5
0

Florida Real Estate Collapse


 invite response                  
2023 Mar 29, 10:07pm   6,035 views  152 comments

by AmericanKulak   ➕follow (10)   ignore (3)  

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/640-Pelican-Dr-Satellite-Beach-FL-32937/43447731_zpid/

2015 - Sold For $155k

2/8/2019 Sold $209,000

Now? Asking $400,000
So we're to believe in 4 years, that this house legit went up almost double. Or in a decade went up almost triple.

Another one:
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/3802-Sunbeam-Ct-Merritt-Island-FL-32953/43404282_zpid/?mmlb=g%2C13

11/25/2013 Sold
$193,500
-3.2%
$98/sqft

2/14/2023 Listed for sale
$514,900
+166.1%
$261/sqft
Source: DBAMLS #1105834 Report a problem

Both of these houses were minimally updated. The first one was built in the 1960s.

I got half dozen more examples. Here's another, it was just under $250k in what looks like a Steelolanogranite Realtor Flip Special in 2019, before COVID. It was purchased late 2018 for under $172k. Now they want almost $500k for it just 5 years later.
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/356-W-Dover-St-Satellite-Beach-FL-32937/43448773_zpid/

If you're curious, check out Palm Bay and Melbourne on the mainland. 1950s/1960s Space Program small cinderblock specials, some with no Central Air, are going for almost the same as brand new construction much larger and more modern.

« First        Comments 113 - 152 of 152        Search these comments

113   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 22, 11:47am  

They did the same thing in St. Lucie County 40 years ago. They got some warehouses and QVC, and then QVC closed, which was a warehouse anyway.

Florida does do a good job with tech training, but eventually they realize how much better both wages are elsewhere. About 1/3 of my HS Grad class moved to other states.

Cabinet installer in the Villages pays $2 over minimum wage.
We got to install them custom cabinets, custom kitchens, deliver-iver-ieeees for $15/hr.
Look at that Yoyo.
That's the way you don't do it.
Lug that shit from your truck in 90 Degrees with 90% humidity
Oh, that's the way you don't do it.
East Virginia rents on a West Virginia mountain mamma salary.
https://www.ziprecruiter.com/co/Kitchen-Tune-Up-The-Villages-and-Chain-of-Lakes/Jobs/--in-Florida
I didn't go looking for this, it popped up when doing state/city comparisons.

"It's an unskilled job!" No, it's not:
Excellent attention to detail and ability to follow directions.
Able to drill for hinges.
Able to install doors and drawer fronts.
Able to install roll-out trays in cabinets.
Ability to safely operate power hand tools including a table saw, band saw, power hand saw, router, planer, and powered nail gun.

It also looks like you're prebuilding at least some cabinets offsite, too.

Cutting custom kitchen cabinetry to size != unskilled slapping Chipotle beans in a box.

Notice no mention of health insurance, just pizza parties (so typical Florida business, LOL)
114   WookieMan   2025 Apr 22, 12:00pm  

AmericanKulak says


Lug that shit from your truck in 90 Degrees with 90% humidity

Sauna workout? Not bad if you're fat. No gym membership.
115   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 22, 12:02pm  

WookieMan says


Sauna workout? Not bad if you're fat. No gym membership.

You also have to assemble and install it, for the lofty sum of $15/hr, no health insurance.

Maybe Mr. Olsen will give you a $10 tip, which was mighty handsome back in 1985 when he was a yung fella just startin out
116   AD   2025 Apr 22, 12:14pm  

WookieMan says

Lug that shit from your truck in 90 Degrees with 90% humidity


No way it gets that bad as far as the heat index (which is 122) in even South Florida.

For Panama City Beach, if it is 90 degs or more then the humidity is rarely over 60%, which means the heat index is always no more than around 100 during the hottest days of the year.

As far as American Kulak comment about Florida offering tech and vocational training, that definitely also applies a lot to Bay County and Panama City. They heavily train locally at Haney Tech for nursing/medical, electrician, plumber, car mechanic and HVAC technician.

.
117   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 22, 2:03pm  

AD says


No way it gets that bad as far as the heat index (which is 122) in even South Florida.

LOL, Florida Summers are infamous, and they begin about May and last till October.

Panama City isn't San Diego, it's about the same as NOLA or Mobile, hot and sweaty half the year. It's at pretty much the same latitude with the same climate on the same body of water.

There are +85F +80% Humidity days, plural, for days at a time, several times a year in New Jersey and Virginia and Ohio and Pennsylvania, much less Florida. Florida summers are a whole other level, there's few breaks. It's as often more humid and steamy after a thunderstorm than before it.

https://weatherspark.com/y/18686/Average-Weather-in-Fort-Lauderdale-Florida-United-States-Year-Round

And Tampa isn't much nicer in the summer.




50% of all days are "Opressive" and 20-30% of all days "Miserable" in Tampa from May to Oct

There's a reason people avoid living in Florida in Summer and why there are misters and A/C rest areas at Universal and Disney.

And a reason my electric bill is $70 Nov-Apr and $140 in May-Oct
118   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 22, 2:09pm  

Panama City, where about 50% of days from May to Mid-October are steamy and miserable. And 90% of the summer - and it often stays in the 80s with heavy humidity at night, too. There's a big reason snowbirds don't come back until after Thanksgiving and leave around Easter

119   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 22, 8:45pm  

Punta Gorda hits 2008 levels of housing inventory
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yckv2HAm-XE
120   AD   2025 Apr 22, 9:46pm  

AmericanKulak says


Panama City isn't San Diego, it's about the same as NOLA or Mobile, hot and sweaty half the year. It's at pretty much the same latitude with the same climate on the same body of water.

There are +85F +80% Humidity days, plural, for days at a time, several times a year in New Jersey and Virginia and Ohio and Pennsylvania, much less Florida. Florida summers are a whole other level, there's few breaks. It's as often more humid and steamy after a thunderstorm than before it.


I've never seen it get above 60% relative humidity in Panama City Beach when the thermometer reports at least 90 degrees Fahrenheit. So yes, it depends on what you define as muggy in regards to the "heat index". But yes, it is humid or muggy weather from mid June to mid September, but so is New York City during that period.
.
121   WookieMan   2025 Apr 23, 4:42am  

AD says

I've never seen it get above 60% relative humidity in Panama City Beach when the thermometer reports at least 90 degrees Fahrenheit. So yes, it depends on what you define as muggy in regards to the "heat index". But yes, it is humid or muggy weather from mid June to mid September, but so is New York City during that period.

I like the humidity was my point in my previous comment. IL is humid as can be during the summer as well. I'll sweat using a rider mower. Sweating is good for you though. Purges' crap out of your body. Then take a cold shower. Also good for you.

Dry heat like AZ I feel like someone put me on a pan in the oven and is baking me. I'll take humidity 10 out of 10 times. All it takes is a fan to cool you down with humidity. In AZ a fan is just a convection oven. Just cooks you evenly.
122   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 23, 5:35am  

AD says


I've never seen it get above 60% relative humidity in Panama City Beach when the thermometer reports at least 90 degrees Fahrenheit.

WookieMan says


I like the humidity was my point in my previous comment.

I gotcha, but the recorded weather records for the region show the high humidity WITH high temps is normal for about half the year.

All it takes is a fan to cool you down with humidity.

Wow, my view is 180. You can't get cool in high humidity without A/C, since a shower doesn't relieve the wetness and a fan just blows the steam around. In dry heat you can find the shade or use water to cool you off. Also you can keep items like paper in the garage or outside on the deck without it getting moldy and rotten.
123   zzyzzx   2025 Apr 23, 8:29am  

https://amp.bradenton.com/news/business/real-estate-news/article304039881.html

Sarasota, Manatee home values tumble, marking one of the biggest drops nationwide

Sarasota County saw a 7% decline over the past year, with Manatee close behind at 5%, according to the latest data from Zillow Home Value Index.
124   AD   2025 Apr 23, 10:46am  

AmericanKulak says


Wow, my view is 180. You can't get cool in high humidity without A/C, since a shower doesn't relieve the wetness and a fan just blows the steam around. In dry heat you can find the shade or use water to cool you off. Also you can keep items like paper in the garage or outside on the deck without it getting moldy and rotten.


I agree as evaporative cooling (or a swamp cooler method) does not work when the relative humidity is greater than around 40%.

The key is to reduce the humidity inside and we keep ours around 60% during the hottest days of summer.

Right now in Panama City Beach the dry bulb temperature is 82 degrees and the humidity is 75%, which means a "heat index" of 88.

During July it usually gets up to 90 degrees with humidity of 60% with a corresponding heat index of 100.

Florida panhandle is in extreme caution for about 3 months of the year, but I have not seen in it danger region of the heat index chart. But the great thing is it's beach weather generally from 1 March to end of November.


125   AD   2025 Apr 23, 2:40pm  

It has been discussed as far as Florida affordability crisis and compare to other states that pay better. I suspect the below job in Maine would pay only $25 an hour in Panama City, Florida, versus around $35 in Maine.

*********************************

We are hiring!
Job Title: Bus Mechanic
Location: 341 Bath Road, Brunswick, ME
Job Type: 3-5 Days a Week
Shift: 7:30-4:30
Company Overview:
Maine Bus Company, located in Brunswick, ME, is dedicated to providing safe, reliable, and efficient transportation services across the region. We’re looking for a dependable and skilled Bus Mechanic to join our team and help keep our fleet operating at its best.
Position Summary:
As a Bus Mechanic, you’ll perform inspections, maintenance, and repairs on school and commercial buses. This includes diagnosing mechanical and electrical problems, ensuring vehicle safety, and maintaining detailed service records.
Key Responsibilities:
• Perform preventive maintenance on diesel engines
• Diagnose and repair engines, transmissions, brakes, suspensions, and electrical systems
• Inspect and service HVAC, exhaust, and fuel systems
• Maintain accurate records of services and repairs
• Respond to road calls and provide emergency repairs when necessary
• Ensure compliance with DOT and state safety standards
Requirements:
• Must have your own tools
• High school diploma or GED
• 5+ years of experience with heavy vehicle or diesel repair (bus experience preferred)
• Valid driver’s license (CDL Class B with Passenger endorsement preferred or willingness to obtain)
• ASE certifications preferred
• Strong mechanical and diagnostic skills
• Ability to lift, bend, and work in varying conditions
• Attention to detail and commitment to safety
Compensation:
- $30-$40/hour depending on experience
Apply Today:
Apply in person at:
Maine Bus Company
341 Bath Road
Brunswick, ME 04011
Or email your resume to: brian@mainebuscompany.com
207-725-7189
126   AD   2025 Apr 28, 11:36am  

AmericanKulak says


Panama City, where about 50% of days from May to Mid-October are steamy and miserable.


In Panama City Beach it is now 85 Degs Fahrenheit and 71% humid and sunny; heat index is around 92, so borderline caution and extreme caution :-(

but during the summer the humidity usually is 55% if the temp is in lower 90s so the heat index usually peaks around 100

.
127   AmericanKulak   2025 Apr 28, 11:48am  

AD says


but during the summer the humidity usually is 55% if the temp is in lower 90s so the heat index usually peaks around 100

The historical weather records say otherwise. It's just like the rest of Florida and the Gulf Coast. Swimmin' in your shorts and drippin' like a mop, in Summer.

It's like other cities along the North shore of the Gulf of America: Mobile, Galveston, and NOLA, not San Diego. Nobody ever says "Wow, it's a dry heat here in Alabama in July"
128   AD   2025 Apr 28, 12:02pm  

AmericanKulak says

AD says



but during the summer the humidity usually is 55% if the temp is in lower 90s so the heat index usually peaks around 100

The historical weather records say otherwise. It's just like the rest of Florida and the Gulf Coast. Swimmin' in your shorts and drippin' like a mop, in Summer.

It's like other cities along the North shore of the Gulf of America: Mobile, Galveston, and NOLA, not San Diego. Nobody ever says "Wow, it's a dry heat here in Alabama in July"


Same goes for east coast like New Jersey, except you can comfortably go to the beach from beginning of March to end of November in the Florida panhandle.

.
129   AD   2025 May 1, 3:07pm  

from June 2020 Reader's Digest page 73

I'm surprised Florida panhandle is average as it's beach weather from March 1 to November 30 and its great for kayaking and boating.

I'm not surprised about Illinois being below average.


130   AmericanKulak   2025 May 1, 3:23pm  

AD says


March 1 to November 30 and its great for kayaking and boating.

And sweating your balls off just to walk to the mailbox within 2 minutes of leaving the A/C hahaha
131   WookieMan   2025 May 1, 3:46pm  

AmericanKulak says

AD says



March 1 to November 30 and its great for kayaking and boating.

And sweating your balls off just to walk to the mailbox within 2 minutes of leaving the A/C hahaha

I like that though. Better than feeling like an oven. Golfed once in 110ºF temps in AZ and it was miserable. I'll take FL any day of the year. I wear long sleeves and pants in warm weather so the bugs won't bother me in humid location FL or an IL summer day.

San Diego area has the best weather in the country. Winter or summer. I like FL, though have never done August or September due to hurricanes. May I think is the best time in the Panhandle. Water is warming up, temps are solid and not generally humid.
132   AD   2025 May 1, 4:03pm  

WookieMan says

AmericanKulak says


AD says




March 1 to November 30 and its great for kayaking and boating.

And sweating your balls off just to walk to the mailbox within 2 minutes of leaving the A/C hahaha


I like that though. Better than feeling like an oven. Golfed once in 110ºF temps in AZ and it was miserable. I'll take FL any day of the year. I wear long sleeves and pants in warm weather so the bugs won't bother me in humid location FL or an IL summer day.

San Diego area has the best weather in the country. Winter or summer. I like FL, though have never done August or September due to hurricanes. May I think is the best time in the Panhandle. Water is warming up, temps are solid and not generally humid.


Exactly Wookie, you will not sweat your balls off by not wearing long sleeve cotton shirts and jeans

Wear this along with nylon (i.e., BREATHABLE) gym pants

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Mens-Athletic-Performance-Shirt-Long-Sleeve-Light-Blue-Mahi-M/215970851

.
133   AmericanKulak   2025 May 1, 4:38pm  

WookieMan says


I like that though. Better than feeling like an oven. Golfed once in 110ºF temps in AZ and it was miserable. I'll take FL any day of the year. I wear long sleeves and pants in warm weather so the bugs won't bother me in humid location FL or an IL summer day.

Exact opposite. I'll take an oven over a sauna every day and twice on Sunday.

Shade actually helps in low humidity.

Just like I prefer the Air Fryer over the Sogginator (my name for Microwaves)
134   AD   2025 May 1, 7:17pm  

AmericanKulak says

Another one:
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/3802-Sunbeam-Ct-Merritt-Island-FL-32953/43404282_zpid/?mmlb=g%2C13

11/25/2013 Sold
$193,500
-3.2%
$98/sqft

2/14/2023 Listed for sale
$514,900
+166.1%
$261/sqft
Source: DBAMLS #1105834 Report a problem


It sold for $450,000 in April 2023 before the housing market started to freeze up

It sold for $134,000 in 2000, and was built in 1997

Went up in value about 5.5% annually from 2000 to 2023 :-/

.
135   WookieMan   2025 May 1, 10:57pm  

AmericanKulak says

Just like I prefer the Air Fryer over the Sogginator (my name for Microwaves)

In agreement. That's for food though. I don't microwave a thing for myself. As a human I'd rather sweat than be put in an oven.
136   AD   2025 May 2, 12:59pm  

.

this 3 bedroom , 2.5 bath, 1 car garage unit in Panama City Beach currently rents for $1895 which is same price it may have rented in 2021
rents have steadied or have dropped some which helps the working class like the hospitality and service workers on the beach

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1609-Annabellas-Way-Panama-City-Beach-FL-32407/87635669_zpid/

My forecast is townhomes in Panama City Beach will drop about 20 to 25% from their all time highs set in early 2022, which are almost the same price level at the peak of the 2003-2006 Bill Clinton Housing Bubble.

............

Florida Housing Market Mirroring 2008 Crash—Real Estate Analyst

https://www.newsweek.com/florida-housing-mirroring-2008-crash-analyst-2067158

.
137   AD   2025 May 2, 3:39pm  

I researched "Hathaway Luxury Apartments" in Panama City Beach (within 1 mile of Hathaway Bridge). It's a huge area where they cleared countless amounts of southern pine trees, as it looks like at least 200 apartment units will be built.

The agent for the Hathaway Luxury Apartment LLC is
Marvin Setness - Controller - RD Offutt Company

I wonder why a major potato company (RD Offutt Company from North Dakota) is an apartment developer in Panama City Beach 😕

But they stopped construction about 4 months ago after they cleared the land, perhaps waiting for the rental market to improve, and/or for interest rates to drop.

Rents seem to remain at 2021 or 2022 levels for at least townhomes on the beach and I don't trust the mega apartment complexes like Urban Blu as they are very deceitful.

US Department of Justice is suing Real Page which is used by apartment complexes to collude on rent.

.
138   AmericanKulak   2025 May 2, 3:47pm  

WookieMan says


In agreement. That's for food though. I don't microwave a thing for myself. As a human I'd rather sweat than be put in an oven.

Microwave devotion is a boomer thing mostly, maybe a few Xers who grew up with that as the primary cooking method. I think it's because it came out when they were kids and is always the "Hot New Thing in the Kitchen" in their mind.

I've seen Boomers look at me aghast when I've not had a microwave. And as if I didn't understand I could get one at the Thrift Shop. No, I just don't use it much, I have one now pretty much as a hotbox to keep food in if I'm making a multi-course meal.

"What about boiling water"? A $20 new electric kettle does the same thing faster, safer, larger quantity.
139   Ceffer   2025 May 2, 4:36pm  

An unplugged microwave is a good place to toss cell phones and small laptops in case of an EMP attack.
140   PeopleUnited   2025 May 2, 9:17pm  

If there was an emp attack, wouldn’t it fry the cell towers and wifi networks anyway? Only hope would be starlink type orbiting internet, but that is assuming that you still have a power source to charge your devices.
141   AD   2025 May 2, 9:34pm  

PeopleUnited says

If there was an emp attack, wouldn’t it fry the cell towers and wifi networks anyway? Only hope would be starlink type orbiting internet, but that is assuming that you still have a power source to charge your devices.


Starlink depends on computer servers in Bastrop, Texas. Use analog systems like a mid 1970s car (or earlier), and HAM radios that are not digital. Wish I had a Volkswagen Beetle built in 1970s.
142   Glock-n-Load   2025 May 3, 5:46am  

AD says

I researched "Hathaway Luxury Apartments" in Panama City Beach (within 1 mile of Hathaway Bridge). It's a huge area where they cleared countless amounts of southern pine trees, as it looks like at least 200 apartment units will be built.

The agent for the Hathaway Luxury Apartment LLC is
Marvin Setness - Controller - RD Offutt Company

I wonder why a major potato company (RD Offutt Company from North Dakota) is an apartment developer in Panama City Beach 😕

But they stopped construction about 4 months ago after they cleared the land, perhaps waiting for the rental market to improve, and/or for interest rates to drop.

Rents seem to remain at 2021 or 2022 levels for at least townhomes on the beach and I don't trust the mega apartment complexes like Urban Blu as they are very deceitful.

US Department of Justice is suing Real Page which is used by apartment complexes to collude on rent.

.

My wife is a property manager and they conduct “Market Surveys” to keep up on pricing. These are phone calls and physical tours of neighboring apartment complexes to see what their rent and amenities are. I’m more than sure this is a tool used to collude also. I fail to see how the colluding could be stopped.
143   HeadSet   2025 May 3, 6:44am  

Glock-n-Load says

My wife is a property manager and they conduct “Market Surveys” to keep up on pricing. These are phone calls and physical tours of neighboring apartment complexes to see what their rent and amenities are. I’m more than sure this is a tool used to collude also. I fail to see how the colluding could be stopped.

Market research is not collusion. Collusion is when a group of landlords get together and agree on pricing.
144   Glock-n-Load   2025 May 3, 8:09am  

HeadSet says


Glock-n-Load says


My wife is a property manager and they conduct “Market Surveys” to keep up on pricing. These are phone calls and physical tours of neighboring apartment complexes to see what their rent and amenities are. I’m more than sure this is a tool used to collude also. I fail to see how the colluding could be stopped.

Market research is not collusion. Collusion is when a group of landlords get together and agree on pricing.


And how do you think they do it? Maybe it isn’t explicit but, it can surely be accomplished like this. Tell me why they would do these market surveys then instead of just running their own businesses according to their own books/accounting? I imagine also, that collusion is very difficult to prove.
145   AD   2025 May 3, 9:08am  

Glock-n-Load says

I imagine also, that collusion is very difficult to prove.


You'd need smoking gun evidence likely to prove antitrust behavior like collusion on depressing wages within a sector or industry, or collusion on rent prices.

I guess hidden camera video would be that, and doubt there would be a paper trail like emails.
146   HeadSet   2025 May 3, 2:40pm  

Glock-n-Load says

Tell me why they would do these market surveys then instead of just running their own businesses according to their own books/accounting?

Prices are set by what the market will bear, not internal costs. When I priced my rental houses I looked at what others were advertising for similar places.
147   AmericanKulak   2025 May 3, 3:13pm  

And the Fed tracks rental prices not buy buying stats from Apartments.com, Zillow, Rental Agencies, etc. but by calling homeloaners who haven't rented in 10-20-30 years or looked at local rentals in a decade, and asking them what they'd pay for their own place as a renter. They don't ask current renters, either.

"Well shucks, after I had two kids and brought a house here in Springfield in 2011, we were paying about $1200/month for a 3 bed, 2 bath ranch. So I guess I'd pay $1400 today in 2025."

In case you were wondering why the CPI for housing is ridiculously low versus reality.
148   AD   2025 May 11, 9:52am  

.

This is why Panama City is betting on tourism, and one major positive is its beach roads are around 11 foot above sea level , which is higher than South Floridas (averaging 4 feet).

Panama City Beach tourism includes a very large Tootsies (worlds largest honky tonk) at the old Spinnakers nightclub as well as so many other venues and attractions like eco tourism (dolphin and sea turtles, fishing on the beach, etc) and its state parks.

It is gearing toward being an affordable Florida vacation and alternative to Orlando / Disney World and Miami Beach, AND for those family vacationers who want to be able to drive to Florida within a 14 hours drive of as far away as Chicago suburbs.

https://nypost.com/2025/05/11/lifestyle/florida-dad-craig-stowell-talks-about-1400-family-disney-world-trip/

.
149   Fortwaye   2025 May 11, 10:07am  

HeadSet says

Glock-n-Load says


Tell me why they would do these market surveys then instead of just running their own businesses according to their own books/accounting?

Prices are set by what the market will bear, not internal costs. When I priced my rental houses I looked at what others were advertising for similar places.


exactly! savings are never passed on to the buyer. chinese shit is cheap, yet our prices are sky high.
150   Maga_Chaos_Monkey   2025 May 11, 10:35am  

AmericanKulak says

Microwave


I just use mine to heat up a coffee cup of water for my instant coffee.
151   zzyzzx   2025 May 14, 10:46am  

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/real-estate/article-14708061/southern-state-housing-market-real-estate-crash.html

Southern state residents 'desperate to escape' but homes won't sell as crash looms

Panic selling is setting in, with residents spooked by skyrocketing HOA fees, especially in the wake of the 2021 Surfside condo collapse, as well as soaring insurance premiums.
152   AD   2025 May 14, 10:58am  

zzyzzx says


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/real-estate/article-14708061/southern-state-housing-market-real-estate-crash.html

Southern state residents 'desperate to escape' but homes won't sell as crash looms

Panic selling is setting in, with residents spooked by skyrocketing HOA fees, especially in the wake of the 2021 Surfside condo collapse, as well as soaring insurance premiums.


Yeah this is true for South Florida for the old high rises. Florida passed or is going to pass legislation to try to alleviate this.

This may have a spill over effect to other housing like townhomes and two floor condos.

Not seeing this a factor in Panama City Beach and panhandle for various reasons as those beach front condos do not have same environmental challenges like Surfside Miami; one reason is the panhandle beach front is at least 10 feet above sea level.

For many, they have a lot of equity in those Miami beach front condos so they'll take a reverse mortgage on them to live in them.

Also a major increase in demand for restoration of those condos will result in an increase in qualified contractors to work on them; this may result in lower prices for the HOAs.

.

« First        Comments 113 - 152 of 152        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste