0
0

Housing Bubble Pre-Flight Checklist


 invite response                
2006 Apr 10, 7:44am   29,442 views  313 comments

by HARM   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

1. Congress enacts/President signs new Tax Code into law (1997) subsidizing real estate speculation? Check.

2. Cabal of arrogant Fed bankers/Washington politicians/Brokerage firms ignore (or actively encourage) massive Dot.com stock bubble? Check.

3. Aforementioned stock bubble imploding in Fed's/Pol's faces (2000)? Check.

4. Extreme Fed/Pol fear of damage to the rest of the economy by ruptured stock bubble and willingness to flood economy with ultra-cheap credit (to inflate new bubble)? Check.

5. Massive GSEs market intervention, allowing private mortgage lenders to shift default risk from themselves onto taxpayers, FCBs & institutional investors (using the magic of MBS/CMOs)? Check

6. Complete erosion of lending standards, thanks to Fed's easy credit + GSE's MBS/CMO mortgage risk transfer? Check.

7. Cabal of arrogant Realt-whores enforcing monopoly MLS, gaming the numbers and lobbying for federal protection? Check.

8. Public's unshakable faith in the impregnability of real estate ("it never goes down")? Check.

9. Public's complete lack of historical memory, understanding of credit bubbles, the Fed/GSEs, business cycles, etc.? Check.

10. China/Japan underwriting much of our toxic MBS/CMO debt, while secretly hoping we fall on our asses? Check.

11. International carry-trade spawning RE bubbles all over the globe, thanks to ultra-cheap $USD ? Check.

HOUSING BUBBLE, YOU ARE CLEARED FOR TAXI

Discuss, enjoy...
HARM

#housing

« First        Comments 140 - 179 of 313       Last »     Search these comments

140   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 4:50pm  

I think sending them a simple sequence of prime numbers would stop them dead in their tracks - Sort of like the Jesuits marching into the Amazon with the Crucifix held high before them.

Braised "prime number" human brain with cracked pepper.

141   astrid   2006 Apr 10, 4:52pm  

Let the feast of a thousand beasts begin!

142   Unalloyed   2006 Apr 10, 4:53pm  

Content has degraded from the thread standard.

143   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 4:54pm  

Content has degraded from the thread standard.

How?

Do you think aliens will eat human sushi? Or they may think we are filthy animals?

144   astrid   2006 Apr 10, 4:55pm  

"Content has degraded from the thread standard."

(I'm gonna incorporate that into a Donnie Darko comment and then head for bed)

145   astrid   2006 Apr 10, 4:56pm  

Peter P,

Are you saying Aliens observe Kosher law?

146   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 4:57pm  

Oops... if aliens are studying this thread... we just gave them some recipes... oh no!

---

Dear aliens, Our brains taste horrible and truffle cream sauce is no good.

147   Unalloyed   2006 Apr 10, 4:58pm  

astrid gently warmed, drizzled with Jake G. cream sauce. Then sent to bed.

148   Unalloyed   2006 Apr 10, 5:02pm  

I guess I'll be banned for sure now.

149   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 5:05pm  

I guess I’ll be banned for sure now.

No one will be banned for suggesting a recipe.

150   Unalloyed   2006 Apr 10, 5:08pm  

Disclaimer: No recipes here posted have been kitchen tested.

151   astrid   2006 Apr 10, 5:09pm  

"astrid gently warmed, drizzled with Jake G. cream sauce. Then sent to bed."

And on that obscurely obscene note, good night to all and to all good night.

152   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 5:14pm  

Disclaimer: No recipes here posted have been kitchen tested.

Also, no animals have been harmed.

153   Unalloyed   2006 Apr 10, 5:22pm  

Disclaimer: All references to Jake Gyllenhaal cream sauce are made without the express consent of Sony Pictures Inc., Paramount Inc., or Warner Brothers Productions.

154   Peter P   2006 Apr 10, 5:55pm  

Okay now, what is Jake Gyllenhaal cream sauce? Is it similar to truffle cream sauce?

155   Different Sean   2006 Apr 10, 11:33pm  

Owneroccupier Says:
I know this Margaret Hwang woman, before she got married. Haven’t been in touch for years.
Let me put it this way, she is not the brightest bulb in our circle of friends, but definitely a climber. Used to intern for some big name senator or something, tried politics, didn’t work, wanted to do ibank, didn’t work. Kinda surprised to find her in academia. One should check who sponsored that study, I bet it is some realtor/builder-related interest that is doing so.

bubble, bubble, toil and trouble,
fire burn and housing double...

reminds me of a fairly useless 1946 paper written by one milton friedman on the cost of housing in chicago etc at a time of similar concern. he actually submitted that you could control all property prices rather than just rents, but kind of dismissed that as a possibility, one memorable line was 'but what of the man who wants to rent?'

http://mason.gmu.edu/~kbrancat/Papers/roofs_or_ceilings.pdf

156   Different Sean   2006 Apr 10, 11:43pm  

oh, Capuchin Economics - the behaviour of Capuchine monkeys - behavioural economics - i'm all for that stuff - i thought the name was like 'latte economics' for a moment...

i like these sorts of quotes:
"In other words, home buyers do not operate in a world of rational expectations. They are easily swayed by low interest payments, low down payments, tax code changes and perhaps most importantly by the emotional tug of being left behind or not getting their fair share of wealth that others are receiving. This last factor is the founding basis for behavioral finance and Capuchinomics. We then fully understand that such behavior is emotionally normal, but financially destructive."

157   Different Sean   2006 Apr 10, 11:49pm  

a recent study found some 8-10% of sheep (rams) were gay...

Inside the Mind of the Gay Sheep
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/03/08/inside_the_mind/
(quite a funny site, too)

a guy called milton diamond (no relation to jared?) postulated 4 stages of pre-natal sexual differentiation through the action of hormones - the derangement of any of the stages would lead to different manifestations of cross-gendered behaviour...

158   FormerAptBroker   2006 Apr 10, 11:51pm  

Different Sean wrote:

>reminds me of a fairly useless 1946 paper written
>by one Milton Friedman
http://mason.gmu.edu/~kbrancat/Papers/roofs_or_ceilings.pdf

Friedman's writings usually make a lot of sense and I did not find anything in the link above that I didn't agree with.

159   Different Sean   2006 Apr 10, 11:57pm  

Bingo. The international carry-trade via ultra-cheap $USD was a huge factor in spawning RE bubbles all over the globe.

hmm, when wall st sneezes, the whole world catches a cold... (not that it was wall st exactly this time, tho greenspan lowered interest rates to save the share market...) interest rates definitely went down in many countries following 9/11 and all the rest.

tho wendell cox at demographia.com insists it is urban consolidation housing policies alone that drive up prices, when you consider parts of america are still very cheap (the smith article calls these "screaming bargains") - i am somewhat surprised in fact that people haven't swooped on every part of america and tried to milk the ROI on investment property - if you get good cash flows on cheap property in nebraska or wherever, why haven't all those places gone through the roof as well - interstate investors buying up all the places?

160   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 12:13am  

wee

161   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 12:16am  

sorry about the post above. For some reason my last post wasn't posted.
Anyhow, About the baby boomers selling off their houses in 10 years.. I was reading an article the other day and the scary thing it mentioned was that the next big baby boom is pretty much happening right now. Get this- The majority of those having kids are: you guessed it- Baby Boomers! Yay! another entirely new generation of boomers to start all over again! The good thing is that by the time lil' Jr gets old enough to buy anything, we'll hopefully be out of this mess and be in homes of our own( if you aren't already.)

162   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 12:30am  

SFwoman,
When I lived in Berkeley, I knew a lot of people who claimed to have their home residences at their friend's houses just so their kids could go to Berkeley High School. Amazing. I think they have since cracked down on that because Berkeley had a huge amount of students for a few years.

163   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 12:41am  

It sort of scares me at the level of hostility being exhibited in those posts. Someday, I might be one of those guys with california tags driving around there. I hope they don't associate all californians simply as "assholes". I can understand the fear of people coming in and jacking up their prices, but I'm sure many of the people who moved there are in my same boat and needed the ability to attain upward mobility, not just cash out and gorge on cheaper real estate.

164   Different Sean   2006 Apr 11, 12:44am  

When I have looked at the Demographia papers they always seem vaguely like Heritage Foundation papers, the outcome is known before the data/study is put together. Suburbs=good,...

yeah, i don't agree with his single-cause theory, it has to be interactive at the very least. i initially took offence at his 'anti-urban planning posture', because it seemed like a near-trivial input to inflation. however, he is adamant it's the main driver. i suggested to him it is a correlation at best, like eating ice-cream doesn't cause you to put on sunscreen, altho both behaviours are present on a hot day.

further, with the current fuel crisis, peak oil, etc i completely disagree with his 'flight to suburbia' - i argue for better train links, higher densities, and so on - but then he has arguments saying it is costlier to run trains. other reasons not to sprawl are that it cuts into arable farmland and costs much more to implement infrastructure over large areas - therefore all environmentally wasteful activities...

he has a good grasp of demographic data tho... and points out that housing is affordable in houston area, altho it takes in millions of people... and the US experience has been that the coasts have become particularly unaffordable, other areas not so bad...

the Schiller house bubble hedge

how will it work?

165   skibum   2006 Apr 11, 12:50am  

nomadtoons2 Says:

About the baby boomers selling off their houses in 10 years.. I was reading an article the other day and the scary thing it mentioned was that the next big baby boom is pretty much happening right now. Get this- The majority of those having kids are: you guessed it- Baby Boomers!

I don't know if the article you refer to is talking about the same thing, but there's a well-described phenomenon of the "echo boom", ie, boomers' kids are in another generation that has a larger population than its predecessors and successors. I'm gen-X (yes, that term fell out of vogue long ago it seems), so we're stuck being in a minority demographic and subject to mass effect from the boomer generation. They're certainly not all evil, but there sure are a lot of them.

166   Different Sean   2006 Apr 11, 12:50am  

maybe the californians will be mistaken for terrorists, targeting the wal-mart...

167   Different Sean   2006 Apr 11, 12:55am  

Friedman’s writings usually make a lot of sense and I did not find anything in the link above that I didn’t agree with.

it makes some sort of sense in some sort of status quo way, but so what? he really is working inside the box, working in a model he has been given - no useful suggestions for ameliorating a problem. hence, i wouldn't go to him for any kind of useful social policy advice... maybe there's a reason he struggled as an academic for a long time, until market fundamentalism and laissez-faireism and economic rationalism became the order of the day in a new era... and homo economicus was born...

168   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 12:55am  

SFwoman,
I was in one of those moods yesterday, as you could see. You're right. People lump others into groups generically. After living in all these places, people act the same everywhere. But.. there are some cultural diffrences from region to region. Small things, like the way people greet each other, talk, and hold conversations. I can imagine that someone coming from say LA and going to a tiny place like Asheville might feel a bit of a shock from the shifting of gears. I know that it took me about a year to get used to San Francisco. Now it feels like all the other places I've lived except the weather ( is usually) pretty good. I can recall living back home and knowing only what people told me about California, which was that they were all rich and eccentric. People from New York were simply known as stupid Yankees, and people in Alabama.. well they were considered toothless hicks.
Seeing all these people from California must strike fear in the minds of North Carolinians who have only heard about what people " are like" from California. I'm sure some of those Californians had perceptions of what North Carolina would be like as well. Hopefully they'll both get along just fine.

169   skibum   2006 Apr 11, 1:13am  

nomad, SFWoman,

While we're on the subject of population demographics, IMO, the CA invasion phenomenon is inevitable, even without the housing bubble being concentrated in coastal regions (although the bubble has accentuated this phenomenon). The coasts have always been the main entry points for immigration, the primary population and economic centers of the country, and therefore the source of substantial intra-country out-migration in addition to the in-migration due to job seekers and the like. As the cost of living goes up and the quality of life goes down, the out-migration surpasses the in-migration. That's led in part to all the stories from Seattle and Portland 10 yrs ago hating newbies from CA, then more recently the same stories from Boise, Santa Fe, Reno, SLC. Similarly, the same thing seems to be happening on the East Coast (NY/CT/MA/NJ moving to VT, NH, ME, PA).

170   skibum   2006 Apr 11, 1:16am  

SFWoman Says:

the perception of Californians will become one of wealthy nasty people (with small weiners) instead of wealthy laid back people.

The wealthy laid back ones usually stay. Why would they leave?

171   skibum   2006 Apr 11, 1:18am  

goober Says:

More boometts = more social security tax revenues for X’ers…..

Problem is, social security will have collapsed by then.

172   Different Sean   2006 Apr 11, 1:21am  

Economists predicted 9 out of the last 3 recessions....

would we be any worse off if we let economists predict the weather and meteorologists predict the economy?

Mathematics brought rigor to Economics. Unfortunately, it also brought mortis...

hee hee

173   edvard   2006 Apr 11, 1:45am  

Sort of going off topic here, and perhaps about to make an obvious statement that's probably been discussed here... but.. It seems to me that all of this mess started in 1978 with the passing of Prop 13. It's what got Reagen in the office, and if you look at what occured afterwards, there has been a fluctuation of housing booms and bursts in California ever since. There is no money for schools and public works because Prop 13 strangled the amount of money the state gets. It also is the main reason housing is unaffordable to younger less affluent people. Prop 13 has outlived it's usefulness and caused an unforeseen problem that's just as bad as the problem it served to fix. So why not advocate tax reform that is somewhat flexible? of course this means some pain for homeowners, but then again, non-homeowners have been dealing with the pain for years, so why not spread the love around. I'm all about repealing Prop 13, and jack the taxes on property until it makes it at least 30-40% less profitable. It will solve so many problems for the state and the approximatly 50% of the residents priced out, and ultimatly, even the homeowners.

174   Randy H   2006 Apr 11, 1:51am  

Economics is not to be confused with Econometrics.

175   astrid   2006 Apr 11, 1:56am  

Phil,

Sorry if last night's transcript wasn't to your taste. To make it slightly more on topic, I'm retroactively naming the women line of discussion "how to avoid marrying a Century 21 harpy."

Also, please free to contribute more and steer the conversation to matters more to your liking.

176   Randy H   2006 Apr 11, 2:00am  

A shame to see a newswoman on MSNBC today bragging that a house sold for $250,000 over asking price in her DC neighborhood. As if she was bragging she lived in Shangri La or something something.

The HSBC research shows DC as by far the worst bubble in the US by almost every approach they simulate. Compared to DC, the Bay Area looks only a little bit loony. DC will implode, in my opinion.

177   astrid   2006 Apr 11, 2:03am  

The biggest problem with "californication" is not what they do to house prices across the country, that's a short term effect that will be reversed by the bubble burst. My problem is with the sort of houses the Californians are buying. They often have a taste for tacky and oversized McMansion. Those houses are just kind of worthless because of the layout (cooling 20 ft ceilings in Atlanta? 200 sq. ft. bathroom?) and the shoddy construction.

178   skibum   2006 Apr 11, 2:45am  

astrid,

I'm not sure the McMansion taste is a California-only phenomenon. Having visited many parts of the country in recent years, I've seen each region's version of the McMansion: California prefers the stucco, often Spanish-style McMansion, Texas and the South prefer the light-colored brick colonial, and the Northeast seems to prefer the red-brick or faux-wood siding colonial look.

Either way, the useless 20ft ceilings and the shoddy construction are things I can't stand either. Have you noticed in those airplane on-board catalogs (Frontgate and similar crap), those ladders and duster/light bulb changing extension tools these people sell for McMansion owners so they can change recessed lighting for these 20ft ceilings? Ridiculous. There must be a light bulb joke in there somewhere involving FB's...

179   astrid   2006 Apr 11, 2:50am  

skibum,

I don't think McMansion taste is California only. However, I do think that a lot more Californians and New Yorkers are able to afford such white elephants.

« First        Comments 140 - 179 of 313       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste