4
0

Need Patnetters Help - Life Situation


 invite response                
2022 Mar 6, 6:42pm   8,436 views  167 comments

by porkchopXpress   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

My wife and two high-schoolers currently live in the San Diego area renting a house. Since getting a new job last Fall that's fully remote, I've been pushing to move out of CA for more freedom, lower taxes, and to avoid the new vaccine mandate for K-12 students. My wife had the jab and is fine with our sons getting it to stay in CA, but I'm adamantly against it for all of the obvious reasons...they've even had Covid already.

We all decided that the Nashville area (i.e., Franklin/Brentwood) is where we'd all agree to move this Summer, but the house prices are INSANE. We've only ever rented and she will NOT agree to moving to another rental; she wants to buy. So, I'm stuck between stretching ourselves a bit to buy a $1.4M home in Nashville area, or staying in our current rental but making our boys get the vaccine to stay in school. My boys are already bummed about the thought of switching high schools, so they'd be willing to get the vaccine to stay in their current school. I feel like I'm alone in fighting against the easier path, which is clearly staying put in our current place until they finish school.

What would you guys do?

P.S. Given the no state income tax and the down payment I've saved up, I could theoretically make a $1.4M work but it's beyond what I'd prefer to pay. I'm also scared shitless that housing is going to crash, but what if it doesn't?

« First        Comments 54 - 93 of 167       Last »     Search these comments

54   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 6, 9:25pm  

NuttBoxer says
Don't spend so much on housing you never have money for living.
Totally agree. It has been my mantra. Keep my fixed costs low so I can flex with variable and have $ for kids' programs, vacations, high quality food, etc.
55   mell   2022 Mar 6, 9:44pm  

Novavax announced their Phase 3 trial success (pediatric expansion) for kids 12 and up in February, they will apply for authorization in this quarter. If your kids are old enough or your wife can wait til they're 12, then you can go with that jab as a much safer alternative, in case you can't convince her to move out of state and must jab.
56   Bitcoin   2022 Mar 6, 9:49pm  

NuttBoxer says

We looked in '11, but even then, couldn't go see a house, think about it, then make an offer. We won't be rushed into buying, so we passed


Holy shit, you almost bought a house in 2011 and rent since then?!

WOW. I am sry. My house bought in 2020 appreciated by 400K already. Imagine the equity gain if you'd bought in 2011 in the greater SD area.
57   Bitcoin   2022 Mar 6, 9:53pm  

NuttBoxer says
Have never paid as much as a mortgage would have cost us


Are you planning to rent until you die? Rents ever increase, a mortgage stays the same or goes down if you refinance. Meanwhile your house value went through the moon in the last 14 years. Your mortgage on that 2011 house price would be a joke compared to your rent in 2022. I am sry man. Thats a really sad story.
58   RC2006   2022 Mar 6, 10:01pm  

porkchopexpress says
komputodo says
porkchopexpress says
For once in my life? No need to be a dick about it, but thanks for the idea.

well you act like its an insurmountable problem like metastasized cancer in your whole body....hell, this vax thing is hardly a speedbump...if you are uncomfortable asking around, get one of your buddies to do it..i'd find a POC nurse in a poorer clinic......one that could use another $1000 cash.....theres a lot of those
I didn't mean to seem like it's an insurmountable problem, just a tough situation to be in. It'll get it figured out, but I wanted advice from other smart brains. Personally, I'd just rather get out of dodge instead of finagling the tyrannical system in CA. If it's not one thing, it'll be another. And who knows what CA will do when we have our next plandemic, which we all know is going ...


With all thats going on in CA the vax mandates were not even our biggest concern when we bailed. I just didn't want my kids growing up there. The writing is on the walls and if there are any failures in the US CA will be one of the ground zeros.

With mandates in CA is it also enforced with private schools?
59   GNL   2022 Mar 6, 11:32pm  

porkchopexpress says
WineHorror1 says
I feel very bad for you. Seriously, good luck.
Thanks man. I think about the shit going down around the world and my problems are miniscule. I just have to keep things in perspective, and ensure that my sons getting the jab is an absolutely dealbreaker no matter which path we go down.

When you have children, this is your most important motivator in life. I have paid some price while raising my 2 girls. I will always know that I did the best I could for them because I put their wellbeing first. No, I did not do everything the right way but I know my intentions and actions were always believed, at the time, to be the right decision.
60   joshuatrio   2022 Mar 7, 4:32am  

I think when you leave CA, you'll feel significantly less stressed and be blown away at how different the world is, vs how California perceives it lol.

Franklin TN is suppose to be a good area. I have friends out that way and they love it. Food in Nashville is outstanding too! Check out Chattanooga as well. Smaller city, cool area and probably a bit cheaper.

Buy now or catch a falling knife if it collapses? That's a tough one. We have been looking for a second home and have seen things flatine and have been seeing price cuts where we are looking in Florida. It's stupid expensive right now, and most of my friends are just sitting on the fence right now as they are beginning to refuse to participate.

For what it's worth, my bro in law is a realtor. He is trying to convince my parents to sell now, rent and then buy again when it gets cheaper. My parents are staying out but I wonder if even he sees a crash coming.
61   Al_Sharpton_for_President   2022 Mar 7, 5:38am  

Check out Maryville, TN, a suburb of Knoxville. Vonore, and thereabouts if you want to live near the water.
62   zzyzzx   2022 Mar 7, 6:09am  

porkchopexpress says
So, I'm stuck between stretching ourselves a bit to buy a $1.4M home in Nashville area,


Why is the alternative a 1.4M home in TN?
If that's what houses cost there now I wouldn't move.

Did I miss something here? No way local fundamentals support that type of price for an average house in Nashville.
63   RWSGFY   2022 Mar 7, 6:51am  

porkchopexpress says
RWSGFY says
File for a religious exemption. I think it's the best path forward.
I've thought about that. I did it for my new job and avoided the jab, but I'm not sure how CA schools would take an exemption, but it's definitely an option.


If denied you can sue, I believe. Buys you more time. Eventually this coof shit will be forgotten and there will be much less zeal to enforce these mandates.
64   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 6:56am  

NuttBoxer says
What about home-school? At least they'd still get to see their friends.
We can't. My wife is going to school remotely and has zero desire to home school them.
65   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 6:58am  

RC2006 says
With mandates in CA is it also enforced with private schools?
I believe so. Newsom said all schools including private.
66   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 7:00am  

joshuatrio says
I think when you leave CA, you'll feel significantly less stressed and be blown away at how different the world is, vs how California perceives it lol.

Franklin TN is suppose to be a good area. I have friends out that way and they love it. Food in Nashville is outstanding too! Check out Chattanooga as well. Smaller city, cool area and probably a bit cheaper.

Buy now or catch a falling knife if it collapses? That's a tough one. We have been looking for a second home and have seen things flatine and have been seeing price cuts where we are looking in Florida. It's stupid expensive right now, and most of my friends are just sitting on the fence right now as they are beginning to refuse to participate.

For what it's worth, my bro in law is a realtor. He is trying to convince my parents to sell now, rent and then buy again when it gets cheaper. My parents are staying out but I wonder if even he sees a crash coming.
Thanks. With rising interest rates, the writing sure does seem to be on the wall.
67   RWSGFY   2022 Mar 7, 7:00am  

porkchopexpress says
RC2006 says
With mandates in CA is it also enforced with private schools?
I believe so. Newsom said all schools including private.


Private schools would be much more receptive to religious exemption requests. Especially Christian.
68   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 7:01am  

zzyzzx says
porkchopexpress says
So, I'm stuck between stretching ourselves a bit to buy a $1.4M home in Nashville area,


Why is the alternative a 1.4M home in TN?
If that's what houses cost there now I wouldn't move.

Did I miss something here? No way local fundamentals support that type of price for an average house in Nashville.
I know. Prices have absolutely soared because of sheer demand for that particular area. People are flooding TN, TX and FL because of the economic freedom and politics, and the rich are specifically hitting Franklin/Brentwood area because the schools are some of the best in the country.
69   zzyzzx   2022 Mar 7, 7:15am  

porkchopexpress says
I know. Prices have absolutely soared because of sheer demand for that particular area. People are flooding TN, TX and FL because of the economic freedom and politics, and the rich are specifically hitting Franklin/Brentwood area because the schools are some of the best in the country.


Then wait for the housing bubble to pop before leaving.
70   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 7:54am  

zzyzzx says
porkchopexpress says
I know. Prices have absolutely soared because of sheer demand for that particular area. People are flooding TN, TX and FL because of the economic freedom and politics, and the rich are specifically hitting Franklin/Brentwood area because the schools are some of the best in the country.


Then wait for the housing bubble to pop before leaving.
It's a good plan. I would just need to figure out how to navigate California's vaccine mandate for my sons to attend public school. That's the big sticking point.
71   NuttBoxer   2022 Mar 7, 9:04am  

Save_Ukraine says
WOW. I am sry. My house bought in 2020 appreciated by 400K already. Imagine the equity gain if you'd bought in 2011 in the greater SD area.


I don't consider bubbles investments. And I adjust for inflation.

Did you sell and collect the $400k?

When will you admit you're Logan?
72   NuttBoxer   2022 Mar 7, 9:08am  

Save_Ukraine says
Are you planning to rent until you die? Rents ever increase, a mortgage stays the same or goes down if you refinance. Meanwhile your house value went through the moon in the last 14 years. Your mortgage on that 2011 house price would be a joke compared to your rent in 2022. I am sry man. Thats a really sad story.


As long as it's cheaper. My rent was $1375 back then, and it's $1600 now. If I bought would have been around $1900 plus maintenance.

Are you jealous that I've saved money and been able to enjoy my life without committing to a huge debt? Or maybe stories like mine are bad for your bottom line... Logan.
73   WookieMan   2022 Mar 7, 9:09am  

porkchopexpress says
Agreed but we don’t want rural. We like action.

I haven't read all the comments yet, but I'd give going rural a thought. Don't dismiss it out of the gate. Sounds like you have some moving parts with the kids ages and your wife wanting something specific.

If you can get social connections in a new community that's small you won't regret it. We have 2,200 people roughly and in 7 years and basically have vast resources (connections and on boards) to run the town and school district in essence. Everyone knows who we are. We have 4-5 restaurants and walk in and everyone knows us. They know what I want to drink when I walk in #Cheers

The music thing seems like a tough box to check. If it's super important then you gotta do what you have to, but I wouldn't let that be a deciding factor. As a drummer there are a ton of resources out there for self teaching/learning. The kids just have to put in the work. If they love it enough they will. If they don't love it they won't and it's not worth over spending potentially hundreds of thousands for a hobby that likely won't result in much. No different than sports where a tiny fraction of 1% even can make decent income with it.

Action is what you make it and who you know. I love not seeing fucking Chilis, BWW, McDonalds, etc. Urban and suburban America has become so bland and commercial. Plus you can get land, get toys (ATV's, golf carts, UTV's, etc.) and have a blast. Get a camper and drive 30 minutes to a cool place. The money you save going rural can create the action. Get a $500k house and buy a $200-300k boat on a lake in TN as a "cabin" so to speak.

TL:DR - Don't handcuff yourself with an expensive house. Make your own fun and friends and the action will happen.
74   NuttBoxer   2022 Mar 7, 9:11am  

porkchopexpress says
I believe so. Newsom said all schools including private.


Yes, but I'm not sure about the school my daughter attends. East El Cajon, I'm sure you know which one. I emailed the VP about it late last year, never got a response, and he's responded to every other email I've sent. I don't think he wants a written record of what the schools doing.
75   Shaman   2022 Mar 7, 9:53am  

I still live in California. No plans to move in the next three years. My kids will never be vaxxed with the mRNA shit. We are a Pureblood family and we will stay that way.

My oldest daughter is 14 almost 15. I figure we have a year or so before any existing mandates get enforced on her. But my philosophy with these mandates has always been to stall for time. The more time that goes by, the more likely it is that the mandates:
1)will be declared illegal by a judge
2)will be dropped as an adherence to Narrative 2.0 and the Democrats wanting to win future elections
3)will cease as people recoil in HORROR to the increasingly bad prognosis of the vaxxed.

You need to stall for time, bro. And visit some other places! I have a good friend living in a suburb of Nashville and he says the prices are crazy. There’s land all around, just a CURRENT scarcity of dwellings, given all the rich California transplants relocating to the suddenly popular area. Given time, the prices will fall again as thousands more houses get built. It’s a bad time to buy in Nashville.

My advice is to do vacations in other possible locations. Check out South Carolina or Georgia. Or Florida of course. There are some absolutely beautiful places in Carolina to live. And my seventeen year friends who just moved to Georgia are loving their new home and new life. Their kids are happy and going to public school. The community is welcoming. Life is good.

I firmly believe the vax is long term TERRIBLE for people. My 40 year old friend took one J&J and has been totally disabled for the past five months with no improvement. You can NOT unvax yourself! She sure wishes that was possible.

Also the vax DOES CHANGE YOUR DNA, possibly for your gonads as well! It’s life altering and family altering. You become a GMO organism which perennially produces toxic spike proteins. Your immune system is compromised and due to OAS can’t develop immunity to new viruses and variants! And then there’s the 300% rise in cancers among the vaxxed. That isn’t an accident and it’s going to happen more often in the future.

Finally, check out this article:
https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2022/03/new-orange-county-athletes-plan-participate-sports-year-must-electrocardiogram-test/?source=patrick.net

So the Orange County health authorities are worried enough about the heart health of teenagers that they’re requiring an ECG of all student athletes? I’m not opposed to the health order which could catch some congenital cardiac issues. I had a friend in high school who died suddenly of that, so it’s real. But the TIMING is absolutely indicative of a larger problem.

Don’t vax your kids. Stall for time. Ignore the wife’s temper tantrums. She might not be around much longer anyway.
76   B.A.C.A.H.   2022 Mar 7, 11:15am  

porkchopexpress says
What would you guys do?

Nashville sounds like a good choice for a Californian who wants to leave.

If you did not live in Nashville before California, how about renting in that area for a while, like at least a year or two, in the beginning of your relocation to assimilate yourselves into local knowledge, get accustomed to the region, different communities, neighborhoods and schools, instead of parachuting in from California without the benefit of your boots on the ground perspective?
77   zzyzzx   2022 Mar 7, 11:30am  

B.A.C.A.H. says
If you did not live in Nashville before California, how about renting in that area for a while, like at least a year or two, in the beginning of your relocation to assimilate yourselves into local knowledge, get accustomed to the region, different communities, neighborhoods and schools, instead of parachuting in from California without the benefit of your boots on the ground perspective?


Generally speaking a good idea, but with the eviction moratorium available apartments are scarce a well.
Plus after living in a house it's difficult to go to an apartment, even if it's the smart thing to do (would need storage for all the "house" stuff in the new place a well).
78   zzyzzx   2022 Mar 7, 11:31am  

Shaman says
But my philosophy with these mandates has always been to stall for time. The more time that goes by, the more likely it is that the mandates:
1)will be declared illegal by a judge
2)will be dropped as an adherence to Narrative 2.0 and the Democrats wanting to win future elections
3)will cease as people recoil in HORROR to the increasingly bad prognosis of the vaxxed.


Already worked for federal workers.
79   GNL   2022 Mar 7, 11:39am  

zzyzzx says
Shaman says
But my philosophy with these mandates has always been to stall for time. The more time that goes by, the more likely it is that the mandates:
1)will be declared illegal by a judge
2)will be dropped as an adherence to Narrative 2.0 and the Democrats wanting to win future elections
3)will cease as people recoil in HORROR to the increasingly bad prognosis of the vaxxed.


Already worked for federal workers.

There is no mandate for federal workers any more?
80   Eric Holder   2022 Mar 7, 11:50am  

WineHorror1 says
zzyzzx says
Shaman says
But my philosophy with these mandates has always been to stall for time. The more time that goes by, the more likely it is that the mandates:
1)will be declared illegal by a judge
2)will be dropped as an adherence to Narrative 2.0 and the Democrats wanting to win future elections
3)will cease as people recoil in HORROR to the increasingly bad prognosis of the vaxxed.


Already worked for federal workers.

There is no mandate for federal workers any more?


GOOOOD MOOOOOORNING!
81   GreaterNYCDude   2022 Mar 7, 12:05pm  

porkchopexpress says
RWSGFY says
File for a religious exemption. I think it's the best path forward.
I've thought about that. I did it for my new job and avoided the jab, but I'm not sure how CA schools would take an exemption, but it's definitely an option.

Are private schools also subject to this new requirement? Or is it only the public schools?
82   NuttBoxer   2022 Mar 7, 12:11pm  

As was already stated, their all "subject". But as I've mentioned, enforcement is more up in the air than people assume, at least at my school.
83   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 12:21pm  

WookieMan says
TL:DR - Don't handcuff yourself with an expensive house. Make your own fun and friends and the action will happen.
It's good advice, thank you. When I say we don't prefer rural, it means having convenient access to amenities like a nice gym (for me), bars and live music (for my wife and I), music community for my kids, and a good selection of shopping including higher end grocery items.

I realize we can't have it all, but it's always trying to prioritize what's most important and then making trade-offs. One thing I do know is we don't want to drive 20 minutes or more to the things I mentioned above...we'd rather take a worse house to have more convenience and access to amenities (within reason).

I understand the "Cheers" feeling because we have that here in our current community, and it's a smallish town outside of San Diego. So, you're completely right that all it takes is frequenting some of the same local places, investing the time meeting people there, and boom...you have a network of friends and things to do. We hope to follow that same formula no matter where we end up.
84   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 12:22pm  

GreaterNYCDude says
Are private schools also subject to this new requirement? Or is it only the public schools?
I've heard it's supposed to apply to private schools as well, but who knows what kind of court battles will ensue this Fall when the rubber hits the road. Problem is, I can't wait and find out the outcome because then we're stuck with it...it's hard to just up and move in a month's time since I'll be stuck in a lease, etc.
85   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 12:25pm  

B.A.C.A.H. says
porkchopexpress says
What would you guys do?

Nashville sounds like a good choice for a Californian who wants to leave.

If you did not live in Nashville before California, how about renting in that area for a while, like at least a year or two, in the beginning of your relocation to assimilate yourselves into local knowledge, get accustomed to the region, different communities, neighborhoods and schools, instead of parachuting in from California without the benefit of your boots on the ground perspective?
I 1000000% agree with renting, but my wife is so fucking adamant against it because we've only rented since we've been married. She's so tired of renting and thinks we'll continue to get priced out as time goes by and it will only get worse. Of course I've been telling her that there's likely to be a crash at some point, but it just hasn't happened so she thinks it'll never happen. Plus, this area of Nashville is crazy hot with people leaving blue states and moving in, so maybe she's right and it won't really drop that much or at all. It's all a gamble to a point.

Having said all that, I may end up dropping the hammer and requiring we rent a place and just deal with her tantrum. At the end of the day, I make the money and she lives in her bubble world as a housewife and mother.
86   NuttBoxer   2022 Mar 7, 12:27pm  

porkchopexpress says
I've heard it's supposed to apply to private schools as well, but who knows what kind of court battles will ensue this Fall when the rubber hits the road. Problem is, I can't wait and find out the outcome because then we're stuck with it...it's hard to just up and move in a month's time since I'll be stuck in a lease, etc.


I'd say to wait as long as you can before pulling the trigger. Sounds like you have an out to the shot, though not your ideal one. But overpaying for a house is still better than potential life-long health issues for your kids right?
87   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 12:27pm  

Shaman says
Don’t vax your kids. Stall for time. Ignore the wife’s temper tantrums. She might not be around much longer anyway.
Great post and great advice. Thanks.
88   porkchopXpress   2022 Mar 7, 12:30pm  

NuttBoxer says
porkchopexpress says
I've heard it's supposed to apply to private schools as well, but who knows what kind of court battles will ensue this Fall when the rubber hits the road. Problem is, I can't wait and find out the outcome because then we're stuck with it...it's hard to just up and move in a month's time since I'll be stuck in a lease, etc.


I'd say to wait as long as you can before pulling the trigger. Sounds like you have an out to the shot, though not your ideal one. But overpaying for a house is still better than potential life-long health issues for your kids right?
Exactly. I can control the situation of leaving CA this Summer when our lease comes up and just bail. If I renew because we can't find a place, I'm rolling the dice that I can get my kids out of the shot somehow. Is there a good chance of that? Sure...but this state is turning into a Left-wing tyrannical nightmare, so I don't discount what they're capable of and I don't want to sit around and see.
89   RedStar   2022 Mar 7, 12:33pm  

I"m in a pretty similar situation as the OP. The wife just refuses to admit reality and is clinging to some hope that the gene therapy shots wont be enforced. My kids are still in elementary and no way in hell will they be getting them, so homeschooling them would be the only option, but I work 60 hours a week and don't have the time or mental energy to home school. Wife recently started working after we put them in private school. We bought a small house in Idaho already, that we are renting out right now because she refuses to leave her stupid social circle and immediate family. If we sold and got out she would never have to work again but that doesn't sway her.
90   RedStar   2022 Mar 7, 12:35pm  

porkchopexpress says
B.A.C.A.H. says
porkchopexpress says
What would you guys do?

Nashville sounds like a good choice for a Californian who wants to leave.

If you did not live in Nashville before California, how about renting in that area for a while, like at least a year or two, in the beginning of your relocation to assimilate yourselves into local knowledge, get accustomed to the region, different communities, neighborhoods and schools, instead of parachuting in from California without the benefit of your boots on the ground perspective?
I 1000000% agree with renting, but my wife is so fucking adamant against it because we've only rented since we've been married. She's so tired of renting and thinks we'll continue to get priced out as time goes by and it will only get worse. Of course I've been telling her that there's likely to be a crash at some point, ...


Id try to hold out and rent for another year or so until the economy really takes a shit in and maybe prices drop. But its the Californian exodus that is creating the inflated prices in these select states, and I'm not sure that will stop even if the economy crashes.
91   RedStar   2022 Mar 7, 12:36pm  

GreaterNYCDude says
porkchopexpress says
RWSGFY says
File for a religious exemption. I think it's the best path forward.
I've thought about that. I did it for my new job and avoided the jab, but I'm not sure how CA schools would take an exemption, but it's definitely an option.

Are private schools also subject to this new requirement? Or is it only the public schools?


Private schools are also subject to and may in fact be more demanding to avoid trouble with the government.
92   SunnyvaleCA   2022 Mar 7, 12:46pm  

Renting as part of escaping California…

If Socal is anything like silicon valley, the monthly rent payment doesn't seem so painful because it's likely only 1/2 of what the mortgage payment would be if you bought now. My cursory research reveals that "cheap rent" is not likely in other parts of the country. Since you can't change the past (benefits of owning when the prices are zooming) you should frame your plans using expectations of the future, not reality of the past.

If you jettison many of your household possessions (furniture and a bunch of stuff accumulated over the years), the move will be easier. The second move will be easier still because of less stuff, things still in boxes, and a local move.

Although a high school might be very highly rated, it might not be great for your kids. Specific school programs, the friends they make, and the vibe of a school are more important than the school's reputation or goal-seeking on arbitrary benchmarks. In today's woke college admissions, going to a highly-rated school means your kids will be penalized in the college admissions process.

Given the Zillow search you specified above, it looks like Brentwood is a "fortress" area, as we call it in the Bay Area. These are places where there are lifelong owners who paid off the mortgage decades ago and won't move until it's feet-first in an ambulance. Others are dual-income professional couples who just bought and will hold on tenaciously. A third category is the already wealthy who can easily afford to stay in a downturn. In addition to not being forced out by a crash, the 2nd and 3rd category will actively buy is the prices dip by even 20%. The last category will buy with cash if interest rates go year 1980 on us.
93   B.A.C.A.H.   2022 Mar 7, 12:47pm  

zzyzzx says
with the eviction moratorium available apartments are scarce a well.
Plus after living in a house it's difficult to go to an apartment


I did not suggest renting an apartment.

A big city area like Nashville will have some SFH for rent. And I betcha, no matter how expensive, less expensive than a comparable rental SFH in San Diego.

« First        Comments 54 - 93 of 167       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions