« First « Previous Comments 73 - 112 of 261 Next » Last » Search these comments
I don't know Patrick, if congress, the president, parents & even my wife are conspiring against me (Chapt. 2), I think I may have bigger problems than owning some real estate. Perhaps a little too much hyperbole?
Not hyperbole at all!
Has Congress or the President ever suggested that promoting mortgage debt is a bad thing? I don't think so.
What do your parents think about your buying a house? Ask them.
Same for your wife.
In the large majority of cases, they all want you to buy and don't understand (or don't want to understand) the idea that you might be far better off financially by renting.
Patrick says, "In the large majority of cases, they all want you to buy and don't understand (or don't want to understand) the idea that you might be far better off financially by renting."
This was almost exactly my experience of the last seven years. My parents and friends swore up and down that I was throwing away money on rent when I could be building equity by buying. I gave up explaining my position and the fact that the RE market was bubbled after a few years. Honestly tho, if my wife wasn't on board with my reasoning it would have been much harder to wait it out and rent. A few coworkers were pushed into big expensive home purchases by their wives and are now renters again, having been foreclosed. All this despite making six figure salaries.
Your book is very aptly named.
Thumbs up!
Same for your wife.
For the next version, you might want this chapter to be entitled 'Your Spouse.' Albeit, I haven't read the contents of the chapter but I would imagine similar arguments come from husbands. I've got a friend whose husband doesn't want kids yet because he wants to be a homeowner first! Personally speaking, I have a husband who has no interest in financial decisions but has always dreamed of being a 'homeowner'--both due to pride and wanting to customize his garage...
Plus, the label makes it sound like a wife is not an equal contributer in 1) the household income or 2) the financial decisions of the family.
It's not politically correct to say so, and of course there are exceptions, but even today a house is generally seen as something provided by a husband for a wife -- and that's in just about every culture on earth.
The characters in "Suzanne Researched This" are playing on these traditional roles because that's what's in people's brains:
Ordered your book over the weekend...I have learned many a lesson over the past few years reading here...looking forward to the book. Thx.
Well, that title does make it sound like you aim to provide your male readers with ammo against their wife's irrational demands to spend their husbands money on a big house. I just think there are more exceptions to that notion than you believe (like as in it's not true in real life anymore) but this book really isn't about that.
True that. But she still gets half your stuff if she divorces you.
Aren't both entitled to half of everything they acquired during their marriage? So if they contributed equally (or the wife contributed more), the husband wouldn't be 'losing' anything.
Well, that title does make it sound like you aim to provide your male readers with ammo against their wife's irrational demands to spend their husbands money on a big house. I just think there are more exceptions to that notion than you believe (like as in it's not true in real life anymore) but this book really isn't about that.
I think it still is somewhat more than half true. About 2/3 of men earn more their wives in the US.
And I think if you flip it around, you'd probably find that about 2/3 of women are the ones driving the purchase of a house. But I'm just guessing there, from my experience living in this culture.
And yes, the book is all about ammo. That what it is, really: a self-defense course for people being pressured to buy. The wife thing is just one part of it.
Make a DRM-free ebook (pdf, Kindle formatted, whatever) for the same price as the physical book and I'll buy one immediately.
Patrick,
Do you think there'll be momentum for more items for sale (similar to xkcd)?
you already have a book, may be you can add more merchandise.
just a thought.
I think it still is somewhat more than half true. About 2/3 of men earn more their wives in the US.
How many of that 2/3 are the sole wage earner? Women making 85% of their husband's wage probably don't like to throw their money down the crapper either...
And I think if you flip it around, you'd probably find that about 2/3 of women are the ones driving the purchase of a house. But I'm just guessing there, from my experience living in this culture.
Maybe but I just gave you two examples of where a wife had to provide the arguments against buying. So in my demographic, this doesn't seem all that true to me. Does that matter? Only if you might offend someone in your intended audience.
And yes, the book is all about ammo. That what it is, really: a self-defense course for people being pressured to buy. The wife thing is just one part of it.
Agreed, I just wouldn't want your other ammo to be ignored by some people in your potential audience because of a possible interpretation of a (as you say) somewhat politically incorrect statement....
I'd be delighted if there were.
I have bumper stickers, but maybe should branch out into posters and clothing.
I think it would be funny to create OVERPRICED stickers for people to put on for-sale signs, but I'd probably get in trouble for that...
Agreed, I just wouldn't want your other ammo to be ignored by some people in your potential audience because of a possible interpretation of a (as you say) somewhat politically incorrect statement....
I had my own wife review the book, and our marriage survived.
I don't want to offend women, but I honestly believe a lot of mortgage debt is created by realtors pressuring wives to pressure husbands. Just like in that video.
How can I put it without lying about what I really think?
From the female perspective--We were in the process of relocating out of state and I was the one that found this site and presented it's arguments for renting vs. buying. However, we both struggled with the "emotional" arguments for home..or rather...mortgage ownership...and caved and bought after a year. Honestly, the emotional card to buy is the most difficult to overcome, because we had all the head knowledge not to. Fortunately, for us, we were able to take advantage of this crazy AZ market...and were able to sell, and get all our $$ back. Didn't make any, but didn't loose any. I certainly would not recommend the path we took, but we learned some valuable life lessons in the process. Happy to be renting again...
It's not politically correct to say so, and of course there are exceptions, but even today a house is generally seen as something provided by a husband for a wife -- and that's in just about every culture on earth.
The characters in "Suzanne Researched This" are playing on these traditional roles because that's what's in people's brains:
Shutup woman, I just came into the kitchen for a beer at half-time.
A little more background on men and women in buying houses:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/07/garden/07men.html?pagewanted=all
Married couples make up the largest group of new home buyers. Next, according to research from the National Association of Realtors, are single women, who in the last 12 months represented 21 percent of home buyers; single men were just 10 percent. That gap has opened up in the last decade, said Paul Bishop, vice president for research at the association.
Those women want that house. The men, not so much. By a factor of more than 2 to 1.
http://www.youtube.com/embed/nVGxJAd0iYs
Men are supposed to be the providers - the hunter/gatherers. If you don't buy your wife a house you're a useless piece of shit who wasn't good enough to marry her in the first place - if only the good one hadn't gotten away....
Women are emotional when it comes to home buying. And men have no ammunition against emotion.
I still don't see how to publish on Kindle without giving up rights to publish anywhere else.
I'm tempted just to give away a PDF that has maybe 25% of the book in it, and let people copy that however they want as advertising for the paper book.
I love paper books.
It's not JUST home buying... they are emotional with every other issue of life!!
Oh, so you think I'm an emotional mess? sniff.... you hurt my feelings! I can't do anything right! I never should have answered that post!
Other people answered my posts without making me cry... don't know why you chose to pick on me! I'm calling all my girlfriends and telling them that you said I wasn't good enough! (heavy sob)...
I still don't see how to publish on Kindle without giving up rights to publish anywhere else.
I'm tempted just to give away a PDF that has maybe 25% of the book in it, and let people copy that however they want as advertising for the paper book.
I love paper books.
Just a thought, but would it be bad to only sell on Amazon? I don't like their rights restrictions, but then at the same time it's just for this one book.
Any restriction on where I can sell my own work is not acceptable.
I'm actually kind of amazed anyone puts up with it.
I wish this could go mainstream, but unlikely. Just this weekend I was out with friends and talk about the house next door (I rent) being up for sale for 350k with 10k in taxes was viewed as a "good price." I was trying to make a joke about it being a "bargain," but to my disappointment, they took it seriously. Keep in mind this house sold for 195k in 2001, and taxes have more than doubled since then.
Sadly, not informed enough to realize a 3000/month expense is far from a "bargain."
Any restriction on where I can sell my own work is not acceptable.
I'm actually kind of amazed anyone puts up with it.
Patrick - I understand your concern. Keep in mind going through Amazon does reduce the chance of stolen copies getting out there, and its the most popular e-book platform out there.
Woohoo, sales finally hit the 100 mark:
That's all physical copies, and I know at least some people have received them now.
I wish this could go mainstream, but unlikely. Just this weekend I was out with friends and talk about the house next door (I rent) being up for sale for 350k with 10k in taxes was viewed as a "good price." I was trying to make a joke about it being a "bargain," but to my disappointment, they took it seriously. Keep in mind this house sold for 195k in 2001, and taxes have more than doubled since then.
This could go mainstream!
Just loan your copy to them for a while.
Any chance of this being an iBook?
If not I'll order the dead-tree version on Amazon.
Any chance of this being an iBook?
Yes! That's next.
I just finished the Kindle enrollment, and Elliemae was right that I could skip the exclusivity of Kindle "Select". So the Kindle version should be out within a day. The .doc format was really bad, so I left it as PDF, but that got a few formatting issues as well, like missing page breaks. But at least all the content is there.
Now for the iBook format... I will see if I can get that done tonight.
I'm going to the Clark County Republican Central Committee meeting tonight in Las Vegas. The book should be arriving this afternoon, just in time for me to bring it with me to show it around.
Thank you! I think they'll like it, especially since Las Vegas had just about the worst bubble and crash of anywhere in the US except maybe Phoenix.
Not available in stores!
I'd like for stores to carry it, but I don't have a distributor, and bookstores don't like to deal with each individual author.
Elliemae told me that she paid the $25 to createspace.com to have "expanded distribution" through stores and other online sellers, but all they did was undercut her price, bringing her profit to $0, so she doesn't recommend that that.
Women are emotional when it comes to home buying. And men have no ammunition against emotion.
It's not JUST home buying... they are emotional with every other issue of life!!
Humans are emotional beings. I used to generalize that it was "all the womens fault", until I experienced my assumptions in real life role reversals first hand, over and over again. It just seems to manifest itself differently, and we see it through our male eyes,,,,
Both men and women are emotional, just about different things. Different triggers set us off, and they align by gender. Speaking as a man, what sets me off the worst is lack of respect. When a coworker maligns me or makes light of what I do/did, I get angry as hell. When my wife makes the mistake of belittling me or talking down to me, even if she has a point about something, I get mad! If she nags at me like I'm a child that needs to be told again and again, I get mad, and nothing productive is accomplished.
On the other hand I think that women are set off more by the presence of or lack of shown love. If I refuse to help my wife with something, that to her, shows lack of love and she gets upset. If I don't compliment or dote on her and make her feel like I want to be with her, again lack of love = meltdown. If I, heaven forbid, make a disparaging comment about her person, that is just asking for an estrogen bomb! Forgetting birthdays, anniversaries, v-day etc are all manifestations of a lack of love.
Guys might feel love for their sweetheart all the time, but she needs us to show it for it to be any good for her.
At the risk of getting called sexist, I think you're right about that.
Men are wired to be acutely aware of their position in the heirarchy, and respect is how they measure that. Women want to know they are personally valued by their mate so that they can count on his help when they need it. Maybe an overgeneralization, but I don't think so. It just follows from reproductive biology.
Having had roosters and hens, you can clearly see gender roles there. There is no political correctness in chickens. The roosters are cocky. The hens are good mothers who need that rooster around for protection and support. Roosters feed the hens sometimes, giving them bugs and such.
The attitude toward owning a house is partly just biologically different in men and women, IMHO.
The Kindle version is now available!
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B009DRL91K
I'll make a separate thread about that.
Men are wired to be acutely aware of their position in the heirarchy, and respect is how they measure that. Women want to know they are personally valued by their mate so that they can count on his help when they need it. Maybe an overgeneralization, but I don't think so. It just follows from reproductive biology.
Yes, men and women are wired differently, but...it is not binary. There is a scale of behavior and while men tend to be grouped at one end and women on the other, depending on the behavior, there can be a lot of overlap.
There are probably many women who have felt pressured into buying a home by their "conspirator" husbands.
Your Parents 27
Your Wife's Parents 27
Your Wife 27
Indicate that the book was written for men. Why not "Your Spouse's Parents" and "Your Spouse?"
Having had roosters and hens, you can clearly see gender roles there.
Humans generally have a much wider range of behavior than most other animals so it is a difficult comparison to make. I would wager that even with roosters and hens, if closely studied, you would see a "scale" of behavior.
« First « Previous Comments 73 - 112 of 261 Next » Last » Search these comments
It's $12.50 so that if you buy two (makes a great gift!) then you don't have to pay any shipping charges.
Here is the table of contents:
Trapped! 8
Can't Sell 9
Can't Pay Off Mortgage 10
Must Keep Obeying Boss 10
The Conspirators 12
Your Agent 12
Your Mortgage Broker 18
Your Bank 18
Fannie And Freddie 19
The Federal Reserve 20
Newspapers 21
The NAR 23
Congress 24
The President of The United States 25
Current Owners 25
Your Boss 26
Your Parents 27
Your Wife's Parents 27
Your Wife 27
Fallacies and Fantasies 30
Appreciation 30
Building Equity 32
Renters Throw Money Away 34
Tax Deduction 37
Real Estate Is Local 39
So Little Supply 40
So Many Buyers 40
Foreigners 41
House Prices Don't Fall To Zero 41
Supply And Demand 42
Land Shortage 44
Fundamentals Don't Matter 44
Commissions Don't Matter 45
Agents Don't Care What You Pay 46
My Neighborhood Is Different 46
You Have To Live Somewhere 47
Rentals Not Available 48
Rentals All Suck 48
Owners Can Remodel 49
But The Newspapers Say... 50
But The Appraiser Said... 51
Home Sweet Home 52
Status 53
Affordability Is Good Now 53
Owning Limits Your Monthly Payment 54
People Buy On Emotion 55
Baby Needs House 55
I Just Want It 56
Scams and Dirty Tricks 58
Realtors® Claiming They re "Free" 58
Claiming That You Need An Agent 60
Showing You The Ugly Dogs First 61
Underpricing 62
Missing Price 64
Missing Address 64
Renting Property Without Permission 65
Straw Buyers 65
Faking Comps 66
Faking The Dimensions 67
Faking The Sale 67
Erasing Price History And Relisting 68
Faking Higher Offers 69
Hiding Your Low Offer 69
Taking Bribe To Hide Your Offer 70
Hiding Offer To Get Double Commission 70
Hiding Offer To Get Seller To Take Loss 71
Photoshop 71
Advertising Agent Instead Of House 71
Kickbacks 72
Bribes 72
A Trick Of Your Own 73
What Should You Do? 75
Be Paranoid 75
Never Sign Any Agent Agreement 75
Never Reveal Your Price Limit 77
Hire Your Own Independent Inspector 78
Favor FSBOs 78
Do Not Rush 80
Do Not Overpay 81
Deliver Offer To Seller Personally 83
Pay Cash 84
Long Term Lease 85
Walk Away 85
If You're A Realtor® 87
Calculating Fair Price 88
Two Kinds Of Rent 89
Borrowing Does Not Help 91
Downpayment Doesn't Help Much 91
Conventional Mortgage 92
Deduction Doesn't Help Most People 93
Appreciation Is Uncertain 95
Taxability Of Gains 96
What About Leverage? 97
What About Inflation? 98
Rules Of Thumb 99
Anything else? 101
Long-Term Solutions 102
Call Housing Inflation What It Is 102
Help Correct Reporters 103
No Public Guarantees For Private Debt 104
No Mortgage Interest Deduction 105
Public Bids On Housing 107
Legally Binding Offers To Sell 108
Eliminate Comps As Meaningless 108
No Empty Houses 109
Publicly Financed Elections 110
End Proposition 13 In California 111
The Georgist Land Value Tax 112
Spread The Word 113