0
0

Bloomberg to WaMu: "Be careful what you wish for"


 invite response                
2007 Nov 8, 4:48am   23,214 views  161 comments

by HARM   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

WaMu's Wile E. Coyote moment

Bankruptcy Law Backfires as Foreclosures Offset Gains (Update1)

Nov. 8 (Bloomberg) -- Washington Mutual Inc. got what it wanted in 2005: A revised bankruptcy code that no longer lets people walk away from credit card bills.

The largest U.S. savings and loan didn't count on a housing recession. The new bankruptcy laws are helping drive foreclosures to a record as homeowners default on mortgages and struggle to pay credit card debts that might have been wiped out under the old code, said Jay Westbrook, a professor of business law at the University of Texas Law School in Austin and a former adviser to the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank.

``Be careful what you wish for,'' Westbrook said. "They wanted to make sure that people kept paying their credit cards, and what they're getting is more foreclosures.''

Washington Mutual, Bank of America Corp., JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Citigroup Inc. spent $25 million in 2004 and 2005 lobbying for a legislative agenda that included changes in bankruptcy laws to protect credit card profits, according to the Center for Responsive Politics, a non-partisan Washington group that tracks political donations.

The banks are still paying for that decision. The surge in foreclosures has cut the value of securities backed by mortgages and led to more than $40 billion of writedowns for U.S. financial institutions. It also reached to the top echelons of the financial services industry.

...'Let the House Go'

People are putting their credit card payments ahead of their mortgages, said Richard Fairbank, chief executive officer of Capital One Financial Corp., the largest independent U.S. credit card issuer. Of customers who are at least three months late on their mortgage payments, 70 percent are current on their credit cards, he said.

"What we conclude is that people are saying, 'Honey, let the house go,''' but keep the cards, Fairbank said Nov. 5 at a conference in New York sponsored by Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.

All I can say is... BWAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!
It looks like the Law of Unintended Consequences rules the day (again). So much for the "no bankster left behind" BK bill. Couldn't have happened to a greedier, more evil group of thugs.

Pigs getting their just desserts.
Chickens coming home to roost.
Life for a debt-free bubble sitter: wonderful.

Discuss, enjoy...
HARM

#housing

« First        Comments 24 - 63 of 161       Last »     Search these comments

24   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 9:31am  

Now, in reality, the new BK law does allow people to walk away from their CC debts IF they're earning below the median income for their area, the best place I know of to find out about this is the good old Nolo Press which I think may be www.nolo.com - the truth is, I think people are keeping their CCs up to date and letting the house go because a house is a huge money-sink where they can go rent a place for 1/2 or 1/3 of what they were paying for the house.

Kinda like the Joads leaving the farm but keeping the truck.

25   hugel   2007 Nov 8, 9:35am  

We need Ron Paul!!

http://www.abcnews.go.com/Politics/Vote2008/Story?id=3839318&page=3

"There's a dollar crisis out there and people's money is being stolen; people who have saved, they're being robbed. I mean, if you have a devaluation of the dollar at 10 percent, people have been robbed at 10 percent. But how can you pursue this policy without addressing the subject that somebody's losing their wealth because of a weaker dollar? And it's going to lead to higher interest rates and a weaker economy."

26   Claire   2007 Nov 8, 10:19am  

I thought people were using their credit cards to pay their mortgages, I guess they realized that was a pretty useless idea of prolonging the agony.

27   Claire   2007 Nov 8, 10:20am  

Does that then mean, they will spend spend spend at Christmas time, as they will not bother keeping the mortgage up - and it is cheaper to rent!

28   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 10:23am  

They're not going to spend spend spend, this Xmas will be a lean one.

29   StuckInBA   2007 Nov 8, 10:28am  

Here is a nice chart.

http://quotes.ino.com/chart/?s=NYBOT_DX&v=d12

If you are outside US, the US stock market has crashed big time for you already. Somehow, I don't feel foreigners will come bargain hunting for our stocks yet.

30   StuckInBA   2007 Nov 8, 10:29am  

They’re not going to spend spend spend, this Xmas will be a lean one.

The retailers are already hurting. Pain comes early this Xmas.

31   Peter P   2007 Nov 8, 10:31am  

Is shorting UUP a viable strategy?

32   Claire   2007 Nov 8, 10:40am  

So if the big banks “failed” - would all credit cards stop working too? Would it all become cash only? Or would people still be able to operate their accounts?

Should I withdraw some savings and stash it in the mattress? How much?

33   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 10:41am  

StuckInBA - it's UnAmerican to mention that the dollar has fallen 30% over the last few years.....

34   Peter P   2007 Nov 8, 10:43am  

So if the big banks “failed” - would all credit cards stop working too?

Big banks will not fail... they are too big to LET fail.

35   Peter P   2007 Nov 8, 10:45am  

it’s UnAmerican to mention that the dollar has fallen 30% over the last few years…..

Nothing is more unAmerican than being a renter.

http://patrick.net/wp/?p=446#comments

36   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 10:48am  

Claire - what's happening is, people are unable to make their credit card payments, then if the cards aren't already up there, the interest is raised to 30% and sometimes even more - which eats up any "room" they had, and people get threatening letters. Actually the letters are amazingly polite so far, it's a very interesting process to watch lol.

As you may guess, this is my situation so I am happy to share my experiences with anyone here curious about, or looking forward to, the life of an insolvent bum.

So.... since I can't charge, the only card useage I enjoy right now is using my food stamp card, I have to admit that's fun.

It's all cash for me, I don't have a bank account and in fact, this is funny but right now I don't have the $100 cash to start one at the local bank. I'll open one when I make some money doing something I guess. It's all cash for me right now.

Hmm, now if the banks fail ...... I'd say that yeah, let's say you have a Citi card that you have little or no balance on, you're a good user, and you use it for say your Starbucks purchases and pay it off each month. It's a good way to have all your purchases for the month on one bill actually. And, let's say Citi fails, they're bankrupt, will your faithful Citi card still work at Starbucks? I'm going to guess it will, because Citi will get bought out by some other bank, or they will try to keep doing business as long as they can - which apparently companies can when in chapter 11. If for some reason the bank just plain stops operations, I'm sure you'd get a polite letter saying your card will stop working and that's that.

Depending on how fast things fall, and how much of the financial system is automated, maybe we will see CCs just stop working. I think ultimately we will see people going back to cash - a lot of us are going to become cash-only curmudgeons!

37   Richmond   2007 Nov 8, 10:49am  

I finally talked to my buddy down in El Mirage, AZ. I sent him the link from the last thread.
He says, "Sounds about right. There are 50 to 60,000 homes for sale in the Phoenix Metro area and a full one third are unoccupied."
Can you imagine that? Geeeez.
I'll agree that it is a big area, but still.

38   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 10:49am  

PeterP - I've got you beat, couch-surfer in a paid-for place. Who eats old fashioned Quaker Oats for b'fast.

39   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 10:50am  

El Mirage is a hellhole. At least it was when I last drove by it, about 3 mos. ago.

40   Paul189   2007 Nov 8, 11:01am  

Coworker just returned from Toronto - He paid $5 CAD for a gallon of milk. The inflation will ravage both strong and week currencies!

41   Richmond   2007 Nov 8, 11:02am  

It's the newer area over by Suprise, east of Luke. Nice neighborhood, but then again, I like it when war hardware flies overhead. Watching those F-16's stand on their tails and hit the gas--- YEA BABY--- that's horsepower. The one thing I will not do is visit in the summer. TOOOO DAMN HOT!

42   Paul189   2007 Nov 8, 11:04am  

It's time to get mad as hell!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90ELleCQvew

43   Paul189   2007 Nov 8, 11:05am  

French subtitles for our friends up north.

44   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 11:06am  

Yes it was around the beginning of August when I blew through there..... great place if you likes planes though.

I had all kinds of military hardware overhead in Sunnyvale, one day I looked up and saw an AWACS you know, the plane with a frisbee on it, it was cool. I often could just about count the rivits on the undersides of the cargo planes flying in and out of Moffett from my ghetto-partment micro-porch.

45   Peter P   2007 Nov 8, 11:08am  

I often could just about count the rivits on the undersides of the cargo planes flying in and out of Moffett from my ghetto-partment micro-porch.

Can you see the Google Jet from there?

47   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 11:13am  

PeterP - I'm not in the bay area any more.

Brilliant video clip - of course things are MUCH worse now than in 76, and I doubt anyone would stick their head out of the window and yell now - people are much better controlled and brainwashed now.

48   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 11:16am  

Wow - "Rollover" is such a dangerous film I've never heard of it and I'm willing to bet maybe 10 or 15 americans ever have.

What we're undergoing is a Tainterian collapse, and but we'll experience it as is a financial collapse.

49   Peter P   2007 Nov 8, 11:27am  

I’m not in the bay area any more.

Bay Area is a scam anyway. Hope you will do well.

50   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 11:31am  

Thanks PeterP.

Follow my posts on here, I'm not keeping my situation any secret lol.

51   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 12:08pm  

Same pay in Podunk towns and in the Bay Area, yeah I'd say it's a scam.

52   goober   2007 Nov 8, 12:26pm  

http://tinyurl.com/2wosv4

(my tinys never work?)

53   goober   2007 Nov 8, 12:26pm  

that one did

54   anonymous   2007 Nov 8, 12:45pm  

Cool link Goober. Boats'n'booze.

Good points on boats - that they are the most discretionary purchase, not being needed unless you're a fisherman "and we don't have many of those".

Around here a lot of "discretionary" vehicles are used for practical purposes - ATVs used to putt around town, and Harleys are very popular and scooters, and in town bicycles are used a lot.

it's not uncommon to see a bicyclist loaded up with stuff and I don't mean a yuppie either, intrepidly pedaling along Route 89, gettin' somewhere.

I myself have developed a huge "Jones" for a Honda Rebel 250 mo'cycle, which is normally considered a discretionary purchase but I figure it's SO much cheaper to operate than even the junkiest car, and would be great for getting around except on snow days but it's best to stay home on those days.

55   Different Sean   2007 Nov 8, 3:42pm  

I just realised that if you scale the Oz govt surplus to the American population, you would have an AUD$1.5 trillion surplus now... and we may as well call dollar parity for all intents and purposes...

56   HARM   2007 Nov 8, 4:05pm  

@Rob Dawg,

Thanks --hey, it's funny how we both posted near-identical threads on the same article.

57   StuckInBA   2007 Nov 8, 5:33pm  

The rereport.com folks come out with their numbers earlier than DQ and have much better data.

http://rereport.com/scc/

Please go the the next page (link at bottom right) and look at individual cities. Anything that is not Fortress is hurting big time, and this of course is not clear from the headline. Forget Gilroy, even San Jose has more than a year's worth of inventory.

Typically inventory goes down this time of the year. It has gone down, but not so much. Evergreen is still at 530+ (max was 550). It did not go over 400 in entire 2006.

Now even the smart techie guys understand that future is bearish for RE in Bay Area. But given what Fortress buyers are doing many might be thinking it's a temporary blip and good buying opportunity for the "long term".

58   danville woman   2007 Nov 8, 10:24pm  

It is 5:22 a.m. and just checked Bloomberg. Yen at 111.24 Maybe I'm still dreaming but this looks like major stuff. Carry Trade Unwind ? Hold on to your hats in the stock market!

59   goober   2007 Nov 8, 11:43pm  

We may get to revisit the 12,000's before the day's end......

60   Duke   2007 Nov 9, 12:45am  

Ah yes, we have moved on to credit cards. A trillion here a trillion there and pretty soon we are talking about real money.

Look, everyone can calm down about putting gold in the toilet or stuffing their mattresses with Swiss francs. The financial sector will not dissolve. And it will not be the governement riding to the rescue.

Banks will lose money, stocks will devalue, and at some point people with cash will say, "Hey, that's a bargain!" and buy these companies. The trick is figuring how far they will have to drop until that happens.

Long before Citi and Wachovia and every other credit card company dissolve, countries with trade surpluses (and thus cash reserves in stronger currencies) will move in to buy these companies. Heck, with any luck a German owned Citi bank will not pay its CEO 100+ million dollars.

Life as you know it will not change.

What I do foresee is that the world GDP will contract. During the upcoming global recession people will examine what went wrong and excesses will be wrung from the system.
In the US, this will mean banking regulation, tax law changes, credit regulation(the credit card system is sooo bad - regulating who gets credit and how much is painfully needed) and hopefully a new social contract.
I say a new social contract becasue of the massive moral failings in the US.

Using sports as a metaphor for current culture we can see in the Patriots football team, the entire sport of cycling, baseball, etc the following unstated assumption, "Everyone else is cheating. If I do not cheat, I cannot compete." Becasue of the perception that everyone else is doing it we have the self fulfulling prophecy of an entire sport's worth of cheating.
Now, lets look at the social contract. The perception is that everyone esle is gaming the system by walking away from their investment homes since the payments were too high, or walking away from credit card debt because the companies charged too much, or taking very risky investments because the only downside is governement bailout. Thus, everyone takes that course.

A new social contract would say to borrowers, "It is not okay to get too far into debt. It is not okay to walk away from debt." We need to restore the social stigma of doing so. On the other side we need to enforce that corporate entities do not offer credit to deadbeats just becasue they can charge higher rates to everyone to cover the losses, plus makes fees on processing the bad debt. Systematically we need to insist, as a society, that everyone do their part to keep financial prudence and solvency as a core value. Just because you can legally walk away from that investment property, declare bankruptcy, or move every two years to reap massive capital gains windfalls, DOES NOT MEAN THAT YOU SHOULD! Corporations that say, "I had to take on MBS' and CDOs because my competitors were making tons of money and it forced me to do so or lose my customers." Or Countrywide, "We had to give mortgages to deadbeats because our competitors were."
Look, I hate to harp on this, but I think it is impossible for a society to function on legal imparitives alone. Enforcement would be too expensive. Society needs moral persuassion; moral rights and wrongs. I am hoping this recession provides the impetus for a return to core US values: honesty, hard work, financial prudence, innovation (man I hate business plans whose sole purpose is to buy patents, then sue for their infringment), and compassion to name a few.

61   DinOR   2007 Nov 9, 1:18am  

Duke,

Well said, very well in fact. Sure they'll be some bumpiness along the way and your insights may be awhile off, but they are both true and necessary.

What I wish we "could" see is folks moving on to 'the next big thing'? Can we please stop jumping through hoops to shore up housing and move on? It's gotten embarrassing... already. I'm not an innovator (some of you could probably tell that) but they are still about. Let's tally up and settle up before the endless obsessing over "saving the housing sector" consumes us!

62   SP   2007 Nov 9, 2:53am  

Duke said:
Look, I hate to harp on this, but I think it is impossible for a society to function on legal imparitives alone. Enforcement would be too expensive. Society needs moral persuassion; moral rights and wrongs. I am hoping this recession provides the impetus for a return to core US values: honesty, hard work, financial prudence, innovation (man I hate business plans whose sole purpose is to buy patents, then sue for their infringment), and compassion to name a few.

Agree with you, but my hope is somewhat tempered by the experience of the last few years.

After watching firsthand the evaporation of ethical behavior among executives during the dot-com days, I hoped that the dot-com bust would be the end of this - but sadly it only seems to have gotten worse. The phony revenue-recognition and insider stock placement games that pre-IPO dot-coms did seem like child's play compared to the stuff that happened since then.

63   SP   2007 Nov 9, 2:54am  

correction to the last sentence:
The phony revenue-recognition and insider stock placement games that pre-IPO dot-coms _played_ seem like child’s play compared to the stuff that happened since then.

« First        Comments 24 - 63 of 161       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions