2
0

Why pseudo-rationalists hate the rich


 invite response                
2012 Dec 8, 3:28am   69,807 views  190 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

Because they think they are the greatest, yet they are rarely rich. Therefore, they try to invent reasons to explain why wealth beyond a certain point (i.e. a level attainable by their professions) should be re-distributed away.

The consequence of accepting that some people "deserve" their "excess" wealth is too severe for their egos to bear.

« First        Comments 181 - 190 of 190        Search these comments

181   leo707   2012 Dec 14, 2:35am  

Peter P says

That we are cute?

In is that your theories make you cute.

But then again, the same cute theories make you horrifying if you get the power to inact them.

182   Peter P   2012 Dec 14, 2:44am  

leo707 says

Peter P says

That we are cute?

In is that your theories make you cute.

But then again, the same cute theories make you horrifying if you get the power to inact them.

Only if you reject Utopia. ;-)

183   Dan8267   2012 Dec 14, 2:54am  

Peter P says

It is not a tax, it is a fee. There is also competitions.

First, Fees are taxes just under a different name.

Second, there is no real competition as banking is largely a cartel.

Third, pure capitalism will never yield 0% transaction costs because

Only centralized control can reduce wasteful siphoning to 0%.

184   Dan8267   2012 Dec 14, 2:56am  

leo707 says

justme says

Peter P says

It is not a tax, it is a fee. There is also competitions.

Oh, please. VISA/MC and Discover is a duopoly with no real competition, plus all the banks like their cut of the fees, too. Who's to stop them?

Stop complaining, your free to start your own credit card company! It's a free market right?

http://www.youtube.com/embed/mL-AFSAIln0

185   Tenpoundbass   2012 Dec 19, 10:51pm  

121212 says

Fool, go divide your own party.

Peter P and I are joining mental telepathy powers to divide 121212's party. "wooooooo wooooooo woooooo"

(Opening one eye, to see if it's working)

186   MisdemeanorRebel   2012 Dec 20, 12:14am  

Peter P says

Who was behind the French Revolution?

The Poor and Middle Classes, who were being taxed to death to give Nobles and the Bourgeoisie salaried positions for doing nothing. The rich also voted (yes, France had Estates, but only for the Rich and High Clergy) themselves immunity from lawsuits (oh, we're being sued too much - sound familiar?), the right to imprison anybody indefinitely without charge or trial (Cachets d'Iforget), and no taxes. Almost all taxes were paid by the peasants (who paid 4/5th of their crop in rent and taxes, often to the same person) and the middle class.

There were also a few relatively poor noblemen who seethed over not getting any positions in the Army or Bureaucracy, because they weren't rich enough to buy themselves a salaried office.

187   Peter P   2012 Dec 20, 1:29am  

Also, which group ended up benefiting from the French Revolution permanently?

http://mises.org/daily/1504

Bankers loved that.

188   Peter P   2012 Dec 20, 1:38am  

We need a small but flat or regressive income tax plus a flat land value tax.

189   nope   2012 Dec 20, 12:38pm  

Peter P says

Also, which group ended up benefiting from the French Revolution permanently?

http://mises.org/daily/1504

Bankers loved that.

I had to stop reading after "centralized, totalitarian, managerial, pseudo-democratic despotisms that now reign over the West."

I wish I was allowed to live in a different reality when I chose to.

190   nope   2012 Dec 20, 12:46pm  

Peter P says

But it is a mistake to apply value judgement to any kind of economic activity.

Only if you're a psychopath.

I could become very wealthy by murdering people and taking their money. I could become very wealthy by deceiving people into signing unfair contracts. I could become very wealthy by planting rumors of a major corporate acquisition and buying stock appropriately.

The idea that economics exists independent of ethics is a ridiculous fantasy ideal of libertarian fundamentalists who never have been nor ever will be in a position to actually have to make major financial decisions for anybody.

« First        Comments 181 - 190 of 190        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions