2
0

Suggestion to Trump: allow tax-free 401(k)/IRA withdrawals by married couples to spend on their first house


               
2026 Jan 8, 1:28pm   1,217 views  69 comments

by Patrick   follow (59)  

This would directly benefit me and my wife, but it would also help young couples who want to start a family.

Why trap their money to be fully taxed on withdrawal at age 60 or so when they really need it when young to buy their first house?

Buying a house is also a kind of retirement savings.

Make it limited to direct payment on principal of a house, and make it so that selling that house would require that they put the principal in another house, or back in the 401(k)/IRA.

« First        Comments 64 - 69 of 69        Search these comments

64   Patrick   2026 Jan 16, 10:58am  

Yes, I sure hope this happens. I have selfish reasons, but I think it's also good for couples that want to buy a house to have babies in.

My only worry is that the new flow of money will drive up house prices to some degree, negating the benefit.

The real solution is to build more houses near where the jobs are.
65   floki   2026 Jan 16, 11:05am  

Yeah we'll see the details next week.

But @Patrick, they're talking about only down payments though, a good step but not the full costs. Well we'll see.
66   stereotomy   2026 Jan 16, 11:52am  

Down payment assistance (which is really what this is) will spike prices in the short term. It will probably be neutral in the longer term as people become a lot more shy about gambling their own retirement money on FOMO feels.
67   HeadSet   2026 Jan 16, 1:24pm  

Patrick says

My only worry is that the new flow of money will drive up house prices to some degree, negating the benefit.

That house price rise is a given.
68   Blue   2026 Jan 16, 2:32pm  

floki says





Crossing fingers

https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2026/01/16/trump-to-unveil-plan-allowing-401k-withdrawals-for-home-down-payments/

This is not even click worthy, 10% of what, average median 401(k) balances I believe is below 300K.
Current 401(k) Loan Rules for Home Purchases:
Lesser of 50% or $50K.
It’s fair to assume that all politicians throw nothing burgers at public to get votes.
69   floki   2026 Jan 16, 3:28pm  

I'd speculate that many younger home buyers get some help with the downpayments from families, especially on a first home. Maybe just enough help to get into one. For those that do not, this proposal just might be the difference between owning a home or not. It's supposed to be a tax and penalty free withdrawl as opposed to being a loan as is available today so no post-tax repayments taken out of their wages either. Overall, I think that's a good thing for those intent on buying one after having considered all other pros and cons.

« First        Comments 64 - 69 of 69        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste