0
0

Protecting Your Savings


 invite response                
2008 Jan 27, 5:53am   46,859 views  390 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (59)   💰tip   ignore  

safe

With the government now mounting a full-scale assault against savers by cutting interest rates, attempting to keep housing prices unreasonably high, and even handing out raw cash (do I hear helicopters?) what can responsible people do to protect what they've earned?

Some options and problems with those options:

  • CD's: fully taxable, low rates (under 4% now), some risk FDIC won't cover bank failures
  • Treasury Bills: no state tax, less risk, but even lower rates (2.5%)
  • Gold: pays no interest, price very hard to predict. Lost value for 20 years after last peak.
  • Stock: falling prices in falling economy as earnings decline
  • Housing: massively overvalued, likely to keep falling for years
  • Commercial property: also seems to be on downside of a bubble
  • Commodities: falling prices as economy slows

One bright point: if you're saving to buy a house, your cash gets more valuable as house prices fall. And you get interest on top of that.

Patrick

#housing

« First        Comments 383 - 390 of 390        Search these comments

383   northernvirginiarenter   2008 Jan 31, 6:29am  

On topic

Jack Johnny and Jim makes for an interesting store of wealth, similiar to gold, no? Inflation hedge, easy to trade, maybe improves with a little age, and with the added benefit of actually being able to drink it. Is one better off buying and laying down cases of the three B's expensive quality (Blantons, Basil Hayden, & Bookers) or a larger quantity of the rotgut like Evan Williams stuff?

384   PermaRenter   2008 Jan 31, 8:48am  

Countrywide Financial Corp. sent letters to 122,000 customers last week telling them they could no longer borrow against their credit lines because the total debt on the home exceeded the market value of the property. ... The move by Countrywide ... is part of a pullback by lenders nationwide on home equity loans ... with new evidence of sinking home values, many lenders are requiring that homeowners maintain a much larger percentage of equity in their homes as a cushion against financial problems.

385   Randy H   2008 Jan 31, 10:59pm  

I'm admittedly not a connoisseur of quality rotgut. I just rely upon others to point me towards fine bourbons.

I have heard a reasonable set of arguments that wine, if properly cellared, is a far better store of value than gold. It has global appeal, definitely improves with age (assuming you are storing the appropriate sorts), and is of course consumable at any point. Wine also has timeless appeal -- it is a fixture throughout western cultures down through history.

Hmmm, maybe I'll start the US Wine Depository Corp. and get myself a CNBC infomercial slot.

386   Peter P   2008 Feb 1, 5:43am  

Hmmm, maybe I’ll start the US Wine Depository Corp. and get myself a CNBC infomercial slot.

Perhaps something like shares of fine wine stored in a Zurich vaultcellar? Just in case the government decides to confiscate alcoholic beverages. :)

387   Claire   2008 Feb 2, 1:01am  

FYI - if you want to do some troll bashing it seems there is one on Patrick's forum.

388   DJM   2008 Feb 10, 2:08am  

"Which brokerages are seen as the safest? I also wonder if SPIC has ever been stress-tested like FDIC."

The SIPC is a private insurer. It's woefully undercapitalised. I don't think we've ever tested the system with a large failure. All that said, unless your broker has committed outright fraud, in theory you will still get your assets returned to you (and your account moved to another broker). However, given that there may be short sales and clearing failures "in flight" when a failure occurs, it's possibly there won't be enough of whatever you think you own if held in street name, and that is where the SIPC is supposed to step in. As for which brokers are the safest, that is hard to say. Schwab appears to have avoided the sub-prime mess, whereas Merrill, Citi, and UBS are neck deep in it. When in doubt, you can just check the stock price chart for a financial institution - it tells you what the market knows about its solvency.

389   DJM   2008 Feb 10, 2:30am  

"It should go without saying but paying off debt at this point makes the most sense to me."

Call me crazy but I am doing the opposite. I'm refi-ing my house at 4.75% fixed rate.

How many people here are talking about the fed printing money, runaway commodity prices, massive inflation, yada yada yada? Well, what effect do you think all that will have on long-dated fixed-rate debt instruments? If it comes to pass, it will not be good news for the "lender" side of those instruments.

Of course there is the opposite argument, we are in for massive deflation, the price of everything is going down led by house prices, interest rates are going to zero, US = Japan circa 1990, 1930s all over again, cash is king, yada yada yada. Well if that happens, long-dated fixed-rate debt instruments will rise, at least to a point. (The situation is asymmetric - there is a limit to how low interest rates can go, whereas there's no limit to how high they can go.) And there's the kicker: a US-style mortgage gives you a call option to pay off the debt any time you like, so if we head down the deflation path you can pay off the debt rather than accept zero return on your cash.

390   DJM   2008 Feb 10, 3:06am  

"Reuven is the only real victim here. Reuven did what he thought responsible Americans should do: save money. Reuven’s losing money left and right. He can’t barely keep ahead with inflation with CDs, and has to worry about banks going bust."

If you are doing better than just living paycheck to paycheck while hopelessly in debt for useless bling, you are one of the "rich" who is not paying his fair share. Don't expect any sympathy from the proles or their media shills.

"CD rates are shitty low once again. 3.5% average per bankrate ZIRP is killing me, bring back Volcker is he still alive?"

Volcker is very much alive and a strong critic of what's been going on. (Note to self - smoke more cigars.) I am still stinging from the last time rates were driven below inflation, and I'll be damned if I let myself be screwed again. I guess this is the point - money will be driven out of investments that yield a negative real return and into something else. Last time it was houses, and to a lesser extent stocks. This time it could be commodities, or (just a guess) real assets that can produce exportable commodities (farmland, timberland, coal mines).

« First        Comments 383 - 390 of 390        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions