patrick.net

WookieMan says

Government BACKED LOANS! They cannot be discharged. Public or private can be forgiven. Basically every single loan outside of a loan taken out by a student on their own which is maybe 5% or less. It was a FED and bank bailout. BANKS. FED is not government giving money out. Not even a debate. You have to pay the loan and Biden just forgave a ton.

You are wrong. The government made the Federal Student Loans and they are on the government's books -- not a Banks.

Read up on it.

DOGEWontAmountToShit says

Yup. Ever since Obama nationalized student loans. There are a few 'non-profit' banks that still do because they were tied to some Dem big wigs he needed to pass that bill.

@WookieMan ^^^

And:

https://www.axios.com/2022/08/27/the-impact-of-student-loan-nationalization

Repro covered it pretty clearly. Bonds. That's a loan banks buy and lend upon. Let me know the servicer of your student loan debt? I can promise you it's not the Federal government. They borrow from a BANK called the FED. That's not Federal government. It's just called that.

The US has instituted a policy that doesn't allow default. AKA FUCKING GOVERNMENT BACKED. The government won't let you default regardless. The money still comes from a bank not the government, The FED is a bank. They sell bonds to cover it and pay 3rd parties and GUARANTEE it.

Some of you cats don't understand the play on words you've been fed. 95% of all student loans HAVE to be paid regardless of source. There's no out. Government backed. They agree you don't have to pay your debt. Colleges would shut down overnight if student loans could be defaulted and not paid.

The servicer of the debt works for the Department of Education which holds the loans on its books. There is no bank involved. The debt cancellation was NOT a fucking bank bailout.

"But what exactly does “cost the government” mean? Canceled federal student loans would be immediately added to the federal deficit, which measures how much the U.S. spends minus how much it takes in."*

Why deficit? Government has to borrows money (from Federal Reserve-FED and pay interest on it) to pay off variety of banks, which borrowed money for students. D.O.E DOES NOT HAVE A PENNY TO BORROW.

"Canceling federal student loans will cost the federal government hundreds of billions of dollars— and the general public will eventually end up footing the bill."*
*Forbes advisor

REpro says

"But what exactly does “cost the government” mean? Canceled federal student loans would be immediately added to the federal deficit, which measures how much the U.S. spends minus how much it takes in."

Why deficit? Government has to borrows money (from Federal Reserve-FED and pay interest on it) to pay off variety of banks, which borrowed money for students. D.O.E DOES NOT HAVE A PENNY TO BORROW.

"Canceling federal student loans will cost the federal government hundreds of billions of dollars— and the general public will eventually end up footing the bill."
*Forbes advisor

You are so wrong about so many things. The DOE money that went to the students was already funded through the sale of US Treasuries. The loans to the students are on the books of the DOE as they directly loaned the money to the students. It is the Treasury that sells the bills, notes and bonds. These obligations are to the purchasers of that security not to the FED. The Treasury does not borrow money directly from the FED. Again no banks are part of the loan transaction to the student borrowers.

The only thing that you are correct on is that the general public will eat the cost of the loan cancellation either through taxes or inflation.

Financial world is difficult to understand.

WookieMan says

Private banks 100% loan the money. Biden just decided to take Federal money and give it to banks as "loan forgiveness." The money never went to the former student. It went straight to the bank they borrowed from.

None of that is true concerning Federal Student Loans.
Available through the US Department of Education, federal student loans are loans from the federal government that you can use to pay for higher education expenses.
These loans are FROM the federal government itself, not just backed by the federal government.

https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/smart-money/how-do-student-loans-work

HeadSet says

WookieMan says

Private banks 100% loan the money. Biden just decided to take Federal money and give it to banks as "loan forgiveness." The money never went to the former student. It went straight to the bank they borrowed from.

None of that is true concerning Federal Student Loans.
Available through the US Department of Education, federal student loans are loans from the federal government that you can use to pay for higher education expenses.
These loans are FROM the federal government itself, not just backed by the federal government.

https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/smart-money/how-do-student-loans-work

The FED is a bank. Our government sells bonds to cover it. It's a bank. The federal government does not loan the money itself directly from tax payers. It's all borrowed from a bank/bonds. Then backed by the federal government. If I pay $100 in taxes and let's say say $1 goes to student loans, 100% of that is paid to students by a bank, not the government. The government is the guarantor that it will be repaid. Federally backed.

Wife and I had student loans about a decade ago. Nothing was from the federal government. I'm kind of the active baby on this site. No one seems to have college aged kids or kids at all or ever had student loans. Banks loan the money, not the government. They just back that you cannot default. Not sure what's hard to understand here.

TL:DR - Federal loans are from the FED. A PRIVATE BANK. Other loans are from private banks that the government also backs. College kids are never given a dime from the federal budget besides covering the interest.

WookieMan says

Wife and I had student loans about a decade ago. Nothing was from the federal government.

Yes. And since then the business was nationalized.

Good luck, finding in Federal Government budget position, which point on portion of taxpayers money is dedicated or given to DOE specifically for students' loans.

WookieMan says

The university admins are the only winners in this scenario.

The quality of education that students get in undergraduate school is poor too.

gabbar says

WookieMan says

The university admins are the only winners in this scenario.

The quality of education that students get in undergraduate school is poor too.

It was a waste of time for me. Get the experience in the field. An engineer doesn't need to know about the civil war. Does it really make them more educated? I'd rather have a top notch engineer versus someone that can kind of engineer and knows about Gettysburg. Right?

You do that stuff on your free time. If I'm a doctor I can read history in my free time. I don't need to be taught it or take classes. You should be smart enough.

Liberals have too many problems and especially around gender and illegal immigration.. But unlike conservatives they understand danger from BRICS especially Hindu and 🇷🇺.

MAGA crowd is either naive or not loyal to 🇺🇸.

Shia Muslims + BRICs are on one side.
USA + Saudi lead Sunnis + Western Europe on other side.

https://nypost.com/2024/12/05/us-news/only-6-of-federal-workers-show-up-in-person-on-a-full-time-basis-scathing-senate-report-reveals/

Top DOGE Elon Musk, House speaker balk at Senate report showing only 6% of federal workers show up in person on full-time basis: ‘Absurd’

WookieMan says

College kids are never given a dime from the federal budget besides covering the interest.

Correction, the college kids don’t really get any benefit from federal subsidized loans. The real beneficiaries are the banks who earn interest on a nondischargeable loan, and the universities who raise tuition rates as high as the subsidy will allow.

Patrick says

Top DOGE Elon Musk, House speaker balk at Senate report showing only 6% of federal workers show up in person on full-time basis: ‘Absurd’

https://www.ernst.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/final_telework_report.pdf

Bureaucrats Are Playing Hide-and-Seek

Bureaucrats have been found in a bubble bath, on the golf course, running their own business,
and even getting busted doing crime while on taxpayers’ time. Members of President Biden’s
own cabinet claimed to be on the clock while being out of office and unreachable.
Just three percent of the federal workforce teleworked daily prior to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Today, six percent of workers report in-person on a full-time basis, while nearly one-third are
entirely remote.

Most federal employees are eligible to telework and 90 percent of those are. Some come to the
office as infrequently as once a week.
The Biden administration redacted the locations of over 281,000 rank-and-file federal
employees.

Services Suffer as Taxpayers are Put on Hold by Bureaucrats

Phoning It in

Service backlogs and delays, unanswered phone calls and emails, and no-show appointments
are harming the health, lives, and aspirations of Americans.
Thousands of calls from veterans seeking mental health care go unanswered. Remote work may
be partly responsible for the recent baby formula crisis. Small businesses, students, and other
taxpayers seeking assistance are instead getting sent to voicemail.

Public Employees Padding Their Paychecks by Avoiding the Office

Some bureaucrats are claiming to be working in areas with higher pay rates while actually living
elsewhere.

My audits are finding as many as 23 to 68 percent of teleworking employees for some agencies
are boosting their salaries by receiving incorrect locality pay.
Some employees live more than 2,000 miles away from their office and one “temporary”
teleworker collected higher locality pay for nearly a decade.

The best way for the establishment to handle this would be to embrace it and fast track it into existence.
Then just fuck it up like they do every well intentioned agency ever created. There's loads of things they could do, like hold a Congressional vote to replace Elon and Viveck early on while the office is being set up. I mean it's going to be an agency. They don't materialize over night. It will take at least two years before they are up and fully operational. That's a long time for them to put their dirty finger in the pie.

But of course that's not what they are going to do. Instead they are going to unmask and uncover even more dirty secrets that the American people don't know about. Further piss off the voting base on both sides. And make the resolve for the American people to see DOGE a working reality. The Dems and RINOs that stand in the way will be easy picking to replace with DOGE aligned candidates. That will be a fact.

What will be needed to make that a reality is secure elections in the states that still has no ID voting. We will need clean honest fair election in all States, by the midterm. That is the only way DOGE or anything like it will ever be a reality.
The Soros commie judges need to be locked up and thrown off the bench. The City commissioners working with Dominion and Commie operatives to keep the elections a one party decision making process.

The resistance of DOGE is going to be the undoing of every RINO and Commie in politics. It's an issue the voters on both sides can agree on. As we're even seeing true moderate Democrats embracing it.

The voters that wont like it, are the Marxists and the same maskholes that voted for Kamala just because they hate Trump even though they are registered as a Republican.