patrick.net

NuttBoxer says

rocketjoe79 says

BayArea says

When and where were these dogs breed to kill?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_fighting#Breed_origins

Nope. This describes breeding strong animals, nothing in the article says that means they must kill and be aggressive. I own two guns, which I keep loaded at all times, not in a safe. I guess I'm dangerous then, and am about to shoot the next person who walks in my house right? By your logic, body builders are all mass killers, waiting to snap.

Now your just makin up BS. A dog has a mind of it's own. Not only that but, do you reject the fact that breeds are created for certain purposes? How many stories have been told that "the dog was always loving and friendly. I have no idea why it snapped". There was a story of a family that had 2 Pits for over 5 years. One day they both attacked her young children. She did everything she could but to no avail, the dogs killed both of her children right in front of her. What should happen to that woman?

mell says

That's different as most animals, esp. dogs, are instinctive creatures, whereas humans are mainly driven by their brains.

You still believe that human beings are chiefly driven by their intellect after the last 2 years? I respectfully disagree.

BayArea says

Is it ok to have people own lions and alligators in urban high density areas? … because freedom

Yes, it absolutely is.

They just need to be responsible, legally - meaning legally liable, for anything that those animals do.

I remember when some Presa Canario's killed Mr. Whipple's daughter.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Diane_Whipple

Good doggie, good,…., aaaaarghhhh!!!!!

I don't think the babe below would be able to control this dog if it went off.

GNL says

NuttBoxer says

rocketjoe79 says

BayArea says

When and where were these dogs breed to kill?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_fighting#Breed_origins

Nope. This describes breeding strong animals, nothing in the article says that means they must kill and be aggressive. I own two guns, which I keep loaded at all times, not in a safe. I guess I'm dangerous then, and am about to shoot the next person who walks in my house right? By your logic, body builders are all mass killers, waiting to snap.

Now your just makin up BS. A dog has a mind of it's own. Not only that but,...

"Well, he's never hurt anyone before".

NuttBoxer says

You pull up on a leash, never back. Create tension in the opposite direction you want your dog to go.

With all my dogs, I'd train them to heel. It's a shitty process, but it's doable. It's quite simple, if my dog got ahead of me, I'd stop and bring the dog back to my side before we'd continue while saying "heel". It could take me literally an hour to walk a mile. Dogs are goddamn patient, all you need to do is be more patient.

A dog should never pull on leash, and if they do, don't just deal with it, give the animal a sharp yank. Does the bastard just want to do whatever he fucking wants to do? Two can play at that game. When I was training a dog that did that, first it's a light yank to let them know I'm annoyed. If they do it again, it gets harder, and harder and harder, until there's a yelp.

Correction needs to ALWAYS be done. Reward is random, punishment isn't. You always punish. You don't have to hurt the animal, but you correct them.

A dog yanking on the leash is showing you disrespect AND the dog is chocking himself. Don't let your dog be an asshole to you. They aren't kids, but they are KIND of like kids, they don't think about you so much.

There are several dog breeds that cause most human Deaths and Serious Injuries. Pit Bulls are ALWAYS on top of the list. The breed is unnecessary and dangerous. They need to go.

rocketjoe79 says

The breed is unnecessary and dangerous. They need to go.

The breed of human that believes in giving up rights for just a feeling of safety need to go.

You don't want a virus or to get mauled by a bear or get robbed or any number of bad things? Stay inside. I've had quite enough of other people's phobias being imposed on me these past few years.

DhammaStep says

rocketjoe79 says

The breed is unnecessary and dangerous. They need to go.

The breed of human that believes in giving up rights for just a feeling of safety need to go.

You don't want a virus or to get mauled by a bear or get robbed or any number of bad things? Stay inside. I've had quite enough of other people's phobias being imposed on me these past few years.

If someone gets their face ripped off, what should happen to you? What has happened to any of these owners whose dogs have done such things?

My daughter and son in law have a 1 year old Cane Corso. The dog knows me. Last time I was there, I picked up my granddaughter and was playing around with her. She was laughing and having a good time. The dog was jumping at me and and biting my arm. He was doing what he was bred to do. Eventually I had to give the dog a hard knee to the chest. That did not deter him. I told my son in law to handle his dog. We will not go over there again unless the dog is crated. NO, they do not mistreat their dogs.

No, I did not make this story up.

DhammaStep says

rocketjoe79 says

The breed is unnecessary and dangerous. They need to go.

The breed of human that believes in giving up rights for just a feeling of safety need to go.

You don't want a virus or to get mauled by a bear or get robbed or any number of bad things? Stay inside. I've had quite enough of other people's phobias being imposed on me these past few years.

I was knocked down and severely bitten by a German Shepard leaped an 8' chain link fence and chased me to the street when I was a paperboy. Owner is still responsible. They weren't home to "control" their dog.

GNL says

DhammaStep says

rocketjoe79 says

The breed is unnecessary and dangerous. They need to go.

The breed of human that believes in giving up rights for just a feeling of safety need to go.

You don't want a virus or to get mauled by a bear or get robbed or any number of bad things? Stay inside. I've had quite enough of other people's phobias being imposed on me these past few years.

If someone gets their face ripped off, what should happen to you? What has happened to any of these owners whose dogs have done such things?

There was a famous case in SFBA about two dogs getting out of an apartment and killing a neighbor. Both owners went to prison for a long time.

PS. The problem with "bully" breeds in the US is that most of these dogs are bred by lowlife ghetto scum and the the most typical path for these dogs into normal folks' homes is through shelters. So basically you don't know how that adorable pitbull puppy was bred, have no idea of the lineage and whether there were some vicious and uncontrollable dogs amongst its ancestors. When dogs are bred by responsible breeders such bad apples are weeded out from the gene pool. When Jamal and Trayvon decide to run a puppy mill go get some dogs for dogfighting - the opposite happens. And no, you can't control any dog, irregardless of its pedigree - it's just hubris and internet bravado talking.

If I was walking down the street and two pitbulls come running down the street at me my reaction would be 100% different if it was two golden retrievers, it would be common sense. I've seen enough issues with pitbulls going agro, my best friend was attached by one he had to smash its head in to get it to let go.

rocketjoe79 says

I was knocked down and severely bitten by a German Shepard leaped an 8' chain link fence and chased me to the street when I was a paperboy. Owner is still responsible. They weren't home to "control" their dog.

Did you press charges?

RC2006 says

If I was walking down the street and two pitbulls come running down the street at me my reaction would be 100% if it was two golden retrievers, it would be common sense. I've seen enough issues with pitbulls going agro, my best friend was attached by one he had to smash its head in to get it to let go.

Golden retrievers don't appear in rap music videos, not being bred in ghettos, never used in illegal dogfighting, etc. So different reaction is completely warranted. The gene pool of pitbulls, Staffordshire terriers, Presa Canario and several other breeds, has been severely tainted by irresponsible uncontrolled breeding aimed at participation in dogfighting - it's a fact.

GNL says

Now your just makin up BS. A dog has a mind of it's own. Not only that but, do you reject the fact that breeds are created for certain purposes? How many stories have been told that "the dog was always loving and friendly. I have no idea why it snapped".

So you've gotta be against rifles then right? I mean they are created for only purpose, defense of country. Having a dog that can defend your property from intruders, just wrong huh? What about my husky from when I was a kid. She was a stray from the woods in Michigan. Could've had some wolf in here. Dangerous right, since huskies definitely know how to hunt. We found her because the bus stop was at the end of our street, and she used to come meet the kids after school every day. Viscous animal...

I personally have never heard a single story like that, and my BIL has been breeding and selling American Bully's for years. Like I mentioned, the sweetest dog we ever owned was big. My chihuahua is the only one that's ever gone after a kid.

GNL says

One day they both attacked her young children. She did everything she could but to no avail, the dogs killed both of her children right in front of her. What should happen to that woman?

What the fuck man!? You don't think enough has happened to here already. Don't you know not to kick someone when they're down?

GNL says

The dog was jumping at me and and biting my arm. He was doing what he was bred to do. Eventually I had to give the dog a hard knee to the chest. That did not deter him. I told my son in law to handle his dog. We will not go over there again unless the dog is crated. NO, they do not mistreat their dogs.

Great example of someone who should not own a dog. If your son had properly trained and mastered that dog, never would have happened. If he's not careful, he will be one of your statistics.

My wife's friend does rescues for a living. They own the biggest fucking dog I've ever seen in my life. The dog has some training, but friend is one of those uneven people who view dogs as humans, not animals. They started noticing the dog getting anxious around the kids and the pool, so they've stopped having him out at parties. My wife has helped out when they're away a few times. Once she was out in the yard with my youngest, and the dog got a little aggressive with the contact, and very lightly put it's mouth on her arm while she was holding our daughter(because the dog was making her nervous). She jumped the fence and got them both out of there. She won't have my youngest around the dog anymore when she helps out, and is pretty careful herself around the dog. I've been with him since then, thrown his rope toy, played tug-of-war with him. But I make sure to maintain a calm demeanor, and never, EVER let the dog initiate contact with me, or get too close if I don't want him too.

People that don't know what they're doing are dangerous, whether it's guns or dogs.

rocketjoe79 says

I was knocked down and severely bitten by a German Shepard leaped an 8' chain link fence and chased me to the street when I was a paperboy. Owner is still responsible. They weren't home to "control" their dog.

When I was two, neighbor had some big dog, and every day when neighbor came home, I used to say hi to him, and would stick my hand right through the fence to pet his dog. Still have both hands today...

Hugh_Mongous says

has been severely tainted by irresponsible uncontrolled breeding aimed at participation in dogfighting - it's a fact.

So any group that's naturally larger is going to be aggressive, violent, and kill? Guessing you stay far away from Nordic countries. Sweden, Denmark, Holland, dangerous places huh? North Korea on the other hand, or China, super safe, look at how small those Asians are!

NuttBoxer says

Great example of someone who should not own a dog. If your son had properly trained and mastered that dog, never would have happened. If he's not careful, he will be one of your statistics.

It was an example of the innateness in that dog breed. He didn't teach the dog to do that, it was bred into the dog. Don't you get that? Also, comparing dogs and guns is pretty inappropriate.

Hugh_Mongous says

rocketjoe79 says

I was knocked down and severely bitten by a German Shepard leaped an 8' chain link fence and chased me to the street when I was a paperboy. Owner is still responsible. They weren't home to "control" their dog.

Did you press charges?

This was a long time ago and I was a kid. So, no.

NuttBoxer says

Great example of someone who should not own a dog. If your son had properly trained and mastered that dog, never would have happened.

Or he tried and failed because the dog is genetically incapable of being trained to the necessary standard. There are retrievers which can't retrieve, shepherds which can't herd, standard poodles dumb as a bag of rocks, guard dogs which can't guard and then there are overly aggressive dogs which can't be trained to be 100% docile in a normal family environment. Getting a dog from a known lineage with ancestors proven to be able to do what they are supposed to do decreases chances to get a "dud", but does't not 100% guarantees it won't be one.

My other question would be: why the fuck one gets such a dog as a family companion? They weren't bred for that in the first place. What's the point of pressing, say, Dogo Argentino into a job of a coach cushion when they were bred for pack hunting of wild boars?

GNL says

It was an example of the innateness in that dog breed. He didn't teach the dog to do that, it was bred into the dog. Don't you get that? Also, comparing dogs and guns is pretty inappropriate.

Of course he didn't teach the dog to do that. Seems like he didn't teach the dog do much of anything. Didn't teach it he's the master of the house. Didn't teach it not to jump. Didn't teach it to respect others space. Just like if I leave a loaded gun around a 10 year old, and don't teach them shit about it, something bad might happen.

Also agree on the dog/gun comparison, it's not fair to the dog.

Eric Holder says

Or he tried and failed because the dog is genetically incapable of being trained to the necessary standard.

So what about all the stories I've told about big dogs who don't exhibit those behaviors? Do I just happen to know every exception to the rule?

All of you who don't understand dogs. If you want to learn more trying watching one of Caesar Milan's shows. Pretty entertaining, and you'll get to see him train these big vicious animals using the same techniques he applies to small breeds. In fact, he specializes in Pit Bulls, and has refuted every point made here resoundingly, because it's what he does for a living, and how he started his career.
That guy isn't a genius or anything, he just really knows dogs, and his experience shows.

So, according to NuttBoxer, owners of dangerous dogs are supposed to...
1. Be expert dog trainers except there's no governing body to decide who can and who can't own these dogs.
2. Not believe that breeds have been bred for different purposes.

Am I close to correct?

Btw, I agree that my son inlaw should not own a Cane Corso. Now what?

NuttBoxer says

Hugh_Mongous says

has been severely tainted by irresponsible uncontrolled breeding aimed at participation in dogfighting - it's a fact.

So any group that's naturally larger is going to be aggressive, violent, and kill? Guessing you stay far away from Nordic countries. Sweden, Denmark, Holland, dangerous places huh? North Korea on the other hand, or China, super safe, look at how small those Asians are!

I stay out of black areas.

https://www.ktvu.com/news/pitbull-attacks-for-third-time-neighbors-call-for-dog-to-be-euthanized

The chief overpaid dog catcher insists she did the right thing by not euthanizing, the dog in the first place.

https://slaynews.com/news/family-releases-update-on-georgia-boy-mauled-by-pit-bulls-what-little-bit-justin-has-been-up-today-he-just-wanted-to-say-thank-you-to-everyone/

Family Gives Update on Georgia Boy Mauled by Pit Bulls: ‘He Just Wanted to Say Thank You to Everyone’

GNL says

1. Be expert dog trainers except there's no governing body to decide who can and who can't own these dogs.
2. Not believe that breeds have been bred for different purposes.

If you want to own a dog capable of killing someone, absolutely on number one. I don't require anyone else to know that I am personally responsible for my actions and mistakes. For those who do, your problems start there.

I don't believe I ever said anything close to number two. The disagreement here is you believe dogs have been bred to kill, I know they have only been trained to do so, regardless of their genetic capabilities.

The problem here isn't conflicting ideas, it's a knowledge gap. And a very common one from what I see in most dog owners.

NuttBoxer says

body builders are all mass killers, waiting to snap.

Agreed!

NuttBoxer says

GNL says

1. Be expert dog trainers except there's no governing body to decide who can and who can't own these dogs.
2. Not believe that breeds have been bred for different purposes.

If you want to own a dog capable of killing someone, absolutely on number one. I don't require anyone else to know that I am personally responsible for my actions and mistakes. For those who do, your problems start there.

I don't believe I ever said anything close to number two. The disagreement here is you believe dogs have been bred to kill, I know they have only been trained to do so, regardless of their genetic capabilities.

The problem here isn't conflicting ideas, it's a knowledge gap. And a very common one from what I see in most dog owners.

If you're going to compare dogs and guns, then we need dog registration, classes and rules/laws on where you can take them and how old you must be to own one. Seems fair, right?

GNL says

If you're going to compare dogs and guns, then we need dog registration, classes and rules/laws on where you can take them and how old you must be to own one. Seems fair, right?

I think a lot of that is already in place. But again, there's a big difference between something that is made to kill, a gun, and something that must be trained, or neglected to create the same affect, a dog.

The comparison rings true in that owning big dogs, and owning guns requires personal responsibility. The other part that is true, if you see a man with a big dog, or a gun, coming down the street, you assess your risk by the character of the man, not the dog or the gun.

NuttBoxer says

But again, there's a big difference between something that is made to kill, a gun, and something that must be trained, or neglected to create the same affect, a dog.

This is complete bullshit.

That's the kind of response I'd expect from a vaxhead. Goes to show you shouldn't judge them too harshly, as anytime you let emotion rule over logic, you will fall into the same pattern they do.

dangerous weapon

NuttBoxer says

if you see a man with a big dog, or a gun, coming down the street, you assess your risk by the character of the man, not the dog or the gun.

But that means that I would have to be judgmental and possibly racist.

RC2006 says

I stay out of black areas.

That has always been a good policy

https://www.ksat.com/news/local/2023/02/24/watch-live-san-antonio-police-at-scene-of-serious-dog-attack-on-west-side/

SAN ANTONIO – A “horrific scene” unfolded on the West Side Friday afternoon after a brutal dog attack claimed an elderly man’s life and left three other people injured, officials said.

As of Friday night, San Antonio police confirmed one of the dogs’ owners has been arrested.

Christian Alexander Moreno, 31, is facing a felony charge of attack by dangerous dog causes death and a felony charge of injury to an elderly. ...

When San Antonio fire crews arrived at the scene, they saw an 81-year-old man being dragged on the sidewalk by one of the two dogs involved in the attack.

SAFD Chief Charles Hood said the man was “completely bloody” before crews made their way off of the fire truck.

“This is not something normal for us. We usually don’t show up and have to defend patients from animals or ourselves,” Hood said.

The dogs also confronted firefighters, who had to fight them off with pickaxes and pike poles so they could attend to the victims, Hood said.

One of the fire captains was bit in the leg, but is OK. The dogs also attacked a woman, who was critically injured and another person.

First comment in the comment section of that article...

"Pit bulls kill 10 or more babies per year in the USA.

Imagine a helpless baby screaming in agony and terror as a dog rips the facial flesh off, one piece at a time, and eats it. Then they break the jaw and rip out the baby's tongue. 5-10 minutes for baby to finally die of blood loss. This is why coroners don't like to release their reports on these cases, it's too sickening.

Pit bulls were bred in the 1700s to torture bulls in a fighting ring (pit bull).

In American in 2022, we allow these dogs to torture babies.

Congratulations to everyone."

Patrick says

Christian Alexander Moreno, 31, is facing a felony charge of attack by dangerous dog causes death and a felony charge of injury to an elderly. ...

Glad their charging the person responsible, but why isn't it at least manslaughter? If Christian is in this area, see's a gang-banger walk by, and puts his gun on the ground, the hood picks it up and kills the old man, is it really any different?