0
0

Investing in the Japanese market ETF (EWJ) or in stocks of individual Japanese companies...


 invite response                
2011 Mar 29, 11:20am   6,571 views  35 comments

by American in Japan   ➕follow (1)   💰tip   ignore  

Having been back in Japan 2 weeks now, I will finally bring up this topic. (Before anyone blasts me, I didn't even view investments for 3 days).

Would investment in the ETF (EWJ) be wise right now? How about any individual companies?

EWJ is an iShares ETF which approximates the Nikkei-225. Note: It is affected by not only their main market index but also by the yen/dollar exchange rate as the fund is given in US dollars.

http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=EWJ

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=EWJ+Historical+Prices

There are others:
Japan ETF options include (long):

WisdomTree Japan Small Cap Dividend (NYSEArca:DFJ)
iShares S&P/TOPIX 150 (NYSEArca:ITF)
SPDR Russell/Nomura Small Cap (NYSEArca:JSC)
iShares MSCI Japan Small Cap (NYSEArca:SCJ)
SPDR Russell/Nomura PRIME (NYSEArca:JPP)
WisdomTree Japan Hedged Equity (NYSEArca:DXJ)
ProShares Ultra MSCI Japan (NYSEArca:EZJ)

ETF Trends comments and gives a list of Japan related ETFs:

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Taking-A-Bold-Move-With-Japan-ETFTrends-1251553476.html?x=0&.v=1

#investing

Comments 1 - 35 of 35        Search these comments

1   American in Japan   2011 Mar 29, 11:39am  

Warren Buffet felt Japan stocks were a strong buy soon after the disaster:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/21/warren-buffett-japan-pres_n_838281.html

But was he already invested in Japan before saying this and merely creating a "dump" opportunity?

Also if you can trust Barron's analysis (fairly valued now):

http://blogs.barrons.com/focusonfunds/2011/03/29/sp-sees-japan-as-fairly-valued-now-suggests-broad-based-fund-exposure/?mod=BOLBlog

Seeking Alpha:
http://seekingalpha.com/article/258296-japan-is-a-different-type-of-dip?source=yahoo

2   anonymous   2011 Mar 29, 1:07pm  

American in Japan says

But was he already invested in Japan before saying this and merely creating a “dump” opportunity?

No, Berkshire was not invested in Japan, and no, he was not trying to manipulate the market.

I challenge you to find examples of Buffett promoting an investment of Berkshire and then selling it shortly thereafter. Come on. Give it your best shot.

3   American in Japan   2011 Mar 29, 1:20pm  

Not saying either way. It is a genuine question. My tone sometimes seems sarcastic when it isn'tm so I should only indicate (sarcasm) like this...LoL!

I do like to get multiple sources for information in investing opportunities.

4   anonymous   2011 Mar 29, 2:31pm  

The article itself answers your questions:

Buffett said ... "If I owned Japanese stocks, I would certainly not be selling them."

Buffett did not disclose any holdings in Japan on Monday, and Berkshire Hathaway's annual report did not show any major investments there.

As well, Buffett's history is that he very rarely gives any kind of investment advice more specific than "buy index funds and hold on to them". Alluding to attractive opportunities in Japan or (a few years ago) "Buy America, I am" is about the extent of it. A very rare exception was comments during the depths of the finance crisis that made it clear that he felt Wells Fargo was attractive - comments made when WFC was near its lowest point! He was certainly not saying that in order to sell as he continued to buy WFC throughout that period and it is Berkshire's largest holding today.

I don't know why people would even think this stuff, given Buffett's comments and performance since the 1950s.

5   American in Japan   2011 Mar 29, 6:42pm  

@oddhack

Thanks... especially for the Rational Walk link. I don't take much at face value and I was unware of this.
I think Warren Buffet is one of the great investors of our age BTW.
Anyway I have invested some in the Japanese market. I'd like to hear what others think...

6   pkennedy   2011 Mar 30, 4:28am  

Picked up TM and HMC the other day. I was looking at some of their other stocks, but these are the only two that I know as a Brand and would buy myself. They looked to be a decent deal. I'm not sure how much the recovery effort will effect them, I'm guessing the Japanese people will figure out how to keep the lights on in this places.

Btw, what kind of power wastage goes on in Japan? Are they pretty conservative in their usage, or if push came to shove, could they reduce their electrical usage? Eg Compact florescent vs incandescent, does anyone use them? Heating/Cooking? Insulation of homes?

7   theoakman   2011 Mar 30, 7:06am  

I was long Japan before the earthquake and bought in again afterwards. I'm long because any collapse in the bond market is going to cause an exit out of bonds and into equities. The fact that Japan will probably have to monetize debt sooner from this disaster only ensures this outcome comes sooner. Japan's stocks will go up in the face of a crisis, not because of a strong economy.

8   American in Japan   2011 Mar 30, 3:16pm  

>Btw, what kind of power wastage goes on in Japan? Are they pretty conservative in their usage, or if push came to shove, could they reduce their electrical usage? Eg Compact florescent vs incandescent, does anyone use them? Heating/Cooking? Insulation of homes?

They are wasteful with the big neon signs (even though I like them). Even worse, many offices usually waste energy via the A/C. Up to 78 F in the winter and down to 72 F in the summer in many cases (should be the opposite). Home insulation is poor or non-existant. One bright note is that Japan is on the cutting edge of light emitting diode developlment and use (low energy).

10   American in Japan   2011 Mar 31, 2:35am  

>In 2009, Japan started offering an incentive for Nisei to leave the country. These Nissei, mostly from South America (esp. Brazil) did mostly the lower paying, dirty and dangerous jobs. Like Construction, Janitorial Work, Disaster Cleanup, etc.

Correct.

@thunderlips11:

>Uyoku Groups have kept WW2 war crimes out of Japanese Textbooks for 60 years. And there are millions of Japanese who share these sentiments, even if they are not formal members or even remotely sympathizers with the Ultraright.

Doing my best to teach the truth on WW2 but this is another topic for another thread....

11   American in Japan   2011 Mar 31, 11:27am  

One thing for sure. The Nikkei was one of the worst long-term investments you could have made in 1989.
The Nikkei 225 Hit its all-time of ¥38,957.00 on December 29th, 1989. If you had bought then, your investment would *still* be down over 75% over 21 years later! Any lesson to be learned here?

12   pkennedy   2011 Mar 31, 2:17pm  

Well as for energy, it sounds like if push came to shove they could modify their habits a bit and make up for some of the lost power. At least enough to keep their offices/factories online. Wearing a sweater indoors for the next couple of months or doing without a/c.

As far as money, they don't need all that much 500B over 5 years. It's a huge sum for sure. But they've got close to 1T in US treasury debt. They can print their own money. Their debt might be high, but obviously they can support that level, adding a bit more to it to the tune of 100B every year for 5 more years isn't going to be a tipping point for them, likely the last decade + the next 5 years of natural building of that debt will be far worse.

And money will flow in from overseas as family from abroad helps out. I know of several people who did this during the last disaster.

13   FortWayne   2011 Mar 31, 2:40pm  

We invested some money into TM a bit to diversify for a long term. Hopefully it works out.

14   American in Japan   2011 Mar 31, 9:46pm  

I bought Toyota stock last year (after it had been hammered down)... the only individual company stock I had bought in years!

15   theoakman   2011 Mar 31, 11:42pm  

American in Japan says

One thing for sure. The Nikkei was one of the worst long-term investments you could have made in 1989.

The Nikkei 225 Hit its all-time of ¥38,957.00 on December 29th, 1989. If you had bought then, your investment would *still* be down over 75% over 21 years later! Any lesson to be learned here?

What most investors fail to realize is that the lifetime of a bear market rarely lasts more than 20 years. Getting in on Japan, you are buying low. 10 years from now, it will be looked upon as a no brainer.

16   anonymous   2011 Apr 3, 6:37pm  

American in Japan says

The Nikkei 225 Hit its all-time of ¥38,957.00 on December 29th, 1989. If you had bought then, your investment would *still* be down over 75% over 21 years later! Any lesson to be learned here?

One lesson is that it's probably a bad idea to buy an index whose P/E ratio is nearly 80.

17   zzyzzx   2011 Apr 4, 2:14am  

American in Japan says

They are wasteful with the big neon signs (even though I like them). Even worse, many offices usually waste energy via the A/C. Up to 78 F in the winter and down to 72 F in the summer in many cases (should be the opposite). Home insulation is poor or non-existant. One bright note is that Japan is on the cutting edge of light emitting diode developlment and use (low energy).

Home insulation is poor to non-existant in Japan? How did that happen?

18   theoakman   2011 Apr 4, 2:31am  

I think a lot of people are going to miss the bottom fishing opportunity in Japan. Beark market bottoms typically come when everyone least expects it. I called for the bottom a few months ago. Obviously, the Earthquake may have shifted expectations but I do believe a real bottom is somewhere in the near future.

19   FortWayne   2011 Apr 4, 6:14am  

for us the difficulty in investing into Japanese markets comes from the fact that we know too little about Japanese companies. TM is the only one we know specifically, which is why we invested into their stock. But anything else out there would be basically a gamble for us.

Maybe AmericanInJapan can mention which products in Japan are flying off the shelves.

20   American in Japan   2011 Apr 4, 11:36am  

@ChrisLA

LoL!

Potassium iodine, mineral water (and a few weeks ago AA batteries).

@thunderlips11

Agreed.

@zzyzzx

Insulation- electricity costs here are among the world's highest (even before 3-11). I chalk it up to the (often) illogical group think here.

21   American in Japan   2011 Apr 4, 11:37am  

I understand better now with Toyota. It seems that some of the parts are produced only in Japan, so this factor is the "rate determinig step" to have more cars completed in the US assembly plants.

Anyway, I rarely buy into individual companies anymore, but rather (fixed) indexes. The problem for me is I realized that not only can individual companies fail the "regular way" (bad business model, etc.) but sometimes even with a successful company, the president can take the money ut of the company and run.

22   American in Japan   2011 Apr 6, 10:34am  

Good reading here:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/markets/8383373/Japan-earthquake-The-companies-most-affected-by-the-disaster.html#

I still hold EWJ, but I have reduced my position.

Has anyone bought EWJ since the disaster?

24   FortWayne   2011 Apr 8, 1:31am  

I'm coming to conclusion that it's just better to buy individual stocks, seems a lot cheaper per trade.

25   American in Japan   2011 Apr 8, 1:41am  

ETFs can be bought like individual company stocks. (unless I am missing something here...)

26   FortWayne   2011 Apr 8, 1:57am  

American in Japan says

ETFs can be bought like individual company stocks. (unless I am missing something here…)

sorry, I wasn't specific. I meant cheaper than mutual funds as cost per trade, etc...

27   FortWayne   2011 Apr 8, 5:59am  

American in Japan says

@ChrisLA

LoL!

Potassium iodine, mineral water (and a few weeks ago AA batteries).

You are right, I'm trying bit too early. KI is not exactly a great long term investment.

28   American in Japan   2011 Apr 8, 9:59am  

>sorry, I wasn’t specific. I meant cheaper than mutual funds as cost per trade, etc…

Mutual funds generally have higher "management fees" then fixed annuities or ETFs,
I could be wrong if I say all mutual funds, but research the costs.

29   American in Japan   2011 Apr 16, 10:05am  

EWJ climbing up again the last 4 days…

30   theoakman   2011 Apr 17, 9:37am  

For the record, in the past month, Jim Rogers, Marc Faber, and James Grant have all suggested there is huge value to be had in Japanese equities.

31   American in Japan   2011 Apr 20, 10:17am  

A graph of the Nikkei 225 (in yen). It is still well below its 1989 high (around 1985 levels):

32   FortWayne   2011 Apr 20, 1:20pm  

I'm not sure which companies and sectors to invest into here. outside of TM I'm pretty much in the dark.

33   American in Japan   2011 Jun 14, 11:09am  

There are ETFs in which you can invest in the market as a whole…
EWJ

34   American in Japan   2011 Jun 15, 9:28pm  

Lol! I know what you mean!

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste