0
0

Why I hate shower/tub combo


 invite response                
2006 Sep 11, 7:54am   10,662 views  155 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

Most people take showers. What is the point of installing a shower/tub combo when the tub is rarely used? I wonder.

I think we should build more shower stalls in the future. There should be no need for more than one tub (or shower/tub combo) in the house.

What do you hate in your house? Why? How can we build better houses in the future?

« First        Comments 35 - 74 of 155       Last »     Search these comments

35   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 10:38am  

I like all stone bathrooms and saunas

All stone saunas? Will the stone crack because of the heat/humidity?

Perhaps I should become a bathroom designer. Perhaps in the future we will all live in bathrooms with sleeping alcoves.

On the other hand, it would be nice to have a bathroom that can be cleaned by hosing it down with water.

36   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 10:43am  

Personally, I prefer a shower stall with a glass screen - a shower in a tub is dangerous - I once slipped and knocked my chest against the edge of the tub.

Exactly.

Best option of course, is a G-shaped stall - no doors, simple, ventilated and effective.

With glass? I will probably bump into it. How about a shower stall so large that doors are not required.

Don’t really understand the bathroom fetish in McMansions though.

I don't think many McMansions have really nice bathrooms though. People still prefer nice kitchens. Many "luxury" bathrooms only have marble on one or two walls.

37   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 10:45am  

We never use our frozen peas for eating…they are for black eyes and sprains and such!

They are not too bad in a puree. Fresh peas are of course much better.

I have an unwavering belief that all men pee in the shower

Huh? 8-O Another reason for his-and-her baths.

38   skibum   2006 Sep 11, 10:47am  

LILLL Says:

I have an unwavering belief that all men pee in the shower…so no way am I sitting in that thing…no matter how much I clean it!(As I am the only female in this house.)
Eeewww!

Pee is sterile (generally speaking), so technically there's nothing grody about it other than the fact that it's pee.

39   skibum   2006 Sep 11, 10:49am  

SF Woman,
Why do you wash your cat? We've never washed ours, and he's outdoors. Cats are immaculately clean creatures as it is and they clean themselves. However, I've always wondered - their tongues must be filthy. Maybe we just need to rinse their tongues once in a while.

40   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:04am  

Why do you wash your cat? We’ve never washed ours, and he’s outdoors.

I washed my cat before and she hated me for a week. The cat hospital was able to do it nicely though. Strange.

41   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:05am  

Do you notice how no man has proclaimed he DOESNT pee in the shower?

I proclaim that I do not pee in the shower.

42   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:09am  

SP,

Yeah, G shaped stalls are nice. Not very space efficient though.

I guess the shower-bathtub combinations are a lowest common denominator solution that covers the builder's backs - the lowest common denominator being 3 years. That's why we have water temperature regulators so water is never hot enough in winter. That's why the bathtubs are extremely uncomfortable for anyone over 10 years old and hazardous as showers. And the problem is, once the builders design spaces for these awkward tub-shower combos, nothing else really fit into them because they're too narrow for showers and too short for soaking tubs.

I do squeegee. But Pleasanton has really hard water, so the glass still look like it's caked in baking soda. I guess I should use something acidic for them rather than the alkolid cleaning stuff though.

43   HARM   2006 Sep 11, 11:10am  

Peeing in the shower is efficiency in action: kill two birds with one stone. Also saves a couple minutes when you're in a big hurry to get ready --very helpful.

LILLL, embrace it, don't fight it. Btw, can I stay over/shower at your place sometime? :P

44   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:12am  

Peeing in the shower is efficiency in action: kill two birds with one stone.

How about a shower/tub/urinal/sink combo?

Not design advice.

45   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:13am  

Nothing wrong with peeing in shower while water is running (though this statement does not mean I endorse it or does it myself), the salt and uric acid is pretty benign compared to the bathtub cleansers and athlete's foot fungus issues - those things would keep me from bathing in a hotel room.

46   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:15am  

Isn't there a urinal sink combo on the market already? In northern China, you'll sometimes find squat toilets built over showers.

47   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:16am  

(now how's that for disturbing?)

48   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:18am  

Isn’t there a urinal sink combo on the market already? In northern China, you’ll sometimes find squat toilets built over showers.

I only wet my mouth with water during the day when I travel in China. Public bathrooms are never nice but they are downright horrible in China.

49   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:19am  

I am going to have nightmares tonight.

50   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:22am  

I'm lucky to have a strong bladder and an easy to block out memory. Chinese public toilets are generally things of nightmares. If you get desperate, try a McDonald's. They're your best bet for a reasonable clean flush toilet.

(Oh no! Some memory of that hostel toilet in Kangding is coming back!)

51   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:24am  

"It’d be more like showering in a toilet than peeing in the shower."

Yes, it's not a design innovation I plan to ever make, no matter how cramp my apartment gets.

52   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:26am  

Chinese public toilets are generally things of nightmares.

Which country has the best public bathrooms? Surprisingly, Japan has squat-toilets as well. At least in the US, seat covers are usually provided.

53   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:27am  

My apartment in Hell’s Kitchen had the tub in the kitchen; with the addition of a hinged hollow-core door to cover the tub, you had a instant dining room table.

Huh?

54   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:31am  

Hate: Vauted ceilings.

How about coffered ceiling? I kinda want a Las Vegas fake sky at home. :-P

Bathroom doors that hit the toilet

I hate that too. Door should operate freely even with the person sitting on the toilet.

55   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:36am  

Squat toilets are quite sanitary, as long as they are used properly. The main problem with rural Chinese toilets is that they don't flush or ventilate. (I actually like ventilated compost toilets found in national parks and isolated rest stops, they're very eco-friendly. The Chinese really need to discover the wonders of ventilated composting toilets).

56   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:40am  

Squat toilets are quite sanitary, as long as they are used properly.

My wife hates them. Ventilation is essential.

57   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:42am  

Christmas light plug-in under the eaves with a switch in the garage.

I always worry about Christmas lights catching fire though.

58   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:43am  

Well. To go really OT, should say I've just tasted my first pawpaws. They're not quite as good as I imagined. They're kind of like a slightly insipid banana with overtones of pineapple

59   Peter P   2006 Sep 11, 11:44am  

To go really OT, should say I’ve just tasted my first pawpaws.

Food is never OT. :)

60   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:45am  

Don't get me wrong, I don't like squat toilets either. I've been forced to use them on a couple situations of extreme duress, but they're not experiences I care to relive.

61   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:49am  

Most people are not trained to squat for long periods of time. Plus the newbies would fear soiling themselves.

62   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 11:53am  

I would like to live in a glass house located in a really scenic, isolated lot. Barring that, I like designs that incorporate private walled balconies into bathroom/bedroom areas, to bring more natural light into private rooms.

63   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:01pm  

Yeah, a kitchen pantry is much more useful than cabinets. I would like a kitchen with a pantry for storage, plus a rack to pots and cooking utensils and a stainless steel shelf for for plates. That provides much better visibility and utility.

64   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:05pm  

That's the idiocy of the American McMansion phenomena. They want all this land and all this interior space, but they put it all together really poorly and you end up with no privacy from neighbors and no privacy from other people in the house. Most McMansions have their curtains/blinds drawn all the time, which makes you wonder why they got windows in the first place.

65   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:12pm  

One thing that builders never offer are industrial strength kitchen ventilators that vent out. That's incredibly asinine because you really can't cook much unless you have decent ventilators. Without a good ventilator, a kitchen is just a place to chop vegetables and boil water.

66   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:13pm  

His and her closets are a very good idea. Much more important to family tranquility than his and her bathrooms.

67   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:21pm  

alien,

Sorry to be so nosy, but I'm curious where your mentor lives and how much he spent. I agree, it is a really nice way to live.

68   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:28pm  

I've been sketching ideas for underground subdivision housing. The houses would be entirely underground except for the garage doors, roads and a few skylights per house. The space above would open space for play space, gardens, and communal green space. That would offer much better privacy, soundproofing, and insulation than traditional suburban housing. I think the excavation costs would be a bit higher and you need to be careful about drainage and waterproofing, but it seems like a solution that would please open space/green space fanatics.

Has anyone here seen real plans or proposals for this sort of community?

69   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:32pm  

Coos Bay is a lovely area. Actually, all of coastal Oregon and coastal northern California are gorgeous, much more so than the stretch from SF to SD.

70   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 12:37pm  

I wasn't thinking of individual houses but of whole communities. I figure that would cut down on excuvation time and costs (since modern subdivisions already move dirt around and do a lot of compacting). So it's not really an alternative life style, but a green and energy efficient spin on "traditional" suburban housing. The selling point would be the lower running cost(good in really hot and really cold areas), privacy from neighbors (that would not otherwise exist with that kind of density), soundproofing (good for developments near busy roads) and the greater availability of green space.

71   anonymous   2006 Sep 11, 12:47pm  

*unlurks*

From showers and tubs to eco houses! Astrid, you sure have similar interests to me.

My personal favourite is the cordwood house. Essentially, it's short sections of wood (aka firewood) set so that the cut ends form the inside and outside wall surface, long dimension facing in (or out) and stacked with lots of mortar between the cordwood. If you're in a cold climate, like me, your cordwood house can have two layers of cordwood, with a layer of insulating material (e.g. all that sawdust from your construction?) in between. Otherwise, one layer can suffice.

I like it because it looks easier to build, being small chunks of wood that even a small woman can heft. See this website for more details:

http://www.cordwoodmasonry.com/Cordwood.html

The round shape of the houses (looking hobbit-like) is favoured because of the ease of construction, and because a round shape contains more interior area for the same number of linear wall perimeter than rectangular or square shapes. A round house could be interesting for furniture layout!

The dream now (soon as we're done paying off this city house hopefuly in 7 to 10 years) is to get 40 acres located 2 hours (or more) outside of Toronto in good farmland, 50% covered (or more) with woodlot, and build me one of these.

If I buy a plane ticket will Surfer-X also invite me to his next blog party?

*relurks*

72   surfer-x   2006 Sep 11, 12:53pm  

Absofuckinglootly

73   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 1:03pm  

All southern exposure would be nice, though I was thinking of fully underground so there would be fewer site problems. I know that most earthship houses are exposed on the southern side, but I think going completely underground might offer greater flexibility.

It's all a brain fart though. I'm no land developer (which is a good thing) and I would like to live in a temperate climate with lots of glass. But when I hear about $1000/month heating bills in Minnesota or upstate NY, I really wonder why they don't build underground.

TOLurker,

Interesting article, though probably not my kind of house. I like concrete and glass and steel. If that happens for you, please email me and let me know, I may still have viable vegetable seeds from my entirely too large stockpile.

74   astrid   2006 Sep 11, 1:07pm  

SFWoman,

China is not too bad now. Many tourist areas have upgraded their facilities and the major cities now have westernized and clean bathrooms. You're unlikely to ever run into a problem if you stay in a three star or above hotel. Some of my crazier run in with bad Chinese toilets were from ten years ago, and the rest are in really backwoodsy areas.

Even the train toilets are getting upgraded, which makes sleeper trains a much more pleasant experience.

« First        Comments 35 - 74 of 155       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste