0
0

September 12, 2037


 invite response                
2007 Apr 3, 5:37am   23,328 views  333 comments

by e   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

http://www.time.com/time/printout/0,8816,915445,00.html

Unleashing their pent-up demands and taking advantage of fairly easy mortgage money, millions of people are shopping for houses. In Santa Rosa, Calif., a 90-minute commute north of San Francisco, buyers in June began camping out in sleeping bags on a Thursday night to be first in line Saturday morning when 27 houses in a new subdevelopment went on sale. In the Kendall neighborhood of southwestern Dade County, the last open area reasonably close to Miami, prospective buyers on weekends parade caravan-like in cars and campers through flag-festooned developments.

Sound familiar? Yet another story from 2005? Nope... the publication date of this article was September 12, 1977 - nearly 30 years ago.

Let's look at some other snippets from this time capsule:

Rachelle Resnick, 27, a San Francisco school-bus driver, counts herself fortunate to have bought—with much help from her father—a two-bedroom house that she candidly describes as "a little nothing." It cost $48,500, and she will have to spend $5,000 or so to repair termite damage. But had she waited, it almost surely would have gone higher. The house sold in June 1976 for $28,000, and has since been resold four times by four separate speculators, none of whom lived in it.

Such speculation is common in California and is beginning to appear in other states. Indeed, California is a housing Oz unto itself; its population is still growing faster than that of any other large state except Texas; the recession bit especially deep in California, creating a huge backlog of demand, and strict environmental requirements severely limit the land available for housing. Prices are starting to level off, but the level is in the stratosphere. In platinum-plated Beverly Hills, one cynical real estate broker exclaims: "Oh, I have such a dog on the market right now! Come to my Sunday open house and see what I'm offering for $185,000. I can tell you, for $185,000 you get a piece of nothing." Tom Lorch, a high school principal who is looking for a house in San Francisco, adds, "When we talk about houses, it's money, money, money—not how we're going to live, which seems wrong. And these absurd numbers, $100,000. It's some kind of fantasy world."

Does anyone know what happened to the housing market in California after 1977? Or was the impact of Prop 13 too influential in the resulting statistics?

And finally, the social impact:

Like all inflations, housing inflation has serious social effects. Some wives feel forced to go to work, not because they want to have careers or earn their own spending money, but because buying that dream house nowadays usually requires two incomes. Six out often first-time buyers are families in which both husband and wife hold jobs. Couples who want to have children sometimes face the brutal choice of a house or a child—and, more often than in past years, select the house. In the early postwar period, sociologists and merchants suggested that Americans spent too little on shelter, too much on less basic needs. If so, the market has more than corrected that tendency. In order to buy a house, couples are scrimping drastically on other spending—for cars, food and even furniture; not a few fancy new houses are almost bare inside. Young people have always asked parents for help in scraping up the down payment on a home; mortgage bankers call the payoff from papa a "gift letter." Now the pool of cash required to spend the first night in a new house—frequently $20,000 to $30,000—has made this sacrifice of independence a matter of necessity rather than choice.

So... this was in 9/1977. Now, it's hard enough predicting what 9/2007 will be like - but what do you think September 12, 2037 will be like?

Already, both parents are working, realtors are spinning the Bay Area as a place so great that you don't need to take vacations - what's next? Will child labor make a come back? ("Monta Vista High School and Fireworks Factory #88"?) How much more special can it get here?

(Bonus points for including Peak Oil in your prediction...)

#housing

« First        Comments 45 - 84 of 333       Last »     Search these comments

45   Paul189   2007 Apr 3, 10:40am  

"UK? I really can’t seem to find anything the Brits can do that the rest of the world cannot, except for being the money laundry center for the Eastern European drug lords."

Funny - at work today we were talking about the thousands of airline puts bought before 9/11 and how that profit just went over to Europe with no trace of where it went.

46   dp337   2007 Apr 3, 10:42am  

"Stocks Surge on Positive Housing Report...The National Association of Realtors' index for pending sales of existing homes rose in February at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 0.7 percent...That says people are getting mortgages, people are buying houses, people have incomes, jobs, all that good stuff," said Kim Caughey, equity research analyst at Fort Pitt Capital Group. "You'd never go out and buy a house if you think you're going to get laid off. Consumers are optimistic about the future, and as we all know, the consumer drives this economy."

Looks like we'll hear calls for "bottom" from the you know who's....

47   Bruce   2007 Apr 3, 10:43am  

Peter P,

Interesting about worldwide taxation. Is the US in a minority on this, or is the practice fairly common?

48   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 10:44am  

Every year, 200K+ Brits are emigrating (not to be confused with immigrating) to other countries.

With a strong GBP I am not surprised.

My parents live among many British retirees in Oz, and the #1 reason they departed UK was to evade the death tax.

I should have said "worldwide income taxation for residents not domiciled in the UK."

49   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 10:47am  

Interesting about worldwide taxation. Is the US in a minority on this, or is the practice fairly common?

Many countries tax their residents on a worldwide basis. I think US is one of the few countries that also tax their citizens regardless of residency.

50   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 10:48am  

apparently the brits are NOT coming to CA. Never met one here, but 1000’s of asians of every type.

I have several friends from the UK.

51   OO   2007 Apr 3, 10:52am  

#1 destination for British seniors: Spain
#1 destination for British younger than 40: Australia

I have had two British colleagues before, there are 2-3 British stores selling Marmite, Maltesers, etc in the Bay Area.

It is relatively harder for Brits to come to CA, because most of them emigrate to enhance their lifestyle. With their home equity, they can buy a big house in a decent Aussie suburb all-cash. If they come to CA, they don't get half as much upward mobility with lifestyle.

52   OO   2007 Apr 3, 10:54am  

US is the ONLY country on earth that taxes its citizens AND permanent citizens on a worldwide basis regardless of their residency. Other countries don't even dare to think about the concept of taxing their PRs when the PRs are out of the country.

Gotta luv Uncle Sam.

53   Bruce   2007 Apr 3, 11:00am  

Peter P,

I'm a little startled, then, having friends who've moved to Nice and other Mediterranean locations. It must have been a headache for them to move assets offshore (Monaco bank) - and from what you say, an annual tax burden as well.

Certainly helps to keep us at home and xenophobic... :neutral:

54   Malcolm   2007 Apr 3, 11:03am  

Now the pool of cash required to spend the first night in a new house—frequently $20,000 to $30,000—has made this sacrifice of independence a matter of necessity rather than choice.

Pretty sad that in current times most buyers can't even come up with a 1977 downpayment. What does that tell you?

55   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 11:03am  

It must have been a headache for them to move assets offshore (Monaco bank) - and from what you say, an annual tax burden as well.

I believe a competent tax-accountant can work to minimize the liability.

56   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 11:04am  

What does that tell you?

We are f#$ked.

57   Malcolm   2007 Apr 3, 11:05am  

It is going to be bumpy but the market will survive. I hope policy makers have the will and “heart” to let people fail. Destruction is part of the creation process.

This is a foreign concept to most people Peter.

58   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 11:08am  

This is a foreign concept to most people Peter.

I know. :(

59   Allah   2007 Apr 3, 11:08am  

It is going to be bumpy but the market will survive. I hope policy makers have the will and “heart” to let people fail. Destruction is part of the creation process.

This is a foreign concept to most people Peter.

I agree! The price of tulips fell, but the world didn't end....

60   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:12am  

"can't even come up with a 1977 downpayment. What does that tell you?"

What's worse is that those homes should have been paid for. As a matter of fact, this year! They're not. They've probably been flipped, fi'd, re-fi'd and re-fried at least 8-10 times since then.

61   lunarpark   2007 Apr 3, 11:14am  

My friend in MV just got turned down for a HELOC. That's a first...

62   Peter P   2007 Apr 3, 11:17am  

My friend in MV just got turned down for a HELOC.

Is he a renter?

63   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:18am  

lunarpark,

Based on what? Not enough income? Appraisal too low? Getting laid off? Not to be nosy but myself and Mr. skibum would like to know. Our position has been that even lower rates may not be the salvation people are praying for. Low rates of course don't help if you got no job!

Just curious. :)

64   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:20am  

The "burn card" is left for those that have a decent income, house appraised fine BUT..... DTI.... too HIGH!

I've got your "burn card" right here bunky!

65   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:27am  

For those that don't play cards, Spades, Pinochle etc. the "burn card" is something you hold in an otherwise WORTHLESS hand that keeps your opponent/s from running the board or having a perfect hand.

But they think they got it all wrapped up, so they bid (and bid big) never suspecting this lowly deuce of clubs will leave them talking to themselves... all the way back to the ATM! Oh and get me a pizza on the way back!

66   lunarpark   2007 Apr 3, 11:35am  

LOL@Peter P - SHE is not a renter, haha, you made me laugh.

DinOR -

I'm getting this secondhand from a mutual friend - my understanding is that her credit is poor and the HELOC was turned down based on that. She has been taking money out of her place over the last few years. It's never been a problem until now. She has called her realtor and is going (try) to sell asap.

67   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:35am  

Jon,

Well I can't imagine taking THAT lecture sitting down but that's where so many boomers grossly miscalculated. They generalized too much, and not just about finance.

In order to have 1) bought at the absolute perfect time 2) landed lifetime employment 3) cashed out without a hitch AND 4) had a very optimal and cooperative stk. mkt along with 5) a birthday (birthright actually) to assure maximum retirement and health benefits.

Oh... along w/perfect health, NO divorce and model/self supporting children. Is THAT so much to ask!?!

68   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:39am  

lunarpark,

She's your friend so I'm going to tread lightly here. Just saying her credit is poor may not necessarily explain everything. No change in employment or marital status? It's always worked for her/him before, right? Why not now?

69   astrid   2007 Apr 3, 11:41am  

DinOR,

Sometimes I think I'm unmarried, don't want kids, saving half of my income, paranoid about job security, constantly going on and on about immigrating to Australia, etc...just so I can be different.

I suppose if that doesn't work out, I could get some cyanide capsules in case things get really bad.

70   lunarpark   2007 Apr 3, 11:41am  

DinOR -

No changes in employment or marital status. I know she's taken A LOT of money out in the past and it's never been a problem. I don't know anything else - just that she is very upset. Personally I think it's good that she is FINALLY going to sell. Her payments were ridiculous vs her income. Her realtor thinks if she sells now she can still walk away with $50k.

71   Allah   2007 Apr 3, 1:28pm  

The bailout has begun

In my neck of the woods, Spitzer is making a lender payout $6M to the victims. I'm glad this lender is still around to fund it, but when it all hits the fan and all those ARM's reset, I think the taxpayers will ultimately be stuck paying in the long run when the majority of lenders go under.

72   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Apr 3, 2:36pm  

Allah,

That's not so much a bailout but a fine against predatory lending. If you read the story, those guys had people's interest rates up to 13+% with the fees for the loan at 10% of the loan value. It's fairly obvious they were not just 'rose glassing' the housing picture and making unwise loans, they were actively making loans with the intention of foreclosing on the house after they squeezed as much out of those guys as they could.

Also, the total 'bailout' comes to 6k per person. Hardly a home saving bailout. And since it doesn't come from taxpayers, but rather a shady loan company, it's no skin off my nose.

73   B.A.C.A.H.   2007 Apr 3, 2:41pm  

As long as I can remember people have been complaining that housing costs too much here. Some of them leave, but new ones come in.

And much of that timewas before all the new rich from Asia had their sights on moving to the cities along the West Coast.

74   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Apr 3, 3:27pm  

Crap, I missed that. Good eye, Jojo. :D

75   Randy H   2007 Apr 3, 3:35pm  

theOtherside

Thanks for the laughs. It's been a tough day, but you've helped me to end it well.

I recommend you pick up a copy of Mankiw as it will answer #3 for you, and it may help you with your weak understanding of inflation dynamics as expressed in your point (2).

#4 - CA has had 2 major corrections in housing post 1977, and 1-3 minor ones depending upon which metro area. San Diego/OC is the only area to suffer all 5.

#2 - Aren't you the one continually citing an MIT economic report? Well golly willikers if they didn't recently collaborate with the Federal Reserve in an extrapolative model that predicted upwards of 30-50 years of real housing price declines. If your reference isn't too optimistic, then this one isn't too pessimistic.

#1 - It would cost about 12% more than it would have in 1900, up from 5% LESS that it would have cost in 1948, and a measly 5% more in 1970.

Gosh. Inflation is a cruel master, isn't it.

76   surfer-x   2007 Apr 3, 3:42pm  

How many crashed did CA experience between 1977 and 2007

Well the reale questin is hows many uped? Not how many crashed did CA experience. Learn how to write you fat assed troll maggot.

77   Malcolm   2007 Apr 3, 4:16pm  

#1 - It would cost about 12% more than it would have in 1900, up from 5% LESS that it would have cost in 1948, and a measly 5% more in 1970.

I didn't crunch the numbers but until recently I was going to guess inflation pretty much made the gains a push. Remember though the power of leverage, so even a small positive margin translates into a great return on initial investment (the downpayment). Over the really long run, it was a push until scarcity and other factors pushed the new construction rate up causing upward pressure on old home prices. Think about this as Patrick says in his treatise; a house is a depreciating asset. What goes up is actually the land value, and like I said wage inflation, and increasing raw materials costs. The recent bubble defied these fundamentals which is why it was so easy for us to spot.

78   OO   2007 Apr 3, 4:47pm  

Jon,

yeh, a cent above the 255K pound threshold which includes your main residence, you get taxed at 40%. The problem is, almost every single retiree in the southern part of England will have more than that, simply because of the wild asset bubble going on there.

Before long, our seniors will start to flee the US for death tax as well, since all of us will be living in multi-million-dollar homes before long :-) On top of that we have a more broken Medicare system.

Inflation is your friend, don't you wanna drive a hundred grand car and live in a million-dollar home?

79   e   2007 Apr 3, 5:36pm  

People in NYC are sending kids to public schools again not because they have confidence in the crappy public school system, but because they cannot afford to send kids to private school, after buying a $2M condo.

Not all the schools are crappy in NYC. If you can get into Stuy, you're in pretty good shape.

Of course, that means you kid may have a daily commute that's longer than your daily commute (or, you can commute together in the morning!)

It's so cool to see 9 year olds commuting via subway to school (they were not going to Stuy) by themselves. Unlike counting on "Mom's Taxi" like here in the Bay Area or any other suburbanland.

80   Amsterdam   2007 Apr 3, 10:16pm  

Fuck FC Liverpool. Fuck Benitez, Crouch, Gerard, Belammy, Riise. Go Arsenal, go PSV.

81   Amsterdam   2007 Apr 3, 10:24pm  

12 September 2037, Florida gators will still be the champions, Dolphins rule football, Marlins dominate baseball. And the Heat, well if you can't stand the Heat get ot of the kitchen. LoL. In the EU Arsenal kicks ass.

82   Amsterdam   2007 Apr 3, 10:24pm  

One big BooYaa

83   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:29pm  

lunarpark,

Of course without any of the particulars it's hard for us to say but if you're like me you have doubts about your friend "walking away with 50k".

Sounds like more realtwhore (TM) BS to get the listing. Secretly the realtor may even be thinking, "finally... a MOTIVATED seller!" My guess is that if she has tapped out the place (really any place) to the point to where she can no longer make the payments it's doubtful there is any equity beyond the realtor's 6% commission.

84   DinOR   2007 Apr 3, 11:35pm  

astrid,

I'll never fault ANYONE for wanting their life to turn out different. You can only imagine the looks anyone attempting to leave the "paradise" of Cicero, IL gets when attempting to leave! Like, WHAT? Are you STUPID? Why would anyone want to leave here? We got it MADE! :)

« First        Comments 45 - 84 of 333       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions