0
0

Visualizing the housing bubble bust


 invite response                
2006 Mar 14, 12:32pm   18,704 views  173 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

Let's try to visualize the bursting of the housing bubble. Tell us what are your visions. Tell us how a correction towards normality is good for the economy in the long run.

#housing

« First        Comments 74 - 113 of 173       Last »     Search these comments

74   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 2:45am  

Surfer X, SF Woman,

My wife pointed out the "plastic surgery gone bad" website to me awhile ago and it's really funny how someone you had thought of as "attractive" once exposed (for fraud) now repulses you. It's just one of those things in life you can't "un-see".

75   FormerAptBroker   2006 Mar 16, 3:03am  

surfer-x Says:
You can give yourself a brief tutorial in identifying breast fraud.
SFWoman, again, without a clear scientific approach (fondling) there is no way HARM or myself could possibly tell.

My college girlfriend that grew up in Newport Beach used to say that her mom was the only woman with her natural hair color and real breasts living in Big Canyon. In the two years I dated her she had a habit of pointing out every fake blond and woman with fake boobs she saw. Some things I learned 1. Very few females over 14 have natural blond hair. 2. Very few (if any) tall super thin women have natural big giant boobs. 3. A natural breast (and a real expensive fake one) is asymmetrical and has a gradual taper at the top (like a ski jump) while most fake ones look like a round bag of saline was stuck under the skin. I read recently that the real estate slowdown is expected to drastically reduce Harley Davidson sales, I wonder if plastic surgery will drop when the cash out re-fi money goes away??

76   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 3:04am  

that futurist site could be deconstructed all day - it’s a rich vein of material…

This comment should be read as "no comment".

77   LILLL   2006 Mar 16, 3:31am  

When we talk about our governments concern for it's citizens, perhaps we should concider the resume of our commander in chief.
George W. Bush

I was arrested in Kennebunkport, Maine, in 1976 for driving under the influence of alcohol. I pled guilty, paid a fine, and had my driver's license suspended for 30 days. My Texas driving record has been "lost" and is not available.

MILITARY: I joined the Texas Air National Guard and went AWOL. I refused to take a drug test or answer any questions about my drug use. By joining the Texas Air National Guard, I was able to avoid combat duty in Vietnam.

COLLEGE: I graduated from Yale University with a low C average. I was a cheerleader. I also joined the Order of Skull and Bones an elite secret society that uses cover-ups to advance it's members into high office positions. Thank goodness my biggest opponent this year is my fraternal brother.

PAST WORK EXPERIENCE: I ran for U.S. Congress and lost. I began my career in the oil business in Midland, Texas, in 1975. I bought an oil company, but couldn't find any oil in Texas. The company went bankrupt shortly after I sold all my stock. I bought the Texas Rangers baseball team in a sweetheart deal that took land using taxpayer money. With the help of my father and our right-wing friends in the oil industry (including Enron CEO Ken Lay), I was elected governor of Texas.

ACCOMPLISHMENTS AS GOVERNOR OF TEXAS: I changed Texas pollution laws to favor power and oil companies, making Texas the most polluted state in the Union. During my tenure, Houston replaced Los Angeles as the most smog-ridden city in America. I cut taxes and bankrupted the Texas treasury to the tune of billions in borrowed money. I set the record for the most executions by any governor in American history. With the help of my brother, the governor of Florida, and my father's appointments to the Supreme Court, I became President after losing by over 500,000 votes.

ACCOMPLISHMENTS AS PRESIDENT: I am the first President in U.S. history to enter office with a criminal record. I invaded and occupied two countries at a continuing cost of over one billion dollars per week. I spent the U.S. surplus and effectively bankrupted the U.S. Treasury. I shattered the record for the largest annual deficit in U.S. history. I set an economic record for most private bankruptcies filed in any 2-month period. I set the all-time record for most foreclosures in a 12-month period. I set the all-time record for the biggest drop in the history of the U.S. stock market. In my first year in office, over 2 million Americans lost their jobs and that trend continues every month. I'm proud that the members of my cabinet are the richest of any administration in U.S. history. My "poorest millionaire," Condoleeza Rice, has a Chevron oil tanker named after her. I set the record for most campaign fundraising trips by a U.S. President. I am the all-time U.S. and world record-holder for receiving the most corporate campaign donations. My largest lifetime campaign contributor, and one of my best friends, Kenneth Lay, presided over the largest corporate bankruptcy fraud in U.S. history, Enron. My political party used Enron private jets and corporate attorneys to assure my success with the U.S. Supreme Court during my election decision. I have protected my friends at Enron and Halliburton against investigation or prosecution. More time and money was spent investigating the Monica Lewinsky affair than has been spent investigating one of the biggest corporate rip-offs in history.

I presided over the biggest energy crisis in U.S. history and refused to intervene when corruption involving the oil industry was revealed. I presided over the highest gasoline prices in U.S. history. I changed the U.S. policy to allow convicted criminals to be awarded government contracts. I appointed more convicted criminals to administration than any President in U.S. history. I created the Ministry of Homeland Security, the largest bureaucracy in the history of the United States government. I've broken more international treaties than any President in U.S. history. I am the first President in U.S. history to have the United Nations remove the U.S. from the Human Rights Commission. I withdrew the U.S. from the World Court of Law. I refused to allow inspectors access to U.S. "prisoners of war" detainees and thereby have refused to abide by the Geneva Convention. I am the first President in history to refuse United Nations election inspectors (during the 2002 U.S. election). I set the record for least number of press conferences of any President since the advent of television. I set the all-time record for most days on vacation in any one-year period. After taking off the entire month of August, I presided over the worst security failure in U.S. History. I garnered the most sympathy for the U.S. after the World Trade Center attacks and less than a year later made the U.S. the most hated country in the world, the largest failure of diplomacy in world history. I have set the all-time record for most people worldwide to simultaneously protest me in public venues (15 million people), shattering the record for protest against any person in the history of mankind. I am the first President in U.S. history to order an unprovoked, preemptive attack and the military occupation of a sovereign nation. I did so against the will of the United Nations, the majority of U.S. Citizens, and the world community. I have cut health care benefits for war veterans and support a cut in duty benefits for active duty troops and their families in wartime. I am the first President in history to have a majority of Europeans (71%) view my presidency as the biggest threat to world peace and security. I am supporting development of a nuclear "Tactical Bunker Buster," a WMD. I have so far failed to fulfill my pledge to bring Osama Bin Laden to justice while your fathers, mothers, brothers, sisters, sons, daughters, wives and husbands are losing their lives every day.

RECORDS AND REFERENCES: All records of my tenure as governor of Texas are now in my father's library, sealed and unavailable for public view. All records of SEC investigations into my insider trading and my bankrupt companies are sealed in secrecy and unavailable for public view. All records or minutes from meetings that I, or my Vice President, attended regarding public energy policy are sealed in secrecy and unavailable for public review.

78   inquiring mind   2006 Mar 16, 3:49am  

Bay Area DataQuick numbers are in:

http://www.dqnews.com/RRBay0306.shtm

79   OO   2006 Mar 16, 3:53am  

Elsewhere in the world, price/sqft is used to compare housing price. Why is US using median housing price instead of price/sqft? It only makes sense to compare median housing price when you have a rather uniform stock of inventory, which is obviously not the case for us. Any history behind this? Do realtors provide price/sqft number on a timeline basis?

80   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 4:18am  

Viewfromsiliconvalley.com has weekly $/sqft data.

81   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 4:21am  

the Fed’s primary objective (in practice, not on paper) is to ensure full employment of the US.

Who says that? On paper, the Fed has a dual mandate or price stability and full resource utilization. In practice, it needs to maintain health in the financial system. It will not give a shit about employment.

82   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 4:37am  

the Fed’s primary objective (in practice, not on paper) is to ensure full employment of the US.

If you mean by full employment an unemployment rate equal to the computed structural unemployment, then I might agree as a tertiary goal of the Fed. The problem is that the definition of structural unemployment is controversial. There is structural unemployment caused by minimum wage, caused by collective bargaining contracts, caused by corporate wage efficiency, and caused by "unexplained" inefficiencies in the employment market. Some people think 5-6% is a reasonable number, others argue the real number is closer to 15% or even 20%.

83   OO   2006 Mar 16, 4:58am  

Randy,

yeah I meant full employment doesn't really mean FULL employment in the sense of definition, but in a sense of keeping enough people off the street so that we don't end up in turmoil.

Peter P,

In the end, the existence of government is to keep the society stable through various means of social engineering like tax, medicare, social benefits, etc. If Fed's worry is REALLY inflation, Maestro Greenspan would not have artificially kept the interest rate so low for so long. The R word and the D word is what Fed is afraid of the most, not because the stock market is down or whatever, but because it will pose a threat to the very existence of our government. This is particularly the case for America, we have guns, and, we have a dwindling middle class and a greater divide between the rich and poor. America, is a rich version of Latin America. If we didn't have the reserve currency status, we would have gone broke multiple times.

Sunnyvale_Renter, thanks for your support. I just don't think housing bubble or any bubble is a concern for the Fed as long as they are sustainable, till the end of the Fed's chairman's tenure. Let the next chairman worry about the R word and the D word.

84   OO   2006 Mar 16, 5:02am  

Randy, I must be talking and typing at the same time, here I'll try again.

What I meant by full employment isn't referring to the economic definition of full employment of 4 or 5% "accepted" unemployment. It merely means keeping enough people off the street so that we can all live happily ever after.

85   OO   2006 Mar 16, 5:14am  

I guess it is natural for most people who are disgusted by this Re bubble (renters and owners) to wishfully hope for Fed to target the RE bubble - raise interest till it bursts. Well, I think the Fed has bigger fish to fry than the Re bubble. America's financial situation has been on a decline for years, I don't like Bush, but he merely accelerated the process, he was too stupid to be the instigator.

I lately found something really whacky about our economy, It seems like America has turned into a giant bank, this is our national industry, one-trick pony industry. GM, Ford, and other major manufacturers of anything all have a financial arm, and this financial arm is usually the most profitable part of the business. Then, Americans can buy anything 0-down, from homes to cars, furniture to jewlery, you name it, we 0-down everything. And, while most of the businesses are losing money in the last quarter, investment banks are having record revenue and record profit. Now we don't have main street any more, we will have a wall street in every town. It is like, we are nothing but a bunch financiers passing bucks to each other, and this is a far bigger problem than just the RE bubble, the RE bubble is just a symptom of a deep-rooted structural problem of our economy.

Since housing price is not even a part of core CPI, and Fed's "stated" purpose is to fight inflation, why will it target the RE bubble? America imports most of our oil, the spike in oil price is caused by the lack of processing facility, does hiking interest rate help putting more processing facility online or offline? It doesn't make sense for the Fed to halt the oil price spike through hiking interest rate. It is fighting something much larger than its stated purpose, that's my intepretation.

86   OO   2006 Mar 16, 5:20am  

Back to the topic, visualising the bust.

Expect to see lots of homeless, especially in SoCal. They will camp out in particularly nice parts of town where the public infrastructure is good, along lakeside sidewalk, in public park space, near big shopping mall, or under the freeway. It is rather sad to see plenty of those in Tokyo every time I go there, sometimes you see a whole family living under the freeway out of a box. I am pretty sure we will see far more here.

87   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 5:49am  

ReyEstate,

Pure negligence or pure truth? You and your 1 poster aren't really worthy of a response and as we ask all die-hard RE Bulls, if you are so gung-ho about the CONTINUED upside potential of BA ReyEstate what are you doing here? Shouldn't you be closing your next big deal on a 560 sq. ft. condo for 1.3 mil? Rey, we weren't always this popular (please to note our reader count) but we've always tried to be visionary, looking toward the horizon. What would you suggest we do?

88   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 5:55am  

Help u with foreclosure,

Is that through the United Christians Fund? Oh, and welcome!

89   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 5:56am  

If the so-called bubble has indeed burst, then why are you asking your readers to visualize the housing bubble bust? Shouldn’t this be an observation?

Are you looking for a gold star for clever semantic parsing? Even relatively fast corrections in real-estate take some time to unfold. Real estate does not exactly qualify as a liquid market.

By the way, did you secure permission from this blog's owner before including its logo on your own under the title PURE NEGLIGENCE? Doesn't the CAR give you some basic guidelines to follow when propagandizing?

90   patseajul   2006 Mar 16, 5:57am  

I wonder if reyestate is feeling quilty and sending his readers to patrick.net? I am also really confused, the first post is by annon. "propagandist in the media"? Are blogs media?

91   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 6:02am  

Are blogs media?

We have a regular poster named newsfreak. Perhaps that qualifies us.

92   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 6:02am  

Randy H,

Good point! Come to think of it the site does have a certain brand recognition factor. Besides we have our reputations to think of! I suppose to Bulls anything other than blind faith in RE qualifies as "negligence".

93   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 6:04am  

Help u with foreclosure,

Do you actually handle Loss Mitigation or is that just your sense of humor? Either way I like it!

94   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 6:16am  

DinOR,

I sent you an email about a week ago. Did you get it?

95   patseajul   2006 Mar 16, 6:19am  

Are blogs media?

Oops, I guess they are! Just one of those people that stayed blonde after the age of 14. I will leave the blogging up to you smarties from now on!

96   jeffolie   2006 Mar 16, 6:24am  

The Federal Reserve has no intention of preserving all of the recent gains in home price values, said Federal Reserve board governor Donald Kohn on Thursday.

"If real estate prices begin to erode, homeowners should not expect to see all the gains of recent years preserved by monetary policy actions,' Kohn said in a speech prepared for delivery to a European Central Bank forum in Frankfurt, Germany.

In his remarks, Kohn attacked the popular 'Greenspan put' theory that Fed policy would always protect investors from sharp asset market drops while doing nothing to restrain these markets when prices rise.
"This argument strikes me as a misreading of history," Kohn said.
"Conventional policy as practiced by the Federal Reserve has not insulated investors from downside risk," he said.

97   inquiring mind   2006 Mar 16, 6:26am  

"He told me that there were only 5000 permitted and being constructed at the moment"

5000 is still somewhat remarkable considering SF's obvious geographical limitations.

98   sassy   2006 Mar 16, 7:04am  

surfer-x
I strongly recommend not using the words vigorously, fondle, and breast in your request for test subjects-- it just sounds painful.

As for the other bust: I keep seeing posts suggesting moving into gold or cash or offshore for other investments. What about just having a diversified portfolio that includes some of the above, but also has US investments?

SFWoman-In my experience, it is the women who talk about ideas, books, and culture who reveal their "elite" background the best. I mean, goodness, it is rather tacky to talk about money in polite company. That is how I see the "classes" breaking out. I know it sounds catty, but those who talk about shoes, bags, cosmetic experiences, fancy vacations, fancy schools, over the top consumption-- they are the ones who reveal their "lower" origins the most. When the person has to call out the distinction of class, that's when their insecurity about their place in it is made most obvious.

99   FormerAptBroker   2006 Mar 16, 7:26am  

Sassy Says:

"SFWoman-In my experience, it is the women who talk about ideas, books, and culture who reveal their “elite” background the best. I know it sounds catty, but those who talk about shoes, bags, cosmetic experiences, fancy vacations, fancy schools, over the top consumption– they are the ones who reveal their “lower” origins the most."

In my experience talking about shoes, handbags and cosmetics only revels a persons gender and sexual orientation. I can't think of a single female or gay guy (from any background) in SF that does not spend a lot of time talking about shoes, handbags or cosmetics...

100   DinOR   2006 Mar 16, 7:27am  

Randy H,

No actually I didn't and I apologize. HARM has my email and I'd look forward to getting yours as well. Many thanks!

101   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 7:55am  

Prices crash..I buy a decent 4 bed 2 bath (instead of 3/2 that I wanted) about 1800 sq feet for $385,000 with 6.8% 30 year fixed mortgage and 30% down.

You may have to prepare for 8% interest rate just in case.

102   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 7:55am  

I would love to see another thread on economic and Fed policy. I could learn a lot.

I'm not quite up to the intensity of such a thread just now, even when tempted by tall, thin women with natural hair color, who smartly avoided augmentation.

103   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 8:16am  

DinOR,

I emailed to your verizon email. If that's not it, email me from my blog when you get a chance.

104   Unalloyed   2006 Mar 16, 8:16am  

even when tempted by tall, thin women with natural hair color...

In my humble opinion, what makes SFWoman so attractive is her keen intelligence, wide range of interests, depth of insight and curiosity about life. She would be "hot" regardless of social stratum or physical attributes.

105   KurtS   2006 Mar 16, 8:43am  

"I was told by a couple of friends that 20,000 units were to be erected in the next couple of years. Let’s see.

20K units in SF? I thought they weren't 'making any more land' over there (not counting that Marina fill).

106   Different Sean   2006 Mar 16, 8:48am  

Elsewhere in the world, price/sqft is used to compare housing price. Why is US using median housing price instead of price/sqft?

Not necessarily true. Often median price and median income are used. By doing the ratio, you get an immediate indication of affordability. On a large, heterogenous sample this is a fair measure due to a randomisation effect, if you are going suburb by suburb, it's a bit less reliable, as the release of a block of new luxury apartments or houses will skew the figures, as somebody else pointed out. Also, they are building new houses 50% larger than some years ago, so that's another variable to consider in some cases, and, indeed, average house sizes vary from country to country. Further, units of measure and currencies change from country to country - Britain would be £/sq ft, France €/sq m, Oz $/sq m, etc...

107   Different Sean   2006 Mar 16, 9:05am  

the Fed’s primary objective (in practice, not on paper) is to ensure full employment of the US.

There is structural unemployment caused by minimum wage, caused by collective bargaining contracts, caused by corporate wage efficiency, and caused by “unexplained” inefficiencies in the employment market. Some people think 5-6% is a reasonable number, others argue the real number is closer to 15% or even 20%.

I think there is structural unemployment solely due to a lack of demand for labour by employers, don't you? Saying a bare minimum wage (which hardly anyone gets anyway) is causing unemployment is like saying the presence of air traffic controllers is stopping the airlines working efficiently and stopping planes from roaming freely around the skies... Either you need your toilet cleaned or you don't, refusing to pay someone $5 an hour to clean your toilet because it's too much is the height of eco-rat insanity. Anyway, haven't illegal immigrants effectively dismantled the minimum wage system? Not that even they would take the presumed $2 an hour you are offering - it would be better to sell drugs at those rates - I know I would...

108   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 9:18am  

I think there is structural unemployment solely due to a lack of demand for labour by employers, don’t you?

There is a lack of demand at a price that is much higher than the fair price of labor.

Saying a bare minimum wage (which hardly anyone gets anyway) is causing unemployment is like saying the presence of air traffic controllers is stopping the airlines working efficiently and stopping planes from roaming freely around the skies…

Huh?

Either you need your toilet cleaned or you don’t, refusing to pay someone $5 an hour to clean your toilet because it’s too much is the height of eco-rat insanity.

People rather have dirty toilets at $5 an hour. See, the minimum wage system is promoting dirty toilets!

Anyway, haven’t illegal immigrants effectively dismantled the minimum wage system?

Let's look at it his way, illegal immigrants created unemployment in this country because they have an unfair advantage of working below minimum wage. They have the absolute economic advantage of NOT GIVING A SHIT about the law.

109   Randy H   2006 Mar 16, 9:24am  

Different Sean,

I was just enumerating the neoclassical models for structural unemployment. There is probably marginal unemployment caused by the minimum wage, even though I believe that the minimum is ethical and virtuous. Nonetheless, there would be more (extreme low quality) employment if it did not exist.

Collective bargaining, on the other hand, is known to cause structural unemployment. In fact, any not-easily-broken labor contracts, including service worker contracts and even high-knowledge worker contracts, all add to structural unemployment because they put stickyness to wages and inhibit employers from reacting quickly to labor market changes.

Wage efficiency is, in my opinion, the cause of most higher-end structural unemployment -- the kind that affects college educated workers. There are actually many theories comprising this "meta" theory, but they all collapse to "it is more efficient for companies to pay higher-than-market wages for some time after the labor market softens". This causes a long tail of structural unemployment, much like we have today. It also causes dramatic salary discrepencies. Thus the PhD, MSE, MBA, BSEE, etc. who gets $200K per year for the same exact skills that his 6+ months unemployed doppleganger just accepted a $110K a year job for.

Mankiw has a good summary of this in Macroeconomics.

110   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 9:31am  

There is probably marginal unemployment caused by the minimum wage, even though I believe that the minimum is ethical and virtuous.

I am not sure if it is ethical. It is perhaps popular for obvious reasons but I still think it creates inflation and unemployment.

111   Peter P   2006 Mar 16, 9:39am  

Up in Santa Rosa my friends who use the landscape and light construction laborers (illegal I am sure) over on Fulton Road pay $12-$15/hour. They aren’t undercutting the minimum wage.

Then $12-$15 is probably the fair market price.

My point is that minimum wage will not help.

Bush's guess worker program is probably a good idea because it opens up the "hidden" labor market to all employers, instead of just those who are willing to break the labor law. But anyway, getting rid of the minimum wage system is essential. I believe the living standard of workers in general will go up more if there is no minimum wage.

112   Different Sean   2006 Mar 16, 9:55am  

so 'unemployment' is bad, but paying people below subsistence levels is good? once again, self-contradictory stupidity. don't we want decent employment up at decent wages so you don't need welfare? you guys never refer to the dignity of the individual or to the need for a living wage when you make these bizarre neo-classical assumptions. You put inhuman conditions on other people that you would never accept for yourselves. Nice to be in that position. But completely immoral.

What is the price of labour anyway? What arbitrary market force says that I can get $100 an hour to be a crack C++ programmer to program video games (essentially a luxury item), $25 an hour to do systems development/business analysis in MS-Access/VBA, when C++ is much less efficient in terms of outcomes but the skills are rarer. A mortgage broker can make $250K a year working from home just by filling out a few forms. A doctor saving lives and making responsible and liable decisions every moment may well make much less than this. A nurse may make $40 K to monitor vital signs of patients, while the pony-tailed 20-something video game programmer makes $100 an hour. The lying politician who is doing nothing for the public is making good money, as well as taking kickbacks. Michael Jackson made something like $600 million for singing and dancing a bit. Maybe there is something deranged in the way the market values labour and rewards people? Why are you such market fetishists?

You guys overlook all the massive surplus incomes many people make, the money they waste on boondoggles and status symbols, and choose to try to penalise a new serf class instead. Utterly shameful.

113   StuckInBA   2006 Mar 16, 9:55am  

Peter P said

You may have to prepare for 8% interest rate just in case.

I think HeliBen will actually start reducing short term rates at the end of this year. The Contrarian Bill Fleckenstein has been saying that on MS Investor site for some time now. That does worry me a lot.

On the long term, the 10 year treasury rate dropped below 4.7% today again. It seem to have found a support there - or resistance if you look at yield. The 10 year T note is one real tease. God knows when it will jump to 5% ? :-(

So it seems interest rates MAY NOT help in killing this bubble. So that leaves us with what ? Only panic and change in psychology ? Unless the secondary MBS market somehow disconnects itself from the treasury market, and actual mortgage rates rise anyway.

I hope we don't get that dreaded "elevated plateau" which supposedly has happened in UK and Aus.

« First        Comments 74 - 113 of 173       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions