0
0

Credit Crunch might be yummy, but I haven't tasted it yet :-(


 invite response                
2007 Dec 18, 7:07am   26,463 views  123 comments

by StuckInBA   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

In this age of fast moving information, some catchy phrases get very quickly regurgitated by clueless journalists. First it was Goldilocks and now it is the scary monster called "Credit Crunch".

Problem is, I don't see it. I don't doubt that it is happening at the intitutional level where financial institutions are afraid of lending money to each other.

But at the individual borrower level, things seem fine. Now "fine" is a relative word. Things are definitely not fine if you consider recent past as any benchmark. But recent past is simply not a good benchmark.

It should be hard for borrowers to get loans without proving their incomes. It should be hard for borrowers to get loans 10 times their incomes for an asset that is likely to depreciate. It should be hard to to get a negative amortization, 100% loan.

If that is what is happening, then it is simply a return to normal lending standards. This is not credit crunch. This is what it should have always been and I hope this what it will be for a long long time.

When a double income, 800 FICO family finds it impossible to get a loan without 30% down payment - I will call it credit crunch. That may happen very soon, or may take a while.

What do you say ?

StuckInBA

« First        Comments 19 - 58 of 123       Last »     Search these comments

19   DennisN   2007 Dec 18, 8:48am  

Huh? I do not know of a single person buying with 30yr FRM.

I did when I bought my place in San Jose in 1981. Re-fi'ed to another 30yr FRM but paid it off in 2004. PAID IT OFF. Now there's a concept that needs to be revived.

20   DennisN   2007 Dec 18, 8:50am  

Cash is nothing more than another word for a fixed-rate zero-percent mortgage. :)

21   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 8:51am  

I did when I bought my place in San Jose in 1981.

But you are not *buying* right now. ;)

I thought paying a house off is like stuffing money into a mattress... :roll:

23   justme   2007 Dec 18, 8:56am  

YSP = Yield Spread Premium

24   justme   2007 Dec 18, 8:57am  

Uh, that's not a picture of me, up there. GC, what is that guy good for?

25   DennisN   2007 Dec 18, 9:06am  

I never took money out via HEW to buy toys. So when I sold that place in May 2006 (check and you will see I sold at "the peak" :) ) I was able to buy a nice new place in Boise and have about ONE MILLION DOLLARS left over. If I can't live on the return on that amount I should be taken out and shot.

Not all boomers lived an extravagant lifestyle. I'm a millionaire but shop for grocery bargains and change the oil in my vehicles.

26   HARM   2007 Dec 18, 9:11am  

Not all boomers lived an extravagant lifestyle.

Congratulations, DennisN! As a Patrick.net regular and prudent investor-saver of the Boomer generation, you qualify for Un-Boomer (tm) status. You join the august ranks of likeable and popular Un-Boomers such as DinOR, FAB, OO, LILLL, and many, many more!

27   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 9:12am  

If I can’t live on the return on that amount I should be taken out and shot.

Watch out for inflation though.

28   DennisN   2007 Dec 18, 9:28am  

Well yes inflation bothers me. I think the FED should bump up the fed-funds rate to around 8-9% to "flush out" the speculators/unworthy types. Why doesn't the FED realize these guys are screwed already and that it would be better in the long run to "finish them off" ASAP?

Bullfighters know that the "moment of truth" comes when the bullfighter thrusts his sword into the bull's heart. Why shouldn't the government do the same to FB's?

29   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 9:30am  

I think the FED should...

But how should we react if they don't?

30   DennisN   2007 Dec 18, 9:41am  

But how should we react if they don’t?

That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government...

31   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 9:43am  

DennisN, I was talking about investments...

32   Jon137   2007 Dec 18, 10:45am  

Don Harrold: Master of Men

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMTyBCjVWJM

Not a plug for this guy. Just like what he had to say on this one.

33   anonymous   2007 Dec 18, 11:07am  

The place, Teh place, from which I type, was paid for on a liar loan,. 3X payments and paid off.

now the area is larning, yes, larning, that prices have to be predicated on min. wage.

Teh pity, yes Teh pity, is that it's not good for growing crawdads on, however, I have much hope for sparrows, which are a delicacy in Europe and crawdads abound locally.

People will look back upon the 1930s as a time of leisure and mint juleps..........

34   StuckInBA   2007 Dec 18, 11:31am  

If you are waiting for the DQ report for Santa Clara, you may want to chew on this in the meanwhile.

http://rereport.com/scc/

Every single indicator is negative. Except the median of course !

- Inventory is reaching all time high since 1999 spring, and it's still winter.
- Days of inventory going to moon
- The first chart of price v/s sales - note the red line, going to the bottom on the bay
- And people on an average paying less than asking price !

Is this Bay Area ?

35   anonymous   2007 Dec 18, 11:47am  

the number of homeless people and beggars in Santa Clara is a wake-up call.

To properly sense the situation you need to become homeless or nearly so yourself.

Become so, then report back. It's only a matter of time.

36   Malcolm   2007 Dec 18, 1:06pm  

HARM Says:
December 18th, 2007 at 5:11 pm
" you qualify for Un-Boomer â„¢ status. You join the august ranks of likeable and popular Un-Boomers such as DinOR, FAB, OO, LILLL, and many, many more!"

It should go without saying but all of the boomer jabs that I make are directed to the stereotypical grotesque boomers and not to fellow readers here. I do however encourage un-boomers here to pass on what they pick up from the different generations in the hope that they may influence their peers to behave in a manner that is not as repulsive as their normal actions, and also not an embarrassment to the United States when they travel overseas.

37   Malcolm   2007 Dec 18, 1:10pm  

Since boomers were the counter culture maybe enlighted boomers should be called counter-boomers.

38   justme   2007 Dec 18, 1:38pm  

What law gives the Fed the authority to regulate the finer points of mortgage lending and contracts?

39   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 1:40pm  

What law gives the Fed the authority to regulate the finer points of mortgage lending and contracts?

What law prohibits the Fed from regulating the finer points of mortgage lending and contracts?

40   justme   2007 Dec 18, 1:49pm  

Huh?

41   OO   2007 Dec 18, 2:11pm  

dunno about Fed, but Paulson is definitely working in his WS pals' favor. Which means, not a chance in hell for tightening credit, how else are WS bankers going to make easy millions if credit is tight?

Did you guys see the following chart? Shocking
http://www.financialsense.com/fsu/editorials/kirby/2007/1213.html

42   Peter P   2007 Dec 18, 2:16pm  

The Fed does not have to tighten credit. Free Market *always* tightens credit itself in the contraction phrase of an asset bubble.

43   SQT15   2007 Dec 18, 3:33pm  

Maybe it depends on where you live. Out here the realtors® and mortgage brokers are hurting. They made us jump through every hoop in the book to buy. But we have 800 credit and no credit card debt and did 30yr fixed so all-in-all it was very smooth.

But I hear the brokers are absolutely starving. The guy who sold us our house (nice guy-- I wouldn't wish anything bad on him) is going through a divorce and is going to hand his house back to the bank. He can't afford the house and the divorce because the market is so bad no money is coming in.

Our mortgage broker basically reiterated it for us when she told us that no loans are going through right now that aren't spotless. In fact, the loan package we went with won't be offered any more by the end of the year since the banks are getting really edgy. I've seen tons of houses in my neighborhood fall through escrow in the last few months. In fact, it's more unusual if a sale sticks.

I do think that the Sac metro area is ahead of the BA in terms of where we are in the crash. Our declines have been markedly faster and steeper so I think we seeing the crunch first.

44   SP   2007 Dec 18, 5:33pm  

Peter P Says:
Or better yet, a 15yr FRM.

Or a 0% fixed rate - with 100% downpayment...

I disagree somewhat with the original post about the credit-pullback not being seen at the retail level - I used to get two unsolicited letters every day in the mail, offering to refi my mortgage. Now, not so much - maybe two a week.

It isn't quite reached the point where mortgages are not available, but there is still plenty of time left before we reach the bottom here. It will happen.

45   Duke   2007 Dec 19, 12:18am  

Peter P,
So true. The MARKET is tightening credit. The Fed lowering rates is silly and inflationary. I am still wondering what capitulation signal will come that will cause Ben to raise rates. Maybe we should have a vote.

Bill will raise rates when:

a) Oil goes to $200 per barrel
b) Social Security is required to give a COL increase of 10%
c) The monthly cost of military action in Afghanistan and Iraq goes to $10billion
d) Medicare is projected to become insolvent in 2010

46   SP   2007 Dec 19, 12:51am  

Duke Says:
I am still wondering what capitulation signal will come that will cause Ben to raise rates.

That depends on what his real motive is. If really fighting inflation is the true motive, the Fed would have done this already well in advance of the signals you mentioned. Since that is not the case, let us assume price inflation is not the issue.

My guess is that liquidity is the concern, and we have a very long way to go before rate increases. Several layers of derivative markets have become stuck, and the players who made bets in those markets are unable to move or even close out their positions without becoming insolvent and triggering a chain reaction of cascading collapse in their counterparties.

The central banks are trying to resuscitate these markets through desperate liquidity measures. Raising interest rates is simply not an option now, until the patient shows some signs of recovery.

IMHO, it could be misleading to look at prices (housing, oil, gold, etc.) as a signal that the fed will raise rates. They just don't seem to care about shite like that. After all, the price of a McMansion in the Fortress is a mere rounding error compared to what is at stake in derivatives.

47   SP   2007 Dec 19, 1:02am  

News from Sacramento... looks like there were some job cuts at Intel's Folsom location. I didn't see an announcement, but it seems to be related to the sale of Intel's optical platform division to Emcore a few days ago. I don't have specific numbers for the affected headcount, but this can't be good for Sacramento area housing...

48   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 1:05am  

Punchbowl!

While there is no "Min. posts required" to keep one's membership here at Patrick.net current... what the hell have you been doing that's been more interesting than this!

Do tell, oh and good to see you!

49   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 1:07am  

Malcom,

"Counter-Boomer" is absolutely accurate. Just assigning a name to my affliction puts me on a path to recovery. I'm calling the RV dealer as we speak!

50   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 1:16am  

Perma-Rentor and Vernon Smith are GODS!

Thanks so much for that link! I need a printable copy I can forward to... everyone with a mailbox!

"at the end of the capital-gains rainbow"

Almost poetic isn't it!

Can someone, please... that is still in contact w/ astrid forward that to her in thoughtful and caring fashion? It was my crude and frustrated treatment of a long ignored topic that turned her off but perhaps someone w/ Prof. Smith's credentials will convince her I wasn't just taking a position to p!ss her off?

TIA

51   anonymous   2007 Dec 19, 1:26am  

I like that term, Un-Boomer. There are Boomers who are actually not like the people talked about in Ted Rall's book, Revenge Of The Latchkey Kids.

There *are* a huge number of boomers who seem to have taken on as their life's work to act just like the stereotype though!

52   Peter P   2007 Dec 19, 1:26am  

The Fed lowering rates is silly and inflationary.

What else can they do? (other than producing Oracle-of-Delphi-style Greenspeak)

53   Peter P   2007 Dec 19, 1:32am  

Bill will raise rates when...

Also, there is currently double-digit wage inflation in China, on top of appreciation (in measured pace though, still remember this term?) of RMB against the USD. Goods from China will become expensive very soon.

Oil will not be $200 a barrel. When the recession hits, it may go back down below $60.

NOT INVESTMENT ADVICE

54   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 1:54am  

Peter P,

I overheard a great quote today I know you'll appreciate.

"Nothing cures high prices like high prices!" :)

55   Peter P   2007 Dec 19, 1:55am  

Great quote indeed!

56   SQT15   2007 Dec 19, 1:58am  

There *are* a huge number of boomers who seem to have taken on as their life’s work to act just like the stereotype though!

.....speaking of my parents.

They lost their house. Total and complete irresponsibility on their part. Could have been prevented many times over.

57   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 2:01am  

HARM,

You didn't arrive at the CR comments a moment too soon! Thanks, it helped get the discussion re-centered. It's always depressing when you've been waiting patiently in class for your favorite topic to finally come up and the teacher legitimizes some tangent.

I was really dissappointed so many in the CR crowd tried to pretend a half a mil. either way wasn't going to make them of break them. C'mon guys. One of the good quotes came from *tg:

"Housing replaced money as the vehicle to save even if you had to go into massive debt to do it". Think about that for a minute.... Housing replaced money. Meet Debt=Wealth's evil twin.

58   DinOR   2007 Dec 19, 2:03am  

SQT,

I am so sorry to hear that. I know the "saga" started several years back and they sort of refused to confront it. I wish it would've turned out differently.

DinOR

« First        Comments 19 - 58 of 123       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions