5
0

Rise of the liberal urban bourgeoisie, invisibility of the working class


               
2019 Jan 16, 6:02pm   2,478 views  35 comments

by Patrick   follow (59)  

http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2019/01/frances-ghosts-of-68-general-strike-vs.html

Guilluy: We have a new bourgeoisie, but because they are very cool and progressive, it creates the impression that there is no class conflict anymore. It is really difficult to oppose the hipsters when they say they care about the poor and about minorities.

But actually, they are very much complicit in relegating the working classes to the sidelines. Not only do they benefit enormously from the globalised economy, but they have also produced a dominant cultural discourse which ostracises working-class people.

The middle-class reaction to the yellow vests has been telling. Immediately, the protesters were denounced as xenophobes, anti-Semites and homophobes. The elites present themselves as anti-fascist and anti-racist but this is merely a way of defending their class interests. It is the only argument they can muster to defend their status, but it is not working anymore.

Now the elites are afraid. For the first time, there is a movement which cannot be controlled through the normal political mechanisms. The gilets jaunes didn't emerge from the trade unions or the political parties. It cannot be stopped. There is no ‘off' button. Either the intelligentsia will be forced to properly acknowledge the existence of these people, or they will have to opt for a kind of soft totalitarianism."

Comments 1 - 35 of 35        Search these comments

1   FortWayneAsNancyPelosiHaircut   2019 Jan 16, 7:50pm  

Left wants to erase the world and build it new in their way. Just like Stalinists and Nazis, only with an added twist of inclusiveness for sexually confused.

They are same kind of “nihilists”.
2   Patrick   2019 Jan 16, 9:06pm  

HEYYOU says
Wikipedia -
" Zero Hedge expanded into non-financial analysis,[c] where its editorial has been labelled by some as being associated with the "alt-right",[10][11] as well as being anti-establishment, conspiratorial, and showing a pro-Russian-bias.[10][9] Zero Hedge in-house content is posted under the pseudonym "Tyler Durden"; however, the founder and main editor was identified as Daniel Ivandjiiski.[9]

Wikipedia -
"Daniel Ivandjiiski (Bulgarian: Данаил Иванджийски, born 8 November 1978) is a Bulgarian born,"


It's not from Zero Hedge. The original article is from http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/ I updated the post above to reflect that. Zero Hedge was just quoting.

I've met Charles Hughs Smith. He's a good guy. To call him "alt-right" would be so far off the mark as to be laughable. More of a hippie/commie type.

But the Left has no defense these days for the harm they have done to a hundred million workers by exporting their jobs and importing replacement workers that they have to assign guilt to their victims somehow to make themselves feel better. Usually with the "alt-right" smear, or "racism", or various other -isms.

It's getting kinda tiring since it is so predictable.
3   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Jan 16, 9:07pm  

@Patrick, do you think we've reached peak SJW yet?
4   Patrick   2019 Jan 16, 9:11pm  

I think we will know we have reached peak SJW when they start accusing inanimate objects of RACISM!
5   steverbeaver   2019 Jan 16, 9:13pm  

IMO we are close to the peak. I predict tensions will continue to rise, but a disruptive event that makes the masses live rather uncomfortably will set off a rather rapid unwinding. My bet is critical mass will be reached with the next class of FWM's.
6   CBOEtrader   2019 Jan 16, 9:14pm  

steverbeaver says
IMO we are close to the peak. I predict tensions will continue to rise, but a disruptive event that makes the masses live rather uncomfortably will set off a rather rapid unwinding. My bet is critical mass will be reached with the next class of FWM's.


I wasnt aware we had optimists on pat.net . I thought this was a dark corner of the web
7   Ceffer   2019 Jan 16, 9:55pm  

Patrick says
I think we will know we have reached peak SJW when they start accusing inanimate objects of RACISM!

Inanimate WHITE objects.
8   marcus   2019 Jan 16, 10:04pm  

Patrick says
soft totalitarianism



I fear that's coming here. And I fear that the prospect of a leftist totalitarianism will be the justification for the right wing totalitarianism that we get. You can see early hints of it from Trump. All the talk about how political correctness is ruining us. Testing the waters. Can Trump get away with saying that he's not really a joke, and that it's all becasue of the negative media coverage that the global public opinion of him is so low ?
9   Patrick   2019 Jan 16, 10:17pm  

Trump is quite popular in some countries, like Poland.

The more important point is that Trump is not popular with the "liberal urban bourgeoisie" anywhere, and yet is popular with ordinary people in those same places. The same dynamic is going on in Europe as in America: get SJW's to help import masses of unskilled foreigners to drive down wages and call anyone who objects a racist Nazi blah blah blah.
10   GNL   2019 Jan 17, 3:47am  

Patrick says
I think we will know we have reached peak SJW when they start accusing inanimate objects of RACISM!

I think air has been accused of racism.

https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2014/04/air-pollution-racial-disparities/
11   CBOEtrader   2019 Jan 17, 5:48am  

Our world is now broken into journalists vs comment sections. Journalists are a tiny minority trying to control the narrative, and the comment sections masses arent buying it. This is why they need censorship. They are desperate to appear the majority when the majority is starting to catch on.

Patrick says
The more important point is that Trump is not popular with the "liberal urban bourgeoisie" anywhere


The west is fighting back.

It's not just Trump . It's the entire fake package those bougie types want you to accept.

Read the Gillette ad comment section. Or almost any comment section outside of the huffpo. https://news.yahoo.com/51-old-man-arrested-striking-143414130.html for example, go to the conversations in twitter or any forum about this incident. Obviously race flamers came running... but almost EVERYONE who watched the video blamed the crowd of 20 thug idiot children who literally harassed this man until dropped this little girl.

The punch was indeed violent, difficult not to suggest he deserves some punishment.

The point is people arent buying into the narrative anymore. The fake news media can no longer pretend to be the majority or rational narrative. Claims of racism or almost anything coming out of Wapo/CNN/Msnbs/Huffpo are automatically seen as the propaganda by everyone but the most indoctrinated.

It is funny listening to the faithful believers try to say things like "normal people all just KNOW trump is a (liar/racist/etc...).
12   Rin   2019 Jan 17, 7:17am  

This so-called "Nuevo Bourgeoisie" is in essence, the ppl who hang with the Hillary Clintons and Liz Warrens of the world. In other words, they have cushy jobs or consulting gigs, where in effect, they earn money just like any other rentier, who owns lots of proprieties a/o businesses, but in this case, put on an act that they support the poor, the working poor, minorities, and everyone else who's downtrodden.

The truth is that everyone, whose family doesn't already have money, is becoming downtrodden. The forces of offshoring, automation, etc, will eliminate jobs down the road, not increase them. So yes, while it's possible to formulate strategies which can keep jobs stateside for a bit (basically Trump's tough stance on trade, etc), in the end, however, it's only a temporary wrinkle in time, before the jobs disappear once again.

It's over, there is no hope for humanity. By 2050, 80% of today's jobs will be gone forever. And no, the so-called creative economy will not generate jobs which pay. Think about it, how many newly minted "creative" architects, who've put in nearly 4+ years of post-undergrad training and certificates, earn these days? ... some $40K-$60K. Jeez ... a nurse starts at that (and with even less training) and as long as there are hospitals around, will probably find equivalent work if a clinic closes whereas that architect will probably be leaving his field if his firm loses a client or two.

And I'm talking about architects graduating from places like Columbia, Harvard, and MIT. I can only imagine how bad it must be for those from lesser schools.

Right now, because my firm does this PR stunt with academic institutes, you'd be shocked at how many graduate students in areas like architecture, natural sciences, etc, want to work in financial services. I'd say that there's a deluge of applicants coming from those areas and unfortunately, w/o a connection at the firm, most won't get a phone screening.

None of this bodes well. Only a decade ago, despite the outsourcing in IT, many of those same students would opt for a programming career but now, seeing that being Bezo's or Zuckerberg's bitch isn't the best plan, looking ahead, will do anything to get a job in a rentier sector like finance. Some start as programmers, with a hope of segueing into finance later on.
13   FortWayneAsNancyPelosiHaircut   2019 Jan 17, 7:42am  

No it’ll get worse.
Left is very organized, they own education sector, and all that brainwashing against normal society is going to cause a lot of damage still.

They even want to teach gender identity in middle school as propaganda.
TwoScoopsOfSpaceForce says
do you think we've reached peak SJW yet?
14   Bd6r   2019 Jan 17, 8:18am  

marcus says
And I fear that the prospect of a leftist totalitarianism will be the justification for the right wing totalitarianism that we get.

Leftist totalitarianism is already here. Right wing totalitarianism which society might be moving towards is the reaction to already existing left wing lunatic totalitarianism.

If it is perfectly OK to be racist against whites and Asians (including institutionalized, state-sponsored discrimination), to be sexist against males, to bash those population groups, etc, then argument that there is only a "prospect of leftist totalitarianism" is not true. Totalitarianism is already here.
15   NDrLoR   2019 Jan 17, 9:05am  

d6rB says
Right wing totalitarianism which society might be moving towards is the reaction to already existing left wing lunatic totalitarianism.
It's the same principle that caused the rise of The Moral Majority with people such as Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell in the late 70's and into the 1980's. The right was reacting to a decade of societal evisceration caused by the sexual revolution and all the human destruction left in its wake--abandoned children, spouses, significant others who had never been married, STD's that had never existed before and eventually AIDS in the gay community--the source of today's 40% plus out-of-wedlock births among whites and 70% among black people. But let someone stand up and say enough is enough and you would have thought the world was coming to an end such was the hysteria from the left. You would have never had the rise of a Moral Majority in the 1950's or early 1960's because the actual majority was firmly on the side of family stability and sexual restraint even though some did stray as they always do. The stigmas against out-of-wedlock pregnancy and sleeping around worked.
16   georgeliberte   2019 Jan 17, 9:46am  

Patrick says, 'Charles Hughs Smith. He's a good guy. To call him "alt-right" would be so far off the mark as to be laughable. More of a hippie/commie type.'
While I have never met him, I have been reading his writings for a long time and the claim that he is alt-right is silly and I have never seen a hint form him. That is what made this article more poignant. What I particularly like is describing the ctr-left as an elitist exploitative and fascist new bourgeoisie is dead on accurate.
We do not need a rightwing counter reaction, we need common sense and for my bit, libertarian views.
17   Ceffer   2019 Jan 17, 1:49pm  

d6rB says
Leftist totalitarianism is already here.

Pretty much 'Leftism' is nothing more than a duck blind for consolidating power amongst the idiocracy, free-shit proletariat. The Libby Royalty don't believe a bit of it except as points of demagoguery.
18   CBOEtrader   2019 Jan 17, 1:59pm  

Rin says
Some start as programmers, with a hope of segueing into finance later on.


They can just go digital market boner pills. As long as your sex bots do their jobs, should be an unending demand.
19   Heraclitusstudent   2019 Jan 17, 2:30pm  

Patrick says
Now the elites are afraid. For the first time, there is a movement which cannot be controlled through the normal political mechanisms. The gilets jaunes didn’t emerge from the trade unions or the political parties. It cannot be stopped. There is no ‘off’ button. Either the intelligentsia will be forced to properly acknowledge the existence of these people, or they will have to opt for a kind of soft totalitarianism."


Zerohedge is typical Russian propaganda. Always try to foment resentment of people against "the elite".
If necessary do that conflating completely different things: like the leftist gilets jaunes in France against the US liberal elite.
As if the elite in France was "liberal".
As if there were any "gilets jaunes" in the US that couldn't be stopped.
20   Bd6r   2019 Jan 17, 2:35pm  

Heraclitusstudent says
Zerohedge is typical Russian propaganda.

Sadly, true. Putin can never be wrong according to ZH, Russia is ideal despite being the worst kleptocracy in the world, etc. I have stopped reading them because they are blatantly hypocritical. Their adherence to reporting standards of Russia Today make me wonder if ZH is not funded by Russia.
21   HeadSet   2019 Jan 18, 3:11pm  

HEYYOU says
INDEPENDENTS RULE!


You spelled "DEPENDS" wrong, old man.
23   Eric_Holder   2026 Jan 12, 3:13pm  

I don't get all this fellationing of "working class": these fucks are as likely to (attempt to) take you to the cleanears as any other asshole. Probably even more so nowadays when people know more about "white collar" stuff than about "blue collar" stuff. For example I was given quotes for replacement of water heater ranging from $6,000 to $19,000 (not a typo). One working class cunt perfrormed a whole song and dance about how the shttiest, chinesiumest, cheapest brand he was pushing (American Standard) is better than State or even Bradford White ("these aren't what they used to be, maaan"). When I asked another working class clown to itemize the quote he refused because "we're a business and there is all kind of stuff there like worker comp and car insurance and shit so it's impossible to itemize" all to avoid showing the cost of the heater and making it obvious that they are attempting to charge $1000s per hour of labor. If this is salt of the earth types I'd hate to meet real weasels.
24   HeadSet   2026 Jan 12, 3:36pm  

Eric_Holder says

I was given quotes for replacement of water heater ranging from $6,000 to $19,000 (not a typo

Damn! A basic tank water heater should be around $1500 installed, while a tankless should only be around $2400. Even less if replacing electric heater where he just unfastens the old and replaces with similar model.
25   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2026 Jan 12, 3:49pm  

Eric_Holder says


I don't get all this fellationing of "working class": these fucks are as likely to (attempt to) take you to the cleanears as any other asshole. Probably even more so nowadays when people know more about "white collar" stuff than about "blue collar" stuff. For example I was given quotes for replacement of water heater ranging from $6,000 to $19,000 (not a typo). One working class cunt perfrormed a whole song and dance about how the shttiest, chinesiumest, cheapest brand he was pushing (American Standard) is better than State or even Bradford White ("these aren't what they used to be, maaan"). When I asked another working class clown to itemize the quote he refused because "we're a business and there is all kind of stuff there like worker comp and car insurance and shit so it's impossible to itemize" all to avoid showing the cost of the heater and making it obvious that they are attempting to charge $1000s per hour of labor. If this is salt of the earth types I'd hate to meet real weasels.


This is consequence of our nation is drowning in sin, sin that is greed. When society wholesale rejects Christ, this is our consequence, an unbearable society where everyone tries to screw everyone else. So many are just there to see what they can get from someone else, what program they can abuse, from whom they can take, whom can they use to get what they want. This isn't what America used to be.

Too many crapy salesmen everywhere, trying to markup every service and transaction middle manning it.
26   Patrick   2026 Jan 12, 7:56pm  

Eric_Holder says

I don't get all this fellationing of "working class": these fucks are as likely to (attempt to) take you to the cleanears as any other asshole.


They are fellow Americans who have been screwed by outsourcing to China and insourcing criminal aliens.

I don't think they are morally superior to other Americans. I just don't want them to be sacrificed for the profits of bosses and landlords.

Anyway, when the working class gets more money, they spend it. That's good for the economy. When the rich get more money, they throw it on the pile in the basement.
27   yawaraf   2026 Jan 12, 10:09pm  

When the rich get more money they acquire more capital, in immortal structures such as corporations and trusts. They concentrate power, over generations, which makes it unreasonably difficult for those born without to become independent.
28   TheAntiPanicanLearingCenter   2026 Jan 12, 11:25pm  

One negative thing about too much capital is bubbles.

Have we been lurching from one bubble to another this Century so far?
29   Eric_Holder   2026 Jan 13, 9:43am  

HeadSet says


Damn! A basic tank water heater should be around $1500 installed


My problem is I know that. I also can install the fucking thing myself. Which I did eventually after getting tired of dealing with clowns.
30   Eric_Holder   2026 Jan 13, 9:45am  

Patrick says

They are fellow Americans who have been screwed by outsourcing to China and insourcing criminal aliens.


So they feel they have the right to turn around and try to screw me? "What does Marcellus Walles look like?"

And it's not like I wasn't screwed by the outsourcing to India and insourcing of H1B cunts.
31   Eric_Holder   2026 Jan 13, 9:48am  

FortWayneHatesRealtors says


Eric_Holder says


I don't get all this fellationing of "working class": these fucks are as likely to (attempt to) take you to the cleanears as any other asshole. Probably even more so nowadays when people know more about "white collar" stuff than about "blue collar" stuff. For example I was given quotes for replacement of water heater ranging from $6,000 to $19,000 (not a typo). One working class cunt perfrormed a whole song and dance about how the shttiest, chinesiumest, cheapest brand he was pushing (American Standard) is better than State or even Bradford White ("these aren't what they used to be, maaan"). When I asked another working class clown to itemize the quote he refused because "we're a business and there is all kind of stuff there like worker comp and car insurance and shit so it's impossible to itemize" all to avoid showing the cost of the heater and making it obvious that they are attempting to charge $1000s per hour of labor. If this is salt of the earth types I'd hate to meet real weasels.


This is consequence of our nation is drowning in sin, sin that is greed. When society wholesale rejects Christ, this is our consequence, an unbearable society where everyone tries to screw everyone else. So many are just there to see what they can get from someone else, what program they can abuse, from whom they can take, whom can they use to get what they want. This isn't what America used to be.

Too many crapy salesmen everywhere, trying to markup every service and transaction middle manning it.



These were not middle men - these were guys with trucks and wrenches and stained uniforms. Can't trust anybody anymore. There is nothing special about "working class".
32   HeadSet   2026 Jan 13, 12:39pm  

Patrick says

When the rich get more money, they throw it on the pile in the basement.

Working class and middle class do that as well, once they are established. But they will leave it to children and grandkids who will promptly spend it.
33   HeadSet   2026 Jan 13, 12:41pm  

Eric_Holder says

I also can install the fucking thing myself. Which I did eventually after getting tired of dealing with clowns.

I have also installed electric water heaters in my rental properties. I leave the gas hot water heaters up to the pros, though.
34   AD   2026 Jan 14, 10:46pm  

A lot of the left wing upper class work the government like as GS-14's at USAID, Dept of Education, etc.

Loudon County Virginia has a large percentage of federal civil servants and contractors and that explains why it is the wealthiest county in the USA.
35   Patrick   2026 Jan 15, 1:30am  

Patrick says

The middle-class reaction to the yellow vests has been telling. Immediately, the protesters were denounced as xenophobes, anti-Semites and homophobes. The elites present themselves as anti-fascist and anti-racist but this is merely a way of defending their class interests. It is the only argument they can muster to defend their status, but it is not working anymore.

Now the elites are afraid. For the first time, there is a movement which cannot be controlled through the normal political mechanisms. The gilets jaunes didn't emerge from the trade unions or the political parties. It cannot be stopped. There is no ‘off' button. Either the intelligentsia will be forced to properly acknowledge the existence of these people, or they will have to opt for a kind of soft totalitarianism."


They have opted for soft totalitarianism.

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste