2
0

H1B Thread


               
2025 Aug 6, 5:14pm   6,087 views  515 comments

by Patrick   follow (60)  

This thread will be the central point for H1B discussion. The existing H1B threads were all merged into this one.

« First        Comments 306 - 345 of 515       Last »     Search these comments

306   Al_Sharpton_for_President   2020 Apr 21, 3:39am  

Trump says he’ll sign executive order to ‘temporarily suspend immigration’ because of coronavirus

President Trump said Monday night he plans to “temporarily suspend immigration” because of the coronavirus pandemic.

Trump announced his plan to sign an executive order in a 10:06 p.m. tweet.

“In light of the attack from the Invisible Enemy, as well as the need to protect the jobs of our GREAT American Citizens, I will be signing an Executive Order to temporarily suspend immigration into the United States!” he tweeted.

It’s unclear what effect the order will have on the spread of the deadly disease. The U.S. has already seen nearly 750,000 cases of coronavirus, and more than 39,000 deaths -- more than any other nation.

The order marks an extraordinary and unexpected use of executive power amid the coronavirus pandemic, considering his earlier optimism about some states being ready to reopen their virus-shuttered businesses.

An immigration suspension would serve as an extension on the travel restrictions the Trump administration has already imposed on most of Europe, China, Canada, Mexico, Iran and South Korea.

Trump has spent much of his presidency pushing to restrict immigration into the U.S.

The president has taken credit for his restrictions on travel to the U.S. from China and hard-hit European countries, arguing it contributed to slowing the spread of the virus in the U.S.

But he has yet to extend those restrictions to other nations now experiencing virus outbreaks.Due to the pandemic, almost all visa processing by the State Department, including immigrant visas, has been suspended for weeks.

More than 750,000 Americans have come down with COVID-19 and more than 42,000 have died.

Trump’s late-night order drew immediate fire from Rep. Joaquin Castro (D-Texas), who accused the president of trying to create a divisive distraction.

“This action is not only an attempt to divert attention away from Trump’s failure to stop the spread of the coronavirus and save lives, but an authoritarian-like move to take advantage of a crisis and advance his anti-immigrant agenda,” the congressman tweeted. “We must come together to reject his division.”

https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/ny-trump-suspend-immigration-20200421-4nmzcee2azg5tds4mox3q3znty-story.html

307   RWSGFY   2025 Jan 15, 7:32am  

DOGEWontAmountToShit says






Elon has shut his face about the subject too.
308   gabbar   2025 Jan 15, 10:05am  

DOGEWontAmountToShit says






If President Trump + DOGE take action to make modify H-1B, it will be similar to modifying potential/future slavery of American labor force. Let's see if people's interests prevail over corporate interests...
309   preed   2025 Jan 20, 12:54pm  

So many visa programs to abolish, including TN:


310   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Jan 21, 4:27pm  

Story from the internet:



All of this H-1B and India talk reminds me of an old friend of mine from college.
Born in Mumbai, his father was a senior member in the chemical engineering department at Exxon. We met in 2nd level chemistry class in college. Kid had good grades and got into some of the best CE schools in the country but went to my school due to its infamy of being a party school.

He always said he wanted to go to American schools to “date white women and be a chemical engineer” (he was only successful at one of these).

He didn’t have great grades, he would chegg his way through homework and limp his way through exams. Study sessions would quickly get derailed away from academics because he had no inclination to pay attention. Never took notes in class, never went to study hours, spent more time drinking than anything else.
A true example of the “Elite Human Capital” we hear about. Keep in mind his parents were paying upwards of 30k a semester as he was an international student.

After his first sophomore semester his dad got him an internship at Exxonmobil. Anyone who has been to college knows how rare or exceptional it is to land an internship at any billion dollar corporation after merely 3 semesters of university.

My friends and I keep in touch, I even went down to Huston a few times to go visit him. He was working on a project in their EMRD program. He would eventually tell me that his project for the EMRD department was a complete throw away to appease climate activism pressure and really wasn’t going anywhere. While there he was making nearly 70k a year as an intern. He lived with his parents, pocketing as much of the money as possible. Much of it was being sent back to the rest of their family back in Mumbai.

Eventually COVID hits and Exxon is tanking, gas prices are lower than could ever be imagined and the company is bleeding cash. Fellow interns and even full time employees he was working with were being laid off left and right, but not him. Protected by his co-ethnics and father, department after department started to be culled and began to be filled with people that looked like him. The middle management overseeing the cuts were obviously prioritizing Indians. He told me all of this as if it was a good thing.

Eventually he has to work completely remote so he moves back to the college town I was living at and moves in with my friends and I. He would tape an oscillating fan to his mouse and go out with us during the day. While we were studying he would be playing video games, smoking weed, and drinking.

When time on his internship ran out he was offered another intern position at Exxon (who knew). But instead of taking it, or going back to school, he applied to Phillips 66 for a chemical engineering internship. There using his fathers connection they of course made him an offer which paid more than what Exxon was paying him.

He then used that offer from Phillips to tell Exxon that if they didn’t match the pay, then he would quit and go work for Phillips. They capitulated and gave him the raise, as they COULDN’T say no considering the moment they did his father would step in and force them to hire him on the terms of his counter offer.

HE DID ALL OF THIS, not out of some machiavellian ambition to ascend the corporate ladder, but at the behest and guidance of his father. Any person that has lived near these people, watched them work, and has seen their behavior has heard a story like this.

These people aren’t “Elite Human Capital” like Elon, or Vivek, or Hanania would have you believe. They are pirates, raping and looting your homeland and sending away to theirs.

He was a good friend, and at times I admired the things he would do. But it is time for it to end. It is time for them to go home.
311   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Jan 23, 7:31pm  

Why are outsourcing firms allowed at all? They have to work direct for the company. MS has to hire them direct from Mumbai, without "Cognizent" in the way.

The contracting firms are just away to help H1Bs get around the "30 days or leave" rule and insure Nabobs get a cut of profits

All of these are good first steps.

We still need the "Here are 5 qualified unemployed Americans. To obtain an H1B, write a 1000 word essay why each one was unqualfied and submit $1000 processing fee per rejection. Please note if the ask salary was within 15% of the prevailing wage, or they only lacked a fraction of the experience asked for (Ie 4 years of C++ instead of 5), it is not a qualifying rejection reason. "

Also, H1Bs are for a Skills Shortage, Not to facilitate shorter term contracts. Americans can sign short term contracts.
312   gabbar   2025 Mar 2, 4:39am  

So, sounds like Trump aint gonna do anything about the H-1B problem.
313   MolotovCocktail   2025 Mar 2, 8:07am  

gabbar says

So, sounds like Trump aint gonna do anything about the H-1B problem.


Not this time.
314   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Mar 2, 8:58am  

OkDOGEisAmountingToSomething says

gabbar says


So, sounds like Trump aint gonna do anything about the H-1B problem.


Not this time.


nor any other time. illegals or h1b is business subsidy. those businesses have politicians on the take, it’s too hard to fight it. easier let america collapse, much easier.
315   MolotovCocktail   2025 Mar 2, 9:26am  

FortwayeAsFuckJoeBiden says

nor any other time


First term he put a moratorium on it
316   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Mar 2, 9:37am  

OkDOGEisAmountingToSomething says


FortwayeAsFuckJoeBiden says


nor any other time


First term he put a moratorium on it



this time he won’t. big tech sucks, they suck, they don’t care for America. it’s an issue of the heart. that can’t be fixed with moratorium. assholes are assholes for a reason. their employees, and i met few. they utterly hate conservatives. big tech is like a giant club that submits to their ruling group that tells them what to think and believe.
317   MolotovCocktail   2025 Mar 2, 9:44am  

FortwayeAsFuckJoeBiden says

this time he won’t


Yes. That us what I said.
318   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Mar 2, 9:53am  

OkDOGEisAmountingToSomething says

FortwayeAsFuckJoeBiden says


this time he won’t


Yes. That us what I said.


i know, just making conversation
319   RWSGFY   2025 Mar 2, 11:28am  

Yawn, some temporary shit here, some lip service there, but things remain basically the same.
321   AD   2025 Mar 20, 12:45pm  

This is related to work visas as Panama City Beach area (Bay County, Florida) has a lot of work visa employees in the hospitality and tourism industries.

A friend told me today there was a line out the door of job applicants for Auntie Ann's (pretzel shop) in Pier Park Panama City Beach.

Yet the local power brokers claim we need work visas since there is not enough of a local labor pool.

Just go to Employ Bay County page on Facebook to see how a lot of people cannot find work.
322   MolotovCocktail   2025 Apr 15, 11:00pm  

Hmmm....maybe I will go back into Tech again:

Big changes are underway for U.S. visas, quietly.

The age of cheap, temporary H-1B labor is ending.

The Trump administration isn’t just slowing new approvals.
It’s laying the groundwork to make visa sponsorship financially painful.

Under the H-1B Modernization Rule and USCIS’s new fee schedule, costs are rising.
And now, wage floor increases are back under review, targeting exactly how much employers must pay to keep a visa worker.

This isn’t about protecting workers.
It’s about shrinking demand without needing Congress.

These changes affect existing visa holders.
If your role is up for renewal, transfer, or amendment, your employer may soon face higher wage requirements or new documentation standards.

Promotions may be delayed.
Transfers could be reconsidered.
And companies are already rethinking whether H-1B staffing is worth the long-term cost.

They’re starting to prioritize workers they can keep permanently.
That means U.S. citizens.

If you're on a visa and in a cost-sensitive role, understand this clearly.
The pressure is already building.

Citations in comments.
Shout out to my checkers who caught a citation error. Thx.




https://x.com/niftyswell/status/1912256349653590029
323   Patrick   2025 Apr 20, 8:31pm  

It's nice, but not nearly enough. H-1B should be reserved for jobs paying half a million a year or more.
324   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Apr 21, 4:45am  

How does the Indian IT industry survive without giving Pakistanis and Bangladeshis H1Bs?

Clearly Modi must pass a law allowing at least 100k H1Bs into India to work in call centers, before India loses their competitiveness.

hahaha
325   Patrick   2025 Apr 21, 11:09am  

MolotovCocktail says

The age of cheap, temporary H-1B labor is ending.


Occurs to me that this could have a very positive effect on real estate in the Bay Area, meaning lower prices and lower rents.

Fewer H-1Bs means less competition for housing.
327   HeadSet   2025 May 8, 7:25pm  

MolotovCocktail says





Doubtful. I do not think selling Teslas in India is an issue. This sounds like a completely contrived hit piece.
328   Patrick   2025 May 8, 7:48pm  

I agree, sounds like EDS.
329   MolotovCocktail   2025 May 8, 7:55pm  

HeadSet says


Doubtful. I do not think selling Teslas in India is an issue. This sounds like a completely contrived hit piece.


India just negotiated the same thing with the UK and Indian government officials are boasting about doing the same with the US.

Indian H1B workers not subject to FICA is a godsend for corporate America and the final deathknell for remaining US tech workers.

We shall see, tho.

The ones that actually go home, maybe. But if they transition into Greencard status, they should be forced to pony up the FICA that wasn't paid while they were H1B. Because clearly they never went home.

And their employers should be forced to pony up retroactive the employer's half, too.

But we all know THAT won't even happen.
330   MolotovCocktail   2025 May 8, 8:10pm  

Grok on this:


H1B Workers and FICA Taxes (Relation to US-India Context)
The UK-India FTA’s Double Contribution Convention is relevant to your query about H1B workers and FICA taxes, as it mirrors India’s push for social security totalization agreements. However, the UK deal does not directly involve H1B workers or FICA taxes, which are US-specific. Here’s how it connects:

UK NICs vs. US FICA: The UK’s NIC exemption for Indian workers is analogous to a potential US-India totalization agreement that would exempt Indian H1B workers from FICA taxes (7.65% for Social Security and Medicare). India has sought such an agreement with the US to reduce costs for its IT firms, but no deal exists.

US-India Trade Deal Status: No finalized US-India trade deal addresses H1B workers or FICA exemptions. Discussions have been speculative, with posts on X suggesting India seeks FICA exemptions to save $4 billion for its firms, but these lack official confirmation.

UK Precedent: The UK-India deal’s social security provision could serve as a model for US negotiations, allowing Indian H1B workers to pay into India’s social security system instead of FICA, avoiding double contributions. However, US political resistance (e.g., concerns about cheaper foreign labor) makes this unlikely without broader trade concessions.
331   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 May 8, 8:18pm  

MolotovCocktail says

UK Precedent: The UK-India deal’s social security provision could serve as a model for US negotiations, allowing Indian H1B workers to pay into India’s social security system instead of FICA, avoiding double contributions. However, US political resistance (e.g., concerns about cheaper foreign labor) makes this unlikely without broader trade concessions.

Holy shit!
333   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Jun 26, 4:41pm  

KgK one says


What's strange is, if you apply to same jobs as us citizen, there is no reply. Who can you ask why they hire h1b over local talent. Can you send email to hr and ask to justify what unique talent h1b had?

There is some benefit to stealing some really smart phds, not only they help innovate local companies, they also do brain drain other countries. If e.g. 100 start up were in other country, us would lose out on those profits.

Amazon, google, tesla... so many have h1b.


there’s no such thing as brain drain. it was just a made up excuse to sucker fools to support hb cheap labor. i was one of fools who believed it, wasn’t my thing and it sounded ok, but then i saw it wasn’t the case. they lied again, as usual.
335   MolotovCocktail   2025 Jun 30, 2:44pm  

Birthright citizenship is not 'gone'. So I wonder if he's right about even half of this shit.

..but even if only half is true, that's good.

Visa Worker Tide Turning!

• Birthright citizenship? Gone.
• Remittance tax? Coming.
• H‑1B approvals for 2026? Cut by 50,000.

But it doesn’t stop there...

• Visa overstays now trigger lifetime bans
• H‑1B visas revoked after 60+ days abroad... no official rule, just enforcement
• Palantir software now tracks visa holders in real time, linking travel, payroll, and DHS records
• Mandatory 30‑day registration rule now active
• Student and visitor visas paused, revoked, or delayed
• 19 countries blocked from new visas over overstay rates

Applicants are panicking. Students are backing out. Visa holders are racing home. Staffing firms are losing leverage.

And Americans? They're not just exposing the system anymore…

• They're applying to PERM jobs en masse - crashing fake job filters
• They're documenting fraud, flooding forums with screenshots
• And they’re confronting the globalist politicians who sold them out - in town halls, in comment sections, and in primaries

This isn’t just a policy shift. It’s a revolt.
The foreign labor pipeline is cracking.
And finally… it’s cracking in America’s favor


https://x.com/ChiefNiftyswell/status/1939404962053632060
336   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Jun 30, 5:31pm  

AmericanKulakMaximumTrumper says

Why are outsourcing firms allowed at all? They have to work direct for the company.


That one i’ve seen a lot when i worked in manufacturing. you own a factory, you want cheap illegal labor. can’t hire them. but a loophole, you use an agency to hire for you. legally you are not at fault that some run of the mill hired illegals. it’s legal cover. that practice is widespread.

there’s always some mexican running agencies that hire illegals for their clients. seen that everywhere. and that Indian stuff you talking about, it sounds all same.
337   MolotovCocktail   2025 Jun 30, 9:59pm  

Fortwaye says


but a loophole, you use an agency to hire for you. legally you are not at fault that some run of the mill hired illegals. it’s legal cover. that practice is widespread.


Ditto for open discrimination against white males for DEI. The employer says to the recruiter, "we want more diversity' and the agency openly discriminates on candidates for them. Because they are not doing the actual hiring, they legally get away with it.
341   gabbar   2025 Jul 20, 1:53am  

Booger says







This fellow is contesting for Governor of Ohio. I won't be voting for this H-1B supporter in November (but so is Trump)..all rich people are, it seems, at the cost of American middle class.

« First        Comments 306 - 345 of 515       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste