4
0

2015 Housing Predictions: The Bar Is So Low We Might Trip On It


               
2014 Dec 22, 9:48am   24,580 views  49 comments

by _   follow (8)  

http://loganmohtashami.com/2014/12/22/2015-housing-predictions-the-bar-is-so-low-we-might-trip-on-it/

Higher inventories in many areas and low mortgage interest rates lead to lofty promises of booming mortgage purchase applications and nirvana for new home sales. Alas, to the dismay of our many mislead pundits, these promises remained unfulfilled like the aspirations of a democratic candidate during the midterm elections. Despite the fact that mortgage rates were low all year-long, existing home inventory was up and rents have been high and rising, we still experienced negative demand year over year, even with the number of cash buyers 20% above historical norms. Starts, permits and all sales were disappointing in 2014: Mortgage...

#housing

« First        Comments 20 - 49 of 49        Search these comments

20   _   @   2014 Dec 26, 3:30am  

anonymous says

Is this something related to the elections?

Interest rate hikes with duration time frame

More a 2017 story, but if wage growth doesn't rise with rate hikes and a rise in the 10 year then that could be the inflection point pushing consumption toward a negative trend

Right now 4.7% 10 year with a Fed funds rate over 3% is recessionary but that is 2 years away really.

21   _   @   2014 Dec 26, 3:31am  

A 1994 spike in the 10 year could in theory happen, but the world is in such a deflation-airy cycle that It's hard for me to use 2015 and talk about 1994 again

22   _   @   2014 Dec 26, 3:44am  

Its hard for me not to see any rate hikes because 2015 has always been my wage inflation to get to at least 2.4 percent... I know still low... But with that and rent inflation still running at. 3 percent which is 41 percent of CPI. If there is no hikes in 2015 it would have to be based on that Europe, China, Japan, Russia and Brazil got worse in 2015 importing deflation here. Which would keep us in that 2 - 2.5 percent growth mode but if we are pushing 3 percent growth with 230K a month job print I see the Fed starting its rate hike. At least the Fed per their own language has been saying this is the model and they ended QE with their direction

23   _   @   2014 Dec 26, 8:53am  

anonymous says

So what do you see, if those interest rate hikes do not occur? Any thoughts on a deflation scenario?

It isn't great, but with GDP, employment, JOLTS data running past their usual metric points for a rate hike, it will be hard for them to not raise if the economic trend here in the U.S. is still moving forward.

24   _   @   2014 Dec 26, 11:42pm  

One thing for sure is that low yield world deflation has created a lower level yield base cover for the economy.

So QE velocity was horrid in this economy cycle but that in itself would show that the economy and stock market wouldn't collapse at the end or QE. In theory you would have see market discounting this during the taper and the trend since 2013 was always buy the V dips anyone who went to cash would have had to make a decision to get back in or miss the ride from early 2013

25   anotheraccount   @   2014 Dec 27, 12:01am  

Logan Mohtashami says

Its hard for me not to see any rate hikes because 2015 has always been my wage inflation to get to at least 2.4 percent... I know still low... But with that and rent inflation still running at. 3 percent which is 41 percent of CPI. If there is no hikes in 2015 it would have to be based on that Europe, China, Japan, Russia and Brazil got worse in 2015 importing deflation here. Which would keep us in that 2 - 2.5 percent growth mode but if we are pushing 3 percent growth with 230K a month job print I see the Fed starting its rate hike. At least the Fed per their own language has been saying this is the model and they ended QE with their direction

If we get a rate hike in 2015, it will be 25 basis points and done. When the market really gets scared now it only takes two weeks to go down 10% or a month to go down 20%.

26   _   @   2014 Dec 27, 12:08am  

tr6 says

If we get a rate hike in 2015, it will be 25 basis points and done. When the market really gets scared now it only takes two weeks to go down 10% or a month to go down 20%.

There is talk that maybe they even do .125% hikes in this cycle, which is very incremental

27   cloud15   @   2014 Dec 27, 2:04am  

Logan, What's yiur predicting for prices in SF Bay Area ?

28   _   @   2014 Dec 27, 2:13am  

cloud15 says

Logan, What's yiur predicting for prices in SF Bay Area ?

Hopefully they would be flat or fall for the sake of the people their.

However, pricing power still looks good enough to eek out of a gain for 2015.

That market now
2014 Median 2013 Median
San Francisco County $1,050,000 $852,000 23.24%

% change from previous year

http://www.dqnews.com/charts/monthly-charts/ca-city-charts/zipcar.aspx

San Francisco is a very unique market due to high end $$$ and inventory levels that tie to the high end of an economic cycle

29   anonymous   2014 Dec 27, 11:11am  

This is why I left the Bay Area years ago and will never move back. Only the uber rich or suckers would move there now.

30   _   @   2014 Dec 27, 11:14pm  

debyne says

This is why I left the Bay Area years ago and will never move back. Only the uber rich or suckers would move there now.

California itself is a housing inflation nightmare.

My model shows that 82% of working population ( X out the Rich) Cash & 3X median income 189K are priced out housing

I go into California housing in my recent interview with Bloomberg Financial at he BNY Mellon Stock conference

http://loganmohtashami.com/2014/12/04/bloomberg-financial-interview-at-the-bny-mellon-conference-housing-reality/

31   anonymous   2014 Dec 28, 4:58am  

Logan Mohtashami says

California itself is a housing inflation nightmare.

My model shows that 82% of working population ( X out the Rich) Cash & 3X median income 189K are priced out housing

Do you think prices in CA will eventually buckle and come back to reality?

32   _   @   2014 Dec 28, 6:33am  

debyne says

Do you think prices in CA will eventually buckle and come back to reality?

Main Street Reality, not likely

CA is 2 Tier state, broken into 6 it has the 3 richest and 3 poorest states in America.

This state has wealth and high incomes. However, that portion is small compared to the rest.

So, home prices dropping below enough to make sense for the majority is probably unlikely.

You have a lot people with cash both foreign and domestic that step in with CA homes. Then you have group of California residents who make money with every up turn in the cycle

CA has a rental inflation crisis which impacts more of it's citizens, over 50% of L.A. residents are living in multiple households

33   _   @   2014 Dec 28, 9:57pm  

On the new home sale side of the equation which is only 1/11th of sales today. The MI2MP model deviated at the start of the century

34   _   @   2014 Dec 30, 6:25am  

debyne says

This is why I left the Bay Area years ago and will never move back. Only the uber rich or suckers would move there now.

The people who leave CA, from what I see, besides a job factor, it's been cost of shelter is much cheaper from the low end to high end of the market.

If you have a well high paying job 3X median income household then it's not a place to live with the weather and all. However, it's dam pricey on all fronts

35   anonymous   2014 Dec 30, 6:36am  

Logan Mohtashami says

debyne says

This is why I left the Bay Area years ago and will never move back. Only the uber rich or suckers would move there now.

The people who leave CA, from what I see, besides a job factor, it's been cost of shelter is much cheaper from the low end to high end of the market.

If you have a well high paying job 3X median income household then it's not a place to live with the weather and all. However, it's dam pricey on all fronts

I'm actually now in San Diego, which is MUCH cheaper than the BA to live than people think. Before that, I was in Seattle and it was about the same COL as San Diego...San Diego would be cheaper than Seattle if not for CA state income taxes.

36   _   @   2014 Dec 30, 6:39am  

debyne says

CA state income taxes.

Yes!

37   _   @   2014 Dec 30, 9:41am  

anonymous says

retirement there is more I want to do than pay high prices at every turn.

retirement in California, that will be for the very wealthy, very expensive to retire here in the up coming decades

38   MandyLifeboats   @   2014 Dec 30, 12:04pm  

Logan, do you have any insight on the Las Vegas market?

39   _   @   2014 Dec 30, 12:10pm  

Mandy Lifeboats says

Logan, do you have any insight on the Las Vegas market?

Off the top of my head if I remember right per the last report

Sales were down 8% year over year
Cash buyers falling from 43% to 32%
Inventory is up over 20%

Non distress sales were up year over year

Vegas had a big rise in inventory in 2014 but total sales fell and cash buyers not getting the deals they got before so they are falling

40   MandyLifeboats   @   2014 Dec 30, 4:05pm  

You would think that people here in Las Vegas would be worried given the info but my impression is that they feel bad times are behind them and there's only smooth sailing ahead.

Thank you.

41   _   @   2014 Dec 31, 2:44am  

Going forward as well, the past housing cycles rates have been lower for a lot housing cycles, almost impossible to have that trend unless the 10 year breaks under 1%

42   anonymous   2014 Dec 31, 3:46am  

debyne says

San Diego, which is MUCH cheaper than the BA to live

not if you have kids, and wish to use public schools.

debyne says

CA state income taxes.

CA is home to roughly 1/3 of the entire country's welfare recipients.

43   anonymous   2014 Dec 31, 3:53am  

Logan Mohtashami says

California itself is a housing inflation nightmare.

My model shows that 82% of working population ( X out the Rich) Cash & 3X median income 189K are priced out housing

we are over that threshold but have around $2250 per month in daycare costs. very nightmarish indeed! silver lining is that we will bring 100k cash and full income capacity to the housing market once we reach K-5 school age. just need to be patient for now.

44   _   @   2014 Dec 31, 3:55am  

landtof says

$2250 per month in daycare costs

This is why I always talk about LTI as well liability to Income doesn't get discussed much

45   anonymous   2014 Dec 31, 9:57am  

landtof says

debyne says

San Diego, which is MUCH cheaper than the BA to live

not if you have kids, and wish to use public schools.

Not true. If you compare BA (not outskirts) and SD home prices in good school districts, BA prices are SIGNIFICANTLY higher. I've lived in both places with kids in schools, so I have first hand knowledge.

46   anonymous   2014 Dec 31, 11:22am  

debyne says

Not true. If you compare BA (not outskirts) and SD home prices in good school districts, BA prices are SIGNIFICANTLY higher. I've lived in both places with kids in schools, so I have first hand knowledge.

there are only 2 good districts in the entire county - and only one near the coast. please don't tell me that 3bd houses well over $1M are MUCH cheaper than anything.

47   MandyLifeboats   @   2014 Dec 31, 12:13pm  

Re: Vegas...I join those who somewhat regret not buying in 2012. I was ready, willing and able but my LL wanted $50K (30%) over the average estimate at the time (he said it was what he owed - not likely.)

Now I've spent an additional 20K in rent (still in same place, much of my time taken up caring for elderly family member who is quite ill) and feel stupid as prices for house around me have sailed well past what he wanted. (Lately, they're falling.)

A good bit of my hesitation was the neighborhood being marginal; now it is looking even more sketchy than it was at that time. I also thought that prices would to continue to go down and that we might be able to buy in a better area :-p

48   anonymous   2015 Jan 2, 1:28pm  

landtof says

debyne says

Not true. If you compare BA (not outskirts) and SD home prices in good school districts, BA prices are SIGNIFICANTLY higher. I've lived in both places with kids in schools, so I have first hand knowledge.

there are only 2 good districts in the entire county - and only one near the coast. please don't tell me that 3bd houses well over $1M are MUCH cheaper than anything.

Which two? If you compare SD's Poway school district and Cupertino's school disctrict, housing prices within each are not even on the same planet.

49   anonymous   2015 Jan 4, 9:48am  

that's like saying Foothill Ranch in OC is cheaper than Cupertino, so OC is MUCH cheaper to live than the SFBA. it's simply not true. try Irvine and Newport Beach to compare apples with apples.

if you go west of Poway Unified, you will find that RSF, Collins Ranch, Fairbanks Ranch, Carmel Valley, Del Mar, and Solana Beach are very comparable to SFBA house prices. and i forgot about Coronado, that ain't cheap either.

it does depend on geography and schools. Poway Unified is certainly one option if you are OK with inland geography and weather, and there are even pockets within that can be pricey.

i have lived in SD for almost 9 years and have yet to become OK with living anywhere but the coast. have accepted that it will take over $1M to ever afford a house here - and that sounds a whole lot like the SFBA, no?

« First        Comments 20 - 49 of 49        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste