patrick.net

Eric Holder says

What's there to negotiate about, except unconditional surrender?

Exactly. Paleban defenders "Forget" that the UN already approved an Israeli State, but the Palestinians refused to negotiate ANYTHING. They rejected so much as a few miles around Tel Aviv as a Jewish city-state. They keep starting wars and getting defeated but still want "River to Sea".

There was never an Arab Palestinian state in all history, not a one. There is no 'occupied' territory because there is no state that was occupied. Jordan illegally annexed Judea and Samaria in 1947 lacking both a causus belli or international approval, expelled the Jews in 1948, but lost physical control in 1967, and released it's claims in 1981. There is only 'disputed' territory, big difference.

Levantine Arabs have 4 states: Jordan, Syria, Iraq, and Lebanon. The vast majority of Palestinians are decended from either Bosnians brought in around 1890-1900 by the Ottomans to repopulize the almost empty Vilayets of Akko, Nablus, etc. (the Ottomans didn't have a Palestine as a province, either) or Syrians and Egyptians that came when the Zionists began building factories and draining wetlands for farms for work. Most of the native Arabs, the Bedouin, are 90% pro-Israel because Israel treated them better than any Turk or Arab Fellahin (city dweller).

As for Palestinians, Gulf Arabs have long tired of them. Kuwaiti Palestinians helped Saddam invade in 1991. Lebanese Palestinians started the Civil War there when they were kicked out of Jordan for trying to Coup the state and remove the King and Parliament for PLO rule. Syria keeps Palestinians in Ghettos because they have a habit of fomenting insurrection. Egypt has a 3-layer wall with Gaza that's closed tight 99% of the time, because everytime Egypt opens it for a few days, a few weeks later Pyramid or Red Sea resorts tourists are getting shot and planes getting bombed, what a coincidence.

Oh, and when Egypt discovers Hamas tunnels under their wall with Gaza, the Egyptians don't pump sea water into them. They pump sewage.

Attempting to Judaize Palestinians is a good idea, but Islam is so ferocious against conversion FROM Islam, it would probably start a holy war for real.

Nearly impossible to convert muslims

Only because they all feel the threat of violence from other Muslims.

But if a significant number escape Islam without getting killed, I think a huge wave would follow.

Blue says

So does, the Islamic Jihad spreads all over including Latin American now!
https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2023/oct/31/israel-hamas-war-live-updates-latest-news-today-hamas-clashes-idf-gaza-aid-plan-failure

I guess. Just remember that Israel created this problem.

AmericanKulak says

Exactly. Paleban defenders "Forget" that the UN already approved an Israeli State, but the Palestinians refused to negotiate ANYTHING

First, the UN violated the right of self determination in UN Resolution 181 which created Israel. The Jewish population was a minority at the time, and the Arabs were the majority in the region. The majority of Arabs opposed partition, and the majority of Jews favored it, yet the Arab population was ignored.

Second, the Palestinians regularly negotiate, it's Israel that refuses to do it. What was the "generous offer" given to the Palestinians in the 1990's? Nobody knows, because it's not a generous offer and it's kept secret. It's just a claim. Hamas has offered, repeatedly, to return the hostages, of a ceasefire and it's Israel that refuses to do that. Did you know they offered this? We really do not have a press.

AmericanKulak says

There was never an Arab Palestinian state in all history, not a one.

There was never an Israel. There's no mention of it in Roman, Egyptian or Greek historical documents. The entire "state" is Jewish mythology. Name a king of Israel. Find a map of Israel at any time before 1948.

Palestine is a place, like Northern NY or the Donbass, they aren't states either, but people live there.

AmericanKulak says

Levantine Arabs have 4 states: Jordan, Syria, Iraq, and Lebanon. The vast majority of Palestinians are decended from either Bosnians brought in around 1890-1900 by the Ottomans to repopulize the almost empty Vilayets of Akko,

This isn't true. The people of Palestine have been there for 100's of years, under the Ottoman Empire. The Crusades were part of an attempt to recapture the land for Christians.

AmericanKulak says

As for Palestinians, Gulf Arabs have long tired of them. Kuwaiti Palestinians helped Saddam invade in 1991. Lebanese Palestinians started the Civil War there when they were kicked out of Jordan for trying to Coup the state and remove the King and Parliament for PLO rule.

Won't argue this. The Sunni and Shia are stupid and mortal enemies. They hate each other more than anybody else.

richwicks says

Name a king of Israel.

Solomon.

Patrick says

richwicks says

Name a king of Israel.

Solomon.

Outside of the Torah.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon

Solomon also called Jedidiah, was a monarch of ancient Israel and the son and successor of King David, according to the Hebrew Bible or Old Testament.

EVERYTHING about Israeli "history" is based on the Torah / Bible. As far as I know, there are no historical records of an Israeli state ever existing prior to 1948. I could be wrong in this, but I've never seen it. I think that Israel is about as real as Camelot.

In time, it will become established "fact" that Israel was initially a land without a people for a people without a land. We've seen this kind of junk in our lifetime. The Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor for no reason at all, the US was neutral in the war - or so it's taught. The US Civil War was fought over slavery, not taxation. We went to war against Vietnam because of the Gulf of Tonkin Incident. We constantly create mythologies.

Patrick says

richwicks says

Name a king of Israel.

Solomon.

The most superficial examination reveals there are several independently verified by archeaology, including mentions by their enemies, which is the best kind of independent verification possible, being named by the opponents contemporary to your existence:


Then there are chieftains dating all the way back to the Pharaoh Akenhaten (~1300BC):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labaya
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdi-Heba

As well as the Haiburu, shephards who lived between settled states in Israel/Canaan.

@richwicks The Romans waged a war against ancient Israel, and there are non-Jewish records of that.

You could argue that Israel ceased to exist as a distinct country after the Romans destroyed the temple in 70 AD, but there is a ton of evidence that it did exist as a country before that point.

https://www.britannica.com/event/Siege-of-Jerusalem-70

Judea was a client Kingdom of the Romans in many ways similar to Armenian Client Kings of Rome/Parthia, and indeed the Book of Daniel is prophecy that the "Eagle" will (Romans) over come the Greeks (Seluecids)

The Roman Arch of Titus commemorated the Roman defeat of Israel, and even includes an image of a menorah taken from the temple:

AmericanKulak says

Judea was a client Kingdom of the Romans

You're right, the Romans called the area Judea and it was under Roman rule already by that point.

Dawson and the rest of the Repeater Gang aren't great sources for Ancient History. Or Modern, for that matter. Hama early 1980s probably doesn't get discussed, nor the Church of the Redeemer in Ain el-Rummaneh, a suburb of Beirut being gunned up by the PLO.

When Christian Militias began setting up roadblocks to identify and disarm Palestinians refugees in Beirut who arrived after being kicked out of Jordan for trying to topple the King of Jordan, the Lebanese Civil War began. Palestinians were forbidden to bear arms as refugees, and many were illegal and not supposed to be in Lebanon at all. The Muh Assad the Very Great Lion got involved on the side of the Palestinians.

Also, Judea wasn't the only area to be ethnically cleansed by the Romans for revolt. And it was done again under Hadrian.

There's another one. Try to find any reference to "Dacia" on a map or in modern discussion. You can't, because it was turned into...(fill in the blank) and it's inhabitants speak a derivative of Latin!

Finally, the Arabs celebrate Yarmouk, which is a crossing near the Dan River where they beat a hastily put together Byzantine Army and were able to occupy Syria, Israel, and Egypt as a result. Literally celebrating their Battle of Cajamarca or Conquest of Tenochtitlan, which proves who the invaders were, since they admit and celebrate it themselves.

Patrick says

richwicks The Romans waged a war against ancient Israel, and there are non-Jewish records of that.

You could argue that Israel ceased to exist as a distinct country after the Romans destroyed the temple in 70 AD, but there is a ton of evidence that it did exist as a country before that point.

https://www.britannica.com/event/Siege-of-Jerusalem-70

I'm not arguing that Jerusalem didn't exist, it's an ancient city. I'm saying I don't believe ISRAEL existed. They are conflating a people with a nation.

I'll need to read more. The existence of Israel, if it did exist, was at best, fleeting. Lasting under 100 years in eternal conflict.

RWSGFY says

This sounds like something a card-carrying member of BLM would say.

"They dindu nuffin, how dare police shoot at them!"

This sounds like something a deep state neo-con would say. "We must bomb those women and children our they will grow up and become terrorists!"