0
0

Utopia Village


 invite response                
2006 Sep 12, 5:18am   14,842 views  222 comments

by Peter P   ➕follow (2)   💰tip   ignore  

Tell us your vision of a perfect world. What will housing be like in this world? What is the role of development planning?

#housing

« First        Comments 31 - 70 of 222       Last »     Search these comments

31   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 7:50am  

requiem,

I'm certainly not advocating any kind of a police state. Any time someone is transferred to a new mil. base they will rec. an "indoctrination" about local places in town where there have been problems, how to find your way to the hospital and sometimes you'll be assigned a "sponsor".

So it's more about "upholding" tradition as one of the cleanest and safest bases than brow beating anyone. In some cases there really doesn't have to be a threat of conformity. When I was stationed at Long Beach, CA (right off of Santa Fe Ave.) the sirens NEVER stopped! 24/7 emergency goin' down somewhere! Who wanted to get kicked out and have to deal with some apt. complex's "stabbing of the week"?

32   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 7:57am  

"I thought EPA screwed up because of rent control. I have yet to see a nice city that is rent-controlled."

Allegedly, there are some really nice rent control apartments in NYC and Santa Monica, and some pretty good ones in SF...though they're probably nice inspite of the rent control, rather than because of it.

33   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 7:59am  

requiem,

I thought Peter P was talking about the overpopulation problem. The most obvious solution to the problem is to create more land surface (by building up, building down, orbital colonies or whatever).

As for the commuting problem. A transfer booth or transfer beam or dial-a-travel will do just fine.

34   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 8:01am  

I thought Peter P was talking about the overpopulation problem. The most obvious solution to the problem is to create more land surface (by building up, building down, orbital colonies or whatever).

Reducing total population growth to zero is also effective. This is the only thing I have in common with environmentalists.

35   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 8:04am  

The best solution to commuting is to end work. Make computers and robots do all the menial/not fun/drudge work. People can work for fun or lifestyle upgrade, but make work optional.

36   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 8:08am  

The best solution to commuting is to end work. Make computers and robots do all the menial/not fun/drudge work. People can work for fun or lifestyle upgrade, but make work optional.

Possible. The only "perfect" economic system is to have seemingly unlimited resource.

37   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 8:13am  

"Possible. The only “perfect” economic system is to have seemingly unlimited resource."

Yes! Now would you please get on with creating fusion power, making an army of skillful yet completely loyal robot servants and building that Dyson sphere. I'd like to see it soon so I can retire early.

38   requiem   2006 Sep 12, 8:14am  

I'm not sure overpopulation is a problem; it's just that so many people are clustered because of poor transportation options. (Though, cutting down on kids would help a great deal.)

DinOR: if the motivation is not to be kicked out, isn't that a sort of passive-aggressive browbeating? Just tossing out ideas; from my own experience, I think the "upholding tradition" aspect or similar is more than enough for most of the inhabitants.

39   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 8:16am  

I’m not sure overpopulation is a problem; it’s just that so many people are clustered because of poor transportation options. (Though, cutting down on kids would help a great deal.)

If people is the problem that having too many people will be a big problem.

40   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 8:19am  

Upholding tradition aspect only works if you have a relatively homogenous group of individuals sharing similar views and objectives. It's no good if you live next door to a flipper owned house rented out to four illegal migrant families or a meth brewer.

Even well intentioned new immigrant families tend to neglect outside upkeep.

41   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 8:28am  

requiem,

The truth is that the base housing in Long Beach at the time (early 80's) wasn't all that enviable. It had been built in WWII and was showing it's age. But it was affordable and orderly and just outside LB was Hell Hole of the first and worst order!

At the time LB had a higher per capita murder rate than Detroit. Property crimes were so commonplace the PD didn't even respond. Santa Fe Ave. that ran along the east side was known as the Ho Chi Minh Trail b/c it was wall to wall Vietnamese strip clubs etc. To their credit LB has cleaned up somewhat but even Ocean Blvd. was scary. It was a hangover from the Viet Nam era (and boy did it look it). Tattoo parlors, peep shows and pawn shops. In contrast base housing looked LIKE utopia!

42   requiem   2006 Sep 12, 8:30am  

Even well intentioned new immigrant families tend to neglect outside upkeep.

Is this a cultural issue or an available-time issue? (serious question) The case of the flipper and the migrant workers seem solvable by the application of sane economic/immigration/security policies. The meth brewer, well, that's what the local police are for. So, if we end up with a rational environment, will the immigrant family still be neglecting the upkeep?

43   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 8:32am  

In contrast base housing looked LIKE utopia!

Perhaps Utopia is relative.

44   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 8:33am  

austingal,

I tend to lean toward your vision. People that live in climate extremes may want to consider earth sheltered options, folks in moderate climates probably won't worry about it.

The reason I got interested in water catchment systems was for all the rain we get in Oregon our shared well was a pain in the a$$. Always needed work, parts or maint. and by August you couldn't do laundry and dishes at the same time. Is that crazy or what? The spring break quake of 1993 changed our water table that much!

45   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 8:47am  

I think it's more a cultural and a learning curve issue. Chinese people (and presumably Japanese and Koreans) don't really know how to take care of grass. They're also cheap, so they won't water enough to keep the grass green and doesn't seed or fertilize on time.

The best way to get an immaculate lawn/garden is to have the HOA hire an outside contractor to do all the work. You get efficiency of scale and it cuts down weekend noise pollution, and enforcement becomes a non-issue.

46   speedingpullet   2006 Sep 12, 8:52am  

Just for fun!
Put your utopian ideals to the test by creating your own nation state over at

www.nationstates.net

Your government can accept, reject and dismiss an outstanding issue every day, and your answers will affect how well or how badly your country turns out.

You can join together with others to create regions and when you get big enough you get admission to the United Nations.

/Just for fun!

47   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 9:24am  

The building is filled with mostly quite wealthy people who live in gorgeous rentals because there is absolutely no incentive for them to move out of those apartments, ever.

But are they updated with modern kitchens and marble baths? There is not much incentive for landlords to renovate rent-controlled buildings, right?

48   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 9:29am  

Rent control is quasi ownership. The renters can afford to update the interior at their own expense.

49   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 9:30am  

The main point is that while there are many problems with rent control, I don't think you can blame EPA on rent control.

50   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 9:32am  

The main point is that while there are many problems with rent control, I don’t think you can blame EPA on rent control.

Must be the feng shui.

51   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 9:39am  

Prop 13 is vaguely a form of rent control. This is why I am not a supporter.

It is a mistake. We will see more and more examples of resource misallocation because of Prop 13.

52   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 9:46am  

I think the bubble blogs are driving some Realtors insane.

I like marinite, but I am against making accusations against realtors or other individuals.

53   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 9:47am  

One of my friends lives in that building and she did a major renovation of the kitchen and baths and redid the floors, major paint job, gorgeous curtains, etc.

If there is a legally-enforcable long-term lease, why not?

54   HARM   2006 Sep 12, 10:01am  

Has anybody read this?
http://marinrealestatebubble.blogspot.com/2006/09/local-broker-slams-this-blog_11.html

I think the bubble blogs are driving some Realtors insane.

As the bubble collapse becomes undeniable to even the most obstinant perma-bull, watch out for idiots like this to start wagging an accusatory at blogs like this one. Who know? Maybe LAY will sue Peter P for personally lowering her house value by 40%.

I guess we'd better start wearing camo & body armor --"shoot the messenger" season's just started and there are millions of FBs with itchy trigger fingers out there.

55   HARM   2006 Sep 12, 10:02am  

watch out for idiots like this to start wagging an accusatory finger at blogs like this one

56   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 10:06am  

Maybe LAY will sue Peter P for personally lowering her house value by 40%.

It is impossible that any blogger can affect the market as a whole.

This blog is not even targeted towards any particular local market.

57   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 10:13am  

Moreover, everybody knows that the bubble collapses because the Fed has increased interest rate 17 times straight. ;)

58   speedingpullet   2006 Sep 12, 10:15am  

@ newsfreak re: opals

One reason why opals in Oz cost more is that they're probably 'solid' opals - ie a whole stone, rather than a 'doublet' (where a thin section of opal is glued under glass - looks almost the same, but isn't nearly as costly). As well as doublets, many stones touted as 'opals' are in fact synthetically made in a lab.

As for them being more expensive....I bought my opal direct from e-opals. It seems that the link isn't working any more, but I know that many smaller opal mining communities in Aus (including Coober Pedy) have online sites to sell stones - easier, and much cheaper for everyone, than travelling to the Nulllabor to pick your stone by hand!

As with all gemstones, the better the quality the more you pay. I'd have to see the descriptions of the US ones vs the Oz ones to see if they're comparing apples with apples, so to speak. Having researched opals quite a lot when buying the stone for my ring, I got quite good at finding the duds and reading between the lines.

A bit like the 'true' reading of Realtorspeak......

59   Different Sean   2006 Sep 12, 11:00am  

How about a vertical city in which elevators are all you need to get around?

Diminishing returns Peter. THere’s a reason why increasingly higher buildings are approaching asymptotic limits.

interestingly, elevators turn out to be relatively energy efficient, in that it takes energy to raise them, but they return energy to the grid on the way down by using the electric motors for regenerative braking... apart from losses in the system and maintenance costs, they're not too environmentally unfriendly... or so i've been told...

60   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 11:06am  

interestingly, elevators turn out to be relatively energy efficient, in that it takes energy to raise them, but they return energy to the grid on the way down by using the electric motors for regenerative braking… apart from losses in the system and maintenance costs, they’re not too environmentally unfriendly… or so i’ve been told…

For really tall buildings, we probably need a whole new paradigm because the cables will be too long/heavy.

61   Different Sean   2006 Sep 12, 11:13am  

well, yeah, we don't want to build them to the moon...

you could have 'stepped' elevators that go to some number of storeys, then you have to change...

potentially, more people get sunlight and 'a view' with taller buildings rather than 4-5 storey buildings, but I'm presently fighting the state govt who want to put 100 m towers near my place to help their crony capitalist mates who are selling the land... the towers just won't be human scale and will be intimidating, which is admittedly a somewhat subjective architectural appraisal, but not without its adherents...

62   Different Sean   2006 Sep 12, 11:18am  

alien Says:
Concrete is DEFINITELY bad karma - beyond even a hummer! Check the carbon cycle figures out…

just on that, i'm actually quite interested in polystyrene mouldings with 5mm concrete render (despite what people say about them - this is not a joke! you haven't seen the dreary buildings here) and general rendering as a business idea going forward, in conjunction with some more 'green' ideas around water tank designs -- is there a greener material to do exterior mouldings and rendering than using cement? even firing bricks is pretty energy intensive. are there any other formable and smooth finish rapid cladding products out there that are low EE?

63   Peter P   2006 Sep 12, 11:18am  

you could have ’stepped’ elevators that go to some number of storeys, then you have to change…

This is necessary. There can be express elevators that take people only to Lobby, 30, 60, 90, 120 while local elevators can take people to any floor within a 30-level block.

64   Paul189   2006 Sep 12, 11:44am  

With the ongoing commodity crash following the ongoing housing bust we'll have Eutopia with low cost gasoline, copper, gold etc... This will allow for the finest finishes in your home at little to no cost. You can live in exurbia and drive your Hummer for hours to get to civilazation and it will cost next to nothing!

65   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 12:26pm  

HARM,

The Marin Bubble Blog link was hysterical! Randy H and others have shared their stories of watching the canary perish and have been met with "I'm sure things will get better for you" etc. Mr. Realt-whore goes for the ultimate in low blows by implying that the blogger has "lost" his home and it's doubled in value since then!

So that particular blog is HOW old? What, maybe 2 years? So Assuming the Marin blogger lost his on Friday and had his blog up and running the following Monday Mr. Realt-whore thinks a doubling in price every two years is normal? Sure, why not? Makes perfect economic sense to me.

Lastly, the idea that they guy "doctored" or outright falsified data and in effect is "creating a crash" shows how ignorant and desperate these people are becoming. I don't blame the guy for remaining anon. As things heat up I'm adopting a lower profile my damn self!

66   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 12:41pm  

Argghh! Why are we mistaking decent public conduct with a "police state"? In spite of what people might have heard about Singapore there are plenty of places where you can get as rude and ignorant as you wanna be! And for a reasonable fare the cabbie will take there. They just ask you conduct yourself in a presentable manner when in public view.

(it's not that big a deal)

Most people here aren't yet at an age where their children remember the dude urinating in an alley just off the main street. I've been through it and it's hell raising two daughters when it seems just about every public place you go it feels like you walked on to the set of "Jackass".

Please check out the link on Fox News of the reporter in San Diego and listen to "Rosa's" mouth. Now imagine your kids are old enough to know what just a handful of those words mean?

No one is saying we can't be nasty, just not in public. Can we at least give ONE generation the chance to be kids? No Dad, I DON'T want to get "high" with you!

67   HeadSet   2006 Sep 12, 12:51pm  

Utopia - beatiful high end homes falling in price. Everyone can get what they want if they just wait.

Yesterday I had a call from a desperate realtor. This house I have been watching, a 3400 sqft beauty on a 2 acre lot, has already been marked down $70,000. The realtor called to say that if I was still interested I could name my price, and not by "just a few thousand off." I was polite, but told him there was plenty of competition in that price range and I'll call if interested.

Actually, this trend is a relief. For awhile, I was wondering if that damn "soft landing" was going to be real. It seems the downside momentum was long in coming, but is quickly picking up steam.

68   HeadSet   2006 Sep 12, 1:10pm  

DinOr,

Enforcement of decent public conduct you say? Such as not throwing cigarette butts out the car window into yards, not blasting a radio, getting a real muffler for your harley, using a rake instead of a leaf blower louder than an afterburner, cleaning up after your mutt, not spray painting messages, taking that barking lab inside after midnight, etc. Try to enforce these and hear the cry of "police state"

But no outcry for the arrest of the girl who sunbathes topless on the beach or the big fat guy who goes nude from his house to the mailbox at the end of his driveway.

69   astrid   2006 Sep 12, 1:16pm  

It's the stereotypical American public - obnoxious AND judgmental.

70   DinOR   2006 Sep 12, 2:02pm  

Headset,

Well yeah, something like that. All I know is I could be having a really good day and either I get in my car and drive or walk a few blocks and things "can" head south quickly.

It's like we're constantly trying to have some kind of "who can be the most rude, complacent or ignorant contest". If I'm at a bar at closing time, yeah, I expect it but going to check your mail?

« First        Comments 31 - 70 of 222       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions