0
0

Spring Broke 2007!


 invite response                
2007 Apr 24, 6:40pm   20,528 views  190 comments

by HARM   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

Typical specuvestor sobering up after the party

So far, looks like SP wins the "best successor to Robert Cote's 'Silent Spring, 2006' award! (Well, technnically he has to share some of the credit with Nathaniel Welch, but his applying the term to the housing market is original.)

Aside from that story about sales taking their worst plunge in 18 years, does anyone have any local observations from their own neighborhoods? How are things holding up in your neck of the woods? Has the fear and panic started to sink in a little, or are most sellers still drinking The Amerikan Dreamâ„¢-flavored Kool-Aid?

HARM

#housing

« First        Comments 152 - 190 of 190        Search these comments

152   HARM   2007 Apr 25, 3:57pm  

@eburbed (re ACORN housing):

They were mainly educational and not allowed (as a non-profit) to steer you to one particular lender or another, but I do recall they had something called "ACORN partnership loan programs" with some local banks like BofA, Citibank & Chase-Manhattan. Basically, if you qualified as "low income" (tough to do in CA), they would shave a point off the loan, only require 3% down and waive PMI, or some such.

I'm sure the details vary by area (and the current lending environment). You might also look into the CalFHA program like Surfer-X did, whenever you're ready to start seriously looking.

153   Jimbo   2007 Apr 25, 3:57pm  

I got a good deal on a refi by going to LendingTree and doing the "three mortgages bid against each other" deal. One wheeler-dealer from ABN Amro offered me 5 1/8% on a jumbo for a 2-unit building, which the E*Trade Bank woman claimed was "illegal" since the best she would offer me was 5 3/4%. The ABN guy told me he was going to bundle up my loan with a bunch of other $1M San Francisco properties and get me single family home rates that way. I didn't complain. On the day of closing he bumped the rate up to 5 1/4% but it was still by far the best I could get, so I took it. I made sure on the closing papers that I disclosed that it was a two unit building.

My first loan, when we bought the property, I got a far worse deal. We took the mortgage broker our realtor recommended and she initially tried to ream us with a 6 1/2% loan. When my wife, who works in real estate, told her that was too high, they immediately lowered it to 6%. It didn't matter in the long run, since rates when down after that and we re-fied.

Randy, San Francisco homes are mostly going for over asking, at least according to the Alexander Clark newsletter I get every week. Maybe he is lying, I don't know, but he includes the asking and sales price for every property in The City. Last month in Noe Valley, 17 single family homes were sold, all for over asking, with an average sales price of 10% over asking. The average price is $1.5M which is up, but part of that is because the homes here are getting bigger. Quite a few larger, luxury homes have been built over the last few years and they are pushing the market up.

I said earlier that a 3/2 was $1.2M and reviewing the recent sales data I guess I have to admit that I am wrong. The last four 3/2's all sold for $1.4M. Take that for what it is worth.

154   azrob   2007 Apr 25, 4:15pm  

Everything Jimbo writes is nonsense...
building more homes does not push the market up ...anybody heard of supply and demand?
sf homes are not in general selling over asking...
a 30yr fixed rate is flat not available from anyone anywhere at the rates he is quoting. Nobody with any experience in real estate (as allegedly this mogul with a realtor@ wife is) would bother with the scam artists one finds at lending tree... what a crockpot full...

155   Jimbo   2007 Apr 25, 5:31pm  

Sorry reality is such a bummer to you azrob. I refi-ed in March 2004. I can send you a copy of the loan papers if you like.

If you want to review the data on home sales yourself, subscribe to the sfnewsletter and tell me what you think:

http://www.sfnewsletter.com/

Like I said, perhaps the guy is perpetuating some kind of elaborate scam, but he seems legitimate to me.

156   Jimbo   2007 Apr 25, 5:38pm  

My wife is not a Realtor, btw, she actually works for an insurance company, helping finance non-profit real estate. I am not necessarily endorsing Lending Tree, but I am sharing my experience with them. I thought things worked out well.

157   RaiderJeff   2007 Apr 25, 6:04pm  

I don't know if anyone has heard of Ted Lui, and what he's proposing, but I thought I'd post what I found on another board.

"TED LUI (CA assemblyman) and others on the California banking and finance committee passed a proposal Monday to use money from the Affordable Housing Bond to bail out homeowners who were “victims” of “predatory” financing and can’t make their mortgage payments. CALL Ted Lui’s office, talk to Tiffany or Mark, 916-319-2053, and call every assemblyman on the appropriations committee (that’s where it goes to a vote next), and call your local state assemblyman, tell them you don’t want your hard-earned tax dollars going to bail out buyers who overpaid and didn’t read their loan documents, tell them the affordable housing bond money was to be used for affordable housing not for bailouts, call or don’t complain when it happens!"

Here's a response that one poster received after calling Mark...

"I gave Mark every completely rational argument I could give, not screaming or yelling, just speaking in a controlled, professional voice, against this bailout idea…all he could counter was “that’s your opinion”, “I’m sorry you feel that way”, “we’ll just have to agree to disagree so there’s no point discussing this”, and he just kept going on and on about how many people were “victims” of “predatory” lending and that was what this was trying to correct. No explanation as to how such lending was predatory, why the ADULTS who signed the loan documents were not responsible for their actions, why it is my problem as a taxpayer, nor why we should reward those alleged predators by making payments that didn’t pencil for the borrowers to begin with. I hope every one on this board calls him and every other assemblyman you have time to harrass, I mean contact."

Sounds like a prick, but I'm going to call him tomorrow. Might not help, but it certainly won't hurt to give this idiot a call.

158   RaiderJeff   2007 Apr 25, 6:30pm  

Correction, the assemblyman's name is Ted Lieu.

159   azrob   2007 Apr 25, 6:43pm  

jimbo quote, "my wife, who works in real estate"

but now she doesn't work in real estate, she works in insurance? interesting.

Real estate reality isn't a bummer to me, read my previous posts. I own 3 homes free and clear, so I don't need to refi any of them. I have been an active realtor for almost 20 years, now I am less active as I don't need the money, and prefer my other business and academic endeavors.

But i reiterate, there is no way in hell you got a 5.25 fixed loan on a refi in the last 2 years, period. Perhaps you are in the 35% of people who don't know what type of loan they have. Take another good look, and see if a disclosure box about adjustment isn't marked on page one or two. Second, it wouldn't make too much sense to refi a 6% loan into that product anyways, the payment difference would take a half dozen years to offset the expenses of writing the loan. And if your going to say you got a no cost refi to fixed at 5.25% you might as well say the toothfairy brought the docs to the closing. There are enough other people on this blog who will recognize that as nonsense, not just me

160   astrid   2007 Apr 25, 10:01pm  

Not advice of any kind, but:

My experience is that agents and lenders use the standard model form without alteration. I handle my parents' contracts and they always use the cheapest services, so I always see forms that come straight out of the form book with absolutely no alteration.

On the other hand, based on a couple professors who are good transactional attorneys, they always revise their forms based on client. Including excessive language or inappropriate language can get you in trouble if you ever have to go to court.

161   DinOR   2007 Apr 26, 12:41am  

azrob,

Jimbo is what's known around here as a "reason-a-bull". To be distinguished from "perma-bull". Even though he and I disagree from time to time (he's generally flirting with the truth).

162   DinOR   2007 Apr 26, 12:44am  

Interesting snippet on the "Father of MBS"

http://www.economicpolicymonitor.com/2007/04/ranieri-first-time-in-history-median.html

HARM's "buddy" :)

163   DinOR   2007 Apr 26, 12:52am  

@Portland Girl,

No one appreciates the last few relatively rain free days more than I but we shouldn't let that go to our heads. We have problems here in Stumptown. I certainly hope that with the exodus of some major employers and a city council that is outright HOSTILE toward business that you're not implying somehow our "special-ness" will provide insulation from a NATIONAL BUBBLE? (Yes I said national).

The last time we had 2 (let alone 3) decent days in a row would have been in September. Enjoy! :(

164   DinOR   2007 Apr 26, 1:01am  

Raider Jeff,

Too funny! From now on, any time I get caught with my pants down I'll simply say "I'm sorry you feel that way. We'll just have to agree to disagree so there's no point discussing this" and see if my clients let me off the hook?

You will wish me luck, won't you?

165   SFWoman   2007 Apr 26, 1:22am  

I just got an interesting rental observation here in SF. A friend who owns a lovely small building on Nob Hill just renovated a unit in her building that was vacant for the first time in about 25 years. She put in a nice kitchen (yes, stainless/shiny granite), redid the floors, painted. The unit has Golden Gate Bridge to Alcatraz views and is on a very good part of Nob Hill. No parking comes with it.

She said that she received almost no interest in the unit, where as a year and a half ago, when a similar unit she had came up the place was swarmed with applicants.

She told me she had to lower the rent and practically agree to fix the woman up with guys from the yacht club to get her to agree to rent the place. She only had a couple other people come through and look at the place, no one else made an offer to rent it. She said it was hugely different from last year, yet she listed the place in the same listing places as the other apartment.

166   DinOR   2007 Apr 26, 1:37am  

SFWoman,

Welcome back!

Btw, that makes almost NO sense? Sounds like someone should have snatched that up if for nothing else than the view? Has shiny and dense material gone out of fashion?

167   Randy H   2007 Apr 26, 1:37am  

Jimbo

My data is coming from the largest agency dealing with +$2.5m homes in SF, and probably the 2nd biggest in the sub $2.5m market. They had a red hot Feb., strong March, but April is showing a lot of under-asking deals and slowing volume. In fact, April seems like the door got slammed there are so few deals. I believe a lot of this is because of the obscenely high asking prices. Also, word is these guys are severely vetting seller clients and not taking on any who aren't willing to "be flexible" on price, or who won't set a market asking price to start with. They're also clearing out old clients who've been too long on market and won't drop price.

168   skibum   2007 Apr 26, 1:50am  

If you want to review the data on home sales yourself, subscribe to the sfnewsletter and tell me what you think:

http://www.sfnewsletter.com/

Like I said, perhaps the guy is perpetuating some kind of elaborate scam, but he seems legitimate to me.

Jimbo,
I can't let this one slip by. The supposedly "legitimate" site you refer to is a realtor (TM) and his spinmeister newsletter/blog. How can you call this guy on the up-and-up? Yes, I didn't subscribe to his newsletter, but (a) I don't have a realtor (TM) 's MLS number, and (b) I don't want to pay $100/month to hear his musings about SF real estate.

169   FormerAptBroker   2007 Apr 26, 1:57am  

skibum Says:

> I can’t let this one slip by. The supposedly “legitimate”
> site http://www.sfnewsletter.com/
> you refer to is a realtor â„¢ and his spinmeister
> newsletter/blog. How can you call this guy on the up-and-up?

This guy is basically saying “all you Realtors should pay me since I’m so good at spinning data to trick people in to buying”…

170   FormerAptBroker   2007 Apr 26, 1:59am  

SFWoman Says:

> I just got an interesting rental observation here in SF…

It’s good to have SFWoman back from “Spring Break”…

171   skibum   2007 Apr 26, 2:02am  

This guy is basically saying “all you Realtors should pay me since I’m so good at spinning data to trick people in to buying”…

Exactamundo! He's got a slick site, I'll admit. If I were a lowly newbie realtor, I'd consider paying for this Alpha realtor's spinletter and "blog." "Hey, if I can't come up with the fake stories and data, maybe I'll just let someone else do it for me!"

172   skibum   2007 Apr 26, 2:17am  

SFWoman,

Good to hear from you! Were the yacht club dates written into the lease agreement? Maybe it was the clause right after the "feed the squirrels" clause? :)

173   RaiderJeff   2007 Apr 26, 2:36am  

"Too funny! From now on, any time I get caught with my pants down I’ll simply say “I’m sorry you feel that way. We’ll just have to agree to disagree so there’s no point discussing this” and see if my clients let me off the hook? You will wish me luck, won’t you?"

LOL!!! How's it going DinOR.

Yep, I'm going to use those words next year when the time comes to pay taxes.

174   RaiderJeff   2007 Apr 26, 2:45am  

"I sent Ted Liu and email as well. Do these things help? I haven’t been in the habit of “writing my representative”. How many emails before they start to take notice? 1000? 10000? 100000??"

Good justme, I'm glad you took the time to email, I did as well. I don't know what'll take to get through to these people, but I'm sure going to take note of who is doing what now because someone is going to pay later when elections roll around. What else can I do?

175   Peter P   2007 Apr 26, 2:53am  

New thread: Housing Un-American Activities Committee

176   HARM   2007 Apr 26, 3:22am  

Interesting post, DinOR --thanks. I didn't know there was one such person. I just assumed MBSs were something the banksters or GSEs gradually cooked up, while thinking of new ways to avoid having to do proper underwriting.

177   LowlySmartRenter   2007 Apr 26, 3:36am  

"for the first time in history the median home sales price in the United States is likely to decline." Is that true? Hard to believe it is the first time *ever*

The homes closest to me are priced from about 900k to 2.4m. Nothing has sold in the last 3 months, according to ZipRealty.

I think the property that sums up what is happening out here in San Remote is this one:

Price Increased: 12/14/06 -- $744,900 to $775,000
Price Reduced: 01/08/07 -- $775,000 to $739,900
Price Reduced: 04/09/07 -- $765,000 to $749,000

I'm getting queasy on this rollercoaster....

178   SFWoman   2007 Apr 26, 3:40am  

skibum,

I don't think the fixing-up-with-sailors was in the lease, but my friend swears that was part of the agreement. She's bummed because the last time she rented an apartment the market was extremely overheated, and now it seems to be cooling for rentals, although neither she nor I had seen anything in the papers about a cooling rental market here.

She does legal stuff for TICs and she said they are still very hot in SF because they are priced a lot lower than condos and now you can get separate loans on them.

FAB,

I spent part of spring break on the Kona Coast (very easy vacation with kids, expensive food) and a realtor there, who said he was the island's top producer, said the market is starting to tank and he thinks it's in for a major correction. Interestingly, I hadn't heard much about the earthquake there this past winter, but there was a fair amount of damage because of it.

179   Peter P   2007 Apr 26, 3:48am  

Ooh, SFWoman is back! Was the expensive food at least good?

180   Claire   2007 Apr 26, 5:03am  

Anyone know what the Danville area is like/doing?

181   danville woman   2007 Apr 26, 5:27am  

Claire

Hard to tell. It looks as if asking prices in Alamo have gone up this Spring. I'm tracking a few houses there and they are not selling. I went to a few Open Houses on Sunday and things were quiet.

I checked the Sold homes in the local paper in San Ramon and there seems to have been lots of sales in the past month in the lower price points, however, the prices at the Bridges seem a little softer.

182   Claire   2007 Apr 26, 6:34am  

Danville woman,

Thanks for the reply - what's the rental market like too?

Also, do you know if forclosures are on the rise there?

183   astrid   2007 Apr 26, 7:08am  

SFWoman,

Welcome back! We really missed you (not in a creepy or pathetic way though).

184   Jimbo   2007 Apr 26, 8:01am  

The newsletter is free. If you want to redistribute, you have to pay.

But i reiterate, there is no way in hell you got a 5.25 fixed loan on a refi in the last 2 years, period.

Perhaps you did not see where I said that I refi-ed in March of 2004. That was more than two years ago. I paid 3/4 of a point to do the refi. It lowered our monthly payment $350 and has already paid for itself. I think it took about two years to pay back the refi cost. We plan on keeping the place as rental property when we move up, so it made sense to do the refi, even if it would have taken longer.

My wife helps finance real estate construction. I know you in the industry have all these gradations of what being in "real estate" means, but to the rest of us, it is all real estate. She is certainly familiar with what the going rate for borrowing money is.

185   Jimbo   2007 Apr 26, 8:10am  

Also, azrob, a few months back FAB was telling us that he got a 10 year fixed 4 1/4% mortgage. So while mine was good, it is certainly not the best one out there.

http://patrick.net/wp/?p=399

186   danville woman   2007 Apr 26, 1:12pm  

Claire

We pay $1995/month for a 3+ bedroom townhouse in Danville. The house has an outdated kitchen but a nice little yard. We started renting this place in June 2005. Our landlord hasn't raised our rent but I have heard that rents are going up.
Lots of nice places to rent in San Ramon, I hear. School system is good and the places there are newer. Having a dog presented some difficulty renting. If you have no pets it will be easier for you.
Check out the local newspaper - San Ramon Valley Times - Hunting for a place is very time consuming and frustrating. Hang in there !

187   surfer-x   2007 Apr 26, 6:15pm  

CalHFA

188   Claire   2007 Apr 27, 1:03am  

Thanks Danville woman:-)

189   azrob   2007 Apr 29, 1:40pm  

you quote a loan you got 3 years ago on here for comparison purposes jimbo? wow! i bought a new car for $2000 too! I am much better at getting deal than you! oh yeah that was in 1964...

190   Jimbo   2007 Apr 30, 4:07pm  

Uh, we had a big long discussion about various places we had gotten loans and where we had gotten good and bad financing from. Remember this from HelloKitty?

The best loans I ever got were from Wells Fargo and Countrywide going DIRECT -no broker-. I made them match rates by faxing each other the Good Faith Estimate from the other guy.

They hated me for it but put up with me. Wells Fargo beat countrywide and my best loan ever was 4.375 APR amortizing 3/1 ARM (reset in 3 years).

Yet somehow this deal did not raise your ire. You are an odd bird.

« First        Comments 152 - 190 of 190        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste