0
0

Equity gains more than wiped out by equity loans


 invite response                
2008 Apr 2, 1:20am   28,715 views  317 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (59)   💰tip   ignore  

dodo

From a reader:

Americans now own less than 50% of their home for the first time in many years. What I did not hear in the press is that this percentage was reported AFTER home values had increased astronomically. That is, as home prices shot upward, many Americans chased those zooming home prices by adding debt, not by rejoicing that they now owned a larger fraction of their home. To me, the story is not that Americans now own less than 50% of their home, but that this is true after home prices have skyrocketed in recent years, outstripped by debt rising even more rapidly. Consider the implications to baby boomers who hoped to retire soon, but who have already extracted a large fraction of the true equity in their homes and spent it.

This is pretty amazing. After the biggest runup in prices ever, owners managed to blow all of that equity, and then some. And now they've got rapidly declining prices on top of that.

Patrick

« First        Comments 223 - 262 of 317       Last »     Search these comments

223   DennisN   2008 Apr 5, 12:13am  

I can't speak personally to the schools here since I'm one of those never-married guys. Friends that visited went to some website that numerically ranks US schools and claimed that Eagle HS ranks similar to Palo Alto HS. I'm not sure what such numerical rankings really mean.

January and February can get cold here in the valley, but nothing like the central part of the state. Stanley often is cited as being the coldest spot in the contiguous US on national weather reports. For example, last week it got down to 34 deg. here in Boise at night but to -19 degrees in Stanley. Idaho is a large state and straddles the latitudes from the border with Nevada all the way to Canada so there's a huge difference in climate among various parts of the state.

224   SP   2008 Apr 5, 12:22am  

“To me, the layoff was an introduction to the dark side of corporate life,” Ms. Vora said. “It was a reminder that at the end of the day, you are doing breakthrough research for a company that is making decisions about your life, and you have no control over those decisions.”

At any large employer in the tech industry (and yahoo is one of them) , I have never seen a technical R&D person with a strong track-record laid off. The company invariably offers great-to-very-good engineers at least one or two other options transfer internally before a division gets cut.

The only cases in which I know such folks were laid off are at:
1. startups that go bust (happened to me)
2. companies that went bankrupt
3. when the engineer didn't like any of the internal options and opted to take the severance

Based on her own linkedIn profile, Ms. Vora seems to have been a smart but fairly low-level intern in Yahoo' interaction research lab. There is nothing wrong with that, and she has some marquee schools on her resume, and maybe Yahoo made a mistake in laying her off - but it does not quite square with the inflated description of her position as some kind of VIP within the org.

225   lunarpark   2008 Apr 5, 12:54am  

http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_8821074

One in five homes put on the market in Santa Clara County recently is an attempted "short sale"

226   cb   2008 Apr 5, 2:09am  

I have never seen a technical R&D person with a strong track-record laid off.

I agree, if you are good, there will always be work. During the dot com busts, my previous company constantly reminded us that we are lucky to still have a job, the smart ones always have options, the scare tactics just seemed silly.

227   cb   2008 Apr 5, 2:12am  

With regard to the exploding inventory, it seems like it's happening, I use Movoto map view search where it draws a dot on a map for each house for sale. Lately the map is a lot denser, Cupertino has to have 2 or 3 times more houses that came on market than 6 months ago.

228   Peter P   2008 Apr 5, 2:41am  

I have never seen a technical R&D person with a strong track-record laid off.

Perhaps you have not seen enough. With sufficient political skills, that may be true.

229   FormerAptBroker   2008 Apr 5, 2:41am  

DennisN Says:

> Damned. Hillbilly raked in $109 Million since 2000.
> Why would you put up with politics when you could
> just have such a wonderful life with that much scratch?

Some people just seem to like to add stress to their life…

Examples are:

Former First Lady who could easily make $10mm + a year as a corporate atty. Working 20 hours a week but decides to work 100 hours a week as a feeding her ego as politician traveling around the country telling people that a black guy would make a bad president (and black voters should vote for her) …

The super smart son of a Billionaire real estate guy making next to nothing working long hours as the AG of a East Coast state and paying tens of thousands for sex when he could be working just a few house a week as a partner of a Wall Street law firm making millions and getting free sex from super hot NYC models who just want dinner at a nice restaurant…

230   skibum   2008 Apr 5, 2:49am  

RE: this yahoo who got "laid off" at Yahoo, whether or not he/she is any good is to me besides the point. Yes, even in the worst economic times, people with valuable skills will still find work.

During a downturn, it's the ballast that gets jettisoned. And that's already starting to happen, albeit slowly. The extreme example was during the dot-con heyday, where idiots with no skills, no background called themselves "web developers."

Same thing can be said on a larger scale. Companies that add value and have the skill to navigate the downturn will survive and thrive. The ballast should and will be chucked (ie, most of the me-too "Web 2.0" crap).

231   FormerAptBroker   2008 Apr 5, 2:53am  

Peter P Says:

> No fault divorces should be outlawed. If there was no
> fault there would be no justification for a divorce.

There does not have to be a “fault” for there to be a divorce someone may just want a change. If I sign a 10 year contract to sell real estate for a firm they can live up to their end of the contract but I may just want to do something different in 5 years.

If I decided to break an employment contract early when there was no breach by the employer I would have to probably pay them to allow me to break the contract (I couldn’t leave and take half of the company assets with me).

I don’t understand why a gold digger can marry a guy for a few years and after to agreeing to stay with him “until death do us part” break the contract (to move in with her personal trainer) and take half the guys assets…

232   empty houses   2008 Apr 5, 2:54am  

"traveling around the country telling people that a black guy would make a bad president (and black voters should vote for her) …"

Yes, that would be a tough gig. How the hell do you get black people to vote for a white women instead of the potential first black president. It was next to impossible to convince black people that OJ was guilty. Hillary has a very tough job.

233   OO   2008 Apr 5, 3:23am  

Oh well, Obama is NOT your typical black American. He is just a second generation immigrant. He doesn't share the same "legacy" (or baggage if you will) as most black Americans whose ancestors came here as slaves. Obama's dad is an upper class African who after abandoning Obama's mom, bagged another white woman from Harvard. Obama's white mom has a more humble socio-economic background than Obama's black dad.

I chuckle when I read about how American press portray Obama's step-dad as radical Muslim man from a developing country. They probably have never traveled to Indonesia and know nothing about the social fabric over there. While I don't know Soetoro personally, from my experience in that part of the world, I'd venture to guess that he has to be a very mild Muslim (it will be very difficult to find a rich, radical Muslim in Indonesia), and again, from a very moneyed family with far more wealth than Obama's American middle class white mom. Even today, only the top 0.1% Indonesians have a chance to come to America for studies, not to mention 30 years ago. As things always go in developing countries, although they are poor in general, their rich are insanely rich. So Obama was never this kid wandering about in developing world, but lived a far more privileged life over there than here. Everyone I know from Indonesia, with NO exceptions, who is able to come to the US for study, has a whole fleet of servants, gardeners, cook or even personal guards back at home.

To paraphrase George Carlin, Obama is like Colin Powell, he happens to be black, he is openly white.

234   OO   2008 Apr 5, 3:33am  

I once visited a Filipino classmate at his hometown, and this guy was very low key at school, so you would have guessed nothing about his background. When I stepped outside the airport, he got a few armored cars waiting outside with uniformed soldiers manning these vehicles. We went to his house, and it was almost an exact replication of Great Gatsby's mansion.

Unfortunately a few years back there was a coup d'etat which involved his family, and as a result, his family was purged in the political struggle. Nevertheless, most of his close relatives end up in Hawaii resuming a "reduced" lifestyle.

The next time you run into some of those college students from bottom-of-the-barrel developing countries, don't assume that they are dirt poor. The poorer their country is, the richer the person's family is, that is my generalization.

235   OO   2008 Apr 5, 3:37am  

Clarify: If someone comes here from the Philippines or Indonesia on work visa, or illegally, he is likely to be poor. If he comes here on STUDENT visa, watch out, he could very well be a little prince back home.

236   DennisN   2008 Apr 5, 4:22am  

I went on a business trip to the Philippines once with my manager who was Filipino. We were met at the Manilla airport by the Manilla police chief - who turned out to be his uncle.

237   surfer-x   2008 Apr 5, 4:30am  

The only thing worse than being trapped in an office listening to a boomer blather on about themselve, is being trapped on a blog reading a boomer blather on about themselve.

So after you started the civil rights movement, freed the entire world from the yoke of sexual tyrany, and opened up recreational pharma to new generations. You what, got lucky? Simply stunning. Blather on boomer, I am hanging on every word. Please please tell us again how great you are doing, exactly how much you make a year and all your great stories. You really were with the stones at Altamont weren't you.

Take your calias today? If not you might want to add some provigil. Ahhhhh good boomer, now take your speed and shut up.

238   BayAreaIdiot   2008 Apr 5, 4:49am  

The extreme example was during the dot-con heyday, where idiots with no skills, no background called themselves “web developers.”

Stop the hate. Please don't be an idiotcist.

239   surfer-x   2008 Apr 5, 5:04am  

Hey DennisN, how long did it take you to pay back your $19,237* in undergraduate student loan debt? Or were you able to take advantage of the no tuition UC system while simultaneously avoiding the draft. If so, kudos to you Sir, this type of skill is amazing. One might be so shallow as to call it luck, but certainly it was anything such.

*Few students can afford to pay for college without some form of education financing. Two-thirds (65.7%) of 4-year undergraduate students graduate with some debt, and the average student loan debt among graduating seniors is $19,237 (excluding PLUS Loans but including Stafford, Perkins, state, college and private loans), according to the 2003-2004 National Postsecondary Student Aid Study (NPSAS).

240   Peter P   2008 Apr 5, 5:49am  

Anyway, black or white, Obama probably means higher tax.

241   Peter P   2008 Apr 5, 5:51am  

I don’t understand why a gold digger can marry a guy for a few years and after to agreeing to stay with him “until death do us part” break the contract (to move in with her personal trainer) and take half the guys assets…

Because the gold digger is a victim and the rich man is always the bad man?

There should be physical penalties for marital treason.

Even as a libertarian, I recognize the need for the government to enforce private contracts. When a gold digger seek to unilaterally breach the contract, the government should move to block.

242   Peter P   2008 Apr 5, 5:59am  

Any chance Tom McClintock will become our next governor? :(

http://republican.sen.ca.gov/web/mcclintock/article_detail.asp?PID=344

Are they really going to teach "global warming" in public schools? How is that more real than God?

We are supposed to be free from religions.

243   DennisN   2008 Apr 5, 7:31am  

Here's an interesting new story up at the Chron's site:

www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/04/05/RENBVULBH.DTL

I wonder if he was one of the trolls here?

"The people who left are the ones who had other options or just saw the writing on the wall," he said. "The stereotype is that it's the casual agents and the opportunistic ones who are the first to fall off. I don't know if that's the case. The people who I know who are leaving got into real estate for very legitimate reasons and were very dedicated. But if you start doing the numbers, somebody had to go."

244   FormerAptBroker   2008 Apr 5, 9:01am  

DennisN Says:

> Here’s an interesting new story up at the Chron’s site:

We now know why Marina Prime is no longer posting:

"When Jaime Gutierrez got his real estate license in 2005, he thought he had found his new career. Then the housing market crashed, and now Gutierrez works as a cab driver."

245   FormerAptBroker   2008 Apr 5, 9:23am  

surfer-x Says:

> *Few students can afford to pay for college without
> some form of education financing.

As someone who had no problem working to pay for college I don’t understand why most people in America do not expect kids to work over the summer or a little bit of work between fraternity parties to pay their own way through college.

The tuition for a full year with a full load of transfer classes at a Junior College is about $500. A full year at a California State School is about $4K and a UC School is about $7K. So without a penny of student aid or scholarships you can get a Bachelors degree from a CSU campus (after a JC transfer) for about $9K ($43 week over four years)

246   Brand165   2008 Apr 5, 12:10pm  

FAB, you obviously have no idea how difficult it is playing Ultimate Frisbee and drinking beer. There's no time for work!

Most students put more planning into Spring Break than their summer job. Also, that statistic ignores the fact that most students prefer their student loan debt to almost every other kind of credit. It doesn't kick in until you're done (and presumably making better money), and it's at a very low interest rate. Why put clothes, food and entertainment on your expensive credit cards and then pay cash for your education? Uncle Sam is offering you a low low rate on deferred credit! I wonder why the lenders were never able to replicate their HELOC strategy with student loans. "Roll all your debt into one low monthly payment, deferred until graduation!" If they could have just loosened those pesky regulations a bit more.

247   Malcolm   2008 Apr 5, 1:31pm  

Getting a student loan was the very best decision I made. I used it to make a downpayment on my first house.

248   SQT15   2008 Apr 5, 4:17pm  

I'm way late in chiming in here....

First, 50% ownership? That is mind boggling. Who knew Hummers and pergraniteel cost that much?

Second, Surfer-X, my parents-- the boomers--, have lost their home and ended up in Thailand after fleeing almost $1 million in debt and the IRS. Great examples for us all, no?

249   HeadSet   2008 Apr 5, 11:59pm  

Brand says:

I believe that people should be thoroughly informed about their choices. If they need help understanding the potential consequences, then perhaps we should provide our fellow citizens with an impartial, high-quality information source. We should mitigate future housing bubbles by making sure that every single high school graduate in this country understands the different types of mortgages and is literate in reading contracts (or in retaining a lawyer).

That was part of a great post, but I'd like to add.

Knowledge is not really the issue. As long as some people have access to credit to fulfill an immediate wish, they are unconcerned about the long term. Think of all the easy credit stores. I'm sure the customer knows that paying $100/mo for 18 months to buy a flat screen is a bad deal when the same item is available for $1,000 at discount stores, but he gets to take it home today. This "have the bling now" concept also applies to BMW, Lexus, and Escalade leases, and explains the unpaid credit card balances. Unfortunately, houses were not immune to the financially short sighted, and that I do not believe education will have any effect on the "have it now" crowd. Only sensibly tight credit will prevent bubbles.

250   HeadSet   2008 Apr 6, 12:03am  

Ms. Vora seems to have been a smart but fairly low-level intern in Yahoo’ interaction research lab.

Yahoo gives low six figure salaries to interns? That would explain some attitudes.

251   BayAreaIdiot   2008 Apr 6, 2:17am  


As home prices soared in the middle of the decade, consumers tapped the rising value of their property as a source of cash by refinancing first mortgages or taking out home equity loans. But in 2007, as home prices fell and foreclosures skyrocketed, lenders turned wary of the housing market. Home equity lending volume fell sharply in 2007, tumbling to $60.5 billion. By the last three months of the year, such lending slowed to an annual rate of $26 billion.

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
$92.2 $180.5 $138.2 $147.5 $60.5

from today's SFChronicle. Someone here described our economy in the last 5+ years as based on not two but three paychecks (mom, dad, house). Now even the Chronicle and Wall Street economists agree!

So it seems we'll be fine this year because the government in all its wisdom has replaced MEW with tax rebates. What happens in 2009? hahahaha....

253   PermaRenter   2008 Apr 6, 2:28am  

>> When Jaime Gutierrez got his real estate license in 2005, he thought he had found his new career. Then the housing market crashed, and now Gutierrez works as a cab driver.”

He also does substitute teaching:

After two years Jamie Gutierrez has quit the real estate game. During that time he hung on to his cab-driving job; now he's making ends meet by substitute teaching.

Chronicle photo by Katy Raddatz
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/object/article?f=/c/a/2008/04/06/RENBVULBH.DTL&o=0&type=printable

254   Peter P   2008 Apr 6, 2:45am  

Second, Surfer-X, my parents– the boomers–, have lost their home and ended up in Thailand after fleeing almost $1 million in debt and the IRS.

SQT, I thought your parents were Silents.

255   Duke   2008 Apr 6, 3:35am  

BAI,
And in my opinion, we get a better society if we can make it on not 3, not 2, but 1 paycheck. There is a lot to be said for how much a stay at home parent means to a child growing up.

256   KurtS   2008 Apr 6, 3:44am  

…The only thing worse than being trapped in an office listening to a boomer blather on about themselves

LOL…I'm reminded what I missed about this blog: Surfer-X rants on boomers. I used to think he was a bit off-base, but less now. The only thing worse than continually hearing out self-deluded, narcissistic Boomers is dealing with their children-- who fully bought into their parents' path of "success" and entitlement. They're even stupider than their parents, because they have less basis for their assumptions and attitude. So it's not a generational problem, but a defunct mindset that I'll daresay will leave a toxic legacy for years in this country.

257   FormerAptBroker   2008 Apr 6, 4:36am  

Brand Says:

> I believe that people should be thoroughly informed
> about their choices. If they need help understanding the
> potential consequences, then perhaps we should provide
> our fellow citizens with an impartial, high-quality
> information source. We should mitigate future housing
> bubbles by making sure that every single high school
> graduate in this country understands the different types
> of mortgages and is literate in reading contracts

Then HeadSet Says:

> That was part of a great post, but I’d like to add.
> Knowledge is not really the issue. As long as some
> people have access to credit to fulfill an immediate wish,
> they are unconcerned about the long term. Think of all the
> easy credit stores. I’m sure the customer knows that paying
> $100/mo for 18 months to buy a flat screen is a bad deal…

I wish HeadSet was right, but unfortunately knowledge is the issue for most people… Not many people that actually spend time discussing the housing market on line. Most people are either on line looking at porn or reading about celebrities on TMZ or they are watching basketball or American Idol on TV…

My friends kids that go to UHS or SI are all getting a good high school education, but I bet that most of the kids that “graduate” from public schools in California today could not tell you the what the annual interest rate is if you buy a $1,000 TV making 18 monthly payments of $100 (a huge percentage of the graduates would not even understand the question if it was in English)….

In Oakland and parts of Sacramento almost half the kids that start high school don’t even graduate. I’ve done volunteer work in poor schools for over 20 years and the bar keeps getting lower and lower (and the kids keep getting dumber and dumber)…

258   Brand165   2008 Apr 6, 4:42am  

Headset, I will of course agree that there is a huge demographic for instant gratification. However, most people carrying a CC balance or car lease know that they are paying more, but have no idea how much more. They are getting nailed way harder than they think. If those innumerate folks knew up front how much it was going to cost by the end, fewer of them would make that purchase at all, and another respectable chunk would pay off their CC balances quickly.

As for the others, well, staying in debt is their choice. I simply require that in a modern society, it be an informed choice.

One of my biggest complaints is the deliberate information gaps maintained by lenders so that they can keep people hooked on credit. Look at exploding ARMs---how many J6P borrowers can we reasonably believe had the math skills to understand the consequences of using the Pick-a-Payment option, even if it were completely spelled out to them? Heck, most of them don't have a damned clue that a mortgage actually costs them money over the 30 year period, even with house appreciation. Unethical mortgage brokers may have been the spark that ignited an inferno, but the dearth of education on exotic mortgage products was the pile of dry tinder. And there is no reasonable counterbalance to Realtors who can belabor points about tax-deductible mortgage interest and house price appreciation. How much would it really take? A simple picture and a few indisputable equations ought to cover it. You can bet your last leveraged HELOC dollar that if Congress made a push to truly educate its citizens on credit, the backlash from banking and real estate lobbyists would be nothing short of epic.

Of course, the antidote to the information asymmetry created by the uber-wealthy might not be education. It might just be restraining our desires for luxuries like perigraniteel and European cars until we can actually afford them. And perhaps a wise few might start to question if they really need such luxuries them at all... but that's a different rant. ;o

259   Peter P   2008 Apr 6, 4:54am  

I’ve done volunteer work in poor schools for over 20 years and the bar keeps getting lower and lower (and the kids keep getting dumber and dumber)…

Since it is politically incorrect to distinguish performing kids from non-performing kids we can only keep them equally dumb.

260   HeadSet   2008 Apr 6, 7:46am  

Brand, FAB

Good news if you fellows are correct, because solving the problem long term would be merely education and not having to change an ingrained nature. Either way, tight credit will be needed in the short term until the financially innumerate learn.

My viewpoint - that short term greed and not ignorance - is the cause comes from personal observation. I have seen people who are paid on Monday use a check cashing service on the Mondays that banks are closed. When I ask why they can't wait until the next morning and thus save the 10% fee, I get a slack jawed answer like "I needed to buy toilet paper." Even in the example I gave, with the $100 for 18 mo vs the $1,000 for cash, surely one does not need to calculate an APR to know that if one saves for ten months and pays cash, one will save $800. Even more since the price of the flat screen will fall. My perspective may also be influenced because I took an econ elective class in (public) high school that included a textbook called "The Time Value of Money." For that course, we had to calculate loans, present values, and had exercises like comparing a bank loan vs store credit on purchases. I also notice that stores like Target, Kmart, and WalMart all sell several brands of financial calculators. Plus, virtually all spreadsheets have built in financial functions. For anyone who uses the web for any real estate info, you can't help but notice all the "rent vs buy" and mortgage comparison calculators. Who were all the electronic calculators, spreadsheets functions, and web tools made for if no one is using them? Especially since those calculators are sold at stores aimed at the masses, and the web tools ask simple questions requiring no financial expertise (ala TurboTax).

But, since you two may be correct, I would be in favor of high schools having a mandatory "personal finance" course. Teach about checkbook management, time value of money, insurance, savings and investments. This may lead to less victims of "loaded funds," "whole life insurance," "car leases" and "creative financing."

261   DennisN   2008 Apr 6, 9:10am  

I'd even propose a standard college course in "citizen law". There are standard requirements in the humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences for graduates of schools such as the Univ. of Calif. campuses. Why not have a standard requirement for learning about the US legal system? It would be much more meaningful than the typical Mickey-Mouse breadth-requirements courses in French poetry or sociology.

A law degree is little more than a degree in applied library science - I should know, I'm a lawyer. It would be possible in a 2 quarter class to cover a skimpy outline in contracts, torts, real and intellectual property, and constitutional law, with projects in legal research. This at least would alert the so-called "educated classes" to issues in their day to day life. I was completely puzzled about the legal system until at age 40 I dove in and spent 3 years and a lot of money going to law school.

262   BayAreaIdiot   2008 Apr 6, 9:18am  

Call up the Merriam-Webster people. They need to replace their definition of shameless unmitigated gall with this

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/81c05200-03f2-11dd-b28b-000077b07658.html

« First        Comments 223 - 262 of 317       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions