0
0

If you were FDR, what would you have done?


 invite response                
2008 Mar 12, 6:22am   19,285 views  269 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

What would be your economic policies?

What would be your foreign policies?

What would you have done differently?

Hindsight is 20/20, but a healthy discussion is always fruitful.

Peter

« First        Comments 71 - 110 of 269       Last »     Search these comments

71   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 2:20am  

HARM,

I'll see if I can't entice Randy H to chime in but as you'd suspect he had ample data to back his claim. I think it's more a matter of mfr. shift than a mfr. exodus.

True, most of the things we as consumers come in contact with on a daily basis aren't mfr. locally but I don't know anybody that grew up saying they wanted to work in a plastic cup factory? I think most appliances are still made here as well. Kind of inefficient to ship.

72   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 2:23am  

Peter P… your precious gold finally surpassed $1,000 an ounce

Yes, April Gold futures finally breached $1000. There is much shyness in the market though.

I am looking at the 5-min bar chart right now and it is off a bit from the peak.

73   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 2:24am  

sa,

Exactly. (Even if they ARE right in Las Vegas/PHX etc!) I will say though (and I can't believe it myself) but I'm more inclined to agree w/ Harry Reid. Kill the problem at the source. Let local meth addicts take care of the stripping and let the CAT do the rest. Let the banks tally their losses.

Let's git' r' done.

74   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 2:27am  

Hmmmm...if I were FDR.

FDR had a problem in that the Republicans at the time were an isolationist party.

FDR should have put more emphasis on a draft for the Army and Navy, and thereby downplayed the CCC, WPA, and their ilk. Similarly with defense engineering and procurement. Had the P-51 been available even one year earlier we wouldn't have sustained such horrendous bomber losses over Germany. Our troups in the Pacific suffered because there weren't enough M1 Garands to go around and they had to keep using the 1903 Springfield until late in 1943. Had our search radars been produced in more quantity AND integrated into CINCPAC command structure, the Pearl Harbor raid might have turned into the Battle of Midway for the Japanese a year earlier.

If FDR had supported Billy Mitchell and Leo Szilard/Albert Einstein from the get-go, WWII might have ended two years earlier.

75   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 2:29am  

So in a current analogy….how would you feel about President McCain putting Ron Paul in as IRS Commissioner?

Or Treasury Secretary. :)

76   HARM   2008 Mar 13, 2:32am  

Ron Paul for any post would be fine by me. And how about a new cabinet position: Housing Czar. Patrick, Ben Jones or Robert Shiller would all be fine choices.

77   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 2:34am  

Hillary could put in L A-Y....;)

78   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 2:35am  

By the way, whatever happened to HUD? Is it still around as a cabinet-level position?

79   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 2:37am  

RE: Housing Czar.

Why not David Lereah? ;)

80   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 2:38am  

Wow, these guys have sure been quiet lately....
www.hud.gov/about/index.cfm

I thought HUD was one of those departments that Dubya dissolved.

81   Malcolm   2008 Mar 13, 2:39am  

HARM Says:
March 13th, 2008 at 9:00 am
"Just when you thought government bailout proposals couldn’t get any worse:
Congress Considers $15,000 Rebate Checks For All Home Buyers"

These idiots still don't get it. There is no shortage of buyers, it is still a price issue. This is starting to get silly now.

82   OO   2008 Mar 13, 2:41am  

Did anyone watch Dubya interview on PBS yesterday? I was working out when I saw the interview and almost fell off the machine from inability to contain my laughter.

83   Malcolm   2008 Mar 13, 2:44am  

DennisN Says:
March 13th, 2008 at 9:35 am
"By the way, whatever happened to HUD? Is it still around as a cabinet-level position?"

I thought so, that's one of those token black person jobs that will always be around.

84   OO   2008 Mar 13, 2:44am  

These "idiots" understand the issue perfectly. They want to keep up the price so that one low-price transaction won't "destroy" the value for the whole neighborhood - i.e. balance sheet of banks holding these houses as collateral.

85   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 2:45am  

Gold is still dropping. It is not ready for staying above 990 yet. :(

Not investment advice.

86   skibum   2008 Mar 13, 2:49am  

sp,
Thanks for the manufacturing output list. Keep in mind, however, that the numbers from that total list are far overshadowed by consumer spending in this f'ed up country of ours. That's why until recently, bulls and pollyannas kept saying that manufacturing job losses didn't matter as much, since the "reilient" consumer would hold up our economy.

Now look what's happening. So much for that one.

87   HARM   2008 Mar 13, 2:50am  

@Peter P & DennisN,

Sick, just... sick.

88   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 2:52am  

HARM, don't worry. Mr. Market is bigger than any government.

89   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 2:57am  

Anyway, isn't the HUD secretary the "housing czar" you wanted? What the heck is the HUD secretary supposed to be doing in this crisis? Why is the ball in the court of the FED chairman and Treasury secretary?

90   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 2:57am  

"This starting to get silly now"

Certainly is. Johnny Isaccson (rep. AND realtwhore) talks about a serious recession for housing? Well Who TF cares? That's why I think Reid is closer on this one. Firstly it's $10 bil. LESS and secondly rather than focus on propping up prices (bank collateral) his plan salvages the FB's they can and bulldozes the rest!

Get out da' way!

91   skibum   2008 Mar 13, 2:57am  

The DQ numbers are out for SoCal. It's chock full o' eye-popping data:

http://www.dqnews.com/News/California/Southern-CA/RRSCA080313.aspx

How's this one:

"Of the homes that resold in February, about one-third, 33.5 percent, had been foreclosed on at some point since January 2007. A year earlier the figure was 3.5 percent."

Or:

"The median sale price dropped by a record 17.6 percent from a year ago, a real estate information service reported."

Or:

"Last month's sales total was the second-lowest for any month in DataQuick's statistics, which go back to 1988. The prior month's total of 9,983 was the lowest ever. Since September, sales each month have been a record low for that particular month."

92   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 2:59am  

DennisN,

The OFHEO Director has aready gone on the record as saying he thinks bumping Jumbo limits is the dumbest thing he's ever heard so he's been marginalized. What the admin. wants is a Housing Czar that will shore up existing prices!

93   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 3:07am  

Sometimes I wish I knew more about hacking...

www.hud.gov/foreclosure/index.cfm

Wouldn't it be fun to put in a re-direct to www.youwalkaway.com on that HUD page?

94   DennisN   2008 Mar 13, 3:17am  

They want to keep up the price so that one low-price transaction won’t “destroy” the value for the whole neighborhood - i.e. balance sheet of banks holding these houses as collateral.

All they need to do is play with the bookkeeping.

What they could do is publish a "true comps" list. All data for sales such as foreclosures, short sales, and the like would be excluded, and only "true home sales" data would go into the "true comps".

95   Malcolm   2008 Mar 13, 3:24am  

-4. You get a personal consultation with one of our highly experienced Real Estate Attorneys making sure the lender followed the law perfectly. If they did not, you may have a case against them.-

YouWalkAway must be reading the blog since this was my idea for something missing from their model. They used to specifically say they weren't lawyers. Their credit repair is fishy because they just buy a credit repair attempt from one of those shady companies that sends out zillions of frivilous credit disputes to the agencies. My model at least didn't involve credit fraud.

96   Malcolm   2008 Mar 13, 3:27am  

I don't see them on the main page. I guess they aren't advertising with Patrick anymore. I hope he made some money off of them.

97   HeadSet   2008 Mar 13, 3:49am  

Soldiers are not getting payed.

Source?

98   HARM   2008 Mar 13, 3:50am  

Anyway, isn’t the HUD secretary the “housing czar” you wanted? What the heck is the HUD secretary supposed to be doing in this crisis? Why is the ball in the court of the FED chairman and Treasury secretary?

All good questions deserving of further research. As far as I can tell, HUD has little or no authority to regulate mortgage lenders, the GSEs or Realtor groups, such as NAR. Sec. Jackson also does not appear to have the authority to influence rate decisions at the Fed, or to regulate how MBS/CDO securities get issued. So, the short answer is... powerless?

http://www.hud.gov/about/secretary/jacksonbio.cfm
http://www.hud.gov/library/bookshelf12/hudhistory.cfm

99   FuzzyMath   2008 Mar 13, 3:54am  

Only a slight bearing to the subject of the thread... but what is with the EU continuing to harass American companies?

http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/intel-defends-itself-before-european/story.aspx?guid=%7B4CE9A7FA%2DD792%2D4700%2D95B6%2D0AFB77094AA9%7D&siteid=yhoof

Does anyone know exactly where the money generated from these fines go? If their intention is truly to promote fair play in the marketplace, then most of the money should go to the offending company's competitors. However, I would say that is very unlikely. Anyone know?

101   Richmond   2008 Mar 13, 4:09am  

I don't know if you guys heard about the Hershey plant in Oakdale shutting down, but that is one shuttleing that pissed me off. They made Kisses and Miniatures, etc. It was a profitable operation, in the black, stable, local workforce, the whole package. The excuse in the paper was that it was running at 40% capacity. Ok, bummer number, but they closed Oakdale and moved the 40% to Mexico to up the capacity in the cheaper to run plant. It wasn't that Oakdale wasn't profitable, it was that Mexico was MORE profitable. Profit is profit but there is a limit. I would have closed the Mexico location, brought that production here and hired more bodies. Remember, Oakdale was profitable. Can you imagine the public relations boom. WE'RE KEEPING JOBS IN AMERICA! WE'RE PATRIOTIC! WE'RE AMERICA'S CHOCOLATE COMPANY!!!!!! And the list could go on for ever. They wouldn't be able to keep that stuff on the shelves.

If I want to buy foreign chocolate, I'll buy Nestle'. And I do.

NOT CHOCOLATE BUYING ADVICE

My point is that a whole lot of manufacturing could come back to the States and do very well it's just that the proft margin is so much greater when you pay people with grains of rice instead of money. That worm will turn.

102   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 4:22am  

TOB,

Uh... that would be me. I get payed by the post! I have some extruded aluminum engine cowlings, where did you want me to set them? The living room? You got it!

I know plenty of people that work at Leatherman's (tool maker) Warn Winch (automotive/marine) and PrecisionCastParts (aviation). My wife works for a company that makes ultra-sound equipment along with scores of other products primarily re-sold to OTHER mfrs! Now we DID lose Techtronix (and basically Freightliner) but they were on their way out anyway. We have start-up/spin-off firms and St. Jude makes some pretty hi-tech stuff here too. Medicated stent technology.

So whatever.

103   Richmond   2008 Mar 13, 4:30am  

TOB,

You do have a good point.

104   Duke   2008 Mar 13, 5:09am  

Who else finds Paulson's conflict of interest on banking/housing disturbing? I wrankles me when he commnts on regulation.

While I agree it is needed, I am angered to hear it coming from a man whose personal wealth is estimated at $700 million and who made his money in sub-prime and who was only able to exercise his options at an abosulte peak price by taking his current job.

Cnogress just drug Prince, Mozilla, and O'neal into chambers. Why not Paulson?

105   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 5:10am  

"Mexicans are 'pliant'"

I'm not saying that they aren't and I'm not saying they're not capable but my wife's company tried to out-source there to make cables. Not fiber-optic cables like she works with, just AWG copper conductor cables.

In 18 months of sending proto-types back and forth and all kinds of training and visits they were not able to turn out ONE cable that passed QC... not one. This was with the FULL support of a Fortune 500 company!

So if you can show them where they went wrong (after considerable expense) I'm sure they'd be open to hearing about it.

106   DinOR   2008 Mar 13, 5:11am  

Duke,

Hard to argue that!

107   Richmond   2008 Mar 13, 5:17am  

One of the things that will help American manufacturing is the Company Store mentality that's developing with over seas manufacturers.

I had a customer come in the shop a few days ago that needed a shaft for a machine. No biggie. It had a spline, a few seal diameters and a gear cut into it and no heat treatment. The manufacturer wanted almost $8700.00 for the thing with a six week lead time. This was at three in the afternoon. I ordered the material from the local steel house, had it by five. I started cutting at six in the morning. I had it turned, cut, and ground by one in the afternoon. All for about $1200.00. The machine was back up the next day.

In a lot of ways, we are very competative.

108   Peter P   2008 Mar 13, 5:19am  

In the end, the average American did not profit one bit from the whole arrangement.

Average people never profit. Period.

Do you understand the concept of a ZERO SUM game?

(Hopefully, Randy will come back... )

109   OO   2008 Mar 13, 5:21am  

My biggest fear is really about the returning veterans.

The # of payday loans set up right next to GI camp has gone up exponentially in the last few years (I remember seeing a number of 95% growth in 3 years). These people saw their colleagues die, amputated, injured, or may have gone through a few nasty episodes themselves. They will feel maltreated or neglected once they come back home with no jobs waiting for them.

Worse still, the quality of US soldiers has been going down drastically precisely because of Iraq war. People with self-respect or financial options would not join the army in the last 4 years. So who joined? Gang members. Such an unique phenomenon has actually gotten lots of news coverage.

So what do we get when these veterans come home? Disgruntled, hopeless people with combat training. Tim McVeigh won't be the last home-grown terrorist.

110   Duke   2008 Mar 13, 5:34am  

If I were FDR:

1. I woud not have frozen banks accounts.
2. I would not have called loans due.
3. I would have bee pro free-trade.
4. I would not have allowed war-reperations against Germany to be so lopsided as to foment the acceptance of Hitler in the hyper-inlated Germany.

« First        Comments 71 - 110 of 269       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste