1
0

Does Face Value Matter When Buying Gold and Silver Coins?


 invite response                
2014 Sep 10, 9:29pm   14,834 views  59 comments

by smaulgld   ➕follow (4)   💰tip   ignore  

Government minted silver and gold coins are generally considered legal tender in their country of issuance.

The silver and gold content of the coins, however, vastly exceeds the numbers printed on the coins by the government issuer.

The Canadian Mint produces a one ounce coin marked $5. The US mint produces a one ounce coin market $1.
The Canadian Mint also produces a quarter ounce coin marked $20.

Does this matter at all?

https://smaulgld.com/american-silver-eagles-vs-canadian-silver-eagle-coins/

« First        Comments 9 - 48 of 59       Last »     Search these comments

9   HydroCabron   2014 Sep 11, 1:03am  

Face will be the currency in the post precious-metals Nazi cannibal biker gang slaves-tied-to-the-front-bumper road warrior economy.

Kitco and the curreny exchanges should track dollar-to-face, euro-to-face, and renminbi-to-face, as well as the face values of precious metals.

10   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:05am  

Call it Crazy says

smaulgld says

Ultimately its best to have the most silver at the lowest price

Irrespective of face value but if all things are equal its better to have the higher face value coin

What I was asking was, if you need to go out and make a purchase in the general marketplace using a silver coin in the future, is it better to have a Silver Eagle that is marked $1, even though today it's "worth" approx $20.

Or, is it better just to have a Silver Round that is marked as 1 troy oz. that is .999% pure and has no dollar denomination on it?

Silver eagles say $1 and one ounce on them so if you are getting paid on the silver content it shouldnt matter

But silver eagles sell for a premium so if you are only being paid for the silver better to have the silver round
The advantage of the eagle ive heard is they are more recognizable

11   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:06am  

HydroCabron says

Face will be the currency in the post precious-metals Nazi cannibal biker gang slaves-tied-to-the-front-bumper road warrior economy.

Kitco and the curreny exchanges should track dollar-to-face, euro-to-face, and renminbi-to-face, as well as the face values of precious metals.

Would like AF expert view on this

12   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:35am  

Right the silver eagle is NOT recognizable by most people any more than a round
The $1 marking may confuse people

A silver one ounce round is less money to buy and less confusing to sell if selling it as an ounce.

In the unlikely event of a govt confiscation they can claim fair value is $1

13   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 1:38am  

I thought the conventional wisdom was to have silver dimes and quarters?

What else are they going to use?

14   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:42am  

indigenous says

I thought the conventional wisdom was to have silver dimes and quarters?

What else are they going to use?

There is no real conventional wisdom
How much is a silver dime or quarter worth?
An ounce can be valued easier

15   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 1:46am  

smaulgld says

An ounce can be valued easier

making change might be difficult? Assuming big time deflation.

From what I hear, the immigrants who face this problem say silver coins dimes qtrs and halves and dimes are better

16   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:49am  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

An ounce can be valued easier

making change might be difficult? Assuming big time deflation.

From what I hear, the immigrants who face this problem say silver coins dimes qtrs and halves and dimes are better

In that case to avoid the face value issue( and the 90pct silver issue) there are. .999 pure silver 1/10 1/4 and 1/2 ounce rounds that would be easier to price

17   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 1:56am  

Or..
Just buy silver by the ton and sell it to the chinese
http://smaulgld.com/china-boosts-silver-production-domestic-use/

18   NDrLoR   2014 Sep 11, 2:00am  

I called a coin dealer to get an approximate value of an 1898 $5 gold coin that was my father's from the year of his birth and he said without seeing it probably $250--I decided for that I'd rather keep it.

19   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 2:06am  

When they confiscated gold in. 1933 the holder would have got a $5 bill
A few months later they revalued gold from $20.67 to $35
http://smaulgld.com/think-fed-destroyed-dollar/

21   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 2:35am  

smaulgld says

1/10 1/4 and 1/2 ounce

So at current prices that would mean 1/10 would be $2.00

22   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 2:48am  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

1/10 1/4 and 1/2 ounce

So at current prices that would mean 1/10 would be $2.00

Correct and and dime about $1.5

23   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 2:57am  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

An ounce can be valued easier

making change might be difficult? Assuming big time deflation.

From what I hear, the immigrants who face this problem say silver coins dimes qtrs and halves and dimes are better

As long as there are central banks we wont have deflation- we should have had it the last six years

24   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 3:09am  

The Professor says

I particularly like Mercury dimes and Franklin halves

prefer mercury dime to Roosevelt for sure!
can't go wrong with franklins but the walkers are nicer looking

25   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 3:11am  

The Professor says

smaulgld says

How much is a silver dime or quarter worth?

An ounce can be valued easier

IF the time ever comes, the public will quickly learn the difference between a pre 1965 90% silver coin and the parking meter tokens we call money today.

True but a silver dime quarter will have harder to determine dollar values than divisible silver rounds

26   Blurtman   2014 Sep 11, 3:39am  

smaulgld says

Blurtman says

How much is one US dollar marked $1 or one Canadian dollar marked $1 worth?

$1 as legal tender $about $19 for silver content

And the paper of fiat has zero intrinsic value.

Consider the coins to be derivatives (options?), with a face value floor and theoretically unlimited upside, which is subject to manipulation.

27   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 3:45am  

Blurtman says

Consider the coins to be derivatives (options?), with a face value floor and theoretically unlimited upside, which is subject to manipulation.

right and the $5 Canadian one ounce coin would be worth more than the $1 one ounce US coin.

But what do you make of the $20 and $50 coins that have about $5-12 in them.
They will always maintain their face value and they may grow into their face value via their silver content

28   Blurtman   2014 Sep 11, 3:57am  

smaulgld says

But what do you make of the $20 and $50 coins that have about $5-12 in them.

They will always maintain their face value and they may grow into their face value via their silver content

The floor is all you get. The rest is underwater. Since the face value is literally fixed, consider it to be fiat with an intrinsic value option, currently out of the money.

29   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 4:04am  

Blurtman says

Since the face value is literally fixed, consider it to be fiat with an intrinsic value option, currently out of the money.

precisely. And the $5 Canadian one ounce silver coin is a fiat hedge against a drop in the value of the silver in it

30   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 5:03am  

What about Silver bullets vs rounds or coins? https://smaulgld.com/how-to-buy-silver/

31   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 5:46am  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

1/10 1/4 and 1/2 ounce

So at current prices that would mean 1/10 would be $2.00

7:28 – Silver coins are better for small barter transactions.
http://blog.europacmetals.com/2014/09/gold-videocast-peter-schiff-answers-your-faqs-video/

32   EBGuy   2014 Sep 11, 7:50am  

Real men hoard pennies.

34   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 8:40am  

smaulgld says

As long as there are central banks we wont have deflation- we should have had it the last six years

If inflation gets going Yellin will have to raise interest rates which will cause some/many to default. This will bring about deflation. How do see this not happening?

35   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 8:51am  

indigenous says

If inflation gets going Yellin will have to raise interest rates which will cause some/many to default. This will bring about deflation. How do see this not happening?

another disincentive to raising rates much- the US can't afford it nor can the economy or any one who owes any money -they want and need inflation and they will have it.

http://mises.ca/posts/blog/government-interest-payments/

36   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 9:01am  

smaulgld says

nother disincentive to raising rates much- the US can't afford it nor can the economy or any one who owes any money -they want and need inflation and they will have it.

http://mises.ca/posts/blog/government-interest-payments/

Yup, BUT if you have printed 4 TRILLION dollars out of thin air the likelihood of inflation is just about guaranteed.

I know but we haven't seen it yet, BUT...

37   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 9:04am  

Call it Crazy says

smaulgld says

What about Silver bullets

The Lone Ranger is still around?

or, were you referring to Coors Light?

No actual silver bullets- They are referenced in one of the early paragraphs with a link here:
https://smaulgld.com/how-to-buy-silver/

38   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 9:06am  

indigenous says

I know but we haven't seen it yet, BUT...

We HAVE seen massive inflation in asset prices of real estate and the stock market-that do not correspond to fundamentals The prices are higher as a result of the inflation of the money supply.
This is the "great deformation" that Stockman writes about.

We also have food price inflation and all prices higher than the otherwise would have been if the market had been allowed to enter its deflationary depression in 2008/09

39   indigenous   2014 Sep 11, 9:20am  

smaulgld says

We also have food price inflation and all prices higher than the otherwise would have been if the market had been allowed to enter its deflationary depression in 2008/09

I'm looking at the purchasing manager's report a week ago and China's PMI report being flat Germans' being down and the US report being up. If manufacturing is on shored as it is being this is one of the ways that inflation can get percolating in the main part of the economy.

40   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 9:31am  

indigenous says

I'm looking at the purchasing manager's report a week ago and China's PMI report being flat Germans' being down and the US report being up. If manufacturing is on shored as it is being this is one of the ways that inflation can get percolating in the main part of the economy.

Could be. I am in the stagflation camp
inflation with no "benefits"

41   smaulgld   2014 Sep 11, 11:11pm  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

As long as there are central banks we wont have deflation- we should have had it the last six years

If inflation gets going Yellin will have to raise interest rates which will cause some/many to default. This will bring about deflation. How do see this not happening?

Zero Hedge: Why we won't have deflation in an era of central banks
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-09-11/death-deflation-central-bank-era

42   indigenous   2014 Sep 12, 1:29am  

smaulgld says

Zero Hedge: Why we won't have deflation in an era of central banks

Yup, BTW we did have deflation from 2009 to 2010.

Japan has been fighting it since the 90s

If inflation gets going the only way to stop it would be to raise interest rates.

With money velocity at record lows that might be considered a form of deflation?

Probably we will see it go back and forth between inflation and deflation unless some of that 4 trillion starts making its way into main st.

43   smaulgld   2014 Sep 12, 1:32am  

indigenous says

smaulgld says

Zero Hedge: Why we won't have deflation in an era of central banks

Yup, BTW we did have deflation from 2009 to 2010.

Japan has been fighting it since the 90s

If inflation gets going the only way to stop it would be to raise interest rates.

With money velocity at record lows that might be considered a form of deflation?

Probably we will see it go back and forth between inflation and deflation unless some of that 4 trillion starts making its way into main st.

What ever happens won't be because of the market determining events but rather incessant massive interference by central banks to create inflation.
If they ever get into a bind whether its a disaster either way- they will ALWAYS choose inflation- because they can always reset after the collapse and still stay rich!

44   smaulgld   2014 Sep 12, 1:33am  

As long as central banks exist there will NEVER be a deflationary collapse, just an inflationary one

45   indigenous   2014 Sep 12, 1:34am  

smaulgld says

What ever happens won't be because of the market determining events but rather incessant massive interference by central banks to create inflation.

Yup

smaulgld says

As long as central banks exist there will NEVER be a deflationary collapse, just an inflationary one

If they are able...

The credit market is 60 trillion the money supply is 12 trillion. They have printed 4 trillion as massive as that is it is 6% of the two combined. Point is that it could get away from them...

46   smaulgld   2014 Sep 12, 1:41am  

Of course it can get away from them but they can print a lot easier than raising rates
A debt laden system based entirely on credit cant raise rates without an entire collapse
Central banks will always choose to inflate away

There is a reason they have an inflation target instead of a deflation target as no amount of deflation is acceptable to central banks

47   indigenous   2014 Sep 12, 1:46am  

smaulgld says

Of course it can get away from them

The current situation is not always...

smaulgld says

but they can print a lot easier than raising rates

Yup

smaulgld says

A debt laden system based entirely on credit cant raise rates without an entire collapse

If inflation really gets going they will not have a choice.

smaulgld says

Central banks will always choose to inflate away

Which is why I vote for honest money after the collapse. Which will come sooner than later.

In the mean time bet on inflation

48   smaulgld   2014 Sep 12, 1:52am  

http://smaulgld.com/negative-interest-rates-and-janet-yellen/
And dont forget greenspans we can always print money

« First        Comments 9 - 48 of 59       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions