7
0

How did we lose our freedom of speech?


               
2021 Apr 24, 9:40am   2,778 views  40 comments

by FortWayneHatesRealtors   follow (3)  

Seriously been pondering this. There are groups and people no one is allowed to criticize or cancel culture nazis come and cancel you. There are words people aren’t allowed to say... depending on whom is saying it and whom ruling class protects. Problems you are not allowed to point out.

Slow erosion of rights. How the fuck did we get here?

« First        Comments 17 - 40 of 40        Search these comments

17   RWSGFY   2021 Apr 25, 10:35am  

ThreeBays says
FuckCCP89 says
Useless without separation between real and BS education.


You're welcome to share other data.


That data is supressed so there is no way for me obtain and share it. But the very fact that the breakdown by type of edumacation is omitted in your data speaks volumes.
18   Maga_Chaos_Monkey   2021 Apr 25, 11:32am  

FuckCCP89 says
Useless without separation between real and BS education.


That's a great point! Not really any more informative than breaking down between who drives red cars vs. blue cars. Except maybe that:

1. Majority of people are indoctrinated.
2. People who have only a HS education are less likely to be indoctrinated but still 52% apparently are.

Reminds me of the statistic: Teenage pregnancy drops precipitously after age 18.
19   Maga_Chaos_Monkey   2021 Apr 25, 12:09pm  

ThreeBays says
via denial of science


Said the non-scientist to the scientist.
20   mell   2021 Apr 25, 12:51pm  

ThreeBays says
Republican politics is a dying breed. Older base that's dying, the base also is suicidal via denial of science, and then if Biden offers free college that will influence future young voters.

What will be the new ballgame? Alt-right activism (aka Trolling) had it's turn and backfired during the era of covid.


If you're talking mainstream Republicans then yes but otherwise the Trump fraction has never been doing better, you just don't hear about it in the lamestream media. It's just the D/R uniparty that is under attack from leftoids and new American patriots.
21   Shaman   2021 Apr 25, 12:54pm  

just_passing_through says
ThreeBays says
via denial of science


Said the non-scientist to the scientist.


Yah lately it’s been the Left that’s actively denying and censoring science and scientists who want to do science without filtering it first through left wing politics. Left owns such gems as gender denial, denial of vaccine risks, pro-masks and lockdowns which have been tried and proven ineffective, and also continued closure of schools when that was thoroughly debunked by scientists as a very bad idea.

Left can’t deal with truth and science is the means of discovering and expressing truth.
22   Onvacation   2021 Apr 25, 1:12pm  

ThreeBays says
Republican politics is a dying breed.

Thank God!

The way the republicans and democrats have sold out this country is scary. It seems that most of our "representatives" are compromised puppets.

We need to get back to the principles of freedom and liberty that our founders founded our country upon.

Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
23   stereotomy   2021 Apr 25, 3:07pm  

How far we have come. At least as far as Patrick.net, there was outrage over mortgage fraud. Now what are we dealing with? Election fraud, big pharma fraud (opioid addiction), NSA fraud (Snowden, universal surveillance), media collapse and subsequent fraud/propaganda, election fraud 2020, Covid fraud, lockdown fraud . . . the list goes on.

Stop this merry go round - I want to get off.
24   Patrick   2021 Apr 25, 5:35pm  

Onvacation says
ThreeBays says
educated liberals

Is that like "jumbo shrimp?


To be "educated" in America is to prove your subservience, obedience, and willingness to suspend reason in order to please your masters.

The more "educated" you are, the more terrified you are of being accused of independent thought:

https://patrick.net/post/1338725/2021-04-07-the-elite-are-the-most-likely-to-censor

As Nassim Taleb puts it, we have a whole class, tens of millions of "intellectual yet idiot" people:

https://medium.com/incerto/the-intellectual-yet-idiot-13211e2d0577
25   PeopleUnited   2021 Apr 25, 7:18pm  

Before we can discuss where freedom of speech was lost and the hows and why’s we must remember how freedom of speech was won. It was won by people who pledged their lives and fortunes and sacred honor to throw off the rulers who sought to infringe on those inalienable rights.

The right to free speech was won with fire, violence, printing presses, pulpits, swords, boats, bayonets, bombs and arms. It was won by people willing to risk all, because they believed that living free was worth fighting and dying for. They believed that death was better than life under rule of tyrants. They gave us a Republic where it is the responsibility of the people to preserve and defend it.

Did our people preserve and defend it?
26   GreaterNYCDude   2021 Apr 26, 8:36am  


Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.

Quite possibly one of the most important paragraphs ever written. We're not nearly at "absolute despotisim" yet in my view, but the overall trend has not been good as of late. (That is to say the long slow decline over the past 20 to 25 years)
27   GreaterNYCDude   2021 Apr 26, 9:23am  

GreaterNYCDude says

Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.

Quite possibly one of the most important paragraphs ever written. We're not nearly at "absolute despotisim" yet in my view, but the overall trend has not been good as of late. (That is to say the long slow decline over the past 20 to 25 years)
28   PeopleUnited   2021 Apr 26, 10:30am  

GreaterNYCDude says
We're not nearly at "absolute despotisim" yet in my view


When one person can unilaterally decide which businesses/schools can open or must close, Or prohibit churches from holding events, and force face diapers as a condition of travel and business I’d say we are already there.

When private businesses collude to prevent truth about a candidate from reaching the public and the justice department colludes with one party and all of mainstream media to impeach a president based on lies I’d say we are already there.

When election laws are violated without any willingness of the courts to hear the cases, I’d say we are already there.
29   AmenCorner_AntiPanican   2021 Apr 26, 11:32am  

stereotomy says
How far we have come. At least as far as Patrick.net, there was outrage over mortgage fraud. Now what are we dealing with? Election fraud, big pharma fraud (opioid addiction), NSA fraud (Snowden, universal surveillance), media collapse and subsequent fraud/propaganda, election fraud 2020, Covid fraud, lockdown fraud . . . the list goes on.

Stop this merry go round - I want to get off.


I wanna get on the Xanadu timeline where I can rollerskate around all day to ELO and drink a beer with Gene Kelly talking about the girls' tight little asses.
30   AmenCorner_AntiPanican   2021 Apr 26, 11:33am  

farmer2021 says
So who are elites among Jews?
Zionists?


Woke Leftist Jews are ANTI-Zionist.

Just like Congress Party in India is ANTI-Hindu.
31   FuckTheMainstreamMedia   2021 Apr 27, 8:46am  

Fortwaynemobile says
Seriously been pondering this. There are groups and people no one is allowed to criticize or cancel culture nazis come and cancel you. There are words people aren’t allowed to say... depending on whom is saying it and whom ruling class protects. Problems you are not allowed to point out.

Slow erosion of rights. How the fuck did we get here?


The liberals abandoned their core values and sucked on the teets of the hard left. Once the ACLU no longer actually stood for defending civil liberties, it was all over.

Moronic assholes.
32   FuckTheMainstreamMedia   2021 Apr 27, 8:55am  

ThreeBays says
Patrick says
Onvacation says
ThreeBays says
educated liberals

Is that like "jumbo shrimp?


To be "educated" in America is to prove your subservience, obedience, and willingness to suspend reason in order to please your masters.

The more "educated" you are, the more terrified you are of being accused of independent thought:

https://patrick.net/post/1338725/2021-04-07-the-elite-are-the-most-likely-to-censor

As Nassim Taleb puts it, we have a whole class, tens of millions of "intellectual yet idiot" people:




Intellectuals abandoned free speech as a core tenant. It morphed to speech that doesn’t offend and now to speech deemed suitable by the corporate establishment as dictated by the educated pink and blue haired fascists.

Vilifying intellectuals will happen if the right abandons the constitutions and strikes back at the Democrats using the Dems own playbook. None of us want that, but I guarantee you that as much as the moronic left( IE millenials) is ok with communism:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.marketwatch.com/amp/story/for-millennials-socialism-and-communism-are-hot-capitalism-is-not-2019-10-28

There’s an good number of religious conservatives who would be a-ok with Gilead https://the-handmaids-tale.fandom.com/wiki/Republic_of_Gilead_(Novel)

The few remaining liberals shouldn’t have been such shitheads. They went from guardians of individual liberties to quelching free speech, in quite rapid fashion
33   Patrick   2025 Oct 7, 12:12pm  

https://www.coffeeandcovid.com/p/crossways-tuesday-october-7-2025


It began quietly, slowly, almost invisibly, around 2013— a revolution without a manifesto, ignited not by riotous mobs in the streets but by millions of disenchanted viewers and readers cutting cable and closing browser tabs. It may have begun with Edward Snowden, who first cracked the façade of benevolent governmental authority; then Gamergate exposed the cultural gatekeeping of legacy press; and folks fled corporate media to Twitter, Patreon, and YouTube, which gave the dispossessed their own printing presses.

That was round one in the conservative counter-revolution. Cue the counter-counter-revolution.

When Democrats and the Autopen took control in 2020, the country was mired in the terrifying fog of covid, and the crisis provided both a mandate and a mechanism for reasserting centralized control. The moral authority of “public health” became a catch-all justification for executive orders, speech regulation, and mass data coordination between government and private tech platforms.

What might once have required long legislative debate could now be implemented overnight by “emergency guidance.” Bureaucracies metastasized; censorship was relabeled as “misinformation management.” In that sense, 2020 wasn’t a restoration of normal governance— it was the beginning of a technocratic counter-counter-revolution, where the institutions that had lost narrative power during the 2013-to-2019 social media decentralization seized a new flag to rally under: safety.

The pandemic emergency gave the old establishment one last lever —control through fear and public-health bureaucracy. But —sadly, for them— it was but a temporary reprieve. As the crisis receded, the public fumed over how much it had been censored, coerced, and patronized. Independent platforms had multiplied; podcasts, Substacks, and alternative networks had already trained millions to think and talk outside the approved script.

The central institutions tried to stuff the free-thinking genie back into the bottle, with “disinformation boards” and fact-checking partnerships, but the social contract had flipped: distrustful audiences no longer assumed legitimacy came from authority. By 2024, after the Twitter Files debacle, the Democrats’ bony grip on speech had slipped. ...

Last week, Gallup’s 2025 survey found only 31% of Americans trust the media to report news “fully, accurately, and fairly,” with only a pitiful 7% expressing “a great deal” of trust. That’s the lowest level since Gallup began tracking trust in the 1970s. After covid, Russiagate, and censorship scandals, legacy media institutions have been fully exposed as sold-out political actors.

Now, the conservative counter-revolution is spreading from its new media redoubt to overtake legacy media as well.
34   Patrick   2025 Nov 12, 1:58pm  




I'm sure that millions of Jews were killed by the Nazis in WWII, along with about 15 million non-combatant or POW Slavs.

But it is wrong to imprison anyone for disputing historical facts.
35   GreaterNYCDude   2025 Nov 13, 4:43am  

Clearly we started to put security over freedom. It started in 2001 / 2002 and amplified in 2020 / 2021. Government rarely wastes an opportunity to exploit a crisis. Our right to simply be left alone is gone. Cameras everywhere. The ubiquitousness of credit cards over cash. Targeted ads based on browsing history. I can't even read the news without feeling like I'm being sold a line of goods. We're devolving from citizens of a free nation to widgets to be exploited by big business.

So... What do we ultimately do about this? Can we get back to the free, independent, unified America of our youth? Did such a country ever even exist or am I simply romanticizing the past?
36   zzyzzx   2025 Nov 13, 5:59am  

FuckTheMainstreamMedia says

The liberals abandoned their core values


Censorship IS a core value for liberals. That is the problem.
37   RWSGFY   2025 Nov 13, 11:56am  

GreaterNYCDude says

Clearly we started to put security over freedom. It started in 2001 / 2002 and amplified in 2020 / 2021. Government rarely wastes an opportunity to exploit a crisis. Our right to simply be left alone is gone. Cameras everywhere. The ubiquitousness of credit cards over cash. Targeted ads based on browsing history. I can't even read the news without feeling like I'm being sold a line of goods. We're devolving from citizens of a free nation to widgets to be exploited by big business.

So... What do we ultimately do about this? Can we get back to the free, independent, unified America of our youth? Did such a country ever even exist or am I simply romanticizing the past?


Unified? Reagan was hated by the left as much as Trump, if not more. Blamed for not saving fudgepackers from dying of AIDS (as if it was in his power), called a bloodthirsty warmonger for putting Pershing-2 missiles in Europe, etc. Unified my ass.
38   WookieMan   2025 Nov 13, 12:27pm  

GreaterNYCDude says

Did such a country ever even exist or am I simply romanticizing the past?

Yes and no. As children I think most of us felt more free and remember that more guessing the demo here. As we age and with widespread internet access developing over the last 30-40 years, notification of what is happening is a constant barrage of information.

Basically we feel like we're being told what to think. All the stuff was always going on, we just didn't hear about it unless we were in the know. It was phone calls and mail to transfer information. Your local plumber could only get information from a newspaper or TV if they could afford it.

I'll pull a former user Rickwicks line, you have a computer in your pocket now that is far more advanced than anything in the 80's or 90's.

I don't agree with it, but with AI a UBI welfare system is coming. I don't think it's near with Trump being in office but I could see in 10-20 years it being a thing unless true conservatives keep the judicial and executive branches. That would be a long stretch though.

Clarence Thomas needs to retire after the midterms. 2028 is no guarantee for Vance, Rubio, Desantis, etc. Thomas is 77 and has exceeded the life expectancy of a black man. Strike while the iron is hot. He seems to be loyal to conservative views. Retire and enjoy what is likely to be maybe another 10-15 years on this planet.
39   Eric_Holder   2025 Nov 13, 1:20pm  

WookieMan says

I'll pull a former user Rickwicks line, you have a computer in your pocket now that is far more advanced than anything in the 80's or 90's.


Didn't stop him from being a complete ignoramus on basic history, geography and engineering topics, lol.
40   FortWayneHatesRealtors   2025 Nov 13, 1:24pm  

Eric Holder says

WookieMan says


I'll pull a former user Rickwicks line, you have a computer in your pocket now that is far more advanced than anything in the 80's or 90's.


Didn't stop him from being a complete ignoramus on basic history, geography and engineering topics, lol.


Just want to say that myself I’m also very darn average in all of those topics and claim no expert knowledge in any of the subjects.

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste