4
0

It feels like 2008…is the bubble about to burst on housing again?


 invite response                
2023 Aug 14, 3:15pm   21,651 views  160 comments

by Broadway_Sam   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

2023 is showing housing at 40% above 3% inflation rate in some areas and I am wondering if banks shadow inventory or lack of building causing this spike. Either way, a new group of fools are willing to pay 800k for a cottage is hilarious to me seeing how we debated this same on Patrick.net back in 2007-2010.

1. Will the bubble burst?
2. When will the bubble burst?
3. Will we ever see 300k homes again in Mexifornia?

Sam

« First        Comments 44 - 83 of 160       Last »     Search these comments

44   Patrick   2023 Aug 18, 3:08am  

Aside from monetary inflation to support the war, the biggest driver of inflation lately is the increase in the cost of energy, which Brandon is also responsible for.
45   GNL   2023 Aug 18, 4:14am  

How far/fast has inflation outpaced incomes? If it continues, it's just a matter of time before almost everyone goes bust.

And btw, how come 10s of millions haven't declared bankruptcy seeing that so many can't come up with $400 in an emergency. Monthly living expenses have gone up around $700/month.
46   HeadSet   2023 Aug 18, 6:29am  

GNL says

And btw, how come 10s of millions haven't declared bankruptcy seeing that so many can't come up with $400 in an emergency. Monthly living expenses have gone up around $700/month.

Can't afford the lawyer?
47   porkchopXpress   2023 Aug 18, 6:39am  

pudil says

To me it doesn’t feel like 2008 at all. Prices have gone up but so have rents and building costs.

I was on this site in the run up to 2008. Patrick had a very simple premise, rents and sale prices were out of wack. And he was right.

I don’t see that pattern in 2023. Prices are high but so are rents and so are prices to build new. If anything, we’re about to see a commercial real estate collapse, but I don’t think that will effect residential negatively.

+1000
48   RWSGFY   2023 Aug 18, 7:20am  

PeopleUnited says

Fine, just buy the raw meat. Sale prices used to dip as low as $2.48 a pound for hamburger. Now $5 a pound is a relatively good deal.

If you don’t see that your grocery bill has gone up in the past few months you probably are not paying attention.


Again, you are answering wrong question and again with feelz. If you insist on picking just one thing - meat - what was the increase of price of meat in %% from May to June, June to July, July to Aug? Did these %% increase, decrease, go up then down, go down then up and by how much?

PS. My local Lucky constantly has sales on tri-tip at $3.97 pp. Does it prove anything? Of course not.
49   KgK one   2023 Aug 18, 7:23am  

There is no inventory. People with houses at 3% mortgage won't sell. Now with higher rents, they are making killing. Also low unemployment, so people can pay.

People without houses will suffer.
With higher rates market should crash but it isn't.
50   stereotomy   2023 Aug 18, 9:34am  

PeopleUnited says

Fine, just buy the raw meat. Sale prices used to dip as low as $2.48 a pound for hamburger. Now $5 a pound is a relatively good deal.

If you don’t see that your grocery bill has gone up in the past few months you probably are not paying attention.

I've been buying grass fed ground beef from local farmers for 15 years. When we started, it was $7.50/lb. Now it's $9.60/lb. What I take away from this is that real (non-industrial) food costs more, but because of the way it's sustainably nourished and grown, as well as the fact that local farmers are not monopolies and can't arbitrarily raise prices without losing a big part of their clientele, the pricing mechanism is less chaotic.
51   GNL   2023 Aug 18, 9:52am  

stereotomy says

I've been buying grass fed ground beef from local farmers for 15 years. When we started, it was $7.50/lb. Now it's $9.60/lb.

I'd you do it right, that's not really that expensive. Americans eat a lot of meat.
52   PeopleUnited   2023 Aug 20, 11:13am  

RWSGFY says

PeopleUnited says


Fine, just buy the raw meat. Sale prices used to dip as low as $2.48 a pound for hamburger. Now $5 a pound is a relatively good deal.

If you don’t see that your grocery bill has gone up in the past few months you probably are not paying attention.


Again, you are answering wrong question and again with feelz. If you insist on picking just one thing - meat - what was the increase of price of meat in %% from May to June, June to July, July to Aug? Did these %% increase, decrease, go up then down, go down then up and by how much?

PS. My local Lucky constantly has sales on tri-tip at $3.97 pp. Does it prove anything? Of course not.


Look, it’s not feelz it’s fact. And its not just meat. Mayonnaise, lettuce, baked goods, corn chips. They are all up. Bury your head in the zelenskis ass if you must, but those of us paying attention to the aggregate grocery bill and energy costs see that prices are rising as a whole. This can be calculated on a monthly basis using more data points (not feelz, facts).
53   Eric Holder   2023 Aug 21, 11:39am  

PeopleUnited says

Look, it’s not feelz it’s fact. And its not just meat. Mayonnaise, lettuce, baked goods, corn chips. They are all up. Bury your head in the zelenskis ass


Dude, this is so idiotic, it hurts. You didn't understand the question and when called out your last straw is zelensky's ass? Stay classy.
54   RayAmerica   2023 Aug 22, 1:10pm  

US Existing Home Sales Weakest July Since 2010

Existing home sales were expected to decline very modestly in July (-0.2% MoM) - after June's drop (the biggest since Nov '22). However, existing home sales tumbled more than expected (down 2.2% MoM), leaving sales down 16.6% YoY...

https://www.zerohedge.com/personal-finance/us-existing-home-sales-weakest-july-2010
55   PeopleUnited   2023 Aug 27, 7:27pm  

The question was about the “rate of inflation”.

Which can only be measured comparing one period of time to another across a broad range of consumer prices.

https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/consumer-prices-up-3-2-percent-from-july-2022-to-july-2023.htm

But the data is clear. Prices continue to rise.
56   AD   2023 Aug 27, 8:59pm  

PeopleUnited says


https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/consumer-prices-up-3-2-percent-from-july-2022-to-july-2023.htm

But the data is clear. Prices continue to rise.


We are going to have to see by end of 2025 if annual inflation has steadied at no more than 3%. There was so much disruption and volatility with fiscal and monetary actions that it was going to cause this much of an economic stir from 2021 to 2025.

Biden should never have spent as much stimulus money ($2.4 trillion, compared to Trump's $2.3 trillion) and the Fed should have started to raised rates by late 2021. The economy was not at risk when Birdbrain Biden took over, so there was no reason for Birdbrain to spend that much.

The question is if median income and wage increases are keeping up with inflation. For my household, we invest some of our money in stocks as a way to keep up with inflation.

.

.
57   AD   2023 Aug 27, 9:09pm  

Big_Johnson says

People without houses will suffer.
With higher rates market should crash but it isn't.


Yes, as there is no pressure to sell at a +20% decrease in the value or sales price of the house when peak prices were realized around early 2022.

There is still not enough supply to create a war between sellers, unlike the glut back in 2008-2011.

Look at the housing starts chart and you'll see why as there was not enough homes built after housing starts bottomed.

.
58   GNL   2023 Aug 27, 9:33pm  

ad says

The question is if median income and wage increases are keeping up with inflation.

Are you seriously wondering if wages are keeping up with inflation?
59   Eman   2023 Aug 27, 9:45pm  

GNL says

ad says


The question is if median income and wage increases are keeping up with inflation.

Are you seriously wondering if wages are keeping up with inflation?

No need to wonder. The answer is NO for the majority. Yes for the lucky few.
60   AD   2023 Aug 27, 9:59pm  

GNL says

Are you seriously wondering if wages are keeping up with inflation?


Si, senor.

.
61   AD   2023 Aug 27, 11:09pm  

.

Read this: https://www.zerohedge.com/personal-finance/airbnb-bubble-popping-will-pop-housing-bubble

I am glad to see a free article on Zero Hedge about such an important housing topic.

They cover the housing data such as number of housing units versus the population size.

.
62   AD   2023 Aug 27, 11:29pm  

.

Interesting as this article presents housing as an ownership crisis due to hoarding by the top 10% and corporations :

https://www.oftwominds.com/blogaug23/hoarding-housing8-23.html

.
63   Misc   2023 Aug 28, 12:30am  

ad says

.

Interesting as this article presents housing as an ownership crisis due to hoarding by the top 10% and corporations :

https://www.oftwominds.com/blogaug23/hoarding-housing8-23.html

.


It's nonsense. We have a higher percentage of homeownership today than at any time in the past. The average Joe is doing quite well.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/639685/us-home-ownership-rate-by-race/
https://ncrc.org/60-black-homeownership-a-radical-goal-for-black-wealth-development/
64   GNL   2023 Aug 28, 5:36am  

Eman says

GNL says


ad says



The question is if median income and wage increases are keeping up with inflation.

Are you seriously wondering if wages are keeping up with inflation?


No need to wonder. The answer is NO for the majority. Yes for the lucky few.

This is what will naturally happen in our system of fiat and debt fueled economy.
65   AD   2023 Aug 28, 10:22am  

Misc says

It's nonsense.


Misc and also Biggie J (Big Johnson): yes, overall home ownership is better than 1995 (the start of the effects of globalization and free trade)

reference: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NHWAHORUSQ156N

That is if the home ownership data is accurate.

For example, is the home ownership data based on total population including those who are not legal citizens ?

.
66   Onvacation   2023 Aug 28, 10:28am  

Big_Johnson says

$5 for a sandwich? An avocado toast is $15.
As a millennial I don’t remember getting a good sandwich for $5. Was that 30years ago?

Before the COVID-19 scam our local bagel shop sold a chicken breast sandwich for less than $5. They now want almost $10.
67   Onvacation   2023 Aug 28, 10:30am  

RWSGFY says

Eh, this is feelz, not data.

Are you saying prices aren't going up? Or just looking for a peer reviewed study that verifies it?
68   AD   2023 Aug 28, 10:30am  

GNL says


This is what will naturally happen in our system of fiat and debt fueled economy.


Yep, designed to help the biggest debtor or borrower, the US federal government.

$1 trillion borrowed in 2023 is only worth at most 97% of $1 trillion in 2024.

Inflate out of a debt crisis by instilling inflation (or hidden tax) on those who are most adversely impacted by inflation.

.
69   AD   2023 Aug 28, 10:35am  

Onvacation says


Before the COVID-19 scam our local bagel shop sold a chicken breast sandwich for less than $5. They now want almost $10.


I'm looking at chicken prices such as at the Walmart in the Florida panhandle and it was 99 cents per pound for chicken legs.

Now it is around $1.20 a pound, which is same price as mid 2022.

So figure for white meat for chicken , the price per pound has increased about 30% since early 2020.

All the other cost increases is attributable to the wage increases, electric utility cost increase, etc.

.
71   RWSGFY   2023 Sep 10, 5:49pm  

Patrick says






We didn't? Securized subprime mortgages is still a thing?
72   Robber Baron Elite Scum   2023 Sep 10, 6:13pm  

Best way to track inflation is the price of gold bullion.
73   Robber Baron Elite Scum   2023 Sep 10, 6:14pm  

Also real estate 🏡
74   AD   2023 Sep 10, 9:56pm  

Robber Baron Elite Scum says

Best way to track inflation


Yeah, also silver. Look at iShares Silver Trust

It was $14 in April 2006. It is now around $21. So it appreciated about 2.5% annually since April 2006. Inflation was about 2.5% to 3% annually since 2006.

.
75   EBGuy   2023 Sep 10, 11:36pm  

RWSGFY says

We didn't? Securized subprime mortgages is still a thing?

MUH subprime...
https://news.uga.edu/new-perspective-on-the-housing-crash/
Conklin’s team looked county by county at the percentage of loans issued to borrowers with credit scores under 660 across the U.S. between 2000 and 2006.
“We looked at the areas where house prices grew and the areas where the number of subprime mortgages grew,” Conklin said. “They’re not the same places at all. If subprime lending was the driver of the housing boom, well then you would think that where house prices rose, you would have seen the largest growth in subprime lending and that’s just not what we found.”
Subprime borrowers were more likely to take out loans to buy entry-level or moderately priced houses in the overheated market, he said.
“And the places where we saw prices rising quickly, that’s where we saw prime borrowers were a larger part of the market,” Conklin said. “[Well-qualified] borrowers were probably able to bid higher than people we would consider marginal borrowers.
“The marginal buyers were priced out of the market; they didn’t get a chance to help house prices blow up because the borrowers with better credit scores and better incomes could bid the highest prices.”
76   EBGuy   2023 Sep 10, 11:53pm  

Loan Originations and Defaults in the Mortgage Crisis: The Role of the Middle Class
Contrary to popular belief, which focuses on subprime and poor borrowers, we show that mortgage originations increased for borrowers across all income levels and FICO scores. The relation between mortgage growth and income growth at the individual level remained positive throughout the pre-2007 period. Finally, middle-income, high-income, and prime borrowers all sharply increased their share of delinquencies in the crisis. These results are consistent with a demand-side view, where homebuyers and lenders bought into increasing house values and borrowers defaulted after prices dropped.
77   Misc   2023 Sep 11, 12:41am  

Much had to do with adjustable rate mortgages. Once the Fed started raising rates, mortgage originators started coming out with negative amortization loans. When the rates went up further they came out with teaser rate loans that would adjust to current interest rates after a fixed period of time (the amount of time before the reset continuously decreased). The underwriters would qualify buyers for the teaser rate payment, even though the payment would double or triple in 3 months.

Flippers went all in.
78   WookieMan   2023 Sep 11, 3:11am  

richwicks says

Rubicon says


As a millennial I don’t remember getting a good sandwich for $5. Was that 30years ago?


20 years ago, you could get a decent grinder (sub, hoagie) for $5.

I remember Arby's 5 for $5 beef and cheese. You don't have to like the food, but for fast food that was a pretty good deal, but I think that was late 90's and phased out early 2000's. I'm a hard pass on Subway. It's just so bland for a sub. Jimmy Johns, Jersey Mikes and Firehouse are the chains around me that I'd pick over Subway 100% of the time. My old local butcher Josef's in Geneva hands down wins the Italian sub game. Best I've ever had or will have I think. Expensive though. Hell, I'll be in that area today. Might make that my dinner.
79   HeadSet   2023 Sep 11, 9:26am  

WookieMan says

Jimmy Johns, Jersey Mikes and Firehouse are the chains around me that I'd pick over Subway 100% of the time.

Wow, must be regional. I have found the Subways in Omaha and Virginia to be quite good. Jersey Mikes around here taste like Oscar Meyer on plain white bread. Jimmy Johns has horrible bread and bland meats, and Firehouse puts honey ham on an Italian sub.
80   AmericanKulak   2023 Sep 11, 9:34am  

Subway has meat that is a day from getting slimy and being tossed. It looks like shit, feels like shit, and has no taste.

When they first came out, Subway was amazing. Now it's like shitty old coldcuts you have to eat before the go bad tomorrow.

This began over a decade ago, and it's true up and down the East Coast. Subway was the first big franchise to really be nasty.

Except Jack Shit in the Box, they tried to open on the East Coast, but apparently their meats were defrosting en route, and a 600 people got food poisoning in the first month and at least one 4 died. Their store didn't last a few months in the NYC suburbs because their E.Coli scandal happened within days of them opening the first locations.

Edit: 4 kids died and of a syndrome related to E. Coli from Jack in the Box. And 600 sick . WOW!
81   Eric Holder   2023 Sep 11, 2:05pm  

EBGuy says

If subprime lending was the driver of the housing boom, well then you would think that where house prices rose, you would have seen the largest growth in subprime lending


I'm not sure that assumption is valid.
82   Tenpoundbass   2023 Sep 11, 3:05pm  

A Suckers Famous Last Words...
"This time is Different!"
83   EBGuy   2023 Sep 11, 3:26pm  

Misc says

Much had to do with adjustable rate mortgages.

Will be interesting to see if this a factor given the extreme rate rise we just saw. Folks we know had to go this route due to self employment. They refinanced their California home to buy their Covid retreat. This, along with the $500k tax free on capital gains from a home sale, may push them to sell.

« First        Comments 44 - 83 of 160       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions   gaiste