -- after fuel...

    London cab drivers have to pass tests on the 'The Knowledge' -- thus, some sort of regulation and accreditation is necessary to make sure drivers are competent. Although, there is a big unlicensed grey market of private vehicles in London also that used to hang around Heathrow and so on...

    Does a 'perfect free market' imply that no-one needs to be accredited, regulated or even trained any more? cool... what does this amazing perfect free market look like? I might hang out a brain surgeon shingle tomorrow...

    56   astrid   2007 Mar 6, 10:05pm  

    Peter P,

    Nope, that condo is advertised as a 5 bdrm, 3 bathroom place, and there were vague references to other rooms as well.

    I would personally pay more for 2 bdrm 2000 sq ft places than 5 bdrm 2000 sq ft places. The latter usually means tiny rooms that need to be combined.

    57   astrid   2007 Mar 6, 10:07pm  

    $1.99/minute is pretty good work, but how do we keep the foolz on the line for 30 minutes?

    58   SFWoman   2007 Mar 6, 10:49pm  

    Peter P.,

    I had a cab driver (Russian) who ran a red light and almost hit a pedestrian (the pedestrian fell trying to get out of the way) crossing the street and was almost T-boned while doing that. I forced him to stop and I got out (At night on Pine Street in that funky 'lower Nob Hill' area). I had his name, the cab number, the time, etc. but I couldn't find anyone to complain to. The cab company, the commission, (I called someone else but can't remember who) all said that the cab driver was an independent contractor over whom they had no authority.

    So the cab companies own all the taxi medallions, keep the cab supply artificially low (try to get a cab on a rainy night), gouge the drivers, but have zero responsibility. I can see why they want no change.

    59   DinOR   2007 Mar 6, 10:49pm  

    LurkinLeech,

    Thanks for the link. It's hard to say for sure (not being psychic and all) but it appears that the realtwhores in ID timed their charge just about perfectly!

    Being at the tail end of the rolling bubble I imagine people are still feeling pretty good about RE in your area. By getting these "minimum service" pieces of legislation passed post haste by the time people figure out RE is a crappy investment they'll be forever saddled w/6% commissions!

    Oh btw I'd read just yesterday that yet another lumber mill is shutting down up there! (Due to the slowdown in the demand of course) so by the time these people get laid off they'll all be able to get jobs as 6% realtors! That's how it's supposed to work, right? :)

    60   DinOR   2007 Mar 6, 11:02pm  

    "If they float they must burn"

    alien, that is so funny you would bring that up! Of late I've kind of visualized the few remaining RE perma-bulls not unlike "The Flagellants" during the plague going from town to town beating themselves to a bloody pulp trying to "cast out" evil!

    More leeches!

    61   FormerAptBroker   2007 Mar 7, 12:39am  

    Different Sean Says:

    > London cab drivers have to pass tests on the
    > ‘The Knowledge’ — thus, some sort of regulation
    > and accreditation is necessary to make sure
    > drivers are competent.

    We don’t have any test in SF. Last year I was going to a dinner at the Slanted Door and told the driver of a cab I on Sacramento Street to take me to the “Ferry Building” and the driver (who looked like he just got here from Africa) asked me (in a thick accent) how to get to the “Berry Building”…

    > Although, there is a big unlicensed grey market of
    > private vehicles in London also that used to hang
    > around Heathrow and so on…

    A tip I learned years ago in NY is to try and make a deal with limo drivers that are waiting around the hotel. You want to make sure the cab drivers don’t figure out what you are doing since they will get mad. Most of the guys are happy to earn an extra $20 and it’s fun to end a night out when you call your “driver” on his cell phone to take you and your friends home…

    > Does a ‘perfect free market’ imply that no-one needs to
    > be accredited, regulated or even trained any more? cool…
    > what does this amazing perfect free market look like?
    > I might hang out a brain surgeon shingle tomorrow…

    The “free market” has “restrictions” but not “prohibitions”. In San Francisco there is nothing “prohibiting” me from going to med school and owning a medical practice there I do brain surgery, but in San Francisco I am “prohibited” from owning and operating my own cab in the city…

    P.S. When we were in High School we used to make extra money driving drunk people home Tahoe City bars in the winter…

    62   Claire   2007 Mar 7, 1:46am  

    Peter P - after my husband experienced a few trips with taxi's from SF airport (i.e had to hold the door closed because it didn't shut properly, scary driving), our next door neighbor recommended a good guy to use for airport runs and we have used him several times - I could post the contact details if you would like them - can't remember his rates though.

    63   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 2:28am  

    Peter P, please tell me you don’t believe in magical thinking.

    Huh? Magic or Magick? They are different, you know.

    64   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 2:31am  

    Peter P - after my husband experienced a few trips with taxi’s from SF airport (i.e had to hold the door closed because it didn’t shut properly, scary driving), our next door neighbor recommended a good guy to use for airport runs and we have used him several times - I could post the contact details if you would like them - can’t remember his rates though.

    Thanks Claire. We also found out that limo/sedan companies charge not much more but they are much better than taxis.

    Just for clarification, we were driving on the freeway and had a scary episode with a cab near SFO. We were not sitting in a cab.

    65   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 2:37am  

    I would personally pay more for 2 bdrm 2000 sq ft places than 5 bdrm 2000 sq ft places. The latter usually means tiny rooms that need to be combined.

    Exactly, although you may want to get a 2000 sqft 9bed/1bath house in the Central Valley. :-P

    NOT INVESTMENT ADVICE

    66   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 2:40am  

    Drivers in some parts of Japan are the meanest I’ve ever seen.

    Really? But they are stop to let me cross the road.

    I have no problem driving in the Bay Area, but would NEVER CONSIDER driving in Japan.

    I was in my friend's car and he was going 120mph on the highway. That was scary. Other than that, it just seems that most Japanese drivers drive like me. :)

    If you ever try to enforce your pedestrian rights in Tokyo, you’ll become another traffic statistic.

    Well you were born there. Can't argue with you.

    67   StuckInBA   2007 Mar 7, 2:45am  

    trader :

    What set Patrick/Ben apart is that they were able to say it publicly. That really saved a few.

    Count me in. No I would not have bought a house even if I had never found out this site. It saved me from losing confidence in my financial sense.

    This very forum is testament to the fact that we all seek affirmation from others.

    It was true that in 2006 this was like my support group. Now I don't the affirmation or the "fix" as much. I come here for sound opinions and smart discussions. I like hanging around with this bunch. Even if they disagree with my views.

    Now my predictions about housing could all be wrong, but what has happened in last 18 months in RE market has at least proved one thing to me. I was not stupid to refrain from buying. Now I am at peace with myself.

    68   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Mar 7, 2:48am  

    PAR, that's classic.

    Honestly.... I'm thinking about taking the 2 week class and getting my license. Not to become a Realtor, but to document what exactly it is that they get 'taught' and how that makes them qualified to give any financial advice.

    69   DinOR   2007 Mar 7, 2:48am  

    BearCat,

    I'll agree, it doesn't exactly take a genius to have put this together. At least not in 2007! :) The truth is, for quite some time there were no overt signs other than things being hunky dory and that WE were missing the boat!

    Now w/FB's defaulting left and right (unimaginable 18 mos. ago) and subprime lenders going under by the day, it all looks so obvious. What I especially enjoy is that almost each passing day a whole NEW swath of people that bought in at or near the peak are seeing their "equity cushion" erode! :) The number of people that never in a million years thought pilfering their own home would ever catch up w/them is growing as we speak!

    A lot of them WILL be surprised to learn that housing blogs go back as far as 2003? and that there WERE everyday people no more qualified than themselves predicting the mess they can not find their way out of.

    70   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 2:50am  

    Perhaps Patrick and Ben are Super-psychic-geniuses.

    71   DinOR   2007 Mar 7, 3:00am  

    "It saved me from losing confidence in my financial sense"

    Amen to that brother! While I can't say that "fix" describes my motivations any more it's still great to have some troll parade the ol' "time machine" around from time to time!

    I don't know if anyone else was offended by it by Caroline Baum of Bloomberg (whom I normally respect) was off the mark when she described ALL subprime borrowers as "dead beats". Evidently this is the way the market portrays this end of debt paper so we can all feel better about ourselves?

    Perhaps NAR and Wall Steet would be infinitely happier if everyone that didn't qualify as "A" paper sat around and rented until A) prices come way down or B) they actually qualify for a traditional mortgage complete w/20% down. (That'll keep the REIC rolling along!)

    72   EBGuy   2007 Mar 7, 3:04am  

    PAR said:
    FAB, the really interesting part is when they go to refi out of their toxic loan (into another reset toxic loan, of course) and the appraisal comes in at 97% of their original purchase price but they owe 110%… This is the surprise that nobody sees coming.
    But it just gets better, the real surprise is that the originator will refi the loan... then when that loan drives them to the poor house the lender says "Oh sorry, you lost your original purchase money, non-recourse loan when you refied. We own you".

    73   DinOR   2007 Mar 7, 3:10am  

    BearCat,

    I was really just kidding. Someone recently mentioned that DL went from not seeing a bubble to calling the bottom all in the span of 3 months! I recognize you as one of the long time posters and SoCalmtguy and I have already hashed out our differences on "tastes great/less filling" (cheap money vs. tax code) long ago!

    For anyone late to the party it's all too tempting to say that the bubble is "solely" cheap money driven. For old time believers, all it facilitated was a way for long time owners w/solid equity and the builders to cash in on both ends of the deal. At the GF's expense of course!

    74   HeadSet   2007 Mar 7, 3:53am  

    "....all said that the cab driver was an independent contractor over whom they had no authority.

    So the cab companies own all the taxi medallions, keep the cab supply artificially low (try to get a cab on a rainy night), gouge the drivers, but have zero responsibility. I can see why they want no change."

    SFWoman, I manage a company that has over 250 cabs so let me add here.

    The medallion concept is a holdover from the New York style political boss days. Originally, the medallians that sold in New York were only $100 apiece, but last time I looked, the cost was up to $275,000. This means a New York cabbie must pay off this medallian mortgage (or pay thousands to rent a medallian), pay to lease his cab, pay to maintain his cab, and pay for credit card services while being restricted in how much he can charge. Not all cities run cabs like New York, but the independent leasee driver / company medallions model is the most common. Thus to make money, cabbies must pick up as many passengers as possible and as many long trips as possible. This is why they drive so fast and ignore pickups (such as in Harlem) that do not usually go far. And yes, the cabbie is an "independent contractor" who gets no benefits, must pay both ends of his SS and his own taxes, and has no workman's comp.

    This is a business that would do well with less gov control. I can see that the city would inspect cabs for safety and cleanliness, and perhaps tax for business use of roads, but the medallion concept is just a method of insuring campaign contributions from the medallion holders. And highly regulated businesses must make campaign contributions. If you request to see your local official about his proposed legislation requiring taxis to pick up the elderly for free, he will flip through his rollodex to see if you made a contribution. If you did not, you ain't seeing him.

    The "they" that want no change are the city officials and their select business croneys. Remove the city meddling and the businessmen would have to compete with price/quality for both drivers and riders.

    I have found Washington DC to be a great place to ride a cab. The market is not regulated, and drivers own thier cabs. They use zone pricing, so the expense of meters is eliminated. Every cab I took there was well kept and clean. Any vehicle type can be a cab there, I have seen everything from sedans to 4x4 trucks.

    75   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 3:56am  

    They are not making any more medallion.

    76   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 4:08am  

    There should be no price control on taxi services. Drivers should be able to charge whatever he feels like so long as the fee schedule is known before the trip.

    77   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 4:09am  

    I have answered this before, FB = Focaccia Bread.

    78   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 4:09am  

    Or F*cked Borrower.

    79   e   2007 Mar 7, 4:27am  

    Speaking of taxis - it's amazing how expensive they are here. Even car service.

    It's over $100 to go from SFO to Mountain View/Sunnyvale via taxi. With car service it's still almost $75. And this is all pre-tip.

    Good grief - it's cheaper to take a taxi in NYC for an equivalent distance.

    And as I like to say, anytime something is more expensive than NYC and it's not in NYC, it's broken.

    80   HeadSet   2007 Mar 7, 4:31am  

    "There should be no price control on taxi services. Drivers should be able to charge whatever he feels like so long as the fee schedule is known before the trip. "

    Bingo, Peter P!

    With today's tecnology, that would be easy. Punch in the destination and out pops a fare. Common destinations could be on an old fashioned fee menu.

    81   Peter P   2007 Mar 7, 4:33am  

    With today’s tecnology, that would be easy. Punch in the destination and out pops a fare. Common destinations could be on an old fashioned fee menu.

    Yep. It should be easy to set up a two-way bidding system using SMS technology.

    Want a cab? SMS dispatch with the route and a bid!

    82   e   2007 Mar 7, 4:36am  

    Highly entertaining exchange in the comments. Realtor tries to skewer with (and then falls upon) the it’s-different-here-sword…
    http://www.sfhomeblog.com/2007/03/if-you-do-fall-behind.html

    To be fair though, they -were- fighting about Central Valley.

    83   bikes2work   2007 Mar 7, 4:57am  

    PAR, have you tried this one for Bay Area listings?

    http://www.mlslistings.com/

    I always thought it worked pretty well.

    84   DinOR   2007 Mar 7, 5:00am  

    My favorite cab?

    CASH CAB!

    There's a thought! Jump in, agree to play and if you miss 3 trivia questions we'll kick ya' ta' the curb! Get 'em right and we'll give YOU cash! I love it!

    85   bikes2work   2007 Mar 7, 5:04am  

    Check out listing MLS#: 703508 on

    http://www.mlslistings.com/

    506 sq ft 53-year old cottage for $999,000 with Los Altos schools (2665 MILLER AV, MTN VIEW).

    86   mat   2007 Mar 7, 5:14am  

    So I am sitting in my office minding my own business, and suddenly there is a phone call.
    Nice automated voice saying that they have been trying to reach me because homeowners in my area are now prequalified for 1% interest rate refinancing, and that I can use this opportunity to pay off my other loans or take a f***ing vacation. Bad credit is apparently still OK.

    Oh and if I would like to take advantage of this wonderful opportunity, I should press "1" now.

    Really pissed me off. When will this crap end?

    87   OO   2007 Mar 7, 5:22am  

    Los Altos doesn't have a good high school, most Los Altos parents send their kids to private high schools, or they choose to buy the part of Los Altos bordering Cupertino to go to Cupertino's high school.

    Paying a mil for a shack on top of private school tuition bill, that is just lunacy. It also doesn't satisfy one's vanity, it is after all Mountain View address.

    88   HeadSet   2007 Mar 7, 5:24am  

    Hey DinOr,

    CASH CAB sounds great. We have in cab cameras that we can use to record the show.

    89   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Mar 7, 5:25am  

    When they can't sell those trash mortgages, which is starting to happen. Of course, Freddie claimed they'll by crap until September, but Bernanke is trying to imply that Fred and Fran will by nothing BUT crap in the future.

    Oiy.

    90   HeadSet   2007 Mar 7, 5:27am  

    "506 sq ft 53-year old cottage for $999,000 with Los Altos schools (2665 MILLER AV, MTN VIEW). "

    This has to be a joke, right? Even has a '60's Earl Sheib painted nerdmobile parked in the driveway.

    91   HARM   2007 Mar 7, 5:27am  

    Really pissed me off. When will this crap end?

    When the last toxic loan peddler files for Chapter 11. Which should not be too long from now:

    http://ml-implode.com/

    92   Different Sean   2007 Mar 7, 5:31am  

    Peter P Says:
    There should be no price control on taxi services. Drivers should be able to charge whatever he feels like so long as the fee schedule is known before the trip.

    Yeah, that's right, same for bus trips, too. The govt bus driver should be able to haggle with every passenger for every fare as they get on, then see if people change their minds and walk. Particularly with pensioners. That would be an efficient process at every bus stop...

    The grey market London cab drivers do just that, in fact -- they offer you a fixed price to get to somewhere, which you can of course accept or decline. Of course, you're getting into an unknown, unlicensed guy's car who might sexually assault you if it's night time...

    93   OO   2007 Mar 7, 5:32am  

    I agree with trader, salute to Patrick and Ben's moral courage.

    As for seeing the bubble, as someone who witnessed the housing bubble unfold in Japan and Hong Kong, I called the top earlier than most people since I was being over-cautious. Although I was very sure that this bubble would end ugly, and it would have horrifying ramifications on social and financial fronts impacting us all, I didn't have the courage to say it publicly, or even among so-so friends. I don't want to be seen as a social outcast, so even when I hear about downright stupid housing investment decisions at a party or over a dinner exchange, I just smiled and said, well done.

    Seeing the bubble and sticking to one's position is not hard, a lot of smart guys do that. But seeing the bubble and doing something about it, even though the action looked odd and goofy at that moment, such are the extraordinary quality that Patrick and Ben have that some of us lack.

    Also, thanks to whoever that makes blog possible. If there were no blogs, the bubble could have gone on even further because ordinary people would have no venue for voicing their opinions loud and clear to audience far and near that care to listen.

    94   Different Sean   2007 Mar 7, 5:34am  

    Further, there should be no consumer protections or consumer certainty in society. That's just boring. People don't want certainty and predictability, or safe neighbourhoods, they prefer to live by their wits and try to avoid getting ripped off or robbed 100 times a day to add a frisson...

    « First        Comments 55 - 94 of 179       Last »     Search these comments

    Please register to comment:

    api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste