0
0

Credit without regard to cash flow


 invite response                
2008 Jun 16, 11:53am   10,370 views  91 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (59)   💰tip   ignore  

Hi Patrick,

I’ve been following your website with some interest. I am just curious about something. Will credit scoring finally be scrutinized as one of the primary causes of this problem with a host of loans now going bad? Everything from Fannie Mae to Freddie Mac to Subprime to Alt A and even Home Equity etc., was all primarily facilitated with the use of the “statistically significant” credit score, whereas such common sense practices as actually cash flowing the borrower to see if they could actually service this debt was abandoned or ignored altogether. Is anyone looking at this to bring this to light? I think people like Fair Isaac have a lot to answer for for getting all this in motion in the first place.

To me this is no different than Moody’s taking significant fees to assign AAA ratings to Subprime mortgage-backed pools of securities that were on their way to being worthless because again, cash flow underlying the ability to service those mortgages was not even considered. Clearly this was a conflict of interest at the time by Moody’s but the fox was already in the henhouse and nobody seemed to care. Now the common taxpayer (who still doesn’t understand this) will have to ultimately bail out entities like Bear Sterns, Countrywide and ultimately the Fed plus who knows how many more because proper cash flow analysis was ignored that if done properly would have never allowed these loans to get on the books in the first place.

Is anybody even looking at this as a core cause (ie, the fact that credit scoring is very much also to blame for this) or are they just looking at other stuff? It seems like someone should bring this point to the forefront and get the Fed looking at it, or Congress, or somebody for gosh sakes.

Just a thought.

Best regards and keep up the good work!

Dave Smith

#housing

« First        Comments 61 - 91 of 91        Search these comments

61   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 19, 8:50am  

It’s Thursday, and Mountain View inventory is back up at 167. I guess we’re on track after all.

62   danville woman   2008 Jun 19, 11:28pm  

@Apostasy and OO

Thank you for the wealth of information about Precious Metals.I have read it over many times. I am visiting Scottsdale at the moment (115 degrees in the shade) but as soon as I return home I will print the info and begin taking action.

THANKS AGAIN !!!

63   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 19, 11:47pm  

The US is more broke than France, by objective measure of deficit/year/GDP.

64   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 1:23am  

The US is more broke than France, by objective measure of deficit/year/GDP.

Measures can be "objective," but applications of measures are subjective.

France is broke broke, by subjective measure of their welfare state.

65   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 1:25am  

Another obvious fact too obvious to be noticed: France does not control its own currency, America does!

66   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 20, 3:06am  

I have a question about investing in or shorting oil. Of course, one can can buy/sell/short oil companies such as CVX or VLO, and there will be some correlation with oil price. On the other hand, there are ETF funds such as

OIL DBO USO USL UGA UHN RJN DBE

Pasting these funds into Google Finance, I see that most if not all are very small (with less than 3B market cap) and have small float. I'm concerned that it may be risky to short them, because it is easy to engineer a short squeeze, somewhat indepedent of the actual oil price.

Any thoughts on this. Needless to say, THIS IS NOT INVESTMENT ADVICE in any way, shape or form. It is a question about the structural properties of the oil market, as seen by a retail investor.

67   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 3:07am  

What's wrong with this?

http://www.nymex.com/QM_spec.aspx

Not investment advice.

68   Duke   2008 Jun 20, 3:11am  

I have a strange intuition that during this 'great delveraging' there is a host of borrowed dollars trying to make as much last-minute cash as it can on its way out of the hands of the hedgies and back into banks.
One of the few markets big enough to handle the size of this cash-pile is oil. Fit me for a tin-foil hat, but I feel like there is not just some, but a lot of oil speculation and it is te hedgies.

Needless to say, I think either long or short positions in oil are exceptionally dangerous as this group has to deep pockets to squash little players at will.

My advice - stay the heck outta oil.

69   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 3:19am  

More importantly, stay the heck outta snake oil. I am sure a lot of fraudsters will be preying on little guys.

70   DennisN   2008 Jun 20, 4:07am  

More importantly, stay the heck outta snake oil.

But it may be a good time to invest in the raw materials themselves: snakes.

Not herpetologist advice.

71   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 20, 4:31am  

Peter,

QM looks good. But do any of the major online brokers support commodity trading?

72   DennisN   2008 Jun 20, 4:33am  

I can't see any advantage to the "Amero". Why would anyone propose such a thing? Any oil we buy from Mexico or Canada is already priced in $US. The only thing worse than an old fiat currency is a new fiat currency.

Already one good chokepoint for illegal aliens from Mexico is the necessity to exchange $US for Pesos prior to shipping funds back home. If required law enforcement would have a good surveilance point. This would go away with a common North American currency.

73   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 5:37am  

QM looks good. But do any of the major online brokers support commodity trading?

I think E-Trade does.

Again, please be very careful because futures is a very sharp two-edged sword. Leverage works both ways.

Many people abuse leverage and they get killed. Others over-trade and they suffer. Nevertheless, oil futures has the highest correlation to oil futures prices. (Duh!)

I have lost money in the futures market.

Not investment or brokerage advice.

74   FormerAptBroker   2008 Jun 20, 7:07am  

The Original Bankster Says:

> Another good one: Chrysler guarantees $2.99
> gas for 3 years with the purchase of an SUV.

I heard a radio ad in Sacramento yesterday where the Chrysler dealer has "Hemi" aka "Gas Sucking" pickups and cars on sale for $9K off sticker...

75   Peter P   2008 Jun 20, 7:11am  

BTW, does anyone know if year 2000 Audi A8 is an okay (reliability-wise) car for occasion uses?

76   DennisN   2008 Jun 20, 8:09am  

National Review has gotten their hands on an internal BofA memo from last March, which purports to be their "wish list" for a bailout.

http://corner.nationalreview.com/post/?q=ODJkN2Q3NTY0MjAwYjJlNTY0NTJmMWEzZTI1OGZjZTg=

It would appear that the Dodd-Shelby bailout bill is just the BofA memo plus some cleanup.

77   DennisN   2008 Jun 20, 10:15am  

Fiat lux - UC motto
Fiat slug - UCSC motto
Fiat currency - government motto? :?

78   coretexity   2008 Jun 20, 10:55am  

# justme Says:
June 20th, 2008 at 11:31 am

Peter,

QM looks good. But do any of the major online brokers support commodity trading?

How different is this than trading USO options?

79   Paul189   2008 Jun 20, 11:33am  

2.99 gas is no different from cash back. They limit how much they will chip in. I see no difference from a cash back offer.

80   Paul189   2008 Jun 20, 11:39am  

Shitty bank (C:NYSE) and SkankAmerika (BAC:NYSE) near 52 week lows!!!

81   Paul189   2008 Jun 20, 11:40am  

GM at 1982 prices

82   Paul189   2008 Jun 20, 11:43am  

What does a GM Bailout look like??? Does anyone recall how up in arms this country was with the Chrysler bailout back in the day?

83   Paul189   2008 Jun 20, 11:45am  

When they had GMAC they could have thrown in a 30 year fixed at 5% when you buy a hummer! Seems they lost their way.

84   lunarpark   2008 Jun 20, 2:41pm  

"BTW, does anyone know if year 2000 Audi A8 is an okay (reliability-wise) car for occasion uses?"

I had an A6 - one of the two best cars I have ever had.

85   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 21, 3:30am  

Coretexity,

My original concern was that ETF offerings such as USO have low float and low market cap. To me that looks like they are susceptible to manipulation, although the fund manager is supposed to make it track oil futures in some sense. So far the tracking has been pretty decent (just overlay the graphs), but can it be guaranteed on a minute-by-minute basis?

It seems more direct to uy/sell contracts (not options) of QMQ8 (august) and so on, but many brokers do not support commodity trading. Peter mentioned Etrade, I could not find anything on their web site. Ameritrade likewise.

I'm not looking for leverage, options or anything like that, just straight long/short contracts would suit me better.

86   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 21, 3:34am  

Speaking of oil futures:

In light if the recent large-scale Israeli air force training exercise (read: preparation for Iran attack), I wonder if the Israeli government or its insiders are going long or short on oil futures? Two reasons, somebody in the government knows what the plans are, and they may also want to hedge against rising oil.

Would that be illegal insider trading ? ;-)

87   DennisN   2008 Jun 21, 10:50am  

Insider trading is defined in terms of insiders to the corporation of interest, not to some outside party that may cause a change to the fortunes of said corporation. For example, if I shorted ExxonMobile prior to blowing up some of their facilities, I would merely be a criminal terrorist and not (God forbid) an inside trader.

88   Peter P   2008 Jun 23, 4:11am  

Anyone tried Wakuriya in San Mateo?

89   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 23, 7:11am  

If I did, would it be illegal insider eating?

90   Peter P   2008 Jun 23, 9:43am  

If I did, would it be illegal insider eating?

Huh?

If you did, I would like to hear what you think about the place.

91   🎂 justme   2008 Jun 23, 12:15pm  

Well, it was because you are a sushi insider, and, uh, I heard about the place from you, and, uh. you know, uh, I was just trying to be funny. Oh well :-)

« First        Comments 61 - 91 of 91        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions