patrick.net

richwicks says

1948 with UN Resolution 181, and then this immediately led to civil war, Count Folke Bernadotte went to try to negotiate a peace, and he was murdered by Lehi. Berandotte was chosen in part for his work with the Red Cross. This led to UN Resolution 194 that called for repatriation of the Palestinians, and it was the first UN resolution that Israel violated.

No Arab state recognized UN Res 181. The PA only accepted it in 1988 when their sponsor the USSR dropped away and the world was changing. The British withdrew from their Mandate and declared they wouldn't enforce the UN mandate, and 5 Arab Nations invaded and annexed what they could including parts not given to Arabs under 181.

The original PLO founding documents recognize the West Bank as part of Jordan, which illegally annexed it without UN authorization when the British Withdrew. Jordan did NOT create another Arab Mandate, but annexed it. That means the PLO thought that...

BUT, it's all about who can hold it. More settlements, puppet governments that allow sale of land to Israelis, etc.

As for Folke Bernadotte, he was assassinated by Lehi extremists. One of the first acts of Israel after winning Independence was to charge the assassins, who were sentenced to prison with Irgun and Haganah generals testifying that their assassinations and attacks hindered the Cause. They were sentenced to years in prison but then a general amnesty for all political militants was passed. Their party got 1.2% of the vote and that was the end of that.

The best thing about the Internet bypassing the past is harder and harder.

The usual suspects are whinging about Gaza being bombed, but the images of the dead Dancers, kidnapped people, and the house-to-house slaughter is too fresh for people to buy the usual Pallywood Hamasbara.

"b-b-but, a buncha settlers yelled and screamed on the Temple Mount after months of harassment by Arabs back in the summer. Nobody died. That justified gunning down 1000 civilians!"

Nobody gives a fuck, no matter how much Mehta on PMSNBC or George Takei or Labourtards whinge.

Just 7 months ago:

March 14, 2023
The Palestinian armed group Hamas said on Tuesday that it sent a high-level delegation to Russia and held talks with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.
In an interview published on Hamas’ website, Saleh al-Arouri, deputy head of Hamas’ political bureau, said party leaders visited Russia and met Lavrov and that the visit was a reflection of Hamas’ weight among major global powers.
"The leadership of the movement visited Moscow and met Sergey Lavrov. It was an important visit that highlights the role of the movement with many global actors," Arouri said. He added that there might be another international Hamas trip "in the coming weeks." Arouri did not specify when the visit to Moscow took place, saying only that it happened "recently."
Commenting on the increasing Israeli attacks against Palestinians ahead of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, Arouri said the movement’s “patience is running out.”
Israeli-Palestinian tension has been rising in the West Bank as Israeli raids have intensified, leading to US warnings about the security situation. Israel has accused several West Bank groups including the Lion’s Den of being backed and funded by Hamas.
Meanwhile, Russian-Hamas relations have steadily grown. Russia has sought to increase its role in the Palestinian reconciliation dossier, with some Palestinians hoping it will break the US monopoly over the file that has been stalled for more than a decade.
Hamas officials have made several visits to the Russian capital, most recently in September of last year.
Moscow’s public support for Hamas also comes as its relations with Israel soured following its invasion of Ukraine last year. Israel has maintained a cautious stance in the war, but Israeli Foreign Minister Eli Cohen’s February visit to Kyiv marked a small shift as Israel grows more concerned about Moscow-Tehran military cooperation and the use of Iranian drones in Ukraine.

Read more: https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2023/03/hamas-says-leadership-visited-russia-met-sergey-lavrov#ixzz8FiFuKrIL

So?

AmericanKulak says

No Arab state recognized UN Res 181.

Why should they? The UN's mandate is for self determination, which means democratic vote. Palestinians (or ARABS if you prefer, who cares), were entirely excluded from any decision making process on the partition of Palestine. 181 is invalid. If it's valid, so it 194. In reality, there are no rules. It's all bullshit to give a veneer of legitimacy - there is no legitimacy at all.

AmericanKulak says

The British withdrew from their Mandate and declared they wouldn't enforce the UN mandate

Of course not. Atlee said openly that it would lead to a civil war, so they abstained from voting on 181 at all, and when it passed, well golly, civil war!!

This whole bullshit is the fault of the British in my opinion. They promised both the Zionists and the Palestinians they would become an independent nation. They lied to both.

AmericanKulak says

BUT, it's all about who can hold it. More settlements, puppet governments that allow sale of land to Israelis, etc.

Yep, it's just might makes right. There's no rules or legitimacy or agreements. Every agreement ever in "international law" is contradicted, and all we hear about are the "rules" that support the side of our government which is closely aligned with the Israeli government. As soon as somebody starts blathering on about the Balfour Declaration, I tell people to read it, and then also point out what right did the British have to make this promise?

Nobody reads it. The Balfour Declaration reads:

His Majesty's Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country.

Who cares? Israel only negotiates if force is used against them, there's no diplomatic solution, and the US will shit money into Israel until the US is fucking dead.

It's so pointless. It's Europe's last colony and the conflict is going to last forever. The US just loves to fucking shit out money everywhere, tons of opportunity for kickbacks with that, Europe doesn't really give a crap either way, Arab states don't care...

Absolutely. Palestinians only accept overwhelming force. Even after the UN forced Israel to accept the 67 Cease Fire on the outskirts of Damascus and while they were physically detonating by hand the 100s of SA-2s the Soviet Advisors set up on the WEST side of the Suez Canal, the Arabs went back a few weeks later and said No to any permanent peace.

Only giving this women a real reason to cry will fix this.

AmericanKulak says

This isn't true.

Find any reporting on MSNBC that favors the Palestinians. Here:

https://www.youtube.com/@msnbc

Find ONE. The idea that the US media defends the Palestinian side EVER, it never happens. This was the first issue to wake me up that MAYBE US "news" media is just propaganda, and that was 35 years ago.

The idea that the US "news" favors the Palestine side is delusional. Did you hear about this?

https://www.theinteldrop.org/2023/07/14/200palestinians-killed-by-israel-since-beginning-of-2023-data-center/

That was printed on July 14, 2023. Why didn't CNN report on it, or MSNBC, or CBS, or Fox, or anybody? And who the fuck knows if it's true anyhow? It's just a stream of endless lies, there is no attempt at truthful informative data.

I can tell you without even looking at any of the "news" in the US what the narrative already is, or will be. "Gaza attacked Israel for NO REASON AT ALL, they just hate Jews". Settlers put bullets in Palestinian's heads all the time, for fun. IDF does too. Who gives a shit?

richwicks says

Israel is actually in violation of the Geneva Conventions by occupying land "illegally", but really who cares?

Zionism was in effect for at least a hundred years before UN Resolution 181 was passed.

World War 2 just dramatically increased its rate as well as the exodus out of the Soviet Bloc countries.

Now you have two significantly different populations who hate each other at least the same as they did 100 years ago.

I agree it does not help that Israel seized land in the West Bank and have put settlements on it . Those settlements likely are heavily guarded by Israeli orthodox fundamentalists (versus the more secular kibbutz's near Gaza).

Just read that Israel is now relaxing its stringent gun control laws.

If I was in those kibbutz near Gaza, I would want to be my own police and security. They really underestimated their own security.

Can't rely on 911.

.

ad says

Just read that Israel is now relaxing its stringent gun control laws.

I have heard a good point made, the people in locations where Israelis were murdered, they probably aren't coming back.

There's also been massive protests against the Israeli government going on for a long time in Israel. IF Israelis collectively think that the Israeli government invited this attack, and purposely let it happen, we may have a change in Israeli government policy.

Gaza really does put up with a lot of shit and humiliations. 100's of Palestinians are killed every year, IDF recorded putting a bullet in a kid's head, laughing about it and posting it to social media, settlers NEVER get prosecuted for killing Palestinians, they turn the water and electricity on and off to Gaza all the time, Israel has destroyed their infrastructure, Palestinians weren't given the "safe and effective life saving vaccine" but that was more about restrictions - Israel had some of the harshest restrictions on vaccine mandates to do stuff and this was a way to exclude Palestinians, there's roads in the West Bank which are for the exclusive use of Jewish settlers - there's a bunch of things like this, and Americans have no clue and when I talk about them, they don't believe it.

There's a lot of enmity between the two groups, and the Israeli government continually exacerbates it. This is an easy way to keep Likud in power. Israel isn't seriously threatened by the Palestinians and so long as this conflict continues, Israel gets plenty of "aid" money.

richwicks says

I have heard a good point made, the people and locations where Israelis were murdered, they probably aren't coming back.

That is what the Hamas terrorists want. Their terrorism had an effect.

If I was those kibbutz, I would make them like a fortress and also arm each resident above the age of 14. I would harden them like those settlements on the West Bank.

Yeah we give about the same as in the 1980's, about $3.8 billion annually.

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/total-u-s-foreign-aid-to-israel-1949-present

.

Yep, Israels GDP is about $488 billion. Don't get me wrong, they ain't gonna say no to free money, but it ain;t gonna make or break 'em.

ad says

That is what the Hamas terrorists want.

Yeah, I know. This is why Israel tries to make life hell for Palestinians as well - they want to get them to leave.

ad says

Yeah we give about the same as in the 1980's, about $3.8 billion annually.

You missed the "current U.S. dollars in millions".

That is NOT measured by CPI. If it was, social security would be "the same" today as it was in 1980.

Misc says

Yep, Israels GDP is about $488 billion. Don't get me wrong, they ain't gonna say no to free money, but it ain;t gonna make or break 'em.

The Israeli government budget is approx $100B/year.

So $3-4B loss would mean a some small mix of spending cuts or tax increases, about 3-4% of the budget, but far from the killing blow that detractors think it will be. Also it was around for 20 years before any substantial US Gov Aid, which started after 1967 to balance out the Soviets massive technical, advisory, and material (1000s of SAMs, Tanks, and MiGs) to Egypt and Syria.

And later, NORK and Soviet piloted missions into Israel - to their chagrin, as they had been razzing the Egyptian pilots yet got their asses beat just as bad.

LOL.

"If only Richard Nixon hadn't held us Pakistanis back in 1971, we Mighty Pakistanis would have been in Delhi in a day!" levels of delusion.

Also fun fact: If you think the Sufis are the peaceful, mystical version of Islam, guess what many Chechens practice?

AmericanKulak says

So $3-4B loss would mean a some small mix of spending cuts or tax increases, about 3-4% of the budget, but far from the killing blow that detractors think it will be.

The problem of aid isn't that Israel needs it, it's placing blood on the hands of Americans. If Israel doesn't need it, fine, let's get rid of it.

AID isn't aid. It's bribes. The US gives money to Israel, and then Israel gives money to US politicians and think tanks, and advocacy groups like AIPAC and god knows what - social media companies, the FIB, who knows?

Why do you think politicians are so eager to continue the Ukraine war? We all know why. Our politicians OPENLY engage in taking bribes. Congress won't even allow the money to be tracked, why do you think that is?

Why do people think Israel is any different? Nobody is different.

AmericanKulak says

"If only Richard Nixon hadn't held us Pakistanis back in 1971, we Mighty Pakistanis would have been in Delhi in a day!" levels of delusion.

Golda Mier actually said that if Israel were to fall, they'd use the "Samson Option" in 1973:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samson_Option#Deterrence_doctrine


There's a quite a bit of evidence that Israel was about to fall actually. Both the US and the USSR drew back, and so did the Arab states because many of them were under the thumb of the USSR.

I guess having this endless bloodshed is better than having a nuclear wasteland there. I bet if it were used, we'd have a REAL clash of civilizations. Too many nuts attach religious significance to the region.

Here is Samerra Khan, buddy buddy with noted Propagandist SyrianGirl.



Now they're fantasizing about Chechen Sufis coming to save Palestine.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGIKctW0oK4

"Harden your Heart, Oh Putin"
"We say to China: Invade Taiwan!"
"We will marry Ukrainian Women!"

Note to skeptics: I got this from a thread full of Arab named commenters, and none contested the translation and were cheering the sentiment.

AmericanKulak says

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGIKctW0oK4

"Harden your Heart, Oh Putin"

Note to skeptics: I got this from a thread full of Arabs, and none contested the translation and were cheering the sentiment.

Why is the quality of the video so low? All the people there seem basically white to me. Who are they? What language is it in? Arabic? Where was the video taken?

MEMRI claiming to be non-partisan was hilarious though. It's run by Yigal Carmen. I'm not going to bother to give you the wikipedia entry.

It's a PR war, where each side seeks to claim to be the bigger victim, and provokes or allows atrocities for that reason.

It is not solvable. The only certain thing is that saying "Look at these atrocities and not those" is what both sides want.

https://twitter.com/stillgray/status/1711771618757030320

AmericanKulak says

Also fun fact: If you think the Sufis are the peaceful, mystical version of Islam, guess what many Chechens practice?

Putin is going to unleash his Muslim jihadis to kill the Nazis in Israel and save Christianity or something.

PS. They were waffling on providing help to Ukraine all this time because their feeble-minded PMs (first Bennet and Netanyahu) were trying to "look into Pukin's eyes and see his soul there" and tiptoeing around to "not provoke the Soviets". How did it work for them? That beta shit haven't worked for anyone since fucking elem school, but yet grown man are still hoping "this time it's different".

Patrick says

It's a PR war, where each side seeks to claim to be the bigger victim, and provokes or allows atrocities for that reason.

It is not solvable. The only certain thing is that saying "Look at these atrocities and not those" is what both sides want.

Makes sense to me. I read, just today, that the Palestinian are not only landlocked but all borders are closed to an extent they cannot even leave. I assume that's why so many are calling Palestine an open air prison. Even if they attempt to leave by sea, the Israelis shoot to kill past 3 miles (maybe it's more. maybe less). This sounds really bad. It's no different than provoking someone to attack you imo. Now, was Palestian's land stolen or not?

Why does it seem like America has some kind of debt we owe to Israel? I would think it's the opposite.

Patrick says

It is not solvable. The only certain thing is that saying "Look at these atrocities and not those" is what both sides want.

Glenn Greenwald made a good point in his last night's coverage. BSD (Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions) are literally illegal in many of the states in the US, and any criticism of Israel is called "antisemitism" - so if there can be no peaceful protests to change this situation, what is left for the Palestinians to do?

We just saw it a few days ago.

Israel is only 10 million people, we put up with an AWFUL lot of bullshit from that tiny minority.

AmericanKulak says

As for Folke Bernadotte, he was assassinated by Lehi extremists. One of the first acts of Israel after winning Independence was to charge the assassins, who were sentenced to prison with Irgun and Haganah generals testifying that their assassinations and attacks hindered the Cause. They were sentenced to years in prison but then a general amnesty for all political militants was passed. Their party got 1.2% of the vote and that was the end of that.

Oh bullshit. Yitzhak Shamir was one of the triumvirate that ordered the murder of Bernadotte. He was part of Lehi at the time, and the 7th prime minster of Israel.

Once a terrorist, always a terrorist, that's what Israel claims - when it's convenient to them. He was a terrorist.

AmericanKulak says

The best thing about the Internet bypassing the past is harder and harder.

The usual suspects are whinging about Gaza being bombed, but the images of the dead Dancers, kidnapped people, and the house-to-house slaughter is too fresh for people to buy the usual Pallywood Hamasbara.

"b-b-but, a buncha settlers yelled and screamed on the Temple Mount after months of harassment by Arabs back in the summer. Nobody died. That justified gunning down 1000 civilians!"

Nobody gives a fuck, no matter how much Mehta on PMSNBC or George Takei or Labourtards whinge.

You're correct, history is harder to erase, but this won't work in the favor of Israel in my opinion.

GNL says

Now, was Palestian's land stolen or not?

the last couple hundred of years it was slowly overtaken and became israel

adolph hitler and the nazi party at one time were major zionists based on his involvement with the haavara agreement

soviet union expelled a lot of jewish people to israel

so the Soviet bloc and Nazi's are attributed to a lot of why Israel exists based on migration patterns to the land where the nation of Israel exists..

so the land once known as kingdoms of judah and israel were the new home to jewish people arriving over the last 100 to 200 years ...they had immigration "somewhat like" the USA has had immigration..

gaza was outside of the kingdoms of judah and israel

i wonder how many of the present day Palestinians can trace their ancestors to being "israeli or jewish and who ' converted ' to islam "

the Mizrahi/Sephardi jews look somewhat Palestinian

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliyah

ad says

gaza was outside of the kingdoms of judah and israel

Egypt won't take it back. It was offered in the Sinai Accords and they were like, yeah, nooo!

GNL says

Makes sense to me. I read, just today, that the Palestinian are not only landlocked but all borders are closed to an extent they cannot even leave. I assume that's why so many are calling Palestine an open air prison. Even if they attempt to leave by sea, the Israelis shoot to kill past 3 miles (maybe it's more. maybe less). This sounds really bad. It's no different than provoking someone to attack you imo. Now, was Palestian's land stolen or not?

There's a border with Egypt, too.

The Egyptians will tell you why they hate to open it.

Because when they do, a few weeks later many terrorists start going boom boom on tourists and resorts in Egypt.

richwicks says

Oh bullshit. Yitzhak Shamir was one of the triumvirate that ordered the murder of Bernadotte. He was part of Lehi at the time, and the 7th prime minster of Israel.

Once a terrorist, always a terrorist, that's what Israel claims - when it's convenient to them. He was a terrorist.

Freedom Fighter.

Leila Khalid was a Terrorist. Very Chic in Leftoid Circles in the 70s and 80s but never reached Che levels of worship.

richwicks says

BSD (Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions) are literally illegal in many of the states in the US, and any criticism of Israel is called "antisemitism"

Nope. It's illegal for the Woke Administrators of State Schools, Departments, etc. to practice BDS. States have a right to forbid their employees from considering which countries they will boycott as Administrators.

Unelected Public Employees, like Presidents of Universities, are not elected officials that have the privilege of making public foreign policy for the state.

Half of them would buy everything from Venezuela if they could.

ad says

adolph hitler and the nazi party at one time were major zionists based on his involvement with the haavara agreement

That's an exaggeration. One Nazi Official was sent down to Israel to see if it was worth transferring the Jews there and had a commemorative token struck. The Nazis decided to collaborate with the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, a Bosniak Muslim imported by Turkey in the late 19th along with others to try to repopulate the deserted province.



He helped raise the SS Scimitar Brigade of Bosnian Muslims to fight in WW2.

Prior to being a "Palestinian", he wanted the British to recreate the Kaliphate of Damascus that would incorporate ALL the Levant, including Lebanon, Syria, the old Sanjaks of Akko, Jerusalem, Nablus, etc. into one Caliphate. Ottoman Empire did NOT have a province of Palestine, but a bunch of counties in the area (aforementioned Sanjaks), and the overarching Over Governor was from Damascus.

Only when it was clear France and Britain were going to create normal states and not a Muslim Empire did he get his knickers in a twist... to ensure South Syria (Jerusalem) would be part of Syria. But then UK and France would cross each other's Mandates, so then he decided there should be a Palestine.

It was his third and least favorite option; he wanted the All-Levant Caliphate with HQ in Damascus.

The Tamimis, including the famous terrorist who continues to hide in Jordan as well as actress Surely Temper, are Bosniaks who came no earlier than many Jews in the 19thC. But of course, call themselves native Palestinians.

TL;DR: It's complicated. Just let the Western friendly nation Kleanse 'Em All and not support a cuck out with peace and happiness for a change.

BTW, "Gaza was Carpet Bombed"

I wish.

Here's the area mostly bombed by Israel in the last night. Other than a few buildings here and there, Hamas Government was concentrated in the Commercial District of Rimal



You can check this for yourself in Google map.

Here's all the Malls in the open air prison camp



And finally, realize that Radicals, Reds, And Terrorists are trying to do this:


And reject their framing.

AmericanKulak says

The Nazis decided to collaborate with the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, a Bosniak Muslim imported by Turkey in the late 19th along with others to try to repopulate the deserted province.

Yep.

"As Grand Mufti and leader in the Arab Higher Committee, especially during the war period 1938-45, al-Husayni played a key role in violent opposition to Zionism and closely allied himself with the Nazi regime in Germany." (. ISBN 978-0-86356-460-4. pp.309,321 )

Plenty of tension and fighting between Muslims and Jews well before the start of World War 2 such as the 1929 Palestinian Riots

He was not a "Bosniak" , he was a Palestinian Arab: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amin_al-Husseini

"Bosniaks" are southern Slavs and are mostly Muslim. They would have been Christians if not from the Ottoman Empire conquest of that region around the 15th century.

Just like the Palestinians today like would have been Jews or Christians if there was no forced or coerced conversion to Islam ????

AmericanKulak says

Freedom Fighter.

Oh bullshit. Yitzhak Shamir was a German that invaded the area. He was an invader.

There is absolutely no question he was involved with the murder of Count Bernadotte. He was a typical terrorist fanatic.

AmericanKulak says

Nope. It's illegal for the Woke Administrators of State Schools, Departments, etc. to practice BDS. States have a right to forbid their employees from considering which countries they will boycott as Administrators.

No they don't!

If I didn't want to buy shit from Russia, or China, that's my right. God, how duplicitous are you?

If I have a problem with, say Georgia, I can boycott them as well. Bunch of left retards did that a few years ago. You think the STATE says I can't do this??

Stop having dual standards, and have consistent ones. It doesn't matter if people agree with your opinions, what matters if they are free to do what they want, even if you disagree with them. Tired of you fascist idiots. You exhibit dual standards, and I cannot believe you don't realize this. You have no principles.

I can accept I am wrong when a majority says I am, I can continue to disagree with that majority, however, I will never adopt dual standards - I believe you are fully aware of your hypocrisy, and have no shame in showing it thinking people are too dumb to pick it up. Absolute arrogance. That's disgusting of you. You're beneath me.