0
0

Why some market regulation is necessary and good for the economy


               
2007 Jul 30, 4:16am   16,160 views  125 comments

by HARM   follow (0)  

We've had many posts on Laissez-Faire, anarchic capitalism vs. regulated markets here before, and I'm sure we'll have more in the future. Just saw this gem today (nod to Ben Jones) and wanted to share it with you. Here is a succinct real-world example of why I believe that some government regulation of credit/capital markets is necessary and good for the economy, and why private firms cannot always be trusted to "self-regulate" all the time.

Fund manager's fun sailing away

John Devaney, the CEO of United Capital Markets, a fund that specializes in buying and selling bonds that are backed by the mortgage payments, particularly adjustable rate subprime mortgages, has put his 142-foot yacht "Positive Carry" up for sale, according to a yacht broker's Web site.

Devaney's fund has run into trouble lately. A spokesman for the firm told Reuters on July 3 that it had stopped honoring request from some of its investors for redemptions, or withdrawal, of investments

"The consumer has to be an idiot to take on those loans," he said. "But it has been one of our best-performing investments."

Discuss, enjoy...
HARM

#housing

Comments 1 - 18 of 125       Last »     Search these comments

1   Bork   2007 Jul 30, 5:36am  

Not so sure who is an idiot in this case. The very fact that Mr. Devaney cannot afford his yacht clearly indicates that he was hoping that the subprime loan music will last forever which is obviously defies the common sense. On the other hand subprime borrowers have a good chance that their distressed baaah-ing will be heard by the government. No mercy for the private fund manager though (predatory lending anyone?).

2   HARM   2007 Jul 30, 5:42am  

@Bork,

No kidding. I wonder, did Mr. Devaney recognize the irony of his "idiot" comment after the fact? (I doubt it)

3   HeadSet   2007 Jul 30, 5:44am  

Maybe Devaney himself paid for the yacht with a no-doc home equity extraction.

4   DinOR   2007 Jul 30, 5:56am  

HARM,

I swear it was like just a year ago someone was doing an article on what a genius this guy was and look at his pretty new yacht! I'll try to google this @$$clown and see what I come up with.

My how things change.

5   Steveoh   2007 Jul 30, 5:58am  

Interesting. So is the contrast between today and this 2004 profile.

http://tinyurl.com/33gvj8

A few quotes:

(In early 2004) “…this man was running his business out of a three-bedroom residential house in Florida.”
“…UCM moved out of the residential house and into a Key Biscayne’s largest office building; the company owns a 142-foot corporate yacht with a crew of nine, a Gulf Stream G400 helicopter and a corporate jet.”

“So it seems that, against all the odds, a firm that started life as a one-man outfit only five years ago has become one of the fastest-growing broker-dealers in a market plagued by headline risk and a conspicuous lack of liquidity”

“The broker-dealer has 18 employees, including professionals poached from Wall Street—Devaney’s cohort on the trading desk is a former ABS trader at Bear Stearns, Sean Kirk.”

“…as a move to add diversity to the firm and balance the risks in UCM’s other markets, UCM also launched a collateralized mortgage obligation (CMO) trading desk based in California run by Dan Steuer, formerly of Countrywide Securities.”

6   DinOR   2007 Jul 30, 6:06am  

Steveoh,

Thanks, nice find. I'm positive they ran the exact same photograph when running the "genius" article a few short months back! I never forget a smug face. Not so smug NOW are ya!

(What is the market for ridiculous yachts these days anyway?)

7   HARM   2007 Jul 30, 6:07am  

Amazing how interconnected the housing bubble-blog world is. It looks like Aaron Krowne (of ML-Implode-O-Meter fame) has bought and taken possession of Casey's site:

http://iamfacingforeclosure.com/history.html

8   Steveoh   2007 Jul 30, 6:16am  

"...I believe that some government regulation of credit/capital markets is necessary and good for the economy, and why private firms cannot always be trusted to “self-regulate” all the time.
"

Absolutely!

But who is in a position to regulate the (private) Fed? They are the definitive *puppet masters* of this whole mess IMHO, and in no danger of being labeled philanthropists

DinOR,

I had that same deja vu feeling. And yes, that is the same (not sure what to do with my hands) picture.

9   DennisN   2007 Jul 30, 6:36am  

"Devaney’s cohort on the trading desk is a former ABS trader at Bear Stearns, Sean Kirk"

Now there's a really good recommendation for you! A Bear Stearns whiz kid!

10   Steveoh   2007 Jul 30, 7:09am  

Sorry of the slightly OT post, but I’m a recovering boat-nut and wondered what this yacht, “Positive Carry” looked like inside. Nice!

http://tinyurl.com/32t9ah

11   Bruce   2007 Jul 30, 7:38am  

Interiors and other pictures of 'Positive Carry' at

http://www.trinityyachts.com/141positivecarry.asp

12   HARM   2007 Jul 30, 7:49am  

But who is in a position to regulate the (private) Fed?

Good question. The President appoints the Fed Chief and the Senate confirms and (in theory) oversees him/her. However, as you pointed out, the Fed isn't a true state "Central Bank" under direct public control, as is the case in most other countries. Personally, I would like to see the private Fed abolished, it's policy of interest rate manipulation (mainly for Wall Street insiders' gain) ended, and its (mostly neglected) "policing" powers passed over to the Treasury Dept --a real government agency. See this previous thread for more details if you're curious.

13   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Jul 30, 8:16am  

Totally off topic, but it appears fancy bikes are getting pawned to keep FBs afloat a little while longer now :

http://tinyurl.com/2x3q43

I don't know how long a bike is going to stave of foreclosure.

14   a_friend_of_patrick   2007 Jul 30, 8:27am  

OT: check out Jim Cramer's Mad money TV show on CNBC today. He is talking real estate among other things... also check this: http://tinyurl.com/yvrwml

15   HARM   2007 Jul 30, 8:30am  

Sadly hilarious new sob-story from a San Diego FB:

http://www.voiceofsandiego.org/articles/2007/07/30/news/02homeshare073007.txt

...And with just a year under his belt in a commission-based business like real estate, Oh knew his income made it impossible to buy alone. So, two years ago, he and two college friends went in together on a three-bedroom, two-bath condo in Pacific Beach.

His friends were dating each other, had been for several years. Oh moved into the second bedroom, and they rented out the third. They wrote up a contract and each has one-third ownership of the condo.

But then, a few months ago, the couple broke up.

...Oh said his living costs quadrupled when he bought his share of the condo unit, but it was worth it to live where he wanted to live and work toward some equity.

"You just have to really make sure everyone's on the same page," Oh said. "If one person or multiple people want to get out of the property, a few years down the line, it's a he-said-she-said. What if you lose your job? What if you get married? It sounds bizarre, but stuff happens."

What's so 'bizarre' about people losing a job, getting married or wanting to move?

My take: gives new meaning to the term "showing your 'Oh' face"!

16   Peter P   2007 Jul 30, 9:29am  

There should be regulations to ensure transparency and integrity in the market.

There should also be regulations against the misuse of democracy. Just look at NIMBYism.

Finally, there should be regulations against the creation of regulations that interfere with the market.

17   Brent   2007 Jul 30, 10:08am  

Do you think Mr. Devaney envisioned an army of idiots leading him to world domination, or is he sincerely surprised that people were so eager to give their lives for him?

18   HARM   2007 Jul 30, 10:15am  

My regulation proposal to cleanup --and hopefully prevent a redux-- of our most recent (and by all accounts, largest ever) housing bubble:

--No more NINJAs, I/Os, neg-ams or hybrids thereof. Period.
If you cannot verify a borrower's income or collateral (W-2, 1099 or from self-employment), then don't make the loan. NINJAs, neg-ams & I/Os are little more than wealth transference schemes to move piles of money from sheeple to uber-wealthy for about 99.99% of the population. For the remaining .01% of Wall Street wizards who used to use them for rate arbitrage or convenience, you'll learn to cope --just like the rest of us hoi-polloi.

--No taxpayer funded bailouts of lenders, hedge funds, FBs, fraudsters or the ignorant/clueless. None of these groups is completely beyond (at least) partial guilt for what happened, and subsidizing this behavior will only get us more of it.

--No more rate-fixing/manipulation by the Fed. In fact, and end to the Fed as we know it (see my 2:49pm post). Ditto for the GSEs: time for some "privatization" of the best kind (for taxpayers).

--No more tax breaks for flippers, 2nd homes or houses you've lived in less than 5 years of continuous occupancy.

--Want an open-borders anything-goes immigration policy? Fine, but you also give up the right to oppose residential construction ANYWHERE except federal & state parkland. Don't like that 2,000 unit high-rise apartment for "guest workers" obscuring your lovely view of the Bay? Tough shit, Marinite --those 15 million "guest workers" (including your own gardener & "nanny") carry a big price tag, and it's your turn to start paying it.

--And end to Prop. 13 and S.O.S. type tax-transference schemes that give land-owning corporations, wealthy Trustafarians, and Boomers/Silent gens a free ride at younger buyers' expense. Want lower property taxes? Petition your local pol to drop (or eliminate) the millage rates --for EVERYONE.

(I won't speculate about the chance of any of the above actually passing a REIC bought-and-paid-for government, but at least you know where I stand ;-) )

Comments 1 - 18 of 125       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste