0
0

Average Joe's Take


 invite response                
2007 Feb 21, 11:50pm   21,179 views  283 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (59)   💰tip   ignore  

From a reader:

I am a renter and I have been thinking that is time to buy RIGHT NOW. What if the market goes up and sellers stop offering price reductions and paid closing costs to buyers. I understand that a lot of home buying and building in the past few years has been speculative. but that means nothing when you consider the fact that the stock market is purely speculative and stock prices still rise. Is that "funny money" when you have stock market gains? It spends the same, it puts food on the table. What's the problem with financial gain whether or not a market is in a "bubble"? Are you opposed to people making money? So when should I stop renting and start taking advantage of the 50% off housing sale? Why buy ever? If buying is 50% cheaper in the future wouldn't rent be even cheaper as well?

Wow, where to start with this guy? How about this:

  • The stock market is not purely speculative. You can measure the value of a stock by its P/E ratio and dividend, among other things. Houses have no dividend, only rental income, or savings on rent. And by those measures, houses are grossly overpriced.
  • If you win the lottery, great. But it's a lousy investment strategy. That's the problem with the bubble.
  • I'm not opposed to people making money, only to millions putting themselves at risk of bankruptcy and foreclosure, and being smug about it.
  • You should stop renting when it's cheaper to own.
  • If house prices go down, that does not necessarily mean that rents will go down. It may make sense to buy then.

Patrick

#housing

« First        Comments 30 - 69 of 283       Last »     Search these comments

30   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 4:42am  

Hedge funds regulation is necessary but a bit too late.

Hedge funds regulation is completely unnecessary. They are just private investment ventures and they should be able to operate freely.

31   FormerAptBroker   2007 Feb 22, 4:42am  

Casey Serin is in the Wikipedia but Patrick Killelea has not made it yet.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casey_Serin

32   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 4:51am  

Well, I don't want to speak for others but 6 bil is 6 bil (no matter you pee'd it away).

For those bored enough, a great description of "fiduciary responsibility" is on www.fi360.com. Perhaps the good folk in San Diego should have read it first.

33   Randy H   2007 Feb 22, 5:01am  

FAB,

You do realize that anyone can write their own Wiki entry I hope. Maybe I'll go create a Randolph entry when I get some free time.

But seriously, we should consider making Patrick Killelea Wiki, x-refing the housing bubble entry, and then we can all link our own sub entries off of there.

Any takers? I'd start the process but I'm bogged down again between real work and not learning my lesson starting blog fights with people who buy cartoon real estate and pay for cartoon sex.

34   Randy H   2007 Feb 22, 5:08am  

There, I started it in a minor way. I added this blog to the external links reference of the Real Estate Bubble wiki entry.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate_bubble#External_links

Maybe I should run a thread that shows everyone how to go contribute to wiki. There's all kinds of bubble and reic stuff out there that could use our love.

35   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 5:09am  

Maybe I’ll go create a Randolph entry when I get some free time.

We should write an entry for King Randolph. Long live the King!

36   astrid   2007 Feb 22, 5:09am  

I wouldn't recommend spending the time to write entries on Wikipedia. Those guys are extremely narrowminded about what's acceptable knowledge. I put up an entry on a rather innovative and popular humor blog and they erased it because they thought it was irrelevant.

At the very least, I'd recommend proposing Patrick's name and then get a wiki "editor" behind the entry, otherwise, any entry you put up is likely to be deleted very soon afterwards.

38   Randy H   2007 Feb 22, 5:12am  

astrid,

My stupid critical article about Second Life landed me in the "mainstream press coverage" wiki on Second Life, which is heavily monitored by the company itself.

I thought they'd delete it, but it seems to have survived. So I'm mainstream now.

Then why have I only earned $2.12 on my blog ad revenues? lmao

39   astrid   2007 Feb 22, 5:14am  

I like Wikipedia a lot as a resource, but it's controlled by a bunch of pinheads. They totally do act like the Encyclopedists from Foundation. Great for finding all the alternate universes in the Marvel/DC Comic canon, less good for current events coverage.

40   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 5:17am  

Wikipedia is a great thing.

Great for finding all the alternate universes in the Marvel/DC Comic canon, less good for current events coverage.

An encyclopedia for current events?

41   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 5:21am  

astrid,

I'd recently read one school is no longer accepting papers from students using wiki as a "reference".

I would preface my argument on the basis that no comprehensive coverage of the bubble is complete without THE NUMBER ONE bubble site (and of course our good friend Casey!)

42   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 5:26am  

I don’t understand why people finance or lease cars, to tell you the truth. I have never owned a vehicle I didn’t buy outright, new or used. If you drive your car to death, you can easily save the cash for a new car.

Huh?

Leasing makes sense because you are paying mostly for the depreciation, which is going to cost you regardless.

Why would anyone ever want to drive a half-dead car? Is it even safe?

43   FormerAptBroker   2007 Feb 22, 5:29am  

007 Says:

> Long time lurker, first time posting,

Welcome, you are probably the only poster with a “License to Kill”…

> I have a question for the group here. Why is it that people in the
> upper middle class seem to be willing to keep on buying in this
> obviously inflated market? I haven’t seen any pull back in the $1.5
> to $2.5M price range, either in the bay area, Los Angeles or North
> County of San Diego. In fact recent figures in SD N.County prove
> out that since the beginning of the year the market is better than
> it was in the same time period for 2006 in houses $1M+.

Many of the $1.5mm - $2.0mm homes selling today would have sold for $1.75mm - $2.25mm last year. If you get details on the new SF condos most are selling for less than comparable units sold for last year even with the HOA fees paid for a year and many upgrades.

Today SF gate had an article about how high end homes were holding their value and I laughed when I saw that the article had a photo of Andre Agassi and Steffi Graf’s house in Marin that sold late last year for $3mm less than they paid it for (after a long time on the market and many price cuts).

> I would make the assumption that people dealing in these price
> ranges have to be somewhat savvy buyers and aware of the
> economic and housing environment. So why would they be buying
> now?

Most people that make enough to buy $2mm homes are “smart” but most are not “savvy buyers”.

44   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Feb 22, 5:47am  

Peter P,

I'm saying that if you buy a new car for cash, drive it until it's pretty much at the end of its useful lifespan, then buy another one for cash, you're saving money over borrowing money to do the same thing. And if you can't afford to buy a new car for cash, buy a decent used car.

I've never understood making payments on cars. They drop in value the second you drive them off the lot. They drop A LOT. Yet people still pay, say, 20k for a car, promise to pay another 5k in interest charges over the next 3-4 years for a car that will be worth at most 10k. They're throwing away 5k, given that they decided that it was worth 10k to drive that car for 3-4 years.

However, for 20k, they can drive that car for 20 years. Sure, maintainance eventually catches up and it's cheaper to get a new car and start the cycle over, but certainly not every 3-5 years.

Leases were invented for people who like to do that sort of thing, but don't pay cash up front. Personally I don't like leases because I don't want to have to worry about violating a milage clause and paying extra when I turn it in, etc. But if you get a good lease it can be cheaper than 'owning' a car outright if you plan on swapping soon.

My main point was being flabbergasted that somebody in a 2.2 million dollar home could be worried about a new car tipping them over the edge.

45   Claire   2007 Feb 22, 5:50am  

Peter P

Leasing often does sound good, but if you buy a second hand car (1 to 2 years old), then most of the depreciation has already been paid for by the previous owner/leasee - besides if it's my car, I won't get it in the neck so much from hubby when the kids put a dent in it or spill a drink!

46   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 6:04am  

SP,

Definitely the "high gloss" stuff! LOL!

I guess what I was trying to say was that it wasn't some big production. A 6' ladder handled most of it. People seem to love vaulted ceilings but somehow forget that a wall of equal height must be on the exterior?

47   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 6:07am  

However, for 20k, they can drive that car for 20 years. Sure, maintainance eventually catches up and it’s cheaper to get a new car and start the cycle over, but certainly not every 3-5 years.

I cannot find a 10 years old car with all the must-have safety features:

1. Front airbags
2. Side airbags
3. Side curtain airbags
4. Traction control
5. Stability control
6. Good frontal and side impact scores
7. Good realibility

The closest one would be a 1997 Lexus LS400. But I believe it does not have side curtains, which are IMO more important than front airbags.

48   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 6:09am  

SFBubbleBuyer,

Well, we're all flabbergasted. But that doesn't mean that people aren't stretching that much to make the numbers "work"! THIS w/half down!

49   Claire   2007 Feb 22, 6:10am  

My hubby keeps pointing to the local BMW and Mercedes dealerships that are offering leases in the $240 pm range - however, I keep telling him he needs to bring me the small print before I'll ok one of those!

I think the next time we buy a car, we will look to see if there are any 0% finance deals, otherwise it will be another second hand car for us - I haven't done the math, but unless their financing is virtually free, I can't see any reason to buy a new car (because of the depreciation incurred just driving it off the lot).

50   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 6:14am  

My hubby keeps pointing to the local BMW and Mercedes dealerships that are offering leases in the $240 pm range - however, I keep telling him he needs to bring me the small print before I’ll ok one of those!

Just ask the dealership to give you a *tax-inclusive* number with

1) zero money down (cap-cost reduction does not make sense)
2) realistic mileage restrictions

$240 may jump to $400, which may or may not worth it.

51   Claire   2007 Feb 22, 6:16am  

DinOR - I would love to know how many people are stretched at the top end, that might give us an idea of how big the crash will be - everyone in this area says the housing won't be affected here (we're different don't you know) but if they stretched to get in their 1.5m house, then I would think that they are just as likely to have problems as the sub prime not so good areas.

Everyone says MV is different, but I just don't think it will be - maybe I'm wrong - some arguments either way would be helpful. By the way, why aren't there many decent rentals out there at the minute - and the ones that are are asking pie-in-the-sky rental prices(or so it seems to me)? I was hoping there would be a lot this year! Looks like we will have to stay put for now!

52   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 6:18am  

Upper-middle class wage earners is what we’re talking about. Very few of them can even count to 5M, let alone pay that much.

Upper-middle class are all "wage" earners in some sense because their own time is the real money maker. If they have enough passive income they would be in the upper class.

53   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 6:23am  

SP,

Excellent summation. We could write an entire book on "that" crowd and I applaud your keeping it on point.

"never even heard of M2 or the yield curve"

"one could argue that he may be better off banking the cash in a more diversified portfolio"

Recently Phil Knight (Nike) began selling out of a fair amount of his company stock. Being at the end of a truly remarkable career, it was well deserved (and necessary). My guess is that PK *wasn't the driving force behind those decisions. In fact I'm willing to bet his financial team had to beat him half to death over it! Great guy though.

54   HARM   2007 Feb 22, 6:29am  

The big deal was the fact that insurance companies, pension funds, and mutual funds had stakes in this venture. That’s the part which is shocking. Only silly rich people: Oil Sheiks, Trust Fund babies, Bling-Bling financiers, etc should be in such a high risk game. The conservative institutional investors are suppose to mind where they put their eggs.

The whole San Diego pension fund/Amaranth hedge fund blow-up seems to be validating my original contention that Wall Street would try to engineer ways to stick ordinary retail investors with the bill for their subprime MBS/CDO "creativity". I took a considerable amount of flack for that, with most of the finance types here saying I was flat-out wrong.

And now there is evidence my original position was right after all....

55   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 6:31am  

Claire,

So would I, so would I. Well the MB's that wrote those loans would certainly have a pretty good idea but they've been oddly mum here lately. Like I've always said, I'm sure there are those that can well afford and it will truly NEVER be an issue for them.

It's just funny that there's ALWAYS been such a huge turn-over in Lake Oswego, OR (the closest thing we have to Beverly Hills) b/c so many move there in the hopes that the address alone will drive business their way. Shortly there after they figure out they *can't afford it on a veternarian's/teacher's income, put it up for sale only to be bought by the next wannabes. It's so...... old.

56   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 6:39am  

HARM,

Sandibe (among others) assured us there was some sort of "Chinese Wall" between rank and file investors and big bad HF's. My point has always been that once the sell off in MBS begins in earnest, credit quality won't matter nearly as much as some would like to pretend. Now we're finding municipal employees are out about $85 mil. in their pension fund. Back to work fellas! :(

57   Different Sean   2007 Feb 22, 7:03am  

Great for finding all the alternate universes in the Marvel/DC Comic canon, less good for current events coverage.

hmm, I've noticed that. Why on earth have they documented every manga series, TV cartoon series and comic book character in such excruciating detail? The Britannica entry on manga or anime would probably be about 1 paragraph long in total...

Further, was wiki seeded by any particular encyclopedia text at inception, or has it all been written from scratch by enthusiasts?

58   Claire   2007 Feb 22, 7:16am  

Land Rovers and Range Rovers are no longer "British" - they were bought by Ford a few years ago.

Need I say more about their reliability now?

59   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 7:17am  

Can I have one of your creampuffs?

60   Different Sean   2007 Feb 22, 7:21am  

Jaguar was acquired by Ford, and started using the same parts. Jags even started looking like Fords, they both make large streamlined saloons...

61   Different Sean   2007 Feb 22, 7:25am  

They say that approximately 40% of the cost of everything we buy goes into advertising. It only costs about $5K or something to 'make' a car, the rest is showrooms, salespeoples' salaries, and massive amounts of advertising...

62   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 7:32am  

There are excellent things from Britain. For example, scones and devonshire cream. Yum.

63   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 7:32am  

Yorkshire pudding too!

64   astrid   2007 Feb 22, 8:00am  

The idea of $2M upper middle class home is just mind boggling. $2M will buy a great (non-working) life style almost anywhere in the world, why in Hades would otherwise intelligent people toil the best years of their life to own something that would cost $150,000-300,000 in most of the country?

65   sfbubblebuyer   2007 Feb 22, 8:36am  

TurboTax does pretty well for probably 70-80% of people's tax needs.

66   DinOR   2007 Feb 22, 8:42am  

TBR,

Every time we have someone come on board in an effort to explain exactly what it is that HF's do (or did) we get an almost completely different telling of the story.

Are you trying to tell us that Vangard, Fidelity and other fund companies were buying "off ledger pink sheet stakes" in complete contrast to their printed prospectus? To my understanding in most cases "fund of funds" were created in-house within firms existing fund offerings. The trend if anything was for the wire-houses to do away with their proprietary funds as quickly as they could to distance themselves from conflict of interest.

If the idea was to "bring home the bacon" this strategy failed absolutely miserably. Have you ever worked in a registered capacity at all?

67   e   2007 Feb 22, 8:50am  

$2M will buy a great (non-working) life style almost anywhere in the world, why in Hades would otherwise intelligent people toil the best years of their life to own something that would cost $150,000-300,000 in most of the country?

It's special here. It's not special anywhere else.

68   e   2007 Feb 22, 8:55am  

It is just one data point, but I know someone who has 1.2M in cash (vested stock actually, but let’s say it’s cash). Family income is around 200K gross, with a working spouse. His realtwhore has convinced him he can ‘afford’ up to 1.8M. He thinks he can manage a 600K loan.

$600k shouldn't be hard for someone with a combined income of $200k. I know people who have $550k mortgages with ~$100k incomes.

No kids though.

69   Peter P   2007 Feb 22, 8:59am  

$600k shouldn’t be hard for someone with a combined income of $200k. I know people who have $550k mortgages with ~$100k incomes.

Is it harder if he needs to pay the T (in PITI) for a 1.8M house, which is more than 20K/year.

« First        Comments 30 - 69 of 283       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions