0
0

High House Prices Hurt People


 invite response                
2009 Feb 4, 4:00am   20,937 views  273 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (60)   💰tip   ignore  

slavery

Why do we see so much suffering and moaning in the press about falling house prices when high house prices have directly injured and enslaved millions of Americans? To quote myself:

Housing is the biggest expense in nearly everyone's life, far more expensive than food, gas, energy, even more expensive than education or medicine. To reduce the time you spend working to pay for housing is to increase the time you have for everything else.

Cheap housing is good for us all! High housing costs take away from families' ability to save for retirement, fund their children's education, travel and lead a quality life.

How can we make lower house prices our official government policy? How can we completely eliminate the mortgage interest deduction which drives up housing costs and discriminates against renters? How can we wipe out Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, the FHA, and other agencies whose job it is to enslave Americans to mortgage debt?

Patrick

#housing

« First        Comments 247 - 273 of 273        Search these comments

247   justme   2009 Feb 15, 4:13am  

Sybrib,

It will be interesting to see whether the masses still only care about mortage rates, or if the asset prices now will be more of a deciding factor.

248   Malcolm   2009 Feb 15, 4:39am  

Bottom definition: When the price of something seems like a bargain based on your own method of valuation. Very simple.

249   B.A.C.A.H.   2009 Feb 15, 4:58am  

No, not a bargain. More like, a "trend".

Residential real estate in the Bay Area and the Fortress in particular is not and probably never will be a "bargain". But the nominal price might've trended to a bottom. ALso the interest rate for borrowing might've, also.

250   PermaRenter   2009 Feb 15, 5:10am  

I have cancelled my Blockbuster account ... now getting DVD from Cupertino Library. I am thus saving around $11/month.

251   tannenbaum   2009 Feb 15, 5:59am  

The only 2 ways people will "flood" the market are the same 2 ways Bay Area real estate bottomed and came to life big time in the late 90s: 1) Jobs have to come back in a BIG way. No way in hell 9% or 10% unemployment will make buyers come back in a huge way regardless of those "bargains". 2) Creative financing will also have to come back in a big way so all the bottom feeders with lousy credit can buy. We can't get all THAT much lower in rates than we have right now and when the economy does improve, they have nowhere to go but up. Just my 2 cents.

252   Peter P   2009 Feb 15, 7:11am  

This Generation has a rendezvous with destiny.

That 1936 generation had a rendezvous with an evil president.

253   justme   2009 Feb 15, 7:15am  

You're talking about Adolf Hitler, one would have to assume.

254   PermaRenter   2009 Feb 15, 9:20am  

Rising gas prices have Silicon Valley drivers howling
By Gary Richards, Mercury News

Crude oil is selling for the low price of under $35 a barrel. The precious black commodity is awash at storage tanks across the country. And drivers from New York to the Bay Area are motoring less and less as the economy continues to sink.

But the price of gas is going up and up and up — to $2.29 a gallon in California on Saturday, 25 cents higher than a month ago and 49 cents more than before Christmas.

What gives?

The price for gas that companies pay on a daily basis in California is now about 50 cents higher than the national price. That's more than double the usual gap.

That has some motorists howling as prices at the pump continue to rise. Many think low crude costs should mean gas selling for under two bucks a gallon like before Christmas, when the state average had fallen to $1.80. Never mind that a year ago South Bay drivers were paying $3.16 a gallon.

"I was furious to see gas at Costco in Santa Clara go up 12 cents a gallon from just eight days earlier," said Randall Fullner of San Jose after a recent fill-up. "Big Oil is fattening its wallet by ripping off the consumer and charging what it can get away with."

Added motorist Roland Beech:

"They can call it scheduled maintenance, but that's not the truth. Let's face it, they are just cutting back to keep prices higher."

255   PermaRenter   2009 Feb 15, 11:02am  

Today I explained the CENTRAL EQUATION of this thread to my relative in Houston:

MONEY = LABOR

He got it ... I gave example how lot of money is sitting in Banks and not moving ... since people who have earned and saved money through their labor do not want money to move.

So we have a confidence (money movement) crisis ... not a credit (money) crisis.

256   Malcolm   2009 Feb 16, 1:41am  

Exactly. I've said many times that I believe Obama will be an effective President because he instills so much confidence that companies will start investing again on things they pulled back on out of fear.

257   Malcolm   2009 Feb 16, 2:00am  

sybrib Says:
February 15th, 2009 at 12:58 pm
"No, not a bargain. More like, a “trend”."

Bargain is solely in the eye of the beholder. If my valuation of what I think BA housing is is higher than someone elses it is a bargain to me, and the bottom is set when I buy. As long as my decision is not emotional speculation it doesn't matter what the trend is. Trends, specualtion, and fraud are what caused the mess in the first place.

The largest lesson in finance this country needs to learn as a whole is how to put a value on something. It still amazes me that people buy houses and have no idea if the price they are paying is high or low, they don't even know how to put a value on it, the bank tells them what they can afford and they shop on payment.

A friend just bought a house near Tracy. He asked if I thought the area had hit bottom. I said there is no way to know if you just look at graphs and interest rates, but in helping him think it through we realized that the selling price was less than the cost to build the house and less than he rented his prior place for. His decision was rational and not emotional. He thinks he did well, I think so as well.

258   Peter P   2009 Feb 16, 3:19am  

When you hear more people saying bottom is in, that is about the time to start shorting again.

Very true. :)

259   B.A.C.A.H.   2009 Feb 16, 5:10am  

Malcolm,

I think trend has everything to do with it. The trend was, about three years ago, that folks were paying more for homes than they could afford, taking mortgages that were irrational, signing up for property taxes that were off the charts. That was the trend, it was irrational and nonsense.

Now the trend is that in SOME cases, housing is become REASONABLY priced here compared to renting, in some cases even with the property taxes can pencil out decently compared to renting. Maybe not in The Enclave/Fortress, but those buyers are in a different dynamic and are mostly not Americans (not naturalized nor native).

There will probably never be bargains here, if you compare the amount of labor an employee or small business owner would have to trade for housing, and what you get for the housing in comparison to the tradeoffs (commuting, public schools, tiny lots, small homes, etc.).

And then there's the other aspect to the Quality of Life in the Bay Area, involving the congestion, higher cost of non-housing stuff like car insurance, hospital stays, childcare, preschool tuition, etc, and of course necessity of sharing the same space with so many Alpha-types who put all else second to coming here from all over the USA and all over the world to "make it".

Why do you suppose that so many local kids from working class, when they come of age, move out of the area? And why so many long-time locals, when they reach retirement age, also do so?

Because if the "trend" is a low point in comparison to renting, housing might be a bargain to a rich person in a crowded place like Mumbai or Shanghai, but to an American, it ain't no bargain.

260   EBGuy   2009 Feb 16, 6:21am  

A quick Fed report for last week. The balance sheet declined by ~$10billion but this week will pick up another ~$35B from last week's TAF auction (28 day facility). It also looks like the Treasury supplemental increased by ~$30B.

261   EBGuy   2009 Feb 16, 8:57am  

This link should probably be in the last thread. Time is money...
In a small, backroom office at the Community Reformed Church in East Oakland's Sobrante Park district, a handful of local residents are running their own neighborhood bank. Instead of U.S. currency, though, the transactions are recorded in hours and minutes.

262   Peter P   2009 Feb 16, 9:11am  

Instead of U.S. currency, though, the transactions are recorded in hours and minutes.

Hours and minutes or what? Swedish massage?

263   DennisN   2009 Feb 17, 12:11am  

... necessity of sharing the same space with so many Alpha-types who put all else second to coming here from all over the USA and all over the world to “make it”.

Why do you suppose that so many local kids from working class, when they come of age, move out of the area? And why so many long-time locals, when they reach retirement age, also do so?

I for one wish that "silicon valley" never happened. My family moved to northern California in the 1860's, and lived in Santa Clara Co. since around 1900. These "alpha types" as you call them really are the root of the problem. People come to SV from all over not to settle there but instead just to "make their bag of gold" after which they leave. Certainly a bunch of H1-B visas doesn't help matters much. The outcome is that there is no sense of community nor the political will to fund needed infrastructure (e.g. transit). Those "alpha types" couldn't care less about SV as a place to put down roots.

And yes I retired out of the area to Boise after selling off my little stucco box in May 2006.

264   justme   2009 Feb 17, 1:26am  

DennisN and Sybrib,

I'm not exactly in disagreement with you, but I think there is another aspects of the situation which is overlooked: The rampant "pyramid-scheming" around the valley by those who have been here longer, exploiting those who arrived more recently.

When times are good, the schemers are cheerleaders because they can sit around and watch their property values and rents go up. When times go bad, as they now have, even some of the same people (and I do not mean any of you two) are whining about immigrants taking their jobs, blah, blah, blah.

There is also a real division among the old-timers between property owners and the plain blue-collar folks. The latter have children that move away, the former have children that become real-estate agents and tax the newcomers. If they are really blue-blood, they dabble in *commercial* real-estate and play lots of golf.

That is more or less the picture, and I think it has been ongoing for a LONG time, maybe since 1940-1945. Right now it looks like the pyramid has stopped growing.

265   justme   2009 Feb 17, 1:28am  

aspects=aspect

266   Peter P   2009 Feb 17, 2:36am  

justme, I agree with you!

That is more or less the picture, and I think it has been ongoing for a LONG time, maybe since 1940-1945.

It was the New Deal's fault.

267   justme   2009 Feb 17, 3:27am  

Hardly. More like the generic tendency of pyramid-scheming in the US, coupled with WW2, Cold War buildup, and so on.

268   Peter P   2009 Feb 17, 3:47am  

New thread:

What now?

269   warblah   2009 Feb 17, 7:33am  

justme, I agree with what you said. Prop.13 is a fine example of this.

270   justme   2009 Feb 17, 10:08am  

No kidding, Prop. 13 preserves the wealth of the haves (and hangers-on of convenience) at the expense of everyone else.

271   Peter P   2009 Feb 18, 2:15am  

I say abolish Prop 13. It is a form of rent control (land rent/tax) and any form of rent control is evil.

272   Tran Harry   2009 Feb 26, 5:00pm  

I agree, I hate the fact that I will need to work for the rest of my enjoyable part of life if I ever wanted to own a home in the area that I grew up in. SF Bay Area.

I won't be able to take vacation days off work, I won't be able to take time off for family, I won't be able to do anything but go to work, they just want us to keep on working so they can keep on taxing, but what incentive is there to work, except to make us pay loads of money for a home.

273   itruth   2009 Feb 28, 4:35am  

Q: Does anyone know if banks --being as they are the effective owners of vast amounts of real estate-- are delaying settlements and recordations on theory that finalizing sales will accelerate the deflation of their assets?

« First        Comments 247 - 273 of 273        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions